Premium Essay

To Whistleblow or Not to Whistleblow

In: Social Issues

Submitted By jaykap94
Words 2100
Pages 9
Jay Kaplan
Business Law and Ethics
Professor Gaston de los Reyes
December 8, 2014

To Whistleblow or Not To Whistleblow?
When an employee of, or group within, a company witnesses misconduct, there are two simple but very different paths that an employee or group can take: expose the issue in order to try and correct the situation or remain mum and let the issue continue to metastasize. It seems quite obvious what path is best and most noble to take; however, the idea that one should expose the truth in order to correct the situation can sometimes also be the quickest path to becoming the company outcast. Witnessing misconduct or alleged illegal or dishonest activity within an organization and exposing it, e.g. advising your superior, is known as whistleblowing. Even though these employees are usually doing it out of the best interest of their company, they can often face ostracization and retaliation as a result of them exposing the truth. The question is, however, should companies promote whistleblowing? They absolutely should. Furthermore, what should companies do to allow whistleblowing? They should establish concrete programs that facilitate and encourage employees to whistleblow.
Why GM Fails at Whistleblowing
In a BusinessWeek article, GM Recalls: How General Motors Silenced a Whistle-Blower, a report blames General Motors with a culture of complacency for the more than decade-long delay before the company recalled millions of faulty vehicles. It described employees as passing the buck and committees falling back on the “GM nod” – the gesture given by members of a large, corporate meeting after the meeting ends where all in the room believe that the “other guy” plans to put whatever was discussed and agreed in place. An example of the effects of whistleblowing is described in the article written by Tim Higgins and Nick Summers. Steven…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Enron Scandal a memo to Ken Lay, "but by the time Watkins and Cooper blew the whistle, much damage had already been done and the shareholders and employees were the ultimate losers."○2 Whistleblower program is very important to minimum a corporation's hazardous activities, but the blower often face some awkward situations, such as fear of the manager's retaliation, fear to be treat as a betrayer by the workmates, unwilling to be a snitch and so on. To fix these situations and finally enhance financial report, we should first establish a company's whistleblowing culture, that means encourage employee to investigate and report flaws they find and give reward instead of punishment, also, the management need to demonstrate a strong will to commit the whistleblow policy, promptly investigate the report and give feedback. Even though sometimes the employee maybe made a mistake about the whistleblowing, managers should not simply blame the person, instead they should make a clarification to the employee about the mistake. From the film "The smartest guys in the room", we can concluded that the collapse of Enron is not just a business or financial problem. Enron Corporation has a unusual relationship with Bush family, it support the G.W Bush to attend the president election, as a return, Bush deregulated the energy industry, as a result, Enron earned a large profit through this policy, later on, when scandals were discovered, the......

Words: 982 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Company Law

...Auditors’ Rights, Powers and Privileges are Inadequate The auditors were equally divided on this point as there is no provision to protect auditors from being removed especially where there are differences of opinion between a 13 company and its auditor. Auditors’ right to make a representation at the general meeting is insufficient 6.2 Arguments that Auditors’ Rights, Powers and Privileges are Adequate The other auditors argued that the rights, powers and privileges granted to auditors are adequate. However, over the years, the duties have increased as the laws wish to take into account the stakeholders’ interests. This is justified since the scandals which involved auditors are on the rise. Furthermore, auditors have a right to whistleblow under the CMSA. 6.3 A Critique of the Auditors’ Views The auditors’ powers are inadequate as they are unable to obtain information from the employees of a company since the CA only empowers auditors to obtain information from the officers. Moreover, auditors are not entitled to receive notices for meetings held by the companies. Thus, they will not be able to know the matters that will be discussed by the companies. S. 174A(2A) of the CA gave more privileges than necessary as the provisions provide that no civil, criminal or disciplinary proceedings can be brought against auditors if they acted in good faith. Auditors may claim that they acted in good faith and thus may not be liable even if the auditors’ report is untrue......

Words: 5159 - Pages: 21

Free Essay

Global Economics and the Impact of Whistleblowing

...that may be able to effect action.” (Near et al., p 6, 1996) Many scholars have opposed this notion and used Hofstede’s Cultural dimensions to explain how a decision is made to commit the act of whistleblowing. Germany has a high power distance, which yields to a more ready acceptance of inequality and paternalism, making it susceptible to whistleblowing. One must however note that such generic theories cannot be applied across the border. (Tavakoli et al., p 49, 2003) Whistleblowing – an act of good will One cannot simply believe that throughout history people have blown the whistle out of pure good will, since psychological ambiguity and diverse points of view surround that specific individual. An increased tendency to whistleblow relies on how positively the act is considered in the nation, within the company, or amongst the surrounding individuals. That is, do the involved people consider it as the right and morally correct thing to do? (Tavakoli et al., p 51, 2003) One can agree that whistle blowers intend to detect and to systematically expose critical and questionable conditions in an institution no matter if it is in the company, government or military sector. Through the research conducted one can see that holding the idea of whistleblowing as a positive and nurturing benefit to society decreases as an individual’s age increases. However, the majority of the population, even though a decrease can be seen, believes that the highly critical act of......

Words: 3369 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay

Qantas Sustainability Review 2013

...Qan ntas Group. Group Audit and Risk also provides independe t s ent, objective as ssurance an consulting services fo nd g or Qantas’ system of risk m managemen internal nt, control and governance. As part of the Qantas f s Group’s risk manageme process, Group Audiit ent and Risk is r responsible for maintain ning and ent improving th Board-ap he pproved risk manageme k framework, bi-annual re eporting to the Board about risk a and performi ing audit an other nd advisory services. Whistleblow Policy wer Qantas has a long-esta s ablished whistleblower process, inc cluding a ‘ho otline’ throug which gh employees may report c concerns. The hotline is a s comprehensive reportin service (t ng telephone, e email and mail) in ndependently managed on behalf o d of Qantas by P Pricewaterho ouseCooper Reports rs. made throu ugh the whis stleblower pr rocess can choose to b anonymo be ous. The Group has a dedicated W Whistleblowe Committee comprising er e g executive and senior m management The t. Whistleblow Committe is respons wer ee sible for overseeing investigation of matters reported a s and it reports to th Board an Audit Com he nd mmittee on a an annual basis and as ot therwise nec cessary. Qantas Group Cod of Condu and de uct Ethics de uct cs The Cod of Condu and Ethic (Code) is the Qan ntas Group’s principal co s orporate governa ance policy. The key principle un nderpinning the Code is g s compliance with law regulatio and ws, ons ethical standards. s Togethe with the o er......

Words: 27168 - Pages: 109

Premium Essay

Barclays Annual Report

...and operating effectiveness of the controls over the occurrence, accuracy and timing of revenue recognised in the financial statements. We also focused on the instances of material judgement by the directors and by management and on those parts of the accounting processes which require manual intervention. We incorporated unpredictability into our testing. We tested key reconciliations and manual journal entries incorporating unpredictability into our approach. We considered whether there was evidence of bias by the directors or by management in the significant accounting estimates and judgements relevant to the financial statements. We also assessed the overall control environment of the Group, including the arrangements for staff to “whistleblow” inappropriate actions, and interviewed senior management and the Group’s internal audit function. How the scope of our audit addressed the area of focus We examined the correspondence between the Group and both the relevant tax authorities and the Group’s external advisers. We examined the matters in dispute and used our knowledge of the law of the relevant tax jurisdictions and other similar taxation matters to assess the available evidence and consider whether the provisions are appropriate. Risk of fraud in revenue recognition We focussed on this area because ISAs (UK & Ireland) presume there is a risk of fraud in revenue recognition as a result of the potential for management bias in order to achieve planned......

Words: 288315 - Pages: 1154

Free Essay

Whistleblowing and Sarbanes-Oxley Due

...practices. The upkeep of the case in the courts costs Zillow a lot of funds that would otherwise get channeled to more useful operations (Brambila, 2015). The whistleblower received criticism especially since he had just lost his position as the vice president of strategic partnerships in the organization. Due to the act of whistleblowing Crocker will have difficulties finding a replacement job as very few companies are willing to hire a whistleblower. The companies believe that a whistleblower is a disadvantage to the company. I disagree with the timing of Crocker in revealing the illegal acts done by Zillow. He should have spotted the practice earlier n while he was still working for Zillow. However, I acknowledge Crocker’s move to whistleblow on Zillow was justified as the organization was using data from other companies to gain competitive advantage. Zillow was using the data from to develop call lists for its gain. All the members in the business world are supposed to follow the principles of ethics and morality when carrying out business operations (Near& Miceli, 1985). The Sarbanes-Oxley Due protects Crocker under the corporate responsibility section that recognizes the senior executives take individual liability for the precision and entirety of corporate financial reports (Baynes, 2002). Under this section, the law limited the actions of the two unscrupulous Zillow officials in using the data of to develop their client base. The corporate......

Words: 951 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

D2 Unit 11 each of them, the Care Quality Commission (CQC), Commission for Health Care inspection and the mental Health Commission were introduced.   To ensure that a new employee is suitable for the job role of caring for vulnerable adults, a CRB check is carried out. This was since October 2009; this is to check if the employee had any history with the police that may mean there would be a possibility that he/she would abuse the health and social care receivers. This helps to prevent the chances of service users receiving abuse from their health care providers. Also in cases of abuse, If another service provider notices abuse towards the service user from a service provider, the service provider that has witnessed abuse have an option to whistleblow which since the public Interest Disclosure Act(1998) the staff have the right not suffer mentally or be fired as a result of disclosing the information. In the past, it has been known that the service user may be called ‘’grass’’ to the service and their employees. For example,In the care home where I work now, carers noted that one of the service users was too stiff and it made it harder to provide personal care, after alerting the nurse, she booked an appointment with the doctor to come and assess whether or not the service user would benefit from some physio to loosen the muscles , after the doctor’s reassurance, a physio was booked to come in every Wednesday and since then, we have noticed a positive change and It’s easier and......

Words: 1495 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Lehman Brothers Holdings, Inc

...registration statements it filed periodically with the Se-curities and Exchange Commission ( SEC). Another revelation in the bankruptcy report that stunned the public was the fact that Lehman’s audit firm had been aware of the billion- dollar transactions the company had used to window- dress its financial statements. According to the bankruptcy examiner, the Big Four audit firm had discussed those transactions on many occasions with company officials but had not insisted or, apparently, even suggested that the company disclose them in their financial statements or the ac-companying notes. The bankruptcy examiner also maintained that the audit firm had not properly ­informed Lehman’s management and audit committee of an internal whistleblow-er’s allegations that management was intentionally misrepresenting the company’s financial statements. Because of alleged professional malpractice, Lehman’s ­audit firm was among the parties the bankruptcy examiner suggested could be held civilly liable for the enormous losses suffered by the company’s stockholders and creditors. The Cotton Kings Political unrest and poor economic conditions in their homeland prompted six mil-lion Germans to immigrate to the United States during the nineteenth century. Those immigrants included three brothers from Bavaria, the beautiful mountainous region of southeastern Germany. In 1844, 23- year- old Henry Lehman arrived in ­Montgomery, Alabama, a small city with fewer than 5,000 inhabitants in......

Words: 7677 - Pages: 31

Premium Essay


...makes the case that if more taxes could be recovered, what is wrong with a little opportunistic encouragement? Mr. ABC seems to understand how to read financial information, tax returns, and tax laws and zeroed in on what is not adding up. 2. Is it ethical for a Wall Street insider to purposefully analyze financial data of an unrelated company in order to identify corporate wrongdoing, report it to the appropriate authorities, and then receive a whistleblowing reward? Mr. ABC has helped the IRS collect taxes owed under tax law. In whistleblowing he may be argued that he is trying to see fair application of the tax law to all U.S. companies, and thus, all U.S. taxpayers. His ethical motivation could only be tested if he would still whistleblow the ITW to the IRS, even if no reward was offered. Part of the IRS reward program is for the reward to encourage whistleblowers to give the IRS tips on taxpayers who are not paying the correct taxes. Mr. ABC did not violate any confidentiality requirements since he didn’t divulge such information of an employer or client. 3. Consider Mr. ABC’s motivation for blowing the whistle in the ITW case and the fact that it was the third time he had engaged in whistleblowing to the IRS. Using Kohlberg’s model of moral development, at what stage of ethical reasoning would you say Mr. ABC was at? Why? Since this is the third time for Mr. ABC to engage in whistleblowing to the IRS, it is hard to judge his motivation from afar. The......

Words: 751 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay


...Shared Values is manifested in the Code of Conduct and Business Ethics (CoBE) and employees are required to strictly adhere to the CoBE in performing their duties. A Whistleblowing Policy is in place to provide an avenue for all employees of PETRONAS as well as members of the public to disclose any improper conduct committed or about to be committed within the Group. This policy addresses the Group’s commitment to integrity and ethical behaviour by fostering and maintaining an environment where employees can act appropriately, without fear of retaliation. Under the policy, a whistleblower will be accorded with protection of confidentiality of identity, to the extent reasonably practicable. In addition, an employee who whistleblows internally will also be protected against any adverse and detrimental actions for making the disclosure, to the extent reasonably practicable, provided that the disclosure is made in good faith. Such protection is accorded even if the investigation later reveals that the whistleblower is mistaken as to the facts and the rules and procedures involved. review is conducted on a semi-annual basis. Action plans to address employee developmental requirements are in place. The Group believes that this will motivate employees to deliver their best so that the Group can meet its business requirements. Conclusion The Board has received assurance from the President & Group Chief Executive Officer and the Executive Vice......

Words: 82448 - Pages: 330

Premium Essay

Final Exam Prep

...The categorical Imperative contains three maxims. Universality: You should only do something if you think it would be ok if everyone did it all the time. E.g. cheating in business, if everyone did it the economy would collapse. Every human should be treated as an end not a means to an end: So you can’t manipulate people to achieve an end. Contrasts to consequentialism which is based on ‘the greater good’. Means you cannot lie, (example about com101 being fav class) Act as if you were the moral authority of the universe: If any action that you undertake, repeated across the universe would create negative effects it is deemed unethical and you should not do it. Whistleblowing WB: Corporate governance codes require people to whistleblow on breaches of the codes. E.g. Enron: Positives: Required by corporate governance to report unethical business actions. Saves future shareholders from losing money Society benefits Stricter frameworks Ripple on effect Negatives: Destroying jobs of colleagues Acting against “tribal” instinct “stealing” information to prove accusers Seen as a ‘dobber’ Can’t get a job in the future Company bankrupt Current shareholders lose money Suicide by Executive Requisites for ethical action 1.Awareness of an ethical problem 2. Ability to reason about ethical issues 3. Having the motivation to act ethically (This is what whistle-blowers have) 4. Having the courage or fortitude to implement the ethical action......

Words: 2581 - Pages: 11

Free Essay

The Paper

...disclosure in other cases and in order for this provision to apply to the worker they must reasonably believe that they will be subjected to detriment if they disclose to their employer, also where there is no significant person the worker must reasonably believe that evidence will be concealed or destroyed if they disclose the information to their employer, furthermore the worker must have already disclosed substantially the same information to either his employer or a prescribed person. Until of recent disclosing information under section 43G would only be safeguarded if the employee had made the disclosure in ‘good faith’ however this condition was abolished under the Enterprise and Regulatory Reform Act 2013. When an employee wants to whistleblow there is a certain whistleblowing policy that the employee needs to be aware of and employers need to make this very clear so that employees know the proper procedure to follow when they want to report misconduct in the office. The employees should be aware of issues such as the kinds of action that will amount to misconduct, they should also know to inform their line manager as soon as they are informed of any misconducting happening or about to happen, the employees should feel comfortable to raise any issues with their employees without fear and they should also feel confortable enough to address the issue with a more senior manager if they feel the need to, and also employees should be aware that they retain the right have......

Words: 3464 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay

Cg Blueprint

...(33%), internal audit review (30%) and notification by customer/supplier (25%). Anonymous letters or whistleblowers (25%) were also a major source of information on fraud. It is therefore important that any impediments which prevent these professionals from acting as effective gatekeepers are addressed. In this regard, section 320 of the CMSA already imposes a mandatory duty on auditors to report breaches of securities laws. The law also provides protection to key officials of a company who whistleblow. These changes have had positive results as between 2007 and 2010, 34 cases were referred to the SC by whistleblowers pursuant to the CMSA. It is thus appropriate and timely to consider amendments to the CMSA for the purposes of expanding the mandatory obligation for whistleblowing to certain other professionals such as corporate advisors and company secretaries. Considerations should also be given as to whether the statutory protection provided by the CMSA to certain company officials who whistleblow should be extended to others. ...appropriate and timely to consider amendments to the CMSA for the purposes of expanding the mandatory obligation for whistleblowing to certain other professionals such as corporate advisors and company secretaries. 58 Securities Commission Malaysia • Corporate Governance Blueprint 2011 5.3.2 Enhancing the role of company secretaries Over the years, the role of company secretaries has changed from the traditional passive role of......

Words: 27564 - Pages: 111

Premium Essay


...Below is a free essay on "Whistleblowing" from Anti Essays, your source for free research papers, essays, and term paper examples. Whistleblowing is a highly controversial and widely discussed topic in today’s society due to many high profile cases including the circumstances surrounding the Space Shuttle Challenger explosion and what was documented in the movie The Insider about the tobacco industry. Ethically, the decision for someone to whistleblow is a tremendous one. The person needs to weigh many factors and take many things into consideration before making that step. This paper will use the movie The Insider, Ethical Theory and Business and material collected from the internet to (1) discuss definitions and conditions of whistleblowing; what motivates whistleblowers; ethical and other considerations including risks and typical results of whistleblowing cases. Definitions and conditions of whistleblowing “A whistleblower is an individual that believes that his or her organization is engaged in or willingly permits unethical, unlawful or otherwise reprehensible activities. Whistleblowers bring attention to the objectionable activity and attempt to effect change. Whistleblowers generally report these actions internally and may ultimately resort to reporting these activities to external authorities or interested parties.” (http:cosign.scu. edu505set01003WhistleblowerProfile.htm) In the essay “Whistleblowing and Professional Responsibility” published in Ethical Theory......

Words: 633 - Pages: 3