Premium Essay

Is the Current Criminal Justice System as Fair and Effective as We Can Reasonably Expect

In: Other Topics

Submitted By cattyd
Words 2491
Pages 10
The long continuing debate of whether the current criminal justice system is 'about as fair and effective as we can reasonably expect' has been addressed in this essay. It is argued throughout this essay that the criminal justice system fails to meet with the protection and well being of the public by not appropriately processing offenders. Six main arguments of this essay highlight weaknesses within the system. The first argument of this essay exposes the time in which offenders spend in remand prior to their trial. The second, debates whether bail over remand is being used appropriately. The third shows how lenient judges sentencing decisions are, and in addition to this, the fourth argument shows what effect the media has on the courts decisions. Then finally the fifth researches the rate of offenders re-offending. This essay concludes that the criminal justice system is not using it's ability to the fullest to stop these offenders from re-offending within our community.
The first argument in the weaknesses of the criminal justice system addresses the time an offender spends in remand, in the wait of their trial date. The length remandees are spending in custody is far too extensive, and more action needs to be done to trounce this problem within our system. When a person is placed in remand it is believed the main factors are; so that they actually show up for their hearing, to protect witnesses, or anyone else if they re-offend, and in some cases the accused themselves need the protection (Sarre et al 1999). Biles (1990) documents that the annual prison census conducted in 1990 shows us that out of 1,843 remandees, 4.3 per cent spent over one year in custody and 13.3 per cent of those served between six to twelve months. Due to this lengthy remand period, we are now seeing an increase in our prison population, mainly that of remandees rather than convicted…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Criminal Justice System

...The Criminal Justice System 2 Abstract This analysis explores the different types of tactics used by the police to control drug problems in different types of drug markets. Overall, the police appear to informally categorize drug-dealing places and to use these cursory site assessments to tailor their drug control tactics. By contrast, the police combine traditional investigation, and prosecution with interactive sources such as the District Attorney, Defense counsel, Judges; both Federal, state and Local. Statistically significant differences in their involvement are found in the investigation in the original stages, as measured by the number of calls services, pre arrest and post arrest. A defense attorney must act as an officer of the court, respecting the need for truth and truth-seeking within the confines of the adversary system and as an active participant of a system that places justice as a core value. Many criminal cases - and almost all civil ones - are heard by a judge sitting without a jury. The judge is the "trier of fact," deciding whether the evidence is credible and which witnesses are telling the truth. Keywords: Police Officer, involvement, investigation, criminal cases, pre/post arrest Criminal Justice System 3 Criminal justice is defined as the system of practices and institutions of......

Words: 1213 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Criminal Justice System

...Criminal Justice System Kristi (Michelle) Flemig CJS/200 November 18, 2012 Tracy Walker Townsend Criminal Justice System The role of the criminal justice system is to respond to crimes in the name of society. It is not confined to one level of government. It spans the federal state and local governments. The lines of authority and distinction between agencies are not always clear and may need to be negotiated according to the jurisdiction of the case. The police, courts and corrections facilities are supposed to work together as a system to implement criminal justice functions. The broad scope and size of the process can make efficient and effective goals, and different agencies within the system emphasize different goals. Sometimes the difference in these goals creates conflict. The five criminal justice goals are not mutually exclusive. Deterrence occurs with an offender is caught, punished, and decides not to engage in further criminal behavior because he or she now understands the consequence of that behavior. Retribution involves the act of taking revenge on a criminal perpetrator. Types of retribution include incarceration, victim compensation, fines paid to public agencies, community service and/or public humiliation or embarrassment. Restoration involves the attempt to make the victim “whole again.” The goal of restorative justice is to repair the harm crime has done to the relationship between the offender and victim and the offender and the......

Words: 879 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Criminal Justice System

...Criminal Justice System The criminal justice system can be a complicated system to try to understand. There are many different laws and regulations that need to be followed to ensure that each person being charged with a crime or the person charging another with a crime get treated equally and fairly as another person would. Morrison  (n.d.), "Crime is associated with harm and violence; harm to individuals, destruction of property, and the denial of respect to people and institutions.” (para. 1). The relation between crime and law is when a person commits an act that is capable of a crime or criminal activity, which can lead to a punishment by the courts and carried out by corrections. In today’s society there are laws made that state what could be considered a federal crime or a state crime. The state level crimes are set by Revised Statutes. Government system for criminal justice. “The Police are to enforce the laws, investigate crimes, apprehend offenders, reduce and prevent crime, maintain public order, ensure community safety, provide emergency and related community service, protect the fundamental rights and freedoms of individuals. The Courts are to conduct fair and impartial trials, decide criminal cases, ensure due process, determine guilt or innocence, impose sentences on the guilty, uphold the law, require fairness throughout the justice system, protect the rights and freedom of anyone facing processing by the justice system, provide a check on the......

Words: 798 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Criminal Justice System Paper

...Introduction The criminal justice system in the United States is multifaceted and is best understood when dissected into individual parts. There are the components of the criminal justice system, classifications for crime, due process, types of punishment and the process of the criminal justice system, all of which only scratch the surface. When studying and working in the criminal justice field it is important to remember that without each part of this system many of the freedoms and rights citizens take for granted every day could not be enforced. Even more important to remember, as annoying as it is sometimes, no law is too infinitesimal to be enforced because without even the smallest law, the society so many Americans love and cherish would not function. Components of the Criminal Justice System Though the criminal justice is complex, when broken down into its individual components is easily dissected and explained. The major components of the criminal justice system are the police, the criminal courts and corrections (Schmalleger, 2008). These components work together to provide safety for the community as well as punishment and rehabilitation for criminal offenders (Schmalleger, 2008). The first component of the criminal justice system is the police. The police enforce the law, investigate crimes, apprehend criminals, reduce and prevent crime, maintain public order, ensure community safety, provide emergency community services and protect the basic rights and......

Words: 2630 - Pages: 11

Free Essay

Criminal Justice System Accessment

...Criminal Justice System Assessment Introduction The criminal justice system is a crucial feature of American culture and the foundation of the Bill of Rights within the United States Constitution. The sole intentions of the laws are to safeguard the people from harm, ensure the publics safety, and uniformly treated. The criminal justice system labors to safeguard the guiltless and discipline the responsible without infringing the right of the suspected offender, refraining from any corruption. As society progresses the criminal justice system must advance so it is vital to establish new laws remain current on the advancement and new trends. As contemporary issues and new trends evolve in society, they can endure a precise affect on the various roles of the criminal justice system, for example, sentencing policy, procedures, technologies, and capital punishment, which harbor immense impacts on the criminal justice system. Furthermore, corrections, courts, and the police additionally take part in establishing retribution. Contemporary and future trends are going to and have direct impacts on the duties of the criminal justice system. Recently technology has been influencing the criminal justice system and will remain. In the forever-changing world of technology, the criminal justice system must keep up with recently developed technologies. This essay will explain recent and future trends and contemporary issues affecting the criminal justice system and the value of the......

Words: 1646 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

The Criminal Justice System

...The Criminal Justice System The United States criminal justice system is perhaps the most intricate process in the developed world. It consists of three parts; the legislative body (responsible for creating laws), corrections (responsible for imprisonment) and the court system. The legislative body is self-explanatory and the bulk of the legislative process is through Congress. The corrections division of the justice system is vital as it facilitates the punishments of the accused who are found guilty. Typically this is comprised of a sentence determined by the court system and varies depending on the severity of the crime. Not all punishments lead to imprisonment however, as there are other means of rehabilitating a criminal such as house arrest, community service and mandatory drug rehabilitation of the situation calls for it. The court system facilitates disputes between individuals and is the administering body for justice. While the system is mainly comprised of the three aforementioned components, the police force is typically considered the face of the criminal justice system and is the basis in which citizens form their opinions of it. The police force is comprised of empowered civilians who are tasked with upholding the law, mitigating crime on a micro-level and are authorized to use force if necessary to carry out their goals. This has often caused an alarming degree of controversy regarding the use of excessive force by the police. The combination of the......

Words: 642 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Criminal Justice System

...Criminal Justice System CJA/204 Criminal Justice System Just about everyone in our modern society knows there are laws that are not meant to be broken. These laws are supposed to be for the well being and protection of all the citizens under their jurisdiction. However, most of us realize that these laws are often broken for various reasons. Greed, ignorance or simply stupidity in some cases. There are many excuses for breaking the laws of our great modern society. However, when a law is broken, the long arm of the law takes action in an attempt to rectify the situation and prevent further damage. Our first line of defense is to try and stop crime before it happens. So, what is crime? The definition of crime is basically breaking the law. Our laws come from local, state or the federal government. Now with that being said, there comes the subject of crime and its relationship to the law. In this arena we have legalistic, political, sociological and psychological areas to understand. The legalistic viewpoint is that there must be a law before a crime can be committed. Even if an act is morally or ethically wrong in the eyes of those who witness it, it legally is not wrong without a law to forbid the actions in the first place. The next topic for discussion is political. The big shots or what some would call the "political elite" control the rest of us by using the laws to their advantage. I believe it was Lord Acton who once said in a letter from......

Words: 831 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Criminal Justice System

...Criminal Justice System Criminal Justice System Crime is defined in different ways by different sources. I will show two different sources that define crime but ultimately they mean the same thing just worded differently. The definition of crime in The Merriam-Webster dictionary is defined as an act or the commission of an act that is forbidden or the omission of a duty that is commanded by a public law and that makes the offender liable to punishment by that law; especially :  a gross violation of law. Crime defined in the criminal justice field is defined as conduct in violation of the criminal laws of a state, the federal government, or local jurisdiction for which there is no legally acceptable justification or excuse. There is a very unique relationship between crime and the law. If there are no laws then what constitutes a crime? There would be no crime because there would be no violations that would be punishable. This would cause mass chaos among the people. People would take matters into their own hands. Each individual would become their own judge, juror, and executioner. This is something that society could not handle and this is why there is a need for order by making laws and enforcing them. The two most common models that society deems what and which acts are criminal are the Consensus model and the Conflict model. The Consensus model is a perspective from the criminal justice field that it is assumed that all the components work together consistently to...

Words: 1214 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Racism in the Criminal Justice System

...Racism in the Criminal Justice System Racism in police treatment of minorities has created great disparities in incarceration amongst the races. Blatant cases of racist law enforcement that are covered in the news are a testament to the fact that racism within police departments exists from coast to coast. However, these are only the cases that people find out about; there are countless other cases of police racism and brutality that are not reported. A series of reports that have been published in the last few years have shown that young black men are being incarcerated at a rate far greater than their number in the overall population. In the fall of 1995, Vincent Schiraldi, executive director of the Center on Juvenile and Criminal Justice in San Francisco, released a study that found that nationally 33% of the black men in their 20~s were under the control of the criminal justice system in some way, shape or form. This shows an increase from 1991, when 25% of the black men nationwide ages 20 to 29 were incarcerated, on probation, or on parole (Butterfield 1996). Schiraldi, attributed the higher incarceration rates for black men to tougher punishment for the use of crack cocaine than for other drugs; harsh new sentencing laws; the prison construction boom; and poverty, lack of good jobs and poor education in inner cities. We will address how tougher punishments have resulted in worse treatment for minorities in the criminal justice system. The tougher punishment for the...

Words: 6993 - Pages: 28

Free Essay

Racism in the Criminal Justice System

...RACISM IN THE CRIMINAL JUSTICE SYSTEM By Nichole Griffith Advised by Professor Chris Bickel SOC 461, 462 Senior Project Social Sciences Department College of Liberal Arts CALIFORNIA POLYTECHNIC STATE UNIVERSITY June, 2012 © 2012 Nichole Griffith Table of Contents Research Proposal ............................................................................................................................1 Annotated Bibliography ...................................................................................................................2 Outline..............................................................................................................................................6 Introduction ......................................................................................................................................7 Research ..........................................................................................................................................8 Conclusion ....................................................................................................................................29 Bibliography .................................................................................................................................31 Research Proposal The goal of my research is to expose the racism in the criminal justice system that is so hidden. I want to show how racism contributes to the huge......

Words: 9753 - Pages: 40

Free Essay

Effective Communication in Criminal Justice

...Effective Communication Martin Roth CJA/304 July 24th, 2014 Douglas Campbell Effective Communication What is communication? The term “communication” in a broad sense is how one listens and corresponds with others. Though there are many definitions of the term everyone may have their own general idea what it is to communicate as well as understand what is being communicated to them. In this paper the author will be discussing some major points such as the process of verbal and nonverbal communication, differences between listening and hearing, formal and informal channels of communication associated with criminal justice, barriers in effective communication, and strategies that may be implemented to overcome those barriers. In order for people to communicate effectively there is a process that involves verbal and nonverbal communication. Within this process there are 5 steps that are followed. The first step is transmitting and idea. This is the forming of one or more thoughts. The expression of the idea is an intentional act put forth by the person with the formed idea. The second step is sending the idea through a medium. There are several different ways to send the message and they are as follows: orally, in writing, or by action. Sending a message that is written vs. orally can make a major difference in how it is understood. When sending a message orally the tone of one’s voice can dictate to another how the message should be taken. Thirdly is......

Words: 912 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

The Criminal Justice System

...Criminal Justice System CJA-204 June 01, 2015 Criminal Justice System Crime is “any act or omission in violation of penal law, committed without defense or justification, and made punishable by the state in a judicial proceeding” (Schmalleger, Hall, Dolatowski, 2010, p. 4). Laws are principles and regulations that are established to keep the people in some form of order. If the people stray from these regulations and principles, they may actually be committing a crime. Government Structure The criminal justice system is made up of agencies from the local, state, and federal levels. There are also three branches of government. These three branches of government include the Legislature, Judicial, and Executive branches. The legislative branch is responsible for making the laws. The judicial branch is responsible for determining if laws are constitutional and can also overturn prior rulings by other judges. The executive branch is responsible for signing and vetoing laws. A president is elected, by the people, to be the head of the executive branch every four years. Choice Theories Choice theories are explanations as to why crime is committed. These theories come in the form of eight general categories. These categories include classical, biological, psychological, psychobiological, sociological, social process, conflict, and emergent. Classical theory involves the individual’s exercise of his or her free will. Biological theory refers to genes that......

Words: 904 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Criminal Justice System

...Components of the Criminal Justice System and the Criminal Justice Process There are three components of criminal justice that we will explain: Police, Courts, and Corrections. Policing is the first component of our justice system. Policemen are the first responders within this system and are the ones who basically see the crime as it happens or right after. They are also the ones who come in contact with the evidence as they search the suspects or their property. They are also responsible for deterring crime with the presence in neighborhoods, highways, and events. They are the ones who serve the community with helping others in distress and protecting citizens from criminals. Police have the ability to determine if a crime was committed or not. Perpetrators are told their rights and taken into custody and transported safely by police. Police are also responsible for being role models within their community and must respect citizens on a mutual level. Too many times we see a case of police brutality and we know that a majority of policemen are good people, but our society sees “CNN”, “FOX NEWS” and our local news media and we only see what the ratings want us to see. Policemen have one of the toughest jobs in the world and yet are some of the most underpaid professionals besides soldiers and teachers. We must understand that policemen are on our side and not always think the criminal is right. The second component of our justice system is......

Words: 849 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Comparative Criminal Justice Systems

...solutions to a nations criminal justice problems in a one page (per county) summary. With the diverse nature of all 4 countries, to be able to “fly” into a foreign land at the request of the leader, and be given “Carte Blanc” to handle their criminal justice problem is about as impossible as implementing all that is needed to fix their criminal justice system issues within the perimeters of this paper. I would actually like to be alive in 2025 and to see this happen (other countries allowing us to handle their criminal justice systems) it might be akin to the forefathers of this country (Washington, Jefferson, Hamilton etc) seeing the implementation of the automobile as a transportation model for the people. I’m sure they could have never imagined people transporting themselves they way we do as people today. This is how I feel about the prospect of the four other nations allowing someone from the U.S State Department handle their individual criminal justice affairs. The problem that we face not only in the United States but worldwide is a highly heated debate. How do we handle this crisis that we are all encountering? It would be simple to only have one nice little problem that when corrected the system worked fine. This would be similar to a car with a flat tire. Nothing is wrong with the main components (engine, transmission, ect) but when the tire is replaced with a new one the car is now able to do the job it was intended to do (run smoothly). But as we know it is......

Words: 5172 - Pages: 21

Premium Essay

Foundations of the Criminal Justice System

...Foundations of Criminal Justice System Amanda Risner American Intercontinental University Abstract I have discussed the three key components for the criminal justice system which are the police, courts and the corrections. Process for which and indictment and arrest follow through our criminal justice system. You can find that I have given my opinions on the aspect of the prosecutor and defense attorneys and when the defense attorney can come forth. Learning about the criminal justice system seem to be a little harder than I had thought it would be but finding it very interesting the further I get into the materials. Foundations of Criminal Justice System Foundations of the criminal justice system as you read through the essay you will find I have pointed out the components of the criminal justice system. I have given an overview of the process for which an arrest would take place and how the process follows through. There are different types of law that there are in the foundations of the criminal justice system. As we look at the criminal justice system the criminal justice system is made from three key components for the system which are the police, courts and the corrections. Although all three make up the criminal justice system they have different jobs in the field, but work together to complete the investigative and prosecutorial process. The process occurs from the interrogation and questioning to the conviction of a criminal act to the custody and......

Words: 1092 - Pages: 5