Premium Essay

Paper Review of "Architectural Innovation: the Reconfiguration of Existing Product Technologies and the Failure of Established Firms"

In: Business and Management

Submitted By joelawawaw
Words 493
Pages 2
The paper introduces the category of “architectural innovation” on the basis that seemingly minor changes to technology which may earlier be classified as an incremental innovation can have competitive consequences of a radical one. The key concept is the distinction between component knowledge and architectural knowledge. The paper argues that firms concentrate on refining components within a stable architecture established by a dominant design, and consequently, their “information-processing capabilities” are shaped by the existing architecture. While building upon component knowledge, their architectural knowledge is outmoded and made obsolete by architectural innovations. Their resulting inability to identify or understand new interactions between components has serious competitive consequences.

The conceptual framework of the paper is clear and straightforward. The main argument is advanced in a logical manner, and supporting premises (such as the way organizations manage knowledge) are supported by prior literature. Within the boundaries of the paper’s assumptions, the argument is persuasive. Furthermore, the application to the photolithographic alignment (PA) equipment industry justifies the model. The trends in the industry suggest the conceptual framework is largely accurate.

Nonetheless, the assumptions made limit the usefulness of the concept. Firstly, the analysis of firms’ information-processing is restricted to communication channels, information filtering and problem-solving strategies, ignoring other institutions, such as “cross-functional” product development teams, that organizations may have. Given that these may have profound impact on the development of architectural knowledge, the model cannot be applied to firms with such institutions. Secondly, assumptions of firms’ behaviours are based strictly on the Abernathy-Utterback model. As…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Paper Review - Henderson & Clark (Innovation)

...Paper Review – Architectural Innovation Incremental and radical innovation have always been the centerpiece and basis of a company’s innovation strategy. Henderson and Clark (1990) however, attempt to bring another categorization of innovation to the foreground. Termed as architectural innovation, they define it as “innovations that change the way in which the components of a product are linked together, while leaving the core design concepts untouched”. This type of innovation serves to make established architectural knowledge, knowledge of how individual components interact with each other, obsolete. In their paper, they established that organizations that are deeply entrenched in existing architectural knowledge have high levels of inertia to change when there is architectural innovation. Firms tend to resist such changes due to the high costs for an overhaul of existing systems or their inability to recognize such innovation. Without recognising and acting upon it, established firms may decline despite being the inventor of the core technologies in a system, much like in the case of Xerox. New entrants, on the other hand, have a greater advantage as they are not encumbered by existing but partially irrelevant architectural knowledge. That being said, it is not easy to recognize such innovation since the core technologies doesn’t change and this could lead firms to mistakenly believe that they are able to comprehend the new technology. This new concept, or rather......

Words: 550 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Innovation, New Product Development and Why Do New Products Fail?

...Innovation: Product innovation is the creation and subsequent introduction of a good or service that is either new, or improved on previous goods or services. Product innovation is defined as: the development of new products, changes in design of established products, or use of new materials or components in the manufacture of established products[1] Thus product innovation can be divided into two categories of innovation: development of new products, and improvement of existing products. Systemmatic Innovation of Products includes: * Technology  strategy * Design thinking skills * Customer needs analysis * Systematic creativity methods * Market and pricing strategy * Design for environmental sustainability * Design of services * Capturing value from innovation * Development process design * Product and service leadership * R&D organization and teams * Managing complex technical projects * The future of design process and culture The development and market introduction of a new, redesigned or substantially improved good or service. might include a new product's invention; technical specification and quality improvements made to a product; or the inclusion of newcomponents, materials or desirable functions into an existing product. Meaning of New Product Development: Product development is a broad field of endeavor dealing with the design, creation, and marketing of new products. Sometimes referred to as new......

Words: 3413 - Pages: 14

Premium Essay

Product Innovation Part 3

...Concept Ideation process 7 Controlled Convergence 8 Positioning statement 10 Product concept 11 Competitive comparison 11 Perceptual map 12 Product design 13 Pricing Strategy 16 Costs 16 Sales Forecast 16 Sales Forecast 17 Profit and Loss Statement 17 Table: Profit and Loss Statement 18 Sensitivity Analysis 18 Margins 18 Break-even Analysis 19 Payback Period 19 Net Present Value of Future Cash Flows 19 Unique selling proposition 20 Launch 20 Fitbit advertisements 20 YouTube Viral video 20 Reebok: Crossfit Games 21 In store/ on ground- gym facilities and sporting events 21 Digital social media 21 Website traffic 21 Google Ad words 22 Feedback 22 Media schedule and messaging 22 Electronic direct mail 22 Stock sale and monitoring 22 Sales statistics 22 Gant media schedule 23 Potholes 24 Call to Action 24 Appendices 1 26 Brainstorming Method 26 The Worst Idea Method 26 Relationship Analysis Method - Multi-dimensional / morphological matrix 27 Problem based approach using Voice of Customer through product reviews 27 Highs 28 Lows 28 Highs 31 Lows 31 Market based ideation 32 Problem Analysis of workout market 32 Attribute ideation Method 33 Appendices 2 34 Appendices 3 36 Executive Summary PIC and target market summary Health is opening up a new revolutionary advances within the industry of wearable technology. It is at the beginning of a massive mainstream uptake of wearable......

Words: 7194 - Pages: 29

Free Essay

Architectural Innovation

...wild crops and animals to domesticate, a larger land mass with fewer barriers to the spread of people, crops, and technology, and an east-west axis which meant that climate was similar across the region. The book is well written and contains not only information about the history of cultures around the world, but excellent descriptions of the scientific methodologies used to study them, from how archeologists study the origin of agriculture to how writing evolved to how linguistics can trace the movements of peoples across huge geographic areas. There are useful examples, maps and charts throughout, which make principles discussed in the body easy to visualize and compare. The appendix includes a chapter by chapter list of further readings on topics discussed. By the time of the beginning of Europe’s worldwide expansion (1500 AD), cultures on different continents showed huge differences in political and technological development. Much of Europe, Asia, and North Africa already had metal-equipped states or empires, some on the verge of industrialization. Aztecs and Incas in America had empires with stone tools. Parts of sub-Saharan Africa had small states or chiefdoms with iron tools. Most other peoples (in Australia, New Guinea, the Pacific Islands, some of sub-Saharan Africa, much of the Americas) lived in tribes using either farming or hunting and gathering technologies. Inequalities in the modern world stem from the same differences in development that occurred between......

Words: 18440 - Pages: 74

Premium Essay

An Approach to Incremental Innovation Theories and Its Methods in Industrial Product Development

...INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON ENGINEERING DESIGN, ICED’07 28 - 31 AUGUST 2007, CITÉ DES SCIENCES ET DE L'INDUSTRIE, PARIS, FRANCE AN APPROACH TO INCREMENTAL INNOVATION THEORIES AND ITS METHODS IN INDUSTRIAL PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT Hannu Oja Tampere University of Technology ABSTRACT A quest for powerful tools to support creation of innovative solutions exists in industry. Majority of development efforts aims for incremental development of products, either by means of improved performance in use or during manufacturing process. New concepts or solutions on product’s functionality and behaviour (behaviour meaning how the functionality is delivered, response) are needed to bring benefits. Generic product development theories, models and methods are applicable for new product development, as their approach is linear and founded on functional requirements and means to execute them. However, in industry the product development activities preferably start from existing product or concept with pre-determined goals rather than from scratch. Creativity techniques and multidisciplinary workgroups have been referred in literature as means for creating innovations. However, these methods lack context of technical system and are general in nature and could be used for any problem with assistance of experienced moderator and a group of individuals. These techniques and methods are not included in this study. An approach from retrospective case study is presented. It was found that the mental......

Words: 4589 - Pages: 19

Free Essay

Technology Brokering Innovation

...Technology Brokering and Innovation in a Product Development Firm Author(s): Andrew Hargadon and Robert I. Sutton Reviewed work(s): Source: Administrative Science Quarterly, Vol. 42, No. 4 (Dec., 1997), pp. 716-749 Published by: Sage Publications, Inc. on behalf of the Johnson Graduate School of Management, Cornell University Stable URL: . Accessed: 29/01/2013 01:51 Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at . . JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact . Sage Publications, Inc. and Johnson Graduate School of Management, Cornell University are collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Administrative Science Quarterly. This content downloaded on Tue, 29 Jan 2013 01:51:00 AM All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions Technology Brokering and Innovationin a ProductDevelopment Firm Andrew Hargadon StanfordUniversity Robert 1. Sutton Universityof California, Berkeley We blend network and organizational memory perspectives in a model of technology brokering that......

Words: 17016 - Pages: 69

Premium Essay

Innovation and Technology Article Review

...themselves. The introduction and literature review is broken down into two main parts: poverty and micro-level behavior, and poverty and the environment. Research on subsistence marketplaces has adopted the bottom up behavioral perspective for micro-level. This research has examined underlying variables that affect how the poor interact with marketplaces, specifically focusing on behavior such as thinking styles, emotional factors, and social relationships. It found that individuals are concrete in their thinking in the following ways. Individuals who subsist use information at a tangible level rather than interpreting or combining it to reach more abstract conclusions. Second, individuals focus on the “what” and “how” rather than the “why” in abstract realms. This suggests a focus on the immediate in terms of environmental issues. Another tendency is pictographic thinking, which is reflecting a comfort level with what is perceived rather than acquired. Another important finding from the research is how big of an emotional toll poverty takes on an individual and how self-esteem is greatly affected, especially in how important it is in marketplace encounters. Self esteem is dependent on how an individual thinks as well as how a person feels. The literature is summarized by the emphasis on immediacy and a focus on interactions of the marketplace. Poverty and the environment is the second area of focus for literature reviews. Overall, environments in poverty are......

Words: 416 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Term Paper

...038 INNOVATION PROJECT MANAGEMENT: A RESEARCH AGENDA SERGEY FILIPPOV; HERMAN MOOI DELFT UNIVERSITY OF TECHNOLOGY, DEPARTMENT OF INNOVATION SYSTEMS RESEARCHER AT DELFT CENTRE FOR PROJECT MANAGEMENT (THE NETHERLANDS) Abstract th Originally developed in the mid-20 century, project management has become a distinctive way to manage business activities nowadays. Another important development is virtually universal recognition of the role of innovation and technology in the corporate change, growth and profitability. It is unsurprising that development of innovation is often run as a project. Yet, theoretically both project management and innovation studies have evolved over time as distinctively separate disciplines. In this paper we make an attempt to conceptualise the innovation project management and to specify the idiosyncratic nature of innovation projects as opposed to conventional projects. By doing so, we contribute to the nascent academic debate on the interplay between innovation and project management. Key words: project management, innovation, technology 1. Introduction This paper is concerned with three topics and the interplay between them, namely “Innovation”, “Research and Development (R&D)” and “Project Management”. The interest in these topics has exploded recently as they emerged both on the policy agenda and in the corporate strategies. The contribution of technological innovation to national economic growth has been well established in......

Words: 9508 - Pages: 39

Premium Essay

Architectural Innovation

...importance of architectural innovation. Much of the authors’ argument surrounds the notion that there is a much more noteworthy type of innovation than radical or incremental that may determine the future of a company more imminently than realized. The author suggests that the failure of some companies to realize the uniqueness of an architectural innovation, because it deals with the same core components that they are used to, and pass it off as an incremental innovation leads to their demise. First the authors describe and provide examples of architectural innovation. Architectural innovation is described as a re-organization or re-combination of components that were previously used in similar technological products or services. The authors state that the level of “innovativeness” may be modest and that the core components or design concepts are left unchanged. The examples of company failure due to architectural innovation span from Xerox’s loss of market share in the copier industry to the photolithographic aligner (semiconductor) industry. The authors explain that these companies failed in part for a few key reasons. First, they didn’t see architectural innovations as a major innovation, so they didn’t realize that they had to view the innovation in a different light. This meant that they treated the innovation as they did with their current products, and did not seek further knowledge or training regarding its new architectural design. ......

Words: 448 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Internationalization, Innovation and Entrepreneurship: Business Models for New Technology-Based fiRms

...J Manag Gov DOI 10.1007/s10997-010-9154-1 Internationalization, innovation and entrepreneurship: business models for new technology-based firms Alberto Onetti • Antonella Zucchella • Marian V. Jones • Patricia P. McDougall-Covin Ó Springer Science+Business Media, LLC. 2010 Abstract New technology-based firms, particularly those that develop their business around a new technological platform, are likely to be impacted by globalization, in terms of both pace of innovation and pressure of competition. For these firms, strategic decisions and growth processes are characterized by a deep interrelationship amongst the processes of internationalization, innovation and entrepreneurship; processes which have tended to be examined independently in distinct bodies of literature. In practice strategic decisions concern each of these processes and address issues such as organizational boundaries, location of the operational activities, what activities to focus on and selection of value partners. The business model by which firms operate needs also to accommodate the spatial dimensions indicated by globalization; and the emergence of global technology markets. Little is known to date about the extent to which business models accommodate or are adapted to internationalization, innovation and entrepreneurship. This paper presents a review of the business model literature from which a generic business model framework is derived, identifying and introducing the main elements...

Words: 11236 - Pages: 45

Premium Essay

Innovation in Product

...Group 16 Innovation in Product Submission #2 Anant Jain B15131 Ankit Goel B15132 Anshul Jain B15134 2015 1. Introduction Innovation is refinement in a product, process, method, or a part thereof. Innovation has become a buzz-word in recent years, with increasing relevance of ‘innovation-centred business models’, and ‘innovation-led-entrepreneurism’. In fact, the success stories of Industrial America, technological Silicon Valley, American financial market, etc., are tales of constant innovations. ‘Digitization’ has shifted access to knowledge and information from a privilege to convenience: anyone who is willing and able to pay, has an access. Also, sharing of information and flow of payments and tenders through internet has changes businesses like never before. 1.1 What is Product Innovation? Product Innovation can be defined as creating a new product, or making changes in the existing product, or creating a differentiation in terms of utility or features of the product. Light Bulb, telephone, microprocessors, digital displays were great innovation in terms of making of new products, i-pods, cell phone, integrated circuits were innovations in terms of modification in existing products. Not all product innovations are technological breakthroughs- take a safety pin for example. Even candle, fountain pen, and scissors are examples of path-breaking revolution, that didn’t require significant technology, or invention capabilities. On the......

Words: 6719 - Pages: 27

Premium Essay

Fdi and Sustainability of Malaysia Technology-Based Firms

...Track 5: FDI Location, Clusters and Spillovers Workshop Paper Foreign Investment and the Sustainability of Malaysian Bumiputera (Indigenous) Technology-Based Firms Umar Haiyat Abdul Kohar School of Management, RMIT University, Melbourne, Australia Email: Associate Professor Adela McMurray School of Management, RMIT University, Melbourne, Australia Email: Dr. Konrad Peszynski School of Business Information Technology, RMIT University, Melbourne, Australia Email: 1 Foreign Investment and the Sustainability of Malaysian Bumiputera Technology-Based Firms ABSTRACT In the new global economy, the importance of inward foreign investment towards a country’s economic growth has become a central issue, especially amongst developing countries. Nevertheless, there is a paucity of literature addressing the implications of foreign investment towards the sustainability of business amongst Malaysian Bumiputera (Indigenous) new technology-based firms (NTBFs). Utilizing Weick’s (1989) conceptual theory building approach, this study provides a foundation for conceptualizing the implications of foreign investment in Malaysian Bumiputera new technology-based firms. Through systematic documentary analysis of the development of foreign investment activities in Malaysia prior to independence (1957) until 2009, our consolidated findings yield a conceptual model showing the......

Words: 8065 - Pages: 33

Premium Essay

Disruptive Innovation in Emerging Markets: Strategies Used

...ETM / IEL Working Paper Disruptive Innovation in Emerging Markets: Strategies Used in India and China Ruan Y., Hang C.C., Subramanian A.M. No. 01/12 Division of Engineering & Technology Management (D-ETM) Institute of Engineering Leadership (IEL) Faculty of Engineering 1    Disruptive Innovation in Emerging Markets: Strategies Used in India and China Ruan Y., Hang C.C., Annapoornima M.S. Abstract The appropriate type of innovation which can meet the needs of the mass population in the bottom of pyramid (BOP) has not been studied much in the literature. Based on the theory of disruptive innovation, we offer 11 cases from India and China – the two biggest emerging markets to show that disruptive innovation could be an appropriate, feasible, and powerful innovation force to the companies and the economies involved. We also examined the R&D strategies used in these cases based on the framework proposed by Yu & Hang (2011) and found that 3 out of the 4 strategies commonly used in the cases from developed markets were also applied in the cases from emerging markets. In addition, we have identified 3 unique strategies which emerged from the cases from India and China, namely frugal engineering, modularization, and drastic manufacturing cost reduction. Based on the frequency of the usage of these strategies, we drew practical implications for local companies and multinational companies. Our study also provides critical insights to policy......

Words: 10301 - Pages: 42

Free Essay

Existing Product to Go Green - Term Paper - Gdot80

...Server Error in '/' Application. [pic] Transaction (Process ID 750) was deadlocked on lock resources with another process and has been chosen as the deadlock victim. Rerun the transaction. Description: An unhandled exception occurred during the execution of the current web request. Please review the stack trace for more information about the error and where it originated in the code. Exception Details: System.Data.SqlClient.SqlException: Transaction (Process ID 750) was deadlocked on lock resources with another process and has been chosen as the deadlock victim. Rerun the transaction. Source Error: |An unhandled exception was generated during the execution of the current web request. Information regarding the origin and | |location of the exception can be identified using the exception stack trace below. | Stack Trace: | | |[SqlException (0x80131904): Transaction (Process ID 750) was deadlocked on lock resources with another process and has been | |chosen as the deadlock victim. Rerun the transaction.] | |System.Data.SqlClient.SqlConnection.OnError(SqlException exception, Boolean breakConnection) +1951450 ......

Words: 294 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Dynamic Capabilities of Firms

...[pic] Ecole Superieures Libre des Sciences Commerciales Appliquees Doctorate of Business Administration Human Capital Management Paper on Dynamic Capabilities of Firms Presented to: Dr. Sherif Delawar By Mohamed Antably March 2012 Cairo, Egypt. Abstract: From one hand the dynamic capabilities of firms are the sources and methods of wealth creation and capture by private enterprise firms operating in environments of rapid technological change. Other hand, Human capital ultimate objectives are linking HR practices and knowledge with goals of the firm to achieve and develop Competitive advantages. Accordingly, linking both statements would generate that HC is not only working to achieve the organizations objectives and but also to formalize, maintain and develop the firm dynamic capabilities. HC should also work on sharing and collecting success stories, lessons learnt and implicit individuals' knowledge into institutional explicit knowledge. The competitive advantage of firms is seen as resting on distinctive processes (ways of coordinating and combining which is more difficult among horizontal levels but easy in the vertical levels applying the chain of command), shaped by the firm's asset positions (such as the firm's portfolio of difficult-to-trade knowledge assets and complementary assets), and the evolution path(s) it has adopted or inherited. The importance of path dependencies is......

Words: 4356 - Pages: 18