Premium Essay

Should Audit Committee Be Established in a Private Company?

In: Business and Management

Submitted By ieziey
Words 2737
Pages 11
As we enter new millennium, it is a fact that the user of financial statement demanded more on audit function to implement audit attestation towards company’s financial statement whether for public listed or private company. It is due to their awareness of having a true and fair presentation of financial statement since they evaluate the company’s performance based on the company’s earnings which used to be the point at which the investors can make decision whether to invest or not.
However, the case of fraud and manipulation in a company are still critical and need to be monitored by certain functional department as such to be the whistle blower for any irregularities that may arise in the company. In fact, over the last decade, there were various regulatory agencies and interest groups in existence which had been aggressively promoting the idea of an effective audit committee in all public listed companies. Yet, the absence of audit committee in a private company might be the cause for unstoppable practices of fraud.
Therefore, the objective of this study is to determine whether the new theory of this formation of audit committee in a private company, can really help to eliminate or at least minimize the fraud. To achieve this goal, the study will conduct a survey based on questionnaires that will be distributed to the top management of a private companies, charted accountant i.e auditors and lecturers of audit course. The findings will be used to support the theory of this research. In the article, Albrecht (2008) declared, “the pressure may be the need to make earnings look better to meet debt covenants” (p. 22). It was true because the profit indicates the performance of a company and so creative accounting might be used to engineer the financial statement to have the so called profitable company.
Basically, there are two types of fraud which…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Masafi Company Marketing Audit

...PETrecycling gives short information about Masafi Company. The company was found in 1976 and now it is a unique brand that has become a generic name for bottled and mineral water in the entire Gulf region. Such a status was acquired because of their high quality products known all over the world for their pure natural freshness. Today Masafi Company can offer a great number of products, ranging from bottled mineral water to soft facial tissues, cups, juices and chips. Gulfbusiness website writes that the main aim of Masafi Company is to strengthen the market leadership. It is distinguished by constant improvement the quality and number of their products and also through the processes of innovative manufacturing, continuous reinvestment and marketing and audit strategies. The target market for Masafi products, as well as any others ones, is distinguished according the following customer characteristics: geographic, demographic, psychographic and behavioralistic. Urban areas of the Middle East region is the main target market for Masafi products. People use water in summer more than in winter. In summer one person uses ten or more glasses of water per day, and can use a couple of glasses of juice. In the Middle East region the temperature is one of the highest on Earth. In most countries of the region the summer is all the year round. It was conducted a survey and analyzed that 40% of individuals are ready to use Masafi products as a regular drink. ...

Words: 1174 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Should Audits for Pay Gender Be Required of Eeoc

...Should EEOC Audits be required for Gender Pay Equality for Employers with more than 100 Employees? The year 2012 statistics show that full-time employed women earned just 80.9% of the salaries of their male counterparts in the United States. The number for 2011 was 82%. The pay gap is now as wide as it has been since 2005, following on the heels of six years of progress. The figures look even worse for some workers. In management professions, men earn $1,328.00 each week while women earn $951.00– A 71.6% gap, for financial professions, it’s 74% and in legal occupations it is 53.7%, (Bureau of Labor Statistics. 2012). Based on this information, a man would make $100.00 compared with a woman making just $80.90... The financial services employed male would make $100.00 compared to only $74.00 for the female (based on Bureau of Labor Statistics)... Employers are not complying with the current EEOC laws as the pay gap is becoming wider, especially in some professions. The EEOC law should be changed to require them to conduct audits of employers with more than 100 employees, to assure compliance with the law. The Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938 was updated in 1963 when congress passed the Equal Pay Act, clearly stating that employers cannot discriminate on the basis of sex by paying wages for equal work less than wages paid to the opposite sex. The problem is that the EEOC who administers the law is a reactive rather than proactive body. They...

Words: 1857 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Audit Summary for 3 Companies in Malaysia

...s in Ma AUDIT SUMMARY LETCURER SIR AMIRUL HAFIZ MOHD NASIR GROUP MEMBERS MUHAMMAD IQMAL HISHAM BIN KAMARUDDIN (1100141) NUR ADILA AYUB (1100720) HALIMAHTUN SAADIAH BINTI ZAKARIA (1100138) NUR FAHANA ZAHARI (1100730) MOHD ZULKEFLI BIN HASAN (1100731) AUDIT ASSURANCE AND SERVICES MAD 3013 COMPANIES BACKGROUND NAME OF COMPANY | FAST TRACK SOLUTION HOLDINGS BERHAD | FLONIC HI-TECH BERHAD | FOKUS DYNAMICS TECHNOLOGIES | BACKGROUND | Fast Track Solution Holdings Berhad, was incorporated in 2003, which is an investment holding of multiple subsidiaries in Malaysia. Throughout our various subsidiaries we are involved and provide activities like R&D, Marketing & Distribution in enterprise hardware and software solutions. In addition, we also provide online games development, publishing, marketing and distribution. | Flonic is a global leading manufacturer of critical & precision cleaning system for all kinds of industries. For more than 20 years, they have been supporting companies ranging from Fortune 500 to small-medium sized enterprises across the globe. With their highly advanced technology available on hand, we are able to cater to virtually any types of cleaning requirements for any industry. | Focus Dynamics Group is a fast developing international business specializing in Energy Efficiency Solutions, LED Lighting, Industrial Control Systems and Products. | YEAR | 2009 | 2010 | 2011 | 2009 | 2010 | 2011 | 2009 | 2010 |...

Words: 1100 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Valuation of Private Companies

...Valuation of Private Companies 1) 2) 3) 4) 5) Comparables Net Present Value Approach Adjusted Presented Value Approach The ‘Venture Capital’ Method Options Analysis Each approach has advantages and disadvantages. Generally there is no “right” answer to a valuation problem. Valuation is very much an art as much as a science! 1 Evaluation of Comparables How to compute comparables: Start with a sample of securities whose business characteristics are similar to the company being valued. Assume that the company has similar financial ratios to the “comparable” companies. A number of different ratios are typically used: Price/Earnings, Market/Book, Market Value/Sales, EBIT. Then back out the implied value of the company being studied. Comparables Approach relies on two assumptions: Comparable companies have future cash flow expectations and risks similar to the firm being valued Performance measure is actually proportional to value 2 Different ways of Doing Comparables “Comparable Company” – Uses a multiple calculated from the trading values of firms in the same industry as the firm being valued. “Comparable Transaction” – Uses a multiple from companies that were involved in a similar transaction as the firm being valued. “Comparable Industry Transaction” – Uses a multiple from companies from the same industry that were involved in a similar transaction as the firm being valued. 3 Problems with Comparables Approach Generally tough to find appropriate......

Words: 1614 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

What Should Auditor Audit

...What Should the Auditor Audit? Successful operational auditing begins with the auditor understanding the business: What are the core products, business units, and employee and customer bases? How can the auditor begin to survey the business to begin to put an audit plan together? What resources are available or should be accessed by the auditor? There are various types of audits depending on the specific type of audit being performed. However, even though there are different types of audits, the audit procedure should remain the same. The audit should look for compliance with the policies and procedures. The Auditor should investigate and evaluate the level of compliance and the effectiveness of the company or organizations. Depending on the type of audit being performed, the audit will evaluate and identify financial issues within the company to determine if it finances are allocated the way they are supposed to be. The auditor also looks at inconsistences to determine if there is a possibility of theft or fraud. There are two different types of auditors, internal and external. Operational auditing is considered to be an internal audit. In today’s society it has become very important to the organization, especially with so much diversity in businesses. An operational audit will allow for the diversified product lines while establishing a global presence. The internal auditors will have to have an in-depth knowledge and a higher level of expertise to maintain the......

Words: 587 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Should the Australian Government Privatise Medibank Private?

...Should the Australian Government privatise Medibank Private? Since the 1990s the Commonwealth and State governments of Australia has privatised a sizeable portion of the public sector (Reserve Bank of Australia 1997). The prospect of privatising Medibank has been a controversial matter since its proposal by the Howard government in 2006, although the former government failed to do so, the Abott government announced on March 26th, 2014 that the company will be sold off through an initial public offering (IPO) in the 2014-15 financial year (Mcllroy 2014). This essay will argue that Medibank Private should be privatised and sold publicly through an IPO for short and long term economic and social benefits. In order to determine the validity of this argument this essay will analyse articles and other academic evidences to first look into Australia’s history of privatisation and a brief history of Medibank Private. The essay will then analyse the conflict of interest the current system generates. Further, it will explore the advantage of privatising Medibank Private, including increasing competitiveness in the market and money generated for other social and economic projects. The Reserve Bank of Australia (1997:7) defines privatisation as the full or partial transfer of ownership of public assets to the private sector (Reserve Bank of Australia 1997). Privatisation gradually increased across the world in the 1980’s originating in Chile, the UK and New Zealand which was...

Words: 1872 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Private Sector Companies

...mydin MOHAMED HOLDINGS BERHAD COMPANY MISSION We aims to be the leading wholesale and retail company by providing the best value, wide assortment of goods and continuous excellence based on our business formula Customers * MYDIN business activity is in retailing and wholesaling directly to the customers and sellers to cater their everyday needs. Suppliers * MYDIN deals with suppliers in providing products range from food line, household, soft-lines and hard-lines items. Managers/employees * MYDIN has more than 90 outlets that invite dedicated and dynamic individuals to be part of the company in order to achieve their mission. Owner * MYDIN has their own business formula in achieving their expected goals to be the leading wholesale and retail company. Community at large * MYDIN serves their products and services to the whole community in range of new born until senior citizen. AIRASIA HOLDINGS BERHAD COMPANY MISSION To attain the lowest cost so that everyone can fly with AirAsia by maintaining the highest quality product, embracing technology to reduce cost and enhance service level. Customer * Airasia focus on their customer’s needs and preferences by providing low cost airline. Supplier * Airasia deals with local supplier in terms of providing foods and beverages as well as Airasia merchandise in enhancing their services. Managers/employees * Airasia needs to maintain the quality of the employees as they provide services......

Words: 270 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Should Audit Firms Be Required to Rotate on Public Companies

...Moffit From: Lloyd Johnson Date: February 26, 2015 Re: Should Companies be required to rotate their auditing firms on a regular basis? As an accountant entering the modern business world, a case instilled in our minds is the Enron Scandal. For accountants, this was an embarrassing scenario and by effect brought numerous reforms, laws, and regulations. Many of these rulings are apparent in the present corporate setting. The division of accounting most affected by this scandal was the role and function of the external auditors. Auditors by trade serve in the public and stockholders interest. Furthermore, the independence of auditors is essential in performing their duties properly. As a result, which practices are needed to achieve total independence? Moreover, how do we weigh the cost of financial misstatements with the cost of redundancy due to rotation of audit firms? Demanding public companies to rotate their audit firms may appear reasonable on paper, however, this rotation brings more concerns than answers. Currently in the auditing of publicly held companies, lead audit partners are required to rotate of audits every five years. This ruling was enacted from the Sarbanes- Oxley Act of 2002 (SOX). Also, SOX requires a 1-year cooling off period if the Chief Executive Officer (CEO), Chief Financial Officer (CFO), controller, etc. was previously employed by and participated in the audit one year prior to the start of the audit. These laws were passed to promote auditor......

Words: 1560 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Discuss the Need for Outsourcing the Internal Audit Function in a Company

...the Need for Outsourcing the Internal Audit Function in A Company Traditional internal audit function is defined as an independent appraisal activity to review internal control activities in companies. Dezoort (2001) implies that with the extension of business activities, the internal audit function has evolved from the traditional supervision to value adding which includes a wider scale of audit-related work so as to maximize the value of a business company. This focus on adding value to the corporation through a variety of internal audit services has raised concerns about the ability of in-house auditors to perform the wider-scale audit function in a more professional and cost-saving manner (Chapman and Anderson, 2002). Due to fierce market competitions and overcapacities, company managements set out to downsize company staff and put the focus on its profit-producing business, tending to outsource (referred to the practice that one accounting firm provides audit-related services for a business organization) internal audit function to engage external specialists to present a highly cost-saving and professional performance. Although some evidence suggests that there are many limitations of outsourced activities, this essay asserts that outsourced internal audit function plays an essential role in the development process of a corporation and there is a need to outsource that function. In consequence, these positive effects on companies will be described principally in......

Words: 2899 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Distinction Between a Public Company and a Private Company

...Legal FAQs -Distinction Between A Public Company And a Private Company Distinction Between A Public Company And a Private Company – Following are the main points of difference between a Public Company and a Private Company :- 1. Minimum Paid-up Capital : A company to be Incorporated as a Private Company must have a minimum paid-up capital of Rs. 1,00,000, whereas a Public Company must have a minimum paid-up capital of Rs. 5,00,000. 2. Minimum number of members : Minimum number of members required to form a private company is 2, whereas a Public Company requires at least 7 members. 3. Maximum number of members : Maximum number of members in a Private Company is restricted to 50, there is no restriction of maximum number of members in a Public Company. 4. Transerferability of shares : There is complete restriction on the transferability of the shares of a Private Company through its Articles of Association , whereas there is no restriction on the transferability of the shares of a Public company 5 .Issue of Prospectus : A Private Company is prohibited from inviting the public for subscription of its shares, i.e. a Private Company cannot issue Prospectus, whereas a Public Company is free to invite public for subscription i.e., a Public Company can issue a Prospectus. 6. Number of Directors : A Private Company may have 2 directors to manage the affairs of the company, whereas a Public Company must have at least 3 directors. 7. Consent of the directors : There is no need......

Words: 611 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Charter of the Finance and Audit Committee of the Oracle Corporation Board of Directors

...CHARTER OF THE FINANCE AND AUDIT COMMITTEE OF THE ORACLE CORPORATION BOARD OF DIRECTORS (As last amended by the Board of Directors on July 13, 2008) I. PURPOSE The primary function of the Finance and Audit Committee (the “Committee”) is to provide advice with respect to the Corporation’s financial matters, to oversee the accounting and financial reporting processes of the Corporation and the audits of the financial statements of the Corporation, to assist the Board of Directors in fulfilling its oversight responsibilities regarding finance, accounting, tax and legal compliance, and to evaluate merger and acquisition transactions and investment transactions proposed by the Corporation’s management. Consistent with this function, the Committee endeavors to encourage continuous improvement of, and foster adherence to, the Corporation’s policies, procedures and practices at all levels. The Committee’s primary duties and responsibilities are to: • • • • • • Serve as an independent and objective party to monitor the Corporation’s financial reporting process and internal control system. Review and appraise the audit efforts of the Corporation’s independent accountants and internal audit department. Evaluate the Corporation's quarterly financial performance as well as its compliance with laws and regulations. Oversee management's establishment and enforcement of financial policies and business practices that are designed to manage business and financial risk and to comply with......

Words: 2675 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Company Law Audit

...The primary purpose of auditor is provided audit service to audit client. Auditor main duty is to offer independence verification of a company's record to make sure that all the information matches up to what was provided. The audit is an important part of the capital market framework as it not only reduces the cost of information exchange between managers and shareholders but also provides a signaling mechanism to the markets that the information which management is providing is reliable. Independence of auditor is important to external auditor’s role. An analysis of various parliamentary reports, statutes such as case law, journals and annual reports will provide a basis for considering the claim that audit independence is a central element to the external auditor's role. It can be seen through APB ethical standards govern issues relating to the integrity, objectivity and independence of auditor. The vital of auditors’ independence can be seen through in the case of Enron. The auditors who were Arthur Andersen received fees for audit and non audit services. Other than that, there were regular exchanges of employees within Enron and Arthur Andersen. Arthur Andersen did not report the fraud to the shareholder although they have made a report on the company’s account. It is because the fraud is committed by management, the auditor need to make sure that they were in management’s good books in order to obtain the contract of non audit service. However, the case of Enron has......

Words: 774 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

The Weaknesses of a Private Company Going Public

...What Are the Weaknesses of a Private Company Going Public? Taking a private company public can be a celebratory time for owners and management. It is the reward for years of successful business practices and positive consumer reception. Taking a company public can also expose significant weaknesses in a company that is unprepared to weather the added financial burdens and loss of control that come with life on the stock market. Distracted Management The process of a taking a private company is a long, complicated affair that can take as long as two years to complete, according to the Reference for Business website. This may open weaknesses in companies that lack good infrastructure directly beneath management. As a result, the daily running of the company and ground-level business decisions could suffer, which could affect the bottom line and consumer confidence when heading into life as a public company. Cost and Exhaustion Taking a company public is expensive -- costing between $50,000 and $250,000 just in fees and publicity costs. This can expose a weakness in funds for some companies that are not prepared to handle the initial financial burden. According to the Reference for Business, a company's initial public offering costs could claim 15 to 20 percent of the stock's total initial value. The process of taking a company public is also exhausting with time taken up meeting with lawyers, accountants and various business model personnel. The process can be so......

Words: 370 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Roles of Audit Committee

...Roles of audit committee An Audit Committee does not focus solely on internal audit activities or on financial issues. Recent trends are for it to take on broader roles and responsibilities. The establishment of an Audit Committee affords the opportunity to set aside time to focus on governance, risk and control issues. The key responsibilities of an Audit Committee include: overseeing the risk management framework and processes; reviewing compliance related matters and internal controls; overseeing the relationship, appointment and work of the external and internal auditors; and reviewing the annual financial statements and recommending them for governing body approval. As it relates to oversight of the internal audit function, the responsibilities of Committee’s include: ensuring that internal audit activity is structured to achieve organisational independence; ensuring the internal audit charter permits full and unrestricted access to top management, the Audit Committee and the governing body; ensuring unrestricted access by internal auditors to records, personnel, and physical properties; ensuring the function is appropriately resourced; and ensuring the function is operating effectively. In relation to its other roles, Audit Committee responsibilities could include: review, with management, the adequacy of policies and practices for risk management and the operation of the internal control system; review, with management, the......

Words: 801 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Audit Committee Report

...Audit Committee Report According to the Malaysian Code on Corporate Governance (MCCG) 2007 (Revised), under the Accountability & Audit, as well as the Bursa Malaysia Listing Requirements, The board should establish an audit committee comprising at least three members, a majority of whom are independent. All members of the audit committee should be non-executive directors. The board should provide the audit committee with written terms of reference which deal clearly with its authority and duties. First off, on the matter of the compliance on the size of the board/committee, all the companies that we reviewed comply with that limit. 2 of the 12 companies were actually surpassed that minimum requirement, where they have 4 members in their Audit Committee. Those companies that we wish to highlight are Kamdar Group Berhad & Key Asic Berhad. This is a good example as the more members there are in an Audit Committee, there more reliable and independent the information involving the financial statements and any other relevant information will be, albeit, the independence of each member would be a factor to consider. Moving on, the question of whether those who are in the Audit Committees are independent or not come in to place. According to the MCCG 2007, the board of Audit Committee must have a majority of who are independent. The point here that we should note is that, all of the members of the Audit Committee should comprise fully of non-executive directors. Going......

Words: 1169 - Pages: 5