Premium Essay

M2A1 Assignment: Critical Thinking Questions: Zimbardo and Miligram

In: Social Issues

Submitted By Dwayne84
Words 607
Pages 3
M2A1 Assignment: Critical Thinking Questions: Zimbardo and Miligram
If viewing this through the Assignment tool, click the title above to go to the Submissions area.

By the end of this activity, you will be able to:
• List and describe the basic steps for conducting scientific research, and know and discuss the research methods that sociologists use and the strengths and limitations of each.
• Summarize the core concepts of sociology and recognize and explain the “sociological imagination” when viewing social phenomena and your own life.
View the Zimbardo Stanford Prison experiment:
• http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z0jYx8nwjFQ
Watch Derren Brown reenactment of the Milgram experiments:
• http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y6GxIuljT3w&feature=related
As you complete this activity, think about the following:
• Where do we draw the line between ethical and unethical research?
• How can sociological research help us to better understand the world around us?
The Stanford Prison Experiment The Stanford prison experiment is a fairly well-known sociology study. Please go through the experiment slide show online at http://www.prisonexp.org/and answer the following questions. The slide show provides a number of video and audio clips that you may want to check out for additional information. Due to the nature of the experiment, you may want to avoid listening or watching these in the presence of small children.

After viewing the slide show, please respond to the following critical thinking questions. Please know that each of these questions should require at least a full paragraph response and that you are expected to bring in details and specific references to the videos and slideshow. Please be sure to list and number each question.
1. If you were the experimenter in charge, would you have done this study? Would you have terminated it earlier? Would you have…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Questions for Critical Thinking 1

...a. Discussion Questions: 9 b. Problems: 6, 9, and spreadsheet problem (p.37) 9) How Is The Concept Of A Normal Return On Investment Related To The Distinction Between Business And Economic Profit? The difference between the business and economic profit is that in economic profit, profit or loss is calculated by subtracting opportunity cost of the inputs used from the revenue of sales. On the other hand, accounting or business profit is the difference between the total revenue and total costs incurred to earn that revenue. Now, in business accounting normal return is the minimum profit that is required to cover the costs of inputs and all of the expenses associated with it. It can be a profit just greater than the breakeven profit (which is zero). The normal return on investment is included as part of profit by businessmen and accountants but as part of costs by economists. Thus, business profit minus the normal return on investment or implicit costs equals economic profit. It is economic profit that is important in allocating society’s scarce resources among competing uses. On the other hand, economic profit is just cost estimation. Therefore, normal profit is required in business profit and not in economic profit, which is one of the differences between the two types of profits (Salvatore, 2012). 6) Determine which of the two investment projects of Problem 5 the manager should choose if the discount rate of the firm is 20 percent. The firm......

Words: 1550 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

My Critical Thinking Assignment

...Critical Thinking Assignment Critical Thinking Assignment Billy L Goe Apologetics 104-B35 Professor Obaina September 25, 2012 Critical Thinking Assignment 1 Part One: The Question of Origin The Quran states that "Allah created the heavens and the earth, and all that is between them, in six days" (7:54). While on the surface this might seem similar to the account related in the Bible, there are some important distinctions. After completing the Creation, the Quran describes that Allah "settled Himself upon the Throne" (57:4) to oversee His work. A distinct point is made to counter the Biblical idea of a day of rest: "We created the heavens and the earth and all that is between them in six days, nor did any sense of weariness touch Us" (50:38). Allah is never "done" with His work, because the process of creation is ongoing. Each new child who is born, every seed that sprouts into a sapling, every new species that appears on earth, is part of the ongoing process of Allah's creation. "He it is Who created the heavens and the earth in six days then established Himself on the Throne. He knows what enters within the heart of the earth, and what comes forth out of it, what comes down from heaven, and what mounts up to it. And He is with you wherever you may be. Allah sees well all that you do" (57:4). Retrieved September 20, 2012 from http://islam.about.com/od/creation/a/creation.htm The Question of Identity The Quran describes how Allah created Adam: “We created......

Words: 1723 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Critical Thinking Assignment

...Destiny They believe Allah is the creator of all things. They believe that they have the right to choose their destiny be it right or wrong. In conclusion comparing Islam to Christianity our Worldviews are somewhat similar. Both the Islamic faith and Christians believe in right from wrong. They also believe in being sincere and good in their thoughts and ways. It has taken me several years to accept Islamic or Muslim people. Being in Law Enforcement and attending several management schools throughout the country I have befriended lots of co-workers from different departments. James Leahy was one of my friends. I kept in contact with him he was one of the 72 officers that died this fateful day. When asked to do a Critical Thinking assignment I never knew that critically thinking would make a tear come to my eye. Since Sept 11th I have prayed and asked the Lord to help me accept these people. I know that we can interact because I do it every day. I deal with Muslims in the community on a regular basis. As with every culture or religion there will be the bad apples. What we do as a country and a community to rid ourselves of these bad apples and coexist in peace is up to us. Just like with Christianity there where 11 fanatics that gave Muslims a bad name. The Lord has helped me work through my own hatreds or prejudices and allowed me to see these people in a different light....

Words: 518 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Questions for Critical Thinking 1

...Questions for Critical Thinking 1 —From the end-of-chapter discussion questions (DQ) and problems (P) Salvatore’s Chapter 1: a. Discussion Questions: 9. How is the concept of a normal return on investment related to the distinction between business and economic profit? b. Problems: 6, 9, and spreadsheet problem (p. 37). 6. Deterimine which of the two investemtn projects of problem 5 the manager should choose if the discount rate of the firm is 20%. 9. A woman managing a photocopying establishment for $25000 per year decides to open her own duplicating plance. Her revenue during the first year of operation is $120000 and her expences are as follows: Calculate (a) the explicit costs, (b) the implicit cost, (c) the business profit, (d) the econiomic profit, and (e) the normal return on investment in this business. Note: 1. P9(e): the normal return on investment equals the implicit cost. 2. The spreadsheet problem (b): for both variables, Time and Age. Froeb et al.’s Chapter 3: a. Individual problems: 3-1and 3-3. Salvatore’s Chapter 3: a. Discussion Questions: 9. Pg.91 How would you react to a sales manager’s announcement that he or she has in place a marketing proram to maximize sales? The way that I would react to a sales manager’s manager’s announcement that he or she has in place a marketing proram to maximize sales depends on how I am involved in this......

Words: 444 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Critical Thinking Questions

...Critical Thinking Questions: Module 7 Chapter 3 Q:Select a recent mass media technology, for example, the iPad, and explain what you think its future will hold as it relates to the stages of technological innovation. A: The future seems very bright for devices such as the iPad and iPhones, and other Smartphone based devices. As the years continue to change so will the needs of the consumers of these technological devices, it is only a matter of time before we are able to use a holographic form of an iPad or iPhone etc. These devices meet the needs of so many people that the growing rate of what is desired on the newest device is hard to keep up with. The need to produce such devices at a fast rate before their competitors may stir up a few technological glitches as the past has deteremined from older devices. My fear is that these technology companies are going to start to cut corners more often than they should just to get the product out to the consumer. In a way the future of an iPad and iPhone will always be a positive once since it is a fairly popular brand all around the world. Perhaps the next best thing that they are able to figure out will to project movies from the phone or work on a holographic keyboard that works on a flat surface. Either of these innovations would inhance the sales of this product, but only if the eagerness to get this product out before their competitors does not affect the actual product. As mentioned before history has shown that the......

Words: 1176 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Critical Thinking: Asking the Right Questions

...CRITICAL THINKING EXERCISE University of Maryland University College   Introduction: In the book, “Asking the Right Questions: A Guide to Critical Thinking (Eleventh Edition), by M. Neil Brown and Stuart M. Keeley”, the authors examine the benefits of critical thinking as it relates to the process of asking the right kinds of questions. The authors state that critical thinking is a method used to improve the way we think by asking the questions that would enable you to reach a personal decision that would eventually give credit to both sides of a discussion. Critical thinking is, in essence, the analysis, synthesis and evaluation of one’s experience, as it relates to the worth of the discussion at hand. The authors define critical thinking as, “the awareness of a set of interrelated critical questions, the ability to ask and answer critical questions in an appropriate manner; and the desire to actively use the critical questions” (p. 4). This paper will evaluate the nature of critical thinking as an intellectual process and apply that to the memorandum date October 10, 2012 to Cynthia Castle from Anil Ravaswami to determine if the issue stated of whether the CEO of the company, Cliffside Holding Company of Massapequa (CHCM) should invest $100,000 per year in leadership training program for junior insurance executives. Browne and Keeley (2010) make it clear that a critical evaluation cannot be done until the conclusion is found and instructs the......

Words: 2930 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay

Critical Thinking Questions 5

...Critical Thinking 5 Assignment NAME GRADE 76 Questions Salvatore 10: Discussion Question 2 (a) What are the advantages of the Herfindahl index over concentration ratios in measuring the degree of concentration in an industry? (b) What is the disadvantage of both? ANSWER: (a) The advantages of the Herfindahl index are: (1) uses information on all the firms in an industry, not just market share of the largest 4,8 or 12. (2) appropriately gives more weight to larger firms than to smaller firms within the industry. (b) Disadvantage to both is that they may overestimate the market power of the largest firms in the industry. Neither model considers contestable markets; this is also a disadvantage of both. Salvatore 10: Discussion Question 8 In what way does OPEC resemble a cartel? How successful is it? ANSWER: OPEC resembles a cartel because it represents a group of producers that exist with the desire to set prices beyond the competitive level. They do this by controlling supply of oil produced by its members. Much like a cartel, OPEC's decisions are dictated in the manner to which they will provide the greatest profit for the cartel members. (b) Not very successful, when OPEC increased prices beyond competitve levels, the market responded by decreasing demand for product, which in turn decreased production and export activity for OPEC members. A number or geo-political factors have both historically and recently created spikes in oil prices. Find the Herfindahl index for......

Words: 1575 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Questions for Critical Thinking Caps

...University of Phoenix Material Questions for Critical Thinking Caps Worksheet Read the description of the six caps and the “Case Study for Six Caps” on p. 175 of Professional Nursing. Answer the following questions individually. Then, discuss your answers in your Learning Team forum online. After you have discussed each question and achieved a consensus, compile a group response, which will be submitted as a Learning Team assignment. White cap: Rachel Skidmore What pieces of information are needed to assist the family in making a decision regarding Marianne’s care? In order for the family of Marianne to make an informed decision certain information is needed. The medical staff needs to review the current prognosis without surgery. What type of treatment or surgery is possible along with the risks, benefits, and recovery required. The staff needs to review if any discussion has occurred in the family with Marianne in the past regarding advance directive wishes even though no formal advance directives have been made. Patient rights need to be reviewed and written copy provided to family. Information on DNR, full code, to allow or when to stop ventilation, and if artificial feedings to be started are a few of the topics that the family needs to have information reviewed to make an informed decision on the care of Marianne. Grief is a natural process that is individual process to each person and the staff needs to allow for the various stages. Red cap: Shirley......

Words: 593 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Critical Thinking Assignment

...Critical Thinking Assignment Sarah Brown L25205543 APOL 104 I.) In Hinduism, the Question of Origin asks how life began. Not a single specific person can be linked to the Hinduisms origin. The word “Hinduism” is not in the scriptures and this makes it difficult for researchers to determine when Hinduism actually began. Hinduism is a system that “attempts to maintain a complex polytheism on the one hand, and an earth-based worship of nature on the other.” (Hindson & Caner, pg 263) At some point in between Hinduism was born. The Question of Identity is answered by the Hinduism worldview as everything is spiritual/sacred in life. Some believe “that a man’s soul is eternal and when he reaches a state of Nirvana, their soul (Atman) will become one with Brahman (Hinduism’s concept of eternal soul).” (Weidler & Gutierrez, 2011) Hinduism believes in reincarnation, which is determined by karma. The Question of Meaning or Purpose is answered by the Hinduism’s worldview as they view everything as an illusion. People usually believe that is a person doesn’t learn to understand this concept that they will stay in the lifecycle of birth, death, and rebirth. “Like a dream or a mirage, our life and everything around us does not really exist as we know it.” (Weidler & Gutierrez, 2011). The Question of Morality is answered by how they strive to be in a state of perfection, also known as moksha. To get there, they must release all wrong and evil doings. They do this by......

Words: 590 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Critical and Creative Thinking Questions

...Critical and Creative Thinking Questions Question 1 is sensation and perception are closely linked. What is the central distinction between the two? Sensation refers to the process of sensing our environment though touch, sight, taste, sound, and smell. This information is sent to our brain in raw form where perception comes into play. Perception is the way we interpret these sensations and therefore makes sense of everything around us. Like if I did not have sensation I could not hear my mom or music I would not able to taste my food that I made. Question 2 is if we sensed and attended equally to each stimulus in the world, the amount of information would be overwhelming. What sensory and perceptual processes help us lessen the din? Our brain sends singles or messages to our brain all at once we feel overwhelmed so we can’t process them. One day I had an overwhelming feeling and to get it to come down I write it all down or I told a friend or talk to someone that I could trust now I am upset that I told and now they don’t believe me on what I told them my story dose not match my emails. Question 4 is what senses, outside of hearing, would likely be impaired if a person were somehow missing all of the apparatus of the ear (including the outer, middle, and inner ear)? They will be able to use there site to see what they are talking about though reading lips and hand singles. For example my friend she is completely death she can’t......

Words: 319 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Critical Thinking Assignment

...Critical Thinking Assignment Part I Buddhism 1. Origin – In the Buddhist Worldview, life and the world have no beginning or end. “There is no reason to suppose that the world had a beginning at all. The idea that things must have a beginning is really due to the poverty of our thoughts” (Russel, 1924) Creation occurs repeatedly throughout time. 2. Identity – The Buddhist believe that they are an impermanent collection of aggregates/for some personal existence continues for a while. 3. Meaning/Purpose – Buddhists believe suffering is real it is not an illusion and that it is the reason man is trapped in the cycle of reincarnation. The purpose is to “eliminate suffering by eliminating desire or craving that which is temporary” (Weider & Gutierrez, 2011 p. 60). This can be achieved by following the four noble truths and the eightfold path, which lead to a state of Nirvana. Buddhists believe we suffer because we strive to hold on to things, which do not give lasting happiness. 4. Morality – It is directly woven into Buddhist teachings. The Third Noble Truth, “The way to liberate oneself from suffering is by eliminating all desire”. The Eightfold path connects to morality with the concepts of right speech, right action, and right livelihood. 5. Destiny - In the Buddhist Worldview, our destiny is not controlled by God but, by us. Actions we take and decisions we make determine if we have good or bad karma. When we go through the cycle of reincarnation,...

Words: 501 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Critical Thinking Zimbardo vs Milgram

...think these were necessary studies but I guess is Zimbardo really was that interested in how power may have corrupted normal people and how normal people would react when exposed to it. I think it went a little bit too far when you look at the results and findings. But that is my personal opinion. Addressing the first question if it went too far. I think even though it ended in half the time it was supposed to run, it did go too far in a few aspects. In the extended documentary that I reviewed a total of four prisoners left in the first five days due to the emotional strains that were put on them specifically by one or two guards that took their roles a bit too seriously in my opinion. Some people will by nature abuse their authority whenever they can or it pleases them instead of only using it when it’s necessary. That I believe is human common sense but as discussed in Chapter 5, common sense shouldn't play a role in studies, however, I believe that the theory or notion that power does corrupt some people is common sense. If not common sense, definitely common knowledge. Some people do not know what to do properly with authority. I think Zimbardo should have stopped his experiment immediately after the first prisoner, #8612 began showing signs of mental breakdown just after four days. Zimbardo also should have noticed that his guards who were really actors were taking things a bit too far. Addressing another question, I can absolutely answer this with......

Words: 878 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Critical Thinking Assignment

...Critical Assignment Apologetics 104 I. Islam is a religion with a great History and although not my personal belief it is the belief of 1.2 billion people around the world. a. On the question of Origin the Muslims have a monotheistic view as God/Allah is the sole creator of the universe and God/Allah is only one being. God is the only one to be worshipped and to do otherwise would totally be considered disrespect and blasphemy. (Weider & Gutierrez, 2011) b. On the question of Identity, the Muslim people and the religion of Islam believe that mankind was made by God/Allah as well as animals and that animals are important and worship Allah as well and that animals are not to be abused. (Weider & Gutierrez, 2011) I know of many Muslims that follow a vegetarian diet and also many that are carnivorous in their food choices. c. Muslims believe that Mankind’s purpose is to know that Allah is the ONE and only GOD, and to follow the writings and teachings of the Qur’an. They are to make a pilgrimage once in their lives to Mecca, to support the poor, to fast during the month of Ramadan, and to profess faith. (Weider & Gutierrez, 2011) d. Muslims believe that in order to have morality one must follow the writings of the Qur’an and the Hadith and to also follow the “The Five Pillars”, which consist of the following: to make a pilgrimage once in their lives to Mecca, to support the poor, to fast during the month of Ramadan, to profess...

Words: 622 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Critical Thinking Questions

...securities to the general public after the original sale. 10. Congress enacted the Sarbanes-Oxley Act to strengthen protection against corporate fraud and financial malpractice, after a few corporate scandals were uncovered. Some companies would take complete advantage of greater society, but the government enacted this law to protect the people from this corporate fraud and malpractice, and protect businesses from each other. An example of a corporation that was guilty of fraud was Enron. 14. I see these people as giving something to society, not just collecting a huge paycheck every year. They get what they put in, which are new ideas and new ways of doing things. Knowing what makes a business successful in this era is the Billion-dollar question, and those few who know the answer are being paid for their insight and direction. Ignoring the factors of economic consequences these payments have on the lower class and the separation of the middle class....

Words: 661 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Critical Thinking Assignment

...Running head: CRITICAL THINKING The Question of: Origin, Identity, Meaning/Purpose, Morality and Destiny Part One: The Question of Origin According to Buddhism, there is no beginning and no end. The world was formed from the interaction of elements and then it “embarks on a downward spiral at the end of which [it is] destroyed in a great cataclysm caused by natural elements such as fire, water or wind. In due course the process starts up again and the worlds once again evolve to complete a full cycle of time known as a “great eon” (mahākalpa)” (Prebish, C. S., & Keown, D. p. 27). The Question of Identity Buddhists believe that the universe and everything in it are equal and are in search of an “eternal oneness” (Weider, L. and Gutierrez, B. p. 58). They believe that upon death they will reincarnate into another life form. The life form they are reborn as will depend on whether they performed good or bad deeds during their lifetime. This is their concept of reaping what they sow, which Buddhist call Karma. The more acts of goodness they accomplish in their life, the closer they get to reaching the state of Nirvana. This level is the highest achievement possible for Buddhist and when it is accomplished it is said that their souls become eternal. The Question of Meaning/Purpose The Buddhists main objective is to perfect their life on earth in order to end the cycle of Samsara, which in it’s simplist form is their reincarnating until they reach the......

Words: 775 - Pages: 4