Free Essay

Fannie Mae: the Most Ethical Company

In: Business and Management

Submitted By eck5838
Words 1753
Pages 8
How Did Fannie Get on the Wall in the First Place?
Fannie Mae was established to facilitate the perceived social responsibility in the United States of encouraging the growth and affordability of housing, especially for disadvantaged groups. During the period in which Franklin Raines was at the helm, the company could seem to do no wrong, garnering recognition for many socially responsible accolades, being “near the top of everyone’s ‘best’ list” (Jennings, 2010, p. 268). For a company, is social responsibility the only mandate? Perhaps for Fannie Mae who was established by federal charter to meet such a mandate, this might be the case, but Milton Friedman argues that “there is one and only one social responsibility of business . . . increase its profits” (1970, para. 33). This author believes that if a company does not minimally maintain cash flow, or “real” profits, over the long term, it will be unable to meet any contrived social responsibility or survive.
How an organization goes about maintaining or increasing cash flow brings into play the idea of governance, which “comprises the roles, responsibilities, and balance of power among executives, directors, and shareholders” . According to Aguilera and Cuervo-Cazurra (2004) there are two purposes of corporate governance policy; improving quality of governance (or the running of the company), and increasing accountability of the leadership. Fannie Mae’s leadership was fixated on a single indicator of company success, while using its other accolades as a means of inviting investment. Ethics indicates the behavior that all individuals should take in any given situation. In regards to Fannie Mae’s governance, the behaviors engaged in by upper management were contrary to good governance, and ethics.
This author believes that there is no direct connection between social responsibility and ethics – because responsibility is an individual acceptance of behavior and obligation, while ethics deals what is right and what is wrong for all individuals. On the other hand, good governance of a company tends toward the continuation of that company. Continuation, works toward the maintaining of jobs for employees, the receipt of quality goods and services by customers, and a solid investment for shareholders. In this way there is a connection between good governance and ethical behavior.
How Many Kings’ Men Passed Fannie and Took No Notice?
The signals that were “overlooked” in Fannie Mae’s devolution, listed by Jennings (2010), were:
“In 1998, Armando Falcone of the OFHEO issued a warning report that challenged Fannie Mae’s accounting and a stunning lack of internal controls” (p. 272).
In 2002, the Wall Street Journal raised issues about Fannie’s accounting practices.
In 2002, Fannie shifted income by lending $40 million to Radian Insurance, listing said investment as an insurance policy.
In 2003, employees “expressed concerns about the company’s accounting policies” (p. 273).
In November of 2003, Roger Barnes “provided a detailed concern about the company’s accounting policy” (p. 272)
In each case, Fannie Mae’s management took no action to investigate these claims. In part this was due to the way that the company was organized, and contributed to their minimal internal controls. The Ethics and Compliance Office at the time was part of Fannie’s litigation division. The principle responsibility of the individual in charge of this office, however, was to “defend the company against allegations and suits by employees” (Jennings, 2010, p. 272). So, even though Barnes included specific information regarding suspected wrong doing in regards to Fannie’s accounting practices, no steps were taken by either that office or The Office of Auditing. Jennings further states that in interviews “many of the officers at Fannie were aware of . . . Barnes allegation . . . but none followed up on the issue or required an investigation” (p. 273).
Holmes, Langford, Welch, & Welch noted that “unethical charismatic leaders have dependent and compliant followers, who learn to rationalize their immoral behavior. These leaders manage to convince followers that immoral behavior is justified” (2002, p. 87). The implication of Jennings case is that management was on the same page to ensure the attainment of the major goals of the corporation, and did nothing to endanger their paychecks, or their bonuses.
Did Fannie Climb or Was It Helped?
With bonuses up to 100% for the attainment of a single accounting measurement each year, each officer was invested and motivated to meet the targeted goal, this is human nature. Without stringent methods of internal control, and empowered external auditors, however, this was a situation fraught with peril to the ethical nature of everyone involved. No one benefitted from a negative report, all of the benefit was in allowing discrepancies in policy or numbers to not be investigated. According to Howell & Avolio (1992),
“Unethical . . . leaders follow standards if they satisfy their immediate self-interests. They are adept at managing an impression that what they are doing conforms to what others consider “the right thing to do.” By applying their enormous skills of communication, they can manipulate others to support their personal agenda” (p. 49).
It is ironic that Raines, while engaging in non-standard accounting practices to “smooth” the earning profile of his company, publicly stated that the boards of public corporations should “select and oversee competent and ethical management”, and that those managers are responsible to “operate the company in a competent and ethical manner . . . never put[ting] personal interest ahead of or in conflict with the interest of the company” (Jennings, 2010, p. 274). By tying incentives to a single accounting measurement, Raines ensured that each officer’s self-interest was potentially in conflict with the interest of the company.
If policies had been put in place, and the organizations structure organized in such a way that safeguards had been put in place to ensure the quality and accuracy of the numbers without the personal involvement of those who were to benefit, then the conflicts of interest between the personal and professional interest of the officer’s may have been mitigated. The use of earnings per share as Raines single determiner of Fannie’s success, however, is even more questionable. Earnings per share should be a straight-forward calculation since it’s supposed to be the net revenue of the company, less dividends to preferred stockholders, divided by the number of common shares extant. With accounting strategies this simple indicator is not as simple as it would appear, as there are GAAP EPS, and pro forma EPS, and EBITDA EPS. It is possible for two companies to have the same EPS number, with one flush with cash, while the other bleeding cash and accruing large amounts of debt. It is a poor investor, and a terrible management team, that relies on one financial measure without it being used in conjunction with statement analysis and other measures or corporate health.
How Do We Achieve Fannie-“ness”?
By working the books backwards Fannie Mae officers were assured of making their goals, and their bonuses. The only way that this could be done over the long haul is to resort to funny numbers and creative bookkeeping. The problem with this strategy is that reality does not change just because you report it differently. For Fannie they were able to build in this fudge factor by invoking the volatility adjustment. This way the numbers worked out, the executives took home huge paychecks, investors were encouraged, analysts supported and the scheme continued.
The longer any measured system is skewed from reality, however, the larger the divergence and the more obvious the difference becomes to knowledgeable observers. A con cannot go on forever, sooner or later it must collapse because it is not built on a sound, square, or true foundation. The longer the scheme goes, the more likely it is to be discovered. If a pilot heads on a bearing that is one-half of a degree off, it may be some time before the pilots error might become noticeable, but in time it would put the airplane hundreds of miles off course if not corrected. This is why honesty is truly the best policy, for any other policy must ultimately result in failure. In the case of Fannie Mae, the volatility adjustment must have been important in the smoothing of financial statements, because after six years of “smoothing” there was the need of a “$6.3 billion restatement of revenue” (p. 274).
Few Noticed the Potential Fall
When Raines decided the goal for the company, the remaining executives got on board. The Vice President of operations risk (auditing) gave a talk to the auditors in 2000, setting a culture for the attainment of the goal – a form of tunnel vision. It has been shown that where lax management attitudes exist in regards to internal controls of accounting there is also the likelihood of fraud, and that auditors should “be especially vigilant in assessing the ‘tone at the top’ and control weaknesses” (Holmes, et al., 2002, p. 86). If the auditors were more invested in the goals of the company, than they were in ensuring the accuracy of the numbers, as is the case with Fannie, they were not doing their jobs. Holmes, et al.’s study indicated that “a lax attitude by top management encourages unethical activity and discourages the reporting of it” (p. 88), which is also seen in the Fannie Mae story. Graham (1995) compared leadership styles in a study to determine the “moral development and organizational citizenship behaviors” of each styles followers (p. 48), and found that leaders who follow a transactional model emphasize “influencing subordinate behavior by connecting it to specific rewards and/or punishments” which allows for “dependable task accomplishment”, but also “provides no check on the possibility of unethical rules or instructions” (p. 49).
The ethical implications of the Fannie Mae failure are many. Perhaps more than any other lesson this author takes from this scenario is that one should not believe the hubris of one’s own moral superiority. Fannie Mae seemed to be the penultimate poster child of social responsibility and ethics, but this was a specious picture that masked the internal workings of a company that was anything but responsible, or ethical. How much of the corresponding rationalization from their dishonest practices came because the executives “knew” they were doing something worthwhile in the service of the disadvantaged, and the down-trodden, the “huddled masses yearning to breathe free” (Lazarus, 1883)? Just because one is doing good, does not mean that one’s every action IS good. The long-term consequences of actions and inactions need to be carefully considered, and if the direction of those decisions are deviant, one needs to apply an immediate course correction.…...

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Fannie Mae Freddie Mac

...Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac are two major mortgage lending companies in the United States. Both these large scale companies have lent out about $5.3 trillion dollars in mortgages. The companies lend other banks and financial institutions money so that the other banks can make new loans to businesses, potential homeowners, and other people looking to borrow money. By lending out all of this new money to other financial institutions the companies are potentially helping increase the economy. Freddie Mac lent out a plethora of money to major financial institutions that were risky institutions to trust to pay back. If a company knows that they are lending money out, and they know that they may never see the money again, it is considered to be very risky. This set’s mortgage lending companies up for disaster. Being an accounting student I have learned that as an auditor you must possess the trait of professional skepticism. Professional Skepticism is an attitude that an auditor must maintain, which includes having a questioning and critical mind when going through accounting records. The accounting methods that were used by both companies were not in any violation of the accounting rules, but from the view of an accountant with professional skepticism, they may have been considered unethical. Freddie Mac took the losses that they have incurred from lending money to financial institutions that were unable to pay back the money that they owed, and “pushed......

Words: 671 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Most Wanted Company Culture

...cushions and beach chairs. Then you glance over to see glass doors opening up to a plush terrace overlooking the city skyline. You ask the receptionist, “Where am I, on vacation?” and the receptionist responds “No you’re at work. Welcome to Google…” Wow is the only word that comes to mind when thinking of the company culture at Google. Many people would agree working at this company is like walking into a dream every morning. Some more of the amenities offered at various Google office locations are a pub-style lounge in Dublin, Ireland, a pool table in the conference room of Tokyo, Japan, a rock climbing wall adorns the “tech talk” area in Boulder, Colorado. (Google, 2012) Google’s company culture is technically an adaptability culture. According to Draft (2010) adaptability culture is defined as “culture characterized by strategic leaders encouraging values that support the organization’s ability to interpret and translate signals from the environment into new behavior responses”. Google is a company whose values promote individual initiative, experimentation, risk taking, and entrepreneurship. (Draft, 2010) Value’s play an important role in developing any companies culture. For example, the National Society of Black Engineers (NSBE) prides itself on recruiting well educated black engineers to improve the black community just like Google prides itself on hiring well educated people who are geniuses in their particular field to improve technological advancement. ......

Words: 710 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Company Stuggle with Ethical Issues

...The Coca-Cola Company Struggles with Ethical issues Dr. Albrani University BUS 508 July 20, 2012 Delineate the ethical issues and dilemmas the company faced. The following is a series of alleged misconduct and questionable behavior affecting Coca-Cola stakeholders. The first ethical issue or dilemma the company faced is the contamination scare which is perhaps the most damaging of Coca-Cola cries- and the situation that every company dreads-began in June 1999, when about thirty Belgian children became ill after consuming Coca-Cola products. Although the company recalled the product, the company eventually determined that the illnesses were the result of a poorly processed batch of carbon dioxide. Questions about Coca-Cola’s market dominance started government inquiries into its market tactics. Because most European countries have very strict antitrust laws, all firms must pay close attrition to market share and position when considering joint ventures, mergers, and acquisitions. During the summer of 1999, Coca-Cola became very aggressive in the French market. As a result, the French government responded by refusing to approve Coca-Cola’s bid to purchase Orangina, a French beverage company. French authorities also forced Coca-Cola to scale back its acquisition of Cadbury Schweppes, another beverage maker. Moreover, Italy successfully won a court case against Coca-Cola over anticompetitive prices in 1999, prompting the......

Words: 2054 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Ethical Issues in Business

...This paper will discuss Ethical Issues in Business and the behavior of the business world. Rigorously, the question of Ethical behavior is raised in the private and federal sectors (more in the private sector when dealing with organizations, businesses, and corporations) and to the extent of the contain that involves this kind of behavior. Ethics is a strong topic that can be discussed in some great length without reaching any kind of consensus stateside or abroad. However I will give some insight on the issues of corporate ethic’s and federal behavior. The responsibilities and objectives of the businesses will be observed, as well as the ethical obligations of the federal sector. One of the major issues that corporations have in the private sector is over reporting and under reporting of net income. Management in the corporate world seeks to show that every quarter the net income of business has grown. The way this is done is by adopting unethical means and illegal means in the operations of financial reporting. One such way this is done in the private sector is in the use of stock options for employees that enable private sector companies to take employment cost off balance sheet and inflate earning. Corporation’s when making decisions must be held to ethical standard as well as a technical or commercial standard. Corporation’s board members must govern the Ethical behavior of its C-level, upper, middle, lower management, and especially its accountant’s...

Words: 1003 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Freddy Mac and Fannie Mae

...Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac are private corporations that were established by Congress and are referred to as government sponsored enterprises or GSEs. They are the largest “packagers” of individual mortgages into mortgage backed securities (MBS) which they guarantee against loss. We will be addressing the following threats to your financial institutions stability. Counterparty risk. Internal and external vulnerability and threats. Stemming the tide of losses from overly aggressive practices in lending continues to retard the marketplace and has yet to reach equilibrium. The use of macro measures is of critical importance in returning the company to profitability. \ The use of Macroeconomic Measures, Using Aggregate Data. These measures approach threats to financial stability from the top down: Is aggregate credit growing too fast? Are credit underwriting standards falling? Are asset prices too high relative to fundamentals? “In an internal boom-bust cycle, an initial market upswing entices new investors and rising prices until additional capital or investors’ nerves are exhausted.”(Evanoff, Kaufman, and Malliaris, 2012). “This process can be amplified by capital rules that encourage banks to increase leverage when the economy is expanding and loan losses are low.” (Hanson, Kashyap, and Stein, 2011). “In the ensuing bust, a credit crunch can occur as participants switch from lending too much to lending too little.” (Brunnermeier, 2009). A......

Words: 960 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Fannie Mae Case Study

...(GSEs) Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac was $130 billion (Cover). This number has been a well-publicized figure signaling the corruption of these two mortgage giants. In fact, enormous sums of money often become the public symbol for corruption when corporate fraud is committed. By the same token, Fannie Mae’s $9 billion of overstated earnings from 2001-2003 also became a strong representation for the executive deception that was committed during this time period (Harvard Law School Case). However, the reasons for the fraud itself are often overlooked. While we can’t be certain that executive compensation practices contributed to this fraud, it undoubtedly did not strengthen the idea of producing firm value for the benefit of shareholders. Fannie Mae was created in the midst of the Great Depression (1938) to buy mortgages from lenders so that money would be freed up for other borrowers (Pickert). Although Fannie started off with just $1 billion to purchase mortgages, the organization was extremely effective and shaped American home ownership for a new class of people that once were not considered creditworthy. Essentially, low to middle income buyers were able to receive credit and become homeowners due to the success of Fannie Mae. It is important to note that Fannie Mae was established with an amazing social mission in mind: to help American homeowners realize their dreams. It could be argued that the company’s leaders have lost sight of this mission as the company......

Words: 5626 - Pages: 23

Premium Essay

Fannie Mae Management Planning

...Fannie Mae Management Planning Planning is a management function necessary for the success of any organization. Organizational planning has to include internal and external environments, evaluation of the marketplace, identifying, and analyzing factors that influence planning. Fannie Mae is an organization with a competitive edge in the housing marketplace. Fannie Mae accomplished this through effective planning. Overview of Fannie Mae Fannie Mae is a government-sponsored enterprise (GSE) chartered by Congress with a mission to provide liquidity, stability, and affordability to the UNITED STATES housing and mortgage markets. Fannie Mae operates in the UNITED STATES secondary mortgage market. Rather than making home loans directly to consumers, Fannie Mae work with mortgage bankers, brokers and other primary mortgage market partners to help ensure they have funds to lend to home buyers at affordable rates. Fannie Mae fund mortgage investments primarily by issuing debt securities in the domestic and international capital markets. Fannie Mae has three lines of business-Single-Family, Housing and Community Development and Capital Markets-that provides services and products to lenders and a broad range of housing partners. Together, these business contribute to the company’s chartered mission to increase the amount of funds available to make homeownership and rental housing more available and affordable (Fannie Mae, 2010). Management Planning Function The......

Words: 1112 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

The World's Most Ethical Companies: Starbucks

...Ethical behavior and corporate social responsibility can offer significant benefits to a company. Ethical business conduct not only gives the company a great reputation but it also has a positive effect on its bottom line. One of the companies listed on the Ethisphere Institute's list of the World's Most Ethical Companies is Starbucks. Starbucks Corporation has 19,972 stores in 60 countries and is world’s largest coffeehouse chain, and is considered one of the world’s most famous and most liked consumer brands (Mocallejon, 2012). Over the last decade, the company has made the lists of Most Admired Companies in the U.S., 100 Best Companies to Work for, 100 Best Corporate Citizens, World’s 50 Most Innovative Companies, and World’s Most Ethical Companies. According to the company’s executives, their success is mainly attributed to their commitment to social responsibility and ethical conduct. Starbucks believes that striving to do the right thing with regards to their consumers, the environment and their employees is vital to the success of the company, and demonstrates its values in a number of ways (Starbucks, 2013). When it comes to being morally responsible towards consumers, Starbucks is committed to provide wellness to its customers by offering low-calorie quality products that do not contain unhealthy ingredients such as dyes, artificial flavors, and high fructose corn syrup. The company also strives to establish a human connection with consumers by ensuring that its......

Words: 1289 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

The World's Most Ethical Companies

...Running head: THE WORLD’S MOST ETHICAL COMPANIES 1 The World’s Most Ethical Companies Elaine Kennedy Professor Victor A. Oladapo Lithonia Campus BUS 309 November 28, 2013 Strayer University The World’s Most Ethical companies Kimberly-Clark is one of the most ethical companies in the world. It promotes ethical and practical business standards and up hold legal compliance that help shape future industries today. It behaves in a morally responsible way toward consumers, the environment and employees in several ways. By placing consumers at the center of ever thing they do through the product they produce that improve their lives on a daily basis. Products like Kleenex, Scott, Pull-Ups, Kotex, Poise and Depends rank high in essentials for consumers today. Kimberly-Clark also gives back to the community through donations to the Boys and Girls Club as well as giving back to the community through jobs and improving and shaping the lives of families. They also support consumers for a stand point of disaster relief in neighborhoods through donations of food, clothing, and financial contributions. From and environmental aspect Kimberly-Clark produce product form all natural wood products, and recycled fibers for third party certified forest systems. These systems are Forest stewardship council (FSC) and also another system includes Sustainable Forest Initiative (SFI). These organizations are associated with the......

Words: 1589 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Fannie Mae

...Paper Fannie Mae, also known as Federal National Mortgage Association was established in 1938 by amendments to the National Housing Act to provide local banks with federal money to finance home mortgages. This was an attempt to raise levels of home ownership and make affordable housing more available by creating a secondary market. Fannie Mae was authorized to buy Federal Housing Administration insured mortgages, replenishing the supply of lendable funds. In 1944 Fannie Mae was authorized to purchase loans guaranteed by the Veterans Administration, and in 1954 they become a mixed ownership corporation owned partly by private stockholders. In 1970 Fannie Mae transitioned from mixed ownership to private organization and was authorized to purchase conventional mortgages. Through the 80’s and 90’s Fannie Mae remained profitable through the use of adjustable rate mortgages and mortgage backed securities. In the late 1990’s and early 2000’s institutions in the primary mortgage market pressured Fannie Mae to ease credit requirements on the mortgages it was willing to purchase, enabling them to make loans to subprime borrowers. As housing prices dropped nationwide and foreclosures increased, Fannie Mae suffered large losses on various investments in their portfolio, such as sub-prime mortgages (loans made to borrowers with poorer-than average credit) and “private label” MBS’s (securities issued and insured by private companies without government backing). Fannie Mae also faced...

Words: 839 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Bus 309 Week 8 Assignment 2 the Worlds Most Ethical Companies

...BUS 309 Week 8 Assignment 2 The Worlds Most Ethical Companies Instructors, training on how to grade is within the Instructor Center.  Assignment 2: The World’s Most Ethical Companies     Due Week 8 and worth 300 points   Review the Ethisphere Institute's list of the World's Most Ethical Companies, located at Research a sampling from the organizations from the list, and identify one (1) company that you believe treats its consumers, the environment, and employees in an exceptional and morally praiseworthy manner.    Write a five (5) page paper in which you:   1.Determine at least two (2) ways in which the chosen company behaves in a morally responsible way toward each of the following:   a.consumers    b.the environment   c.employees   2.Predict the effects that these morally conscious decisions would have on the company's bottom line.    3.Review the company's policies from a critical perspective, and list at least two (2) areas where the company could improve its treatment of consumers, the environment, or employees. Justify the response with specific examples.   4.Use at least three (3) quality references. (Note: Wikipedia and other Websites do not quality as academic resources.)    Your assignment must follow these formatting requirements:   * Be typed, double spaced, using Times New Roman font (size 12), with one-inch margins on all sides; references must follow APA or school-specific format...

Words: 410 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

My Most Interesting Company: Alibaba Group

...Whole Foods Market Social responsibility means that an ethical framework that suggests that an entity, be it an organization or individual, has an obligation to act to benefit society at large. There are many actions can be considered as Social responsibility like Philanthropy, Environment ,Ethical labor practices and so on. One of the example of social responsibility organization is Whole Foods Market, Inc. Whole Foods supports sustainable agriculture, and they promotes the reduction of waste.They also encourages environmentally sound cleaning and cut down consumption of nonrenewable resources. The company created the Local Producer Loan program, which provides $10 million as low-interest loans for small local producers to grow their businesses. The best social responsibility that Whole Foods Market provide is giving back to the global community. Whole Foods works to reduce hunger and poverty around the globe by offering them jobs. Grgurich (2012), "The Whole Planet Foundation, a partnership between Whole Foods Market and Nobel Prize winners Muhammad Yunus andGrameen Bank, provides grants to microfinance institutions in Latin America, Africa and Asia, which provide loans, training and other financial services to the self-employed poor." Whole Foods Market is a trust brand because, it likes the relationships we have with friends and family. They are doing their social responsibility to the world and society. Not just focusing on their own business. The reason why Whole......

Words: 280 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Apple, World's Most Valuable Company

...Apple has toppled Google as the world's most valuable brand Marketing Management – Assignment Case Study Report  CONTENTS CASE DESCRIPTION ...................................................................................................................................... - 3 INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................................................. - 4 HISTORY .......................................................................................................................................................... - 5 CREDIBILITY CHECK .................................................................................................................................... - 6 HOW APPLE ACHIEVED IT? ......................................................................................................................... - 7 Constantly Improving Products ..................................................................................................................... - 7 Creating New Products .................................................................................................................................. - 7 High Margins ................................................................................................................................................. - 8 Distribution .....................................................................................................

Words: 3428 - Pages: 14

Free Essay

Google; the Most Popular and Most Exciting Company

...Google; the most popular and most exciting company Google Google is indubitably the most popular and most exciting company in the world today. According to its corporate website, it's mission is to “organize the world's information and make it universally accessible and useful” (Google, 2010). Google ranked first place in Fortune Magazine's annual “Best Companies to Work For,” besting other top companies for two consecutive years, in 2007 and 2008. The most cited reason its performance as a top employer is because of its internal company culture. Google is the ultimate global company and is described as “high-energy, fast paced work environment” (Google, 2010). On its website, its policy of “favoring ability over experience” rings true as the employees of Google are all college degree holders at the very least. Because Google is oriented toward its “youthful” internet-savvy market, the average age of its employees is noticeably lower than most companies. The median age at Google is 30 years old and the gender distribution is 65% male and 35% female (Linkedin, 2010). The dress code is “casual” and laid-back because the company values ability and hard work, not appearance. Google has a very engaging company culture. Its headquarters at Google Mountain View, CA called Googleplex is designed to be have a “campus-like” feel attuned to its predominantly young college-level fresh recruits (Google, 2010). There are several facilities in Googleplex such as a café, snack rooms that......

Words: 770 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac

...1:10-2:25 Dr. Leinberger The Rescue of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac This paper analyzes the working paper of W. Scott Frame, Andreas Fuster, Joseph Tracy, and James Vickery and their views on the Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac bailout as well as gives a background on the companies and how the bailout was structured and will affect both the government and both firms. At the end I will also take a look at a few views of others on the issue of the bailout. I think that this is a very important topic because it played a huge role during the recession. The financial crisis that started from 2007 to 2008 could have had a completely different outcome had the government not stepped in a bailed out these two large investment firms. It has been a topic of much controversy because it could have had a very different outcome had the government not stepped in to prevent two of the largest investment companies but on the flip side they spend a lot of tax payer money on helping private companies that have failed while the rest of the economy is struggling as well. On September 6th, 2008 a federal conservatorship was imposed on two companies named Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. These two government sponsored enterprises (GSE) play a very central role in the US finance system. This was one of the biggest events during the financial crisis. At the beginning of their conservatorships they held or guaranteed about $5.2 trillion of home mortgage debt. Both companies are public financial......

Words: 3753 - Pages: 16