Free Essay

Sin in "The Minister's Black Veil"

In: English and Literature

Submitted By dani63
Words 1253
Pages 6
Do things you can’t see or understand make you distrusting or afraid? Some people fear the unknown. In fact, the unexplainable often puts irrational fear into the hearts of many. In “The Minister’s Black Veil” by Nathaniel Hawthorne, Reverend Hooper causes discord by wearing a veil in front of his congregation. Never explaining his reasons, he continues to wear the veil every single day. His people begin to shun him, thinking it is strange and unseemly. He wears it the rest of his life, and upon his deathbed explains it is a symbol of the mask everyone is wearing to cover his secret sin. The author emphasizes obsession, isolation, and underlying guilt as aspects of man’s hidden sins by presenting the struggle between the concealed side of man and the ideals of society.
The minister becomes obsessed with his pursuit of showing men’s inner identities. As his bride-to-be Elizabeth confronts him about removing the veil, his response is not to her liking.
“Do not leave me in this miserable obscurity forever!”
“Lift the veil but once, and look me in the face,” said she.
“Never! It cannot be!” replied Mr. Hooper.
“Then, farewell!” said Elizabeth. (417)

The parson is so consumed with being an example for his community that he sacrifices his own happiness. He strives to be in the image of God and to share his true character, and implies his congregation should do the same. However, his withdrawal sets him apart from his people. Therefore, without that contact the minister loses his effectiveness. The author shows the obsession with eradicating sinfulness and the view that anything less than perfection is corruption. He conveys the message that this high standard prevents men from ever showing each other’s true selves. According to Timothy Montbriand, author of “An overview of ‘The Minister’s Black Veil,’” Hooper’s preoccupation with the veil makes him become vain.
The black veil becomes a symbol of Hooper’s sin of excessive pride when he continues to wear it and gets caught up in thinking that he is morally superior because he is the conveyor of such an important message. (n. page)

Hooper initially wears the veil to signify the disguise of sin, but his quest becomes self-fulfilling. He thinks he is above others because of his knowledge and sacrifice, but really it makes him sanctimonious. As a result, the minister’s capability wanes as his congregation distances itself from him. Throughout his life, the veil causes nothing but confusion as no one ever examines the real meaning behind the veil. While he is trying save his congregation from one sin, he is ultimately committing another. Hawthorne characterizes a man who is trying to eliminate a barrier, but perhaps unconsciously creates a new one in its place.
The minister’s veil eventually causes his isolation. Throughout the years, Mr. Hooper continues to live his life with his face covered.
In this manner Mr. Hooper spent a long life, irreproachable in outward act, yet shrouded in dismal suspicions; kind and loving, though unloved, and dimly feared; a man apart from men…” (418)

Initially, by the reverend wearing the veil, the congregation views the adornment as unacceptable and unpredictable, so he is immediately alienated. It becomes frightening to them because he can see into all of their faces but no one can look upon his own. The veil is described as gloomy and disturbing to the community. They believe it is either a sign of mourning or his secret sin. The author seems to suggest humanity can be harsh and judgmental when it comes to someone’s sin to the point of isolation. He demonstrates the barriers among people because they feel judged by showing their faults and shortcomings. In Nancy L. Bunge’s “Nathaniel Hawthorne: A Study of the Short Fiction,” she explains why Hooper is isolated.
They no longer welcome the minister at weddings or Sunday dinner. They believe some occasions go more smoothly without a living parable of evil present. People sin, but they also experience joy and love. (19)

His people don’t want to be around someone who constantly makes them afraid or guilty. His meekness makes him appear unforgiving of himself, at the cost of his happiness. Even though he never marries Elizabeth, she is still at his side at the end of his life. The opportunity for enjoyment is within reach, but the veil inhibits his ability to have a contented life. If only he would cast aside his aspersions for impeccable morality and accept imperfection. Hawthorne shows the incapability to comprehend fallibility by highlighting the barriers it creates.
The underlying guilt of the congregation is inherent the first day Mr. Hooper wears his veil. His sermon that Sunday talks of secret sin.
A subtle power was breathed into his words. Each member of the congregation, the most innocent girl, and the man of hardened breast, felt as if the preacher had… discovered their hoarded iniquity of deed or thought. (413)

The veil mirrors the hearts of the congregation harboring their hidden iniquities. Each person’s veil distances him from his friends, family, and God. Eventually he will have to acknowledge the darkness within himself, because judgment will come for everyone. When Hooper is dying, he tells them not to judge him until they are free from sin. Hawthorne shows humans do not like the idea of committing and repenting of sins. He illustrates men aren’t separated from each other by wickedness, but that all humans are sinful by nature. Timothy Montbriand explains another reason for wearing the veil.
He might have worn the veil for a short time, explaining its significance simply and directly. The fact that he does not do so affirms that his intention is not to inform his congregation about Original Sin, but only to acknowledge its presence in himself. (n. page)

If Hooper really wants his congregation to acknowledge secret sin, during one of his sermons he would encourage them to repent. As it is, he leaves them to guess at the veil’s unclear meaning. The veil also represents the barrier he is trying to rid within himself, the separation of his true self and suppressed sin. Hooper never stepped forward to unveil his secret sin to anyone else, so it makes him as guilty as his congregation. Hawthorne may have created a person who had enough bravery to be an individual standing up for what he knows to be right, but in the end, it produced nothing but a misunderstood and isolated man.
In the end, the minister states, “I look around me, and, lo! On every visage a black veil” (419). Perhaps there are many types of sin, and it is difficult to reveal faults to friends or loved ones. But according to the author, this is what one must do to achieve goodness. Hawthorne expresses the identity of sin through the minister’s obsession, his alienation, and the hidden guilt of humanity. The reader is left to reflect whether to hide or share his secrets.

Works Cited

Bunge, Nancy L. "Isolation and Community." Nathaniel Hawthorne: A Study of the Short
Fiction. New York: Twayne Publishers, 1993. 6-27. Twayne's Studies in Short Fiction 41. Gale Virtual Reference Library. Web. 2 Apr. 2012

Hawthorne, Nathaniel. “The Minister’s Black Veil.” The Bedford Introduction to Literature:
Reading, Thinking and Writing. Ed. Michael Meyer. 9th Edition. Boston: Bedford/St. Martin's, 2011. 411-419. Print.

Montbriand, Timothy. "An overview of 'The Minister's Black Veil." Gale Online Encyclopedia. Detroit: Gale, 2012. Literature Resource Center. Web. 2 Apr. 2012.…...

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Veil Piercing

...section 163 (4) of the Companies Act, No 71 of 2008 codified the common law approach in piercing the corporate veil i.e. to what extent did the 2008 Act brought some certainty regarding to the grounds in which the courts will disregard the juristic existence of a company. To achieve this I’m going to first explore the position of common law in this field of law. As a point of departure, the company is equal in law to a natural person. This is one of the cornerstones of South African company law, and has been since 1897 handed down in the Salomon case namely that a company is a legal entity distinct from its shareholders. It allows a company to perform juristic acts in its own name, as well as to sue and to be sued. Further, members and directors enjoy protection against personal liability. The corporate veil is a fundamental aspect of a company law and is a protective stratagem for those who exist behind it . Although this fundamental rule has a considerable influence in company law, it cannot be absolute and, as such, according to the case of Lock harts ltd v Excalibur Holdings ltd it can be saved for certain exceptions (where the courts may disregard the separate legal personality of the company) Herron CJ in Commissioner of Land Tax v Theosophical Foundation described lifting of the corporate veil as an ‘esoteric’ label, stating further that authorities in which the veil of incorporation has been lifted have not been of such consistency that any principle can be......

Words: 1536 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Innate Nature of Sin

...Innate Nature of Sin Nathaniel Hathorne was an author who consistently wrote about sotires of the Puritan time. His short stories often revolved around themes of sin and how no one could escape from committing sin. The short stories “The Minister’s Black Veil” and “Young Goodman Brown,” written by Hawthorne, reflect these themes through elements of fiction, such as plot, setting, symbolism, and point of view. “The Minister’s Black Veil” is about a town’s minister who walks into Sunday Congregation with a heinous black veil covering his face. The veil shields him from the sins of the rest of the world, and the rest of the world from his sin. “Young Goodman Brown” is about a newly married man who leaves Faith, his wife to follow a man into the forest, where Satanic Rituals occur. These Satanic Rituals are powered by the people Goodman Brown had once known to be the most religious. Through the elements of fiction, the short stories “The Minister’s Black Veil” and “Young Goodman Brown,” show how there is no way for one escape from committing sin, no matter who they are. One of the stories Hawthorne writes is “The Minister’s Black Veil.” The story starts when a minster walks into his weekly Sunday sermon with a veil that cover’s his face.. The veil is seen as symbolic with sin, because the minister has started to wear his sin on his face. He is shunned from the town, as people start to grow uncomfortable in his presence. The veil is a constant reminder of their sins as well.......

Words: 1358 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Women Veil

...Muslim Women and the Veil For this critical review analysis paper, I have chosen to do set four of the project. I will begin to analyze and break down the fundamental themes in each of the articles from the sources provided by the professor. My examination of the texts, Islamic and Body Politics by Asma Barlas and Rethinking Muslim Women and the Veil by Katherine Bullock, will be purely academic. Both these articles share similar views of the concept of veiling and portrayal of the female body by opposing the monolithic and secular views given to the veil by the majority of the world. The view given to the veil is simple and is explicitly cited in Rethinking Muslim Women and the Veil, it is that "the popular Western notion that the veil is a symbol of Muslim women's oppression is a constructed image that does not represent the experience of all those who wear it." My stance on the subject of veiling will be in support of: those who wear the Veil (or as I will interchangeably mention it in this paper, "Hjiab" - Arabic term for head scarf) do it so by their own will and not to represent the view of oppression that has been deemed on it, also, to reiterate that the Qur'an or any other Islamic text do not support the views of oppression of women. Through my investigation of the two given articles, I will support my view with the help of three different articles that share the same type of commentary on the issue of Veiling. My inclusion of the article Eastern Veiling, Western......

Words: 2393 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

The Sin Bin

...English written assignment – The sin bin or Lucy’s heart 1. Lucy. Lucy is very focused on her school and gets good grades. She is the only one, besides Angela Howe who is taking nine O-levels and is one of the brainiest pupils in her school. She also has high hopes for her future and she is dreaming of moving to London when she grows up. Unfortunately, she is worried about her grades because of her new “best friend” Bethan. Bethan is manipulating Lucy to hit her former best friend Penny Jones, to smoke and to wear makeup for example. She is looking forward to her future with hopes that she will not have to “wear a face” to get people to accept her. 2. The heart as a metaphor. a. It is a metaphor to her own life, and heart. It symbolizes her decisions and the fact that she is drawing it black symbolizes her bad conscious and her ruining her own reputation. The second time she draws the heart she paints black corners as if to say that she do have a bad feeling about doing these things, but she does not want to disappoint Bethan with her being a coward. b. When she tells Mr. Paterson to throw the heart out after her detention it is a small symbol of her throwing away her bad conscious and just do what Bethan says. 3. Comment on the kind of bullying seen in the text. There is two different kind of bullying in the text. 1. Peer pressure 2. Physical bullying I think the physical bullying is the worst kind of bullying because I’ve been raised with the......

Words: 386 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

The Veil

...Professor Reader Response 9/12/13 The Veil Satrapi wrote The Veil to describe her childhood growing up during the Islamic revolution, the sudden changes she went through, and the feelings she and others her age had during this time period. It is important to know that as children they didn’t understand what was going on and why this was occurring. Satrapi conveys the emotions felt as these children dealt with changes and who the woman behind the veil is. Satrapi begins by describing her childhood from the age of 10. This was shortly after the revolution took place. She does a great job showing the innocence and vulnerability of these children as they face these changes. When it became mandatory to wear veils to school she depicted the teacher just handing them the veils and saying “wear this’. There was no explanation for the girls being forced to wear these veils in school. They were just handed the veils one day and told to wear them to school all of a sudden. In a way this is the perfect representation of childhood Islamic life during the revolution. A series of changes with no real explanation or purpose. After the girls went from not wearing veils to school to being told they must wear it they had to cope with this change. It was clear that the girls didn’t like nor did they understand why they had to wear these veils to school. They didn’t want to have to wear it especially when it was hot out. They didn’t take the veil serious. As a matter of......

Words: 569 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Deadly Sins

...very good actor. They are absolute opposites, young and older, black and white, spontaneous and thoughtful. Kevin Spacey – John Doe: I’ve read that Kevin Spacey was cast two days before filming began, but if I haven’t read it, I wouldn’t believe it. He plays the role fantastic. He’s so suspicious and convincing in his acting. I was so caught off his appearance at the end of the movie, that I actually thought, he was a murder in real. He managed to live into the psychological drama, without it seems abnormally. The doe, Mills and Somerset will be responsible to investigate a murder, which turns out to be a serial killers cruel life’s work, which is about to be executed. As they face the first murder, they think it’s just another big city murder was committed for no reason. The next day is the murder of a wealthy defense lawyer found dead in his office. The word greed is written in blood beside his body. Mills and Somerset finds out, that this serial killer finds his inspiration in religion. The murder has certainly no connection to the victims. There are no questions of revenge. Somerset and Mills begins to investigate deadly sins in historical writings as an example – Dante, The Divine Comedy. They indentify the seven deadly sins, pride, envy, wrath, sloth, greed, gluttony and lust. The killer, John Doe will commit a murder for every mortal sin and back are basically only waiting for him the strike. The seven deadly sins included in the movie in the way that six out of seven......

Words: 1153 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Veil of Ignorance

...The Veil of Ignorance The concept of justice is one that most people understand, but it is difficult to define. John Rawls give his take on its true meaning in his work, “A Theory of Justice”. In an attempt to explain what justice really is, Rawls uses what he calls a ‘veil of ignorance’. The function of the veil is to make it so that all members of a just society have no knowledge of their own identity, allowing true fairness and equality. Although the veil of ignorance is central to Rawls theory of justice, I believe that it is unrealistic and cannot be applied to real life. Under the veil of ignorance, Rawls thinks that all members of a society would agree to laws that are completely fair. If no one knows their wealth, class, or abilities, then each member would agree to the same rules. He states, “They do not know how the various alternatives will affect their particular case and they are obliged to evaluate principles solely on the basis of general consideration.”(Rawls 118) The veil is a completely hypothetical concept that Rawls uses to explain what justice means. I do agree that under this veil, the laws agreed upon would allow each person the same advantages or disadvantages. However, this veil of ignorance cannot be applied to reality because no such situation has ever existed. Each person has characteristics that cannot be taken away, so each person has a unique identity. No matter how fair a group of individuals tries to be, they will each work to benefit......

Words: 486 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Veil

...A veil is an article of clothing or cloth hanging that is intended to cover some part of the head or face, or an object of some significance. It is especially associated with women and sacred objects. One view is that as a religious item, it is intended to show honor to an object or space. The actual sociocultural, psychological, and sociosexual functions of veils have not been studied extensively but most likely include the maintenance of social distance and the communication of social status and cultural identity.[1][2] In Islamic society, various forms of the veil have been adopted from the Arab culture in which Islam arose The first recorded instance of veiling for women is recorded in an Assyrian legal text from the 13th century BC, which restricted its use to noble women and forbade prostitutes and common women from adopting it.[citation needed] The Mycenaean Greek term a-pu-ko-wo-ko meaning "craftsman of horse veil" written in Linear B syllabic script is also attested since ca. 1300 BC.[3][4] In ancient Greek the word for veil was "καλύπτρα" (kaluptra, Ionic Greek "καλύπτρη" - kaluptrē, from the verb "καλύπτω" - kaluptō, "I cover"[5]) and is first attested in the works of Homer.[6][7] Classical Greek and Hellenistic statues sometimes depict Greek women with both their head and face covered by a veil. Caroline Galt and Lloyd Llewellyn-Jones have both argued from such representations and literary references that it was commonplace for women (at least those of......

Words: 3504 - Pages: 15

Premium Essay

Veil of Perception

...Of all the philosophical discussions and all the topics covered, none I think is more fundamentally important to understanding of the universe than Locke’s idea of the ‘veil of perception’. The idea that what we take in with our senses is not necessarily correspondent with reality shows us, more than anything, that critical thought is as or more important to understanding than observation alone. I think that this lesson is of paramount importance because it runs contrary to our intuition and general ideas about the nature of reality yet must be respected despite the limits it places on what we can objectively ‘know’. Descartes uses the idea when breaking down what he can know exists. He uses the argument that we could be dreaming, our sensory experience coming from a source other than reality, and have no idea that we are viewing an illusory world. From this he states that the only thing we know for sure is that we are beings that have thoughts. Understanding that we are inextricably linked to our bodies’ perception yet cannot trust it is a difficult concept to accept, and one that we try to ignore, however it reminds us that things are not always how they appear. Plato references the perception problem in his theory of forms. The allegory of the cave illustrates that our perceptions of the world are inherently unreliable, and that what we sense is ‘shadows’ of the true forms of objects. While Plato was making an entirely different point about the nature of reality,......

Words: 501 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Veil of Taboo

...Veil of Taboo The daily stresses of life are known to take a toll on both, our mind and body. It’s quite a challenge in this modern world of ours, to maintain our physical and mental well-being! I often ponder, that while we do not hesitate to go to a doctor when we are physically ill, we sure are reluctant to reach out to a professional counsellor or therapist to resolve our emotional problems. Why do we suffer in silence, when we are having trouble coping? Why are we reluctant to admit we are sad, lonely, hurt and need someone to help us regain control of our lives? The history of human evolution shows a definitive co-relation between our physical health and psychological well-being. As our mental health deteriorates, our physical health can worsen. And if our physical health deteriorates, one can feel "depressed". When will there be awareness that a sound mind and a sound body go hand in hand? Getting help in dealing with anguish, heartbreaks, grief, dilemmas, emotions and stressful situations is as imperative, as crucial as getting help with a medical problem like diabetes, asthma, high blood pressure, cholesterol problems etc. There is so much good that can come out of therapy, it can bring about an amazing difference in your life. Through therapy one can discover ways to overcome problems big and small, learn about ourselves, acknowledge shortcomings, develop inner strengths, make positive changes in ourselves and our lives. Perhaps it just......

Words: 358 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

The Color of Sin: White and Black and Perceptual Symbols of Moral Purity and Pollution.

...The Color of Sin: White and Black And Perceptual Symbols of Moral Purity and Pollution. Sherman and Clore (2009) aimed to look at aimed to look at three different conditions involving moral and immoral words appearing in either black or white. They also wanted to see if the time taken to name a colour differs when it black which connects to immorality or in white which relates to morality. In addition to this they added in 2 conditions which took place before naming the colours. They used a series of metaphors in order to explain many of their concepts. Their first study was based on an experiment done by Meier et al (2004) using the Stroop colour- word task (1935). They used the same words and found that immorality-blackness associations operate quickly and automatically. These associations influenced performance on the Stroop task, so a task that requires identifying colours does not require any moral evaluation and can be performed quickly. The second study was the same as the first but used a new set of words, in order to test whether the moral Stroop effect is susceptible to conditions that make immorality more prominent, this was similar to a study by Zhong and Liljenquist (2006). Alongside this task another small task was introduced where they had to read a story which either had a morally wrong or right answer. After analysis of the results they found that people, who showed no Stroop effect initially, were affected by simply being exposed to unethical......

Words: 1291 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Coporate Veil

...THEORY OF PIERCING THE CORPORATE VEIL Most people form corporations to insulate themselves from liability.  The insulation exists because corporations are generally considered by law to be separate and distinct from their shareholders.  This protection is often referred to as the corporate veil.  While most people who incorporate believe they have no personal liability for the debts of the corporation, this is not always true. For example, if a corporation or LLC is used to commit a fraud, injustice, or wrong, it shouldn’t protect its owners from liability. Courts may also pierce the corporate veil in taxation or bankruptcy cases. For example, if a corporation that faces obligations to creditors and potential lawsuits has siphoned off its assets through dividends or salaries, courts may find undercapitalization. Such corporations are called shells or shams designed to take advantage of limited liability. Courts can disregard or pierce the corporate veil in some of these situations where the corporation acts as the alter ego of the shareholders in their dealings with third parties. Alter-ego is the argument that if the limited liability entity is merely treated as an extension of a single person then the entity and individual should be treated as a single individual with no limited liability. In other words, the entity is “dominated” or used as an instrument for a sole individual’s purposes. This is because by law they can be owned and/or managed ie. Dominated by a single......

Words: 552 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

The Minister's Black Veil

...Mary Elrod Rockett English 101- Tuesday/ Thursday 26 July 2015 Behind The Black Veil According to Merriam Webster Dictionary, a veil is worn to cover or hide something else. In this case, Parson Hooper wears a veil to cover his “secret sin.” Being a minister, he is exposed to many sinful situations that are difficult to avoid and he covers his self- conflict with a black veil. Throughout this eye- opening parable, “The Minister’s Black Veil,” by Nathaniel Hawthorne, there are both, positive and negative effects of Mr. Hooper’s black veil. Hawthorn reveals whether or not Mr. Hooper’s black veil is worth wearing by the time he dies at the end of the story. The first time Mr. Hooper wears his black veil, people immediately feel frightened and wonder why their minister “has gone mad” (Hawthorne 9). Mr. Hooper does not mean to scare everyone, he is simply covering his face from the world, in which he says, “If I hide my face for sorrow, there is cause enough and if I cover it for secret sin, what mortal might not do the same?” (Hawthorne 35). Everyone speaks only of bad things about him, “I would not be alone with him for the world. I wonder he is not afraid to alone with himself” (Hawthorne 16). Even his fiancé questions their relationship. No one wants a husband whose face is always covered by a depressing veil. He refuses to remove it and explain to her why he is wearing this veil. Mr. Hooper loves Elizabeth dearly and does not want her to leave him, “Have......

Words: 1108 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Lifting the Veil

...it is trite to say that the Salomon principle could be regarded as a double-edged sword. The Concept of Lifting the Corporate Veil Undoubtedly, the doctrine of distinct legal personality is one of the most underlying principles of company law in the UK. As aforesaid, as the general principle, corporations are regarded as legal entities with rights and obligations independent of those acquired by the members. This principle is so strong that there is nearly no exception to it. “Lifting the veil of incorporation” refers to the judicially imposed exception to the Salomon principle where the courts ignored the separation of the personality of the company and the members, thus the veil of incorporation is said to be pierced. Most significantly, this holds the members of the company responsible for the corporation’s action and debts. In 1926, Benjamin Cardozo described this corner of law as “enveloped in the mists of metaphor,” and the courts have been even stricter in the following years. Most of the cases where the courts are willing to pierce the veil concern circumstances where a company is created with the intention of using it as a vehicle to gain benefits or to evade obligations. If there is a potential for misuse of corporation to defraud creditors, the courts determined the company for this purpose purely as a mere facade and thus the veil of incorporation would be upheld. This exception to the fundamental principle of corporate personality could be found in both......

Words: 3282 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay

Corporate Veil

...Piercing the Corporate Veil The whole objective of piercing the corporate veil is to prevent companies from using the guise of corporate personality to commit illegal and fraudulent and illegal acts. It can perhaps be said that the catalyst of the birth of this concept came about in Solomon v Solomon & Co. Ltd, wherein the concept of the company’s separate legal personality was upheld. The decision came in for severe criticism from some quarters. Otto Kahn Freund called the decision ‘calamitous’ and also proposed the abolition of private companies. There have been times when Indian courts have been slightly conservative in applying the doctrine, calling for its implementation only when it is explicitly provided for in the statute. Nevertheless, this doctrine has found acceptance in a majority of Indian courts, with the Supreme Court noting that lifting the corporate veil is becoming more translucent in modern jurisprudence and that’s its frontiers are unlimited. There are various circumstances under which courts have gone on to lift the corporate veil, such as making the holding company liable for failure to disclose the accounts of its subsidiary company, especially when it appears that the holding and subsidiary are parts of the same concern. Other instances where courts have gone on to lift the corporate veil are where the medium of the company has been used in committing fraud and illegal conduct, determination of enemy character of the company, liability for ultra......

Words: 444 - Pages: 2