Premium Essay

Preferential Hiring

In: Business and Management

Submitted By cyborg13
Words 2014
Pages 9
Ethics and Opinions of Preferential Hiring

Business Ethics
March 24, 2014
2014 Winter Term

Introduction & Definitions

Since the 1960s and 70s, the U.S. (as well as other European countries) have tried to employ policies and programs to increase employment and educational opportunities for minorities and women. The policies differ in approach and opinion.
The lesser of the policies is passive nondiscrimination. It is when a company or educational institution takes into account only the applicant’s ability, and doesn’t take race or sex into consideration. This policy is also called equal opportunity, and is not controversial. It only requires employers to not unjustly discriminate. (Lane, 2010)
Moving past the passive approach is affirmative action. This is defined as an activity that is aimed at securing a more equal workplace. It goes beyond passive nondiscrimination, but doesn’t alter the standards or qualifications for applicants. (Claire Andre, 2005) One way a company can engage in affirmative action is to increase the applicant pool for open positions with the intent to diversify. Though this policy is more active than the passive nondiscrimination, the theory is that the most qualified candidate will get the position, so moral and ethical controversy is limited.
A method beyond affirmative action, and the one I want to discuss in this paper, is preferential treatment, or hiring. This type of policy changes the job standards in an effort to hire more minorities or women. There are two ways this is done: preferential hiring among equally competent applicants; and preferential hiring among applicants who are not equally competent. These policies are called reverse discrimination by critics, and leveling the playing field by supporters. (Lane, 2010)
The most extreme form of policy is the hiring quota. This is a number, a standard,…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay


...Hiring internally is beneficial for both the company and employee. When companys recruit from within, they offer opportunity for advancement and promotion. This technique keeps employees motivated to work hard and as a result, One decreases. Due process policies sense that job security is high, which keeps employees to stay with an organization long-term. Also, companies benefit from internal recruitment by saving money. Recruiting externally costs the company money to train someone new, while the organization can reduce the cost by training someone internally slowly. There are certain business strategies that are best supported by recruiting externally. Firstly, certain entry-level or even upper-level positions may not be filled internally since there is no one available to fill those positions. Furthermore, outsiders can bring new ideas or new ways of doing business that can help the organization. Lastly, bringing in new talent from outside sources can help strenghten an organization and weaken the competitors. On the other hand, there are several strategies that might call for internal recruitment. It is to a companys advantage to hire someone withing who is already well known. The company knows how they work, what they are able to produce, and what they can expect from them. Second, internal employees are well aware of open vacancies withing the company, which minimizes the expectations of the job. Finally, it is faster and cheaper to recruit someome internally. One......

Words: 317 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Hiring the Educated

...USEK | Case: Hiring the educated – A new approach to staffing the automobile factory | Human Resource Management – A strategic Approach | Assaf Ramy – Saad Elissar 11/28/2012 | Introduction This article explains how the automobile industry changed from being dominated by less educated workers to the highly educated workers over the years; it also explains the reasons that made this change occur through studying the staffing process of Ford and Chrysler. The main reasons for this change are four: * Skilled craftsmen are replaced by high-tech machines which needed educated employees to run them instead of increasing the training costs by keeping the uneducated and training them. * Team-based management became a necessity in these factories; the factories needed more educated workers because they are more able to supervise themselves * The nature of the work is changing which requires more educated workers especially in to help with fixing any arising production problem. * Competition is changing since all the automobile factories are on the worldwide market and they needed qualified workers in order to compete with each other. In this case, we also see how Chrysler started its process from high schools and how Ford created a new selection system. Question 1: What do you think Ford’s overall strategic perspective is? How well does its new selection system support this strategy? Ford is looking for better educated employees to staff their...

Words: 1122 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay


...Case: 6:01-cv-00339-KKC-REW Doc #: 669 Filed: 03/01/10 Page: 1 of 17 - Page ID#: .,13376 ,,,:~™~ "' ^tt*** £0 m THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF KENTUCKY EQUAL EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITY COMMISSION. Plaintiff, v. WAL-MART STORES, INC. ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) MAR - | 20tt) ATtnnw ^"^ CIVIL ACTION NO01-339-RICC Defendant CONSENT DECREE The United States Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (the XommissioiT or the "EEOC") commenced this action against Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. ("Wal-Mart") pursuant to Title VII of the Civil. Rights Act of 1964 and Title I of the Civil Rights Act of 1991 ("Title VII") to address allegations that Wal-Mart subjected a class of females to gender discrimination in hiring whenfillingopen orderfiller positions to Wal-Mart's Distribution Center No. 6097 ("DC 6097"), located in London, Kentucky. The Commission and Wal-Mart stipulate to the Court's jurisdiction over the parties. Further, the Commission and Wal-Mart desire to resolve Civil Action No. 01-339-KKC without the burden and expense of further litigation. As a result, and based on the pleadings and the record as a whole, the Court finds that: [i] the Court has jurisdiction over the parties and the subject matter of this action; [ii] the terms of this Decree are adequate, fair, reasonable, equitable and just; [hi] this Decree conforms with the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure and is not in derogation of the rights or privileges of any person; [iv]......

Words: 877 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Hiring Legal

...Abstract This paper will discuss the legality requirement when hiring. The U.S. Department of Labor provides several laws and acts that protect potential new hires from unethical hiring practices. The interpretation of the laws provides their own advantages and disadvantages. Hiring Legalities Introduction When looking to fill positions, whether a promotion or a new hire, employers must list the qualifications and the job requirements. This saves the employer and the prospective employee time. Another factor in hiring that must be considered are the legislative laws that are currently in place. Developing an Effective Job Requisition. Developing effective job descriptions helps employers to articulate the responsibilities and requirement of the job/s that they are trying to fill. An effective job description also serves as the benchmark to tell employees if they are a fit for the job in question. Furthermore, it helps employees to understand the boundaries of the expected performance from the potential employee. Ultimately, the goal of an effective job description is to hire the top candidate based on their skills, education and experience (Heatherfield, 2013). When employers are putting together a job description certain steps must be followed. The first that must be followed is to perform a job analysis. A job analysis will enable hiring managers to collect data that can include, job responsibilities of current employees,......

Words: 764 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Hiring a Hacker

...Hiring a Hacker A hacker, as related to security consulting, is “someone who accesses a computer system by circumventing its security system”. (Wikipedia) This report will take a look at both the pro’s and con’s of hiring such a person as a security consultant for a business. Over the years there have been countless heated debates as to whether or not doing such would be considered ethical. One of the pro’s of hiring a former hacker to work as a security consultant is that they know all of the tricks of the trade. They have studied and paid great attention to many different techniques and how to apply them to reach the goals set forth to get the job done. Because they were at one time in that mindset, they know what other hackers would be doing and thinking in order to try to breech the companies’ security. (Posey, Brien) Another plus of hiring a hacker is that many of them will work for a substantially less salary than will someone who went to college and paid a pretty penny for their education. Hackers seem to truly love what they do; it can sometimes be considered an addiction. Usually money is not the key motivating factor for hardcore hackers. (Shinder, Deb) There are a couple of negatives when hiring a former hacker as a security consultant. The most obvious negative factor of course is the issue of trust. Of course this may be considered an opinion, but it is a major decision to make when owning a successful business. Many things could potentially be......

Words: 491 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Church's Preferential Option for the Poor

...Church’s Preferential Option for the Poor When there is question of defending the rights of individuals, the poor and badly off have a claim to especial consideration. The richer class have many ways of shielding themselves, and stand less in need of help from the State; whereas the mass of the poor have no resources of their own to fall back upon, and must chiefly depend upon the assistance of the State.  The obligation to provide justice for all means that the poor have the single most urgent economic claim on the conscience of the nation.  In teaching us charity, the Gospel instructs us in the preferential respect due to the poor and the special situation they have in society: the more fortunate should renounce some of their rights so as to place their goods more generously at the service of others.  He who has the goods of this world and sees his brother in need and closes his heart to him, how does the love of God abide in him?  Everyone knows that the Fathers of the Church laid down the duty of the rich toward the poor in no uncertain terms. As St. Ambrose put it: “You are not making a gift of what is yours to the poor man, but you are giving him back what is his. You have been appropriating things that are meant to be for the common use of  everyone. The earth belongs to everyone, not to the rich.”  Therefore everyone has the right to possess a sufficient amount of the earth's goods for themselves and their family. This has been the opinion of the Fathers and......

Words: 574 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Hiring and Discrimination

...1. Introduction Philadelphia—the first Hollywood film to acknowledge HIV and homosexuality stars Tome Hanks in 1993. This film shows discrimination in hiring and firing, which are disability and sexual orientation. Discrimination exists in all places, at all times, not just in Canada. Even so, people still feel confused about the bounds of hiring and firing. The definition of this phenomenon is the different treatment of two equally qualified individuals on account of their age, gender and so on. In order to protect the rights of employees, governments establish laws and regulations to restrain employers’ behaviors. At the same time, moral standards can be a looser and more elastic limitation and judgments on people’s actions. To simplify, laws are clear rules written on paper, but moral standards are not clear and depend on different people. So, what is the boundary of employment? My answer is that law is the basic standard, and moral is the justice, and whether there are discriminations or not should be measured both sides—the employees’ and employers’. 2. Kinds of Discriminations Age discrimination One of the global issues is the rapidly aging population. There will be 77.3 million people with a life expectancy of 83 years, which is an estimate by the U.S. Disease Control Center 2010, for the first wave of baby-boomer generation from 1946 to 1964. At the same time, people are working longer than before, because people are living a healthier and better...

Words: 1267 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Leadership and Hiring

...Literature Review #2: Hiring/Firing decisions Genser, E. (2013). Hiring leaders. Leadership Excellence, 30(1), 19. Retrieved from: ABI/INFORM Complete. doi: 1270910265 Annotation Elaina Genser describes the precise method in which to accurately hire a good leader. While conducting a search employers must meet with the internal recruiter and construct a thorough job description. A simple application method is essential in order to receive maximum applications. The employer should acquire as many applicants and then narrow the candidates through the screening of resumes and references. Employers should not only interview external candidates, but should also approach qualified internal candidates. Promotion within the company saves money on the interview and training process that comes with new hires. When making a final decision for recruitment a successful evaluation is made by reaching a consensus and following protocol. Personal Reflection The first step the author advises is to meet with the company’s internal recruiter and discuss the position. Once a consensus is reached on the hiring requirements, a thorough job description should be introduced allowing suitable candidates to apply. I agree with this technique because it allows the applicant to decide whether they can fulfill the needs of the position. The executive must distinguish the leadership competencies that the company needs; and a candidate should be anticipated to follow the company’s......

Words: 451 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Religious Discrimination in Hiring

...Running Head: RELIGIOUS DISCRIMINATION IN HIRING Religious Discrimination in Hiring Religious Discrimination in Hiring The initial concept for this paper was to research and examine reverse discrimination in hiring practices by businesses owned by members of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (LDS) in Utah County. I was trying to find research regarding LDS member owned businesses and preferential treatment to other LDS members when hiring. Through the process of this research I realized that my question was skewed, it wasn’t reverse discrimination at all. The population of Utah County consists of 97.5% members of the LDS church, and 88.7% of the population adheres to the LDS church (The Association of Religion Data Archives, 2010). In this context I will examine the preferential hiring practices of adherent religious member owned businesses when recruiting potential employees. Religion is a protected class, and discrimination of a protected class is a primary concern for the human resource industry. The importance of discrimination laws to human resources comes from a number of reasons: Out of motives ranging from concern for fairness to the desire to avoid costly lawsuits and settlements, most companies recognize the importance of complying with these laws. Often, management depends on the expertise of human resource professionals to help in identifying how to comply. (Noe, Hollenbeck, Gerhart, & Wright, 2011, pp. 72-73) A company found in......

Words: 3710 - Pages: 15

Free Essay

Hiring Dilemma

...Hiring Dilemma By Vivian Jackson A company trying to get started in the evolving business industry, can easily lose sight of the goal by employing personnel that do not meet the qualifications and standards needed to make a bold move to the future. There are many exciting aspects to job hunting and there is an even bigger decision when hiring the right candidate for the position. The position requires substantial knowledge of the duties to be performed, a set of moral standards and definite fairness across the board. When hiring, nepotism should be eliminated and preferential treatment. All positions should be based on merit and honest qualifications. If the hiring process were to cater to the needs of those in desperate need, there will be many shortcomings that the organization would not be able to overcome. I have weighed the thought process of hiring because of a favor and would it be possible to truly appreciate the work ethics of someone you hired unethically. The entry-level position at VJ Productions entails significant dedication and attention to detail. The position will require the applicant fulfill all job descriptions and duties. There will be no additional training, the job will be fast paced and the necessity to implement task immediately. In all fairness to the position, there can be no favoritism or special preferential treatment. The moral high ground is the best choice for the job, the company and the fellow employee’s involved. ......

Words: 664 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Hiring Process

...Human Resource Management Assignment 2.2 Research paper topic Job hiring process When looking for a job it can be confusing and even downright puzzling at times. It is hard trying to apply for a job that you don’t know what the title means or even if you’re qualified for, thus bringing a mountain of frustration and even a sense of anger. Sometimes the hardest part of the whole job searching process is when you have to answer specific questions about yourself to a total stranger who is essentially judging you for the job opening. Lastly, waiting for the results of your interview with either a job offer or not can be nerve racking. This can be an agonizing experience for the applicant, but also a more stressful one for the company and person conducting the pre application phase, the advertising phase, the application phase, the preparing of interview and qualification phase, the interview phase, the verification phase, and extending offer phase. This is all part of the application process for most companies and jobs of most Human Resource departments when trying to fill a job void. For many different reasons, a company could need to fill vacancies and the best way to do that is through the application process. When a company needs to fill an employment void, the company must first engage in a pre application phase. Normally companies have a human resource (HR) department that handles this whole process in the direction of senior leadership throughout the company. The......

Words: 2040 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Hiring Practices

...The Best Way to Hire The best way to approach hiring new employees is to first have a thorough understanding of the position you need to fill. Often times an organization hires an individual based simply on the technical requirements of a position. While on the surface this may seem to have been the best approach, organizations find that the new employee is unable to settle into the position because of personality conflicts and they eventually terminate the employee or find that the employee voluntarily leaves. Technical requirements should not be the only consideration when hiring a new employee. The hiring leader needs to also consider the work environment and the personalities and working relationships of the existing employees. The hiring leader needs to ensure the person they are considering not only possess the technical skills required to do the job but also that the person has the personality or leadership skills required to quickly assimilate into the department and become a contributing team member. Hiring a new employee can be a very simple process depending on an organization’s needs. If you are hiring to fill a high turnover type of position, then ensuring the person is technically qualified may be enough. However if you are looking to hire a quality long term employee, more consideration must be given to how well the potential candidate will fit in with the organizations other employees. There is no magic trick to assessing an individual’s......

Words: 432 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Social Media in the Hiring Process

...SOCIAL MEDIA IN THE HIRING PROCESS Preeti Khare Central Michigan University Human Resource Management MGT-643 Dr. Edward Ward 3/29/2015 Introduction Employers can use Social Networking Websites (SNWs) in two ways when hiring: to recruit candidates by publicizing job openings, and to assess potential candidate’s profile including attitude, behavior, personality and qualifications. Kluemper and Rosen (2009) examined the feasibility of whether the information available on these SNWs really helps to improve the employment selection decisions. They asked 63 raters to rate candidates on intelligence, performance and the Big Five personality traits. They found that based solely on viewing social networking profiles, judges were consistent in their ratings across subjects and were typically able to accurately distinguish high from low performers. In addition, raters who are more intelligent and emotionally stable outperformed their counterparts. Given this reliability of assessment, SNWs such as Instagram, My Space, Facebook, and Linked In with hundreds of millions of profiles could be gainfully deployed in hiring decisions. Not surprisingly SNWs have become extremely popular and useful in the hiring process these days. However, use of SNWs in hiring does not come without accompanied costs and risks. Scholars argue that the use of SNWs increases the chances of decisions being affected by unrelated information such as race, gender, origin, nationality and may increase the......

Words: 1466 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Preferential Healthcare

...Hayden Landry 250 868 235 Prof. Narain Preferential Health Care Health is a very important aspect of our everyday lives. The health of an individual and a nation are crucial to the continued progression of said persons, for without our health, we are all but useless. In this essay I seek to examine the benefits of the public healthcare system over it’s private counterpart, not only in Canada, but any country attempting to utilize their society to the fullest. I will argue that the welfare-state liberalistic approach is much better because it seeks to pool the resources of the many and regulate/distribute it to the few in dire need, hopefully resulting in a diminishing number of sick and homeless. I begin my essay by highlighting the importance and function of both the welfare state liberalist’s public heath care and the neoconservative private health care. My argument stands on the grounds that public healthcare in Canada is more tenable because it works for the common good of all people, regardless of socioeconomic class while also placing a primary focus on efficiency, instead of profitability. A viable counterargument is that most working people do not find it ‘fair’ to have their hard-earned money taken to support the lazy or poor(welfare), although in reality the vast majority of these ‘lazy’ poor people or those outside of a private healthcare system are not in the position out of free will. As we examine the positives and negatives of both systems it becomes......

Words: 2547 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

The Hiring Process

...Angel Helm Liberty University Discussion Board Forum 2 BUSI: 642 Response to DB 2 the Hiring Process While the recruiting process varies by industry, company and even department, the end result is the same: One person out of many receives an offer (Needleman 2010). As illustrated in Stephanie’s post the hiring process can be a lengthy process. Companies take several steps in determining factors that constitute bringing on a new employees. In my own personal experience, the hiring process for my last two positions were very different, but both were created to remedy a problem that exist in a specific department. In the first position, the company which normally promoted from within, realized that not enough qualified or willing participants were available to fill these specific roles. The company decided the best way to fix this problem was to post to the position to the public, and began the hiring process externally. As the discussion post describe, the recruitment process began with the position was made available to external candidates. As the applicants were preselected, they were contact via email to partake in a telephone interview. The telephone interview greatly reduces the number of steps in the recruitment process, ensuring faster recruitment for the open position. Telephone interviews are now common practice among many companies. This tool of the hiring process is very efficient in cost savings, and allows the human resources department to pre-screen......

Words: 563 - Pages: 3