Free Essay

Examine the Argument That Neighbourly Relations Are Characterised by Friendly Stance.

In: Social Issues

Submitted By zapster70
Words 1024
Pages 5
Examine the argument that neighbourly relations are characterised by friendly stance.

In this assignment it will be a chance to examine friendly distance, which is when neighbours are friendly without being too intrusive, or too close. The examples that this essay will talk about is; Jovan Byford’s experience of neighbourly interaction on the doorstep, it will explore Evan Stokoe’ study of neighbourly disputes when boundaries are crossed and Stanley Brandes visit of a Spanish community.

The first example, of neighbourly relations are characterised by friendly stance,
Is the doorstep conversation between Jovan Byford and a neighbour? The scenario occurred after a parcel was misdelivered to a wrong address, 15 Cherry Avenue, and is kindly hand delivered by a neighbour to Jovan’s address, 15 Cherry Grove. Although it is a brief interaction between the two neighbours, it does show the behaviours and actions in a social situation. (Byford: 2009, p254) mentions that, Crowe talks about A neighbour is supposed to be ‘available in times of trouble’, friendly’ and ‘a bit of a giver’, but they should also ‘mind their own business’ and not to be ‘intrusive’. This is displayed between Byford and the neighbour as it is friendly, performed on the outside (front of house) and respects the neighbours boundaries. The interaction was basic and shows the roles that each of the neighbours plays. The lady is part of the friendly stance, apologising for bothering Mr Byford, as this is an ‘occasional activity’ and doesn’t want to feel intrusive, and acknowledging Mr Byford’s right to privacy. Then explaining where she lives, gives her identity, both relational as a neighbour and collective identity as a resident in the neighbourhood. This scenario shows that the neighbours can keep each other at arms length (friendly distance) without invited in or expecting to be invited in.

The second example to support the argument, that neighbourly relations are characterised by friendly stance, is Elizabeth Stokoe study of transcripts from recordings of a mediation session involving neighbour complaints. These complaints led to a dispute between neighbours, resulting in mediators discussing the conduct of a next door couple’s behaviour. On three occasions the young lady’s lovemaking was heard, bad language also, as they performed this act with their window wide open. This resulted in the speaker (neighbour) reporting it to the authorities. They speaker describes himself as good, reasonable and tolerant neighbour. He goes on to add that they talk to the next door and they did not walking by them even though this was occurring, attributes shown by the complainant are how a neighbour should interact. (Byford: 2009, p254) states that, ‘they acquire and developing this knowledge through socialisation practice-through the practice of being a neighbour. The friendly distance has been breached through the behaviour of the neighbour and inconsideration, which has caused the complainant feeling intruded upon, their privacy invaded shown by the lovemaking and bad language. This scenario shows that friendly distance was there, and had become tested by the lovemaking. The open window demonstrates the focus on privacy, the couple could have made love with their windows closed, which in turn would have been considerate and kept it private. The neighbour had reluctantly complained to the authorities before, shows that the neighbour wanted to continue the friendly stance. The mediation work would have helped renegotiate social rules, whilst repairing the relationship with the neighbours through verbal communications.

The last example to support the argument that neighbourly relations are characterised by friendly distance is Stanley Brandes stay in a village in western Spain called Becedas. Brandes spent time observing everyday habits and the culture of the local residents, and the intimacy. His initial experience of the local residents was the way that they freely entered, without hesitation, and unpacking Brandes’s belongings. They introduced themselves warmly, offering future assistance, and immediately pointing the way to their homes. As Brandes says ‘Neighbours took us under their wings to such an extent that we felt we had been initiated into a large family’
(Byford: 2009, p261). These both show the identities of relational identity, both as a neighbour and family. He noticed that the residence went in and out of each others houses without permission, also leaving windows and doors open.
(Byford: 2009,p261) states ’In Becedas, ‘not being intrusive’ and ‘reserve’ were not seen as characteristics of a ‘good neighbour’ but of someone is rude and impolite’. This is the opposite of the friendly stance shown in the first example of the doorstep conversation, where the neighbourly rules were acted out. This seemingly works on the surface for the community life of Becedas, but under the acting there is a lack of friendly distance, there are struggles behind the scenes. The carefree attitude on privacy and the boundaries were blurred, by windows and doors are open, which has led to the intrusiveness of the community. The residents had also become reliant on one another for manual and farm work, social and practical support, so becoming heavily dependent on each other. Brandes started to realise that this closeness developed into surveillance and control; to make sure nobody was hiding anything or scheming behind each others backs. With the ‘pathological fear’ of privacy and the social rules negotiated by the residences, this did not help with trust issues and having confidence in one another. In this neighbourhood the relations seemingly were based on their negotiated social orders, but friendly distance was breached when the community became too close, intrusive and over neighbourly, because of the blurred boundaries.

In this assignment it has discussed some ways where neighbours have developed a very good understanding way to relate to one another. It has also shown that when boundaries are breached, it leaves a neighbour feeling intruded upon and their privacy invaded (Elizabeth Stokoe), leading to a dispute. The assignment has also discussed the friendly distance becoming too close in a small community, which can cause control and surveillance. The argument that neighbourly relations are characterised by friendly distance is true, as the neighbourly relations can break down if social order is breached (noise from the neighbour) or communities getting too close.

Word count¬¬: 1008…...

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Wilson’s Stance During Ww1

...Cem Anil Kenar HIST104A-B02 Spg12 Wilson’s Stance during WW1: From “He kept us out of the War” to “Make the World Safe for Democracy” As it is well-known the World War I was primarily of a war fought due to imperialist aims, stemming from the need to satisfy the demand for raw material in the Europe. With the industrial revolution urge for raw material became of crucial importance for the European states. This was followed by the aggressive colonization projects that eventually led to a harsh competition between different parties around Europe, who want to hold control over the economic resources. The United States was not a super-power, as it is now, at the time of the War. Being aware of this Wilson opted to remain as a neutral observer during the initial phase of the war. It was the third year of the war, when the British intelligence intercepted the coded telegram dispatched by the Foreign Secretary of the German Empire, Arthur Zimmermann, on 16 January 1917. While the two blocs, The Entente Powers (France, The British Empire and Russia) vs. The Central Powers, (Austria-Hungary, Germany and the Ottoman Empire), were fairly evenly balanced between 1914 and 1917, with the year 1917 the Central Powers started to be weakened due to several reasons. The Americans were convinced that the Central Powers were doomed to lose the war, when the Zimmermann telegram was revealed. Therefore, Wilson aspired to take advantage of these circumstances and use the telegram as a......

Words: 2049 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

Neighbourly Relations Tma3 Dd131

...Examine the argument that neighbourly relations are characterised by friendly distance. The practice of being a neighbour is a complex one. There are unwritten rules and expectations of what being a neighbour constitutes. We as a neighbour tend to grow up being a neighbour, and as such we are expected to know how to behave, as a neighbour should. Various studies have given us an insight into to what is actually expected of a good neighbour. The following piece of work examines the argument that, neighbourly relations are characterised by friendly distance. It will also attempt to explain the unwritten rules and guidelines which we live to, in order to live together and yet at the same time live apart. Studies over the years in different settings show widespread agreement on what people in the neighbourhood want from those that live around them. Studies in the 1980s found that the main characteristics that people questioned highlighted were. Friendliness and helpfulness, and distance (Abrams and Brown, 1984). These characteristics appear not to be exclusive to the United Kingdom. Studies in the USA also found that neighbours were expected to be friendly but without intruding on one’s privacy (McGahan, 1972, p, 402). Kate Fox (2004) also suggests in her book that interaction between neighbours is primarily in public spaces and on the boundaries, these being defined as ‘gardens or hedges, driveways’. These spaces constitute a division between public and private places and......

Words: 1124 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Animal Testing: a Reasonable Stance

...Animal Testing: A Reasonable Stance Animals can give us love and happiness when we are caring for them as pets, but what else can animals give us? Over the past century animals have also given us vaccines, drugs, and more that have kept our society healthy and safe from deadly infections, all due to animal testing. But are the welfare of animals something that should be risked to make our lives better? The issue of animal testing has caused an ongoing battle in our society that deals with both science and animal rights. There are those who favor it because it is allows for scientific progress, and there are those who oppose it because it is the ethically right thing to do. Both sides have valid arguments, which most people choose to side with one or the other. With a better understanding of each side of the issue, animal testing, we can conceive a credible truth. The complex issue of animal testing is one that should not be researched in a bias way. One must explore both and all sides of the argument to come to a valid conclusion. While I have yet to find a piece of writing that equally argues both sides of animal testing, the combined research I have done on both sides of the spectrum allows for a solid foundation for this discussion. These two stances on animal testing are opposite not only in position on the issue, but also in reasoning. The side for animal testing is reasoning on the means of science and research used to develop new medical treatment, while the side......

Words: 2983 - Pages: 12

Free Essay

(I) Examine the View That the Cosmological Argument Provides an Explanation for the World and Is a Trustworthy Basis for Belief in the Existence of God. (21

...The cosmological argument (i) Examine the view that the cosmological argument provides an explanation for the world and is a trustworthy basis for belief in the existence of God. (21) The cosmological argument, also known as the first cause argument, is a classical argument for the existence of God. The word cosmological comes from the Greek for order and it is an inductive argument as the premises are true but the conclusion may not be, and it is also synthetic where the truth is determined by experience and needs to be proven. It is also a posteriori and also based on natural theology. The Cosmological argument finds its answer for the start of the universe through causes, meaning everything is caused by something, or everything is dependent on something else. The argument attempts to find proof for God’s existence stating that as something cannot come from nothing God must exist in order for anything and everything else to exist. The origins of the cosmological argument come from Greek philosophers Plato and Aristotle. Plato 428-347 BC records one of the earliest versions of the Cosmological arguments in his book of ‘Laws’. Plato writes about the argument through an exchange between an Athenian and Clianis. The Athenian attempts to prove the existence of the gods by arguing that, of all the different types of motion, the motion “which can move itself” is “necessarily the earliest and mightiest of all changes”. It is clear from his argument that infinite......

Words: 1053 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Examine How the Teleological Argument for the Existence of God Has Developed

...Examine how the Teleological Argument for the existence of God has developed. The teleological argument is the design argument for the existence of God. The name is derived from the Greek word ‘telos’ which means “end” or “purpose”. This theory speaks about things in the universe that appear to fulfil a purpose. Such design could not have occurred by chance, the only explanation has to do with references to an intelligent, personal being. This makes it an ‘a posteriori’ argument. The origin of the teleological argument dates back to the ancient Greek philosopher Plato (424-348 BCE) who believed in a pre-existent universe. He believed that the universe wasn’t created by an intelligent being which he referred to as the ‘demi-urge’. Instead his theory stated that the demi-urge did not create the universe ex nihilo, he simply developed a universe which he already existed in. For Plato, this was a rational explanation as to why there’s order in the world rather than chaos. Aristotle (384-322 BCE) who was a student of Plato also contributed to this theory. He considered that based on all that can be observed in the world and the stars above, the only explanation for all the complexity and beauty that the world contains was a divine intelligence. He believed that there was a first unmoved mover who is responsible for all order that exists. Such a God was also viewed as possessing intelligence, goodness, eternity yet remained incorporeal. St. Thomas Aquinas (13th century)......

Words: 926 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

The Argument Culture

...Let’s Look At All Sides Deborah Tannens, “The Argument Culture,” is an essay in which she voices her concern that our culture “urges us to approach the world, and the people in it, in an adversarial frame of mind” (404). This conveys that there is always a point to be argued and that most people voice their opinion in opposition. This not only causes problems in social circles, but on a worldwide scale as well. She explains that everything is set up as debate where it seems there has to be a winner and a loser. However, this is not always the case because opinions are neither right, nor wrong. That is why they are a personal opinion that a person feels. Tannen is concerned that the argument culture frame of mind leads us to believe that “every issue has two sides-no more, no less” (405). From my personal life experiences, I have observed this to be somewhat true. I don’t believe society portrays every issue to have a “right side” and a “wrong side.” Take the controversial subject of abortion for example. Some individuals believe that abortion is wrong no matter what the situation is, while others think it is a woman’s choice. Then there are the ones who are usually against it but think it is acceptable in certain situations. Or what about the up and coming topic of requiring drug testing for welfare recipients? Some people are all for it, some people think it is a waste of tax dollars, and others think it should be done if the person has had known drug problems in the......

Words: 927 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Examine the Factors That Have Affected the Domestic Divisions of Labour and Power Relations Between Couples

...Examine the factors that have affected the domestic division of labour and power relations between couples (24 marks) Domestic labour consists of housework, childcare and paid work that is being done in the family to keep the family supported. Parsons suggested that the husband and wife have different roles within the family; man’s role being instrumental and the woman’s role being expressive. He is expected to aim and achieve high so he can support the family financially and the wife will be expected to cook, clean, look after the children and be emotionally stable to do so. He said that men and women where biologically suited to these roles, as it was only natural for the men to be successful breadwinners and the women o be stay at home housewives. However a criticism from the march of the progress says that the only reason that things are getting better is because they feel that the men and women are becoming more equal and sharing the roles in the family. Anne Oakley argues that we still live in a patriarchal (male dominated) society, and therefore women occupy a subordinate and dependant role within the family. Young and Willmot (1973) said that the symmetrical family is becoming increasingly popular as this is a type of family in which the domestic chores, childcare and paid work roles are split equally between the man and woman. This family type is becoming so popular because women’s position in society has changed significantly over the recent years and it’s now......

Words: 576 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Pak-Ind Relations

...PAK-INDIA RELATIONS Section I: Introduction It is axiomatic that Pakistan and India share a turbulent and complex, if also short, history. While the dynamics of the relationship may shift from time to time, numerous existential issues remain in place. Characterised by mistrust, contrasting interests and the oft-quoted ‘missed opportunities’, the bloodshed of 1947 has been replaced by a more diverse set of issues that continue to mar the relationship. Kashmir has come to exemplify the classic case of a territorial dispute between neighbouring countries in the modern world composed of nation States. Extended hostile periods have only been sporadically separated by periods of relative peace – interludes that many hoped would prolong into perpetuity. But failures of State, internal conflicts, deep-rooted differences and perhaps unavoidable circumstances have meant that these spells of tranquillity remain mere specks of light in an otherwise dark corridor, at best offering missed opportunities. In studying the Pakistan-India ties, it is simplistic but also convenient to divide them into phases with regard to important junctures in South Asian history. None of the occasions that gave rise to optimism could ultimately become the watershed they were built up to be. The most recent such case was in 2004; following a prolonged period of military standoff, there began a ‘peace process’ led by President Musharraf and Prime Minister Vajpayee. This phase was significant since it......

Words: 15027 - Pages: 61

Free Essay

Critically Examine the Eap Debate

...‘Critically examine the EAP debate. Argue for one position. You may also support your argument with evidence drawn from your own experience.’ This paper critically examines the varied approaches to teaching English for Academic Purposes (EAP). In particular, it examines Critical Pedagogy, Pragmatic Pedagogy and Critical-Pragmatic Pedagogy in the context of teaching academic writing to university students. This is an important issue as there is widespread debate as to what constitutes effective EAP instruction within the academic sphere. The conflicting perspectives are that a critical approach to pedagogy, with its challenge of current ‘implicit and explicit standards’ (Cherryholmes: 1988) is most effective. Other academics argue the case of a vulgar pragmatic approach that relies on structure and ‘the notions of theory and practice’ (Williams: 1983). There is also support for a hybrid approach to EAP learning, known as critical pragmatism. This method encourages the characteristic critical pedagogical challenge of the status quo, while still requiring ideas to be translated and conveyed by means of structured ‘discourse practices’ (Cherryholmes: 1988). Finally, upon examining the aforementioned approaches to EAP by review of scholarly literature, I intend to argue affirmatively that vulgar-pragmatic based pedagogy is the best and most effective method of teaching EAP to university students. The concept of critical pedagogical learning relies on the principle that ‘the...

Words: 2060 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Examine the Factors Affecting the Domestic Division of Labour and Power Relations Between Couples (20 Marks).

...Examine the factors affecting the domestic division of labour and power relations between couples (20 marks). The domestic division of labour refers to the tasks that men and women do in relation to housework, childcare, and paid work. Sociologists are interested in the factors that affect domestic division of labour and whether men and women share domestic tasks equally. A factor affecting the domestic division of labour and power relations between couples is patriarchy. Patriarchy is when the father is the head of the family, dominating everything that happens. Men may feel as though they are the head of the family because they generally earn more money than women, making men feel more superior. This creates a division because the ‘man of the house’ may not allow for the wife to have an input or their opinion in a decision that the man has already made, leaving the wife to keep her ideas, thoughts, and opinions to herself. Also, as men feel as though they are the ones who bring the money into the family, they feel as though they do not need to help out with domestic tasks within the household. Another factor affecting the domestic division of labour is that there are instrumental and expressive roles in which the husband and wife play. In the traditional nuclear family, the roles of husbands and wives are separate and distinct from one another. Talcott Parsons created a functionalist model of the nuclear family in 1955 to show the clear division of labour between the......

Words: 551 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay


...Argument Essay Unit: Lesson Plan and Class Activities Global Learning Outcomes for this Unit *In the course of completing the assignment students will: • Learn to compose an argumentation-oriented thesis • Defend their thesis with academic-quality research that is properly sourced and cited as per the standard of university level writing • Anticipate and respond to counterarguments • Learn to critically engage the revision process through draft writing, instructor conferencing, and peer commentary • Respond the work of their peers as peer reviewers while providing relevant, productive feedback Class 1 – Introducing the Classical Argument Essay *Daily Learning Outcomes: • Reflect on Informative Essay • Introduce Classical Argument Essay • Break down the assignment sheet *Activity 1: Individual Reflection / Class Discussion (15 min) - Students open their portfolios and journals then reflect for ~10 minutes on their experiences during the Informative Essay Unit - Discuss reflections as a class *Activity 2: Introduce Classical Argument (20 min) - Have students bring a hard copy of the assignment to class with a highlighter: a. Get into groups of 4 b. Read the sheet aloud, highlighting all the action verbs c. Discuss the sheet as a group as instructor makes rounds *Activity 3: Mini-Lecture on Assignment /Questions (15 min) - Powerpoint slides “The Features of an Academic Argument” -......

Words: 4392 - Pages: 18

Free Essay

Critically Examine the Impact of a Recent or Proposed Change in Funding on Your Organisation’s Provision in Relation to the Teaching Remit.

...REPORT: Critically examine the impact of a recent or proposed change in funding on your organisation’s provision in relation to the teaching remit. Institutional Context, Nature and Purpose The Careers Development Group (CDG) is a Welfare to Work charity that supports unemployed customers to find and sustain meaningful employment. Customers are aged between 16-64 and referred to 13-week courses from Jobcentre Plus. Many have multiple barriers to employment such as lack of recent work experience, disabilities, health problems and lack of relevant employability skills. In addition, customers often face anxiety, depression and low self-esteem, all of which impact their ability to find employment. To overcome these complex needs, CDG provides training, work experience and other support that can enable customers to achieve a better quality of life. Back to Work activities include job search; job brokerage; work experience placements; environmental and community sector placements; vocational qualifications; information, advice & guidance; pre-employment training; motivation and confidence building; literacy, numeracy and ESOL training. Role within Institutional Context The role of the Senior Personal Advisor (SPA) consists of delivering Literacy, Numeracy and ESOL Qualifications. In addition, internal and external vocational qualifications such as Security, Retail, Forklift and Construction are also organised and financed via the SPA. City & Guilds award......

Words: 1715 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Examine the Argument for the Existence of God from Religious Experience

...The argument from religious experience is the argument from experiences of God to the existence of God. In its stronger form, this argument asserts that it is only possible to experience that which exists, and so that the ‘God’ therefore must be a God; case closed. In its weaker form (logically) the argument asserts only that religious experiences constitute evidence for God’s existence. Richard Swinburne has defended this form of argument with an appeal to the principle of credulity. The principle of credulity claims that rationally we should believe a person’s claim about what they have experienced. Generally, says Swinburne ‘it is reasonable to believe that the world is probably as we experience it to be. Unless we have an obvious objection to question a religious experience, therefore we should accept it as prima facie evidence from the existence of God at least. Although, the atheist Michael Martin criticised Swinburne’s use of the principle of credulity, If as Swinburne suggests that experiences are generally to be treated as veridical, an Atheist could logically argue that as he experiences the absence of God using the principle of credulity, that the world is then as this experience represents it as being Godless. Arguments therefore for the existence of God through credulity can be met with arguments from atheist experiences (fire with fire) which brings the two equal. Swinburne in defence argues that you can’t have a negative principle of......

Words: 1062 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Argument of the Bible, after some sham resistance, yielded. As a result these rates were at the moment too high for the state of the market and would have brought about a conspicuous amount of unemployment. But the ceaselessly progressive inflation very soon caught up with them. Then the unions asked again for new raises and so on. 7. The Purchasing Power Argument It does not matter what kind of justification the unions and their henchmen advance in favor of their claims. The unavoidable effects of forcing the employers to remunerate work done at higher rates than those the consumers are willing to restore to them in buying the products are always the same: rising unemployment figures. At the present juncture the unions try to take up the old, a-hundred-times-refuted purchasing-power fable. They declare that putting more money into the hands of the wage earners — by raising wage rates, by increasing the benefits to the unemployed and by embarking upon new public works — would enable the workers to spend more and thereby stimulate business and lead the economy out of the recession into prosperity. This is the spurious pro-inflation argument to make all people happy through printing paper bills. Of course, if the quantity of the circulating media is increased, those into whose pockets the new fictitious wealth comes — whether they are workers or farmers or any other kind of people — will increase their spending. But it is precisely this increase in spending that inevitably brings......

Words: 10118 - Pages: 41

Premium Essay

Will They Be Friendly?

...16. Will they be Friendly? One question that has plagued the minds of many an educated mind while living on planet earth is the existence of alien life. The earth, which is often referred to as ‘the world’, is the third planet from the Sun and the fifth largest of the eight planets in our Solar System. The earth is only a tiny part of our universe, which is made up of many planets, galaxies, clusters and super clusters. With such an enormous universe, it would be outrageous to even contemplate that there is no extraterrestrial life out there. With this question being so prominent, another question arises and that is ‘if there is other species of life out there, will they be friendly?’ From this question, we can make an assessment on whether we should be advertising our presence by sending messages to stars or just staying quiet. Extraterrestrial life is defined as life that does not originate from earth. ‘Referred to as alien life, or simply aliens these hypothetical forms of life range from simple bacteria-like organisms to beings far more complex than humans’1. Earth is moderately young compared to the rest of the universe, so therefore one can only assume these extra-terrestrials would be far more advanced and complex then ourselves. Although many scientists consider extra-terrestrial life to be plausible, no direct evidence has yet been found. If they do exist, we come back to our will they be friendly question, and we can use certain theories to explore this. A phrase......

Words: 1702 - Pages: 7