Premium Essay

Director Duties and Notion of True and Fair View

In: Business and Management

Submitted By chloeseah
Words 2999
Pages 12
1. Introduction Directors play vital role in corporate governance in which their poor management will lead to a significant change of shareholders value, measured by the company share prices. For example, ABC Learning Centre share price dropped 60% in 2 hours after it announced its profit fell 42% (Couriermail 2008). The purpose of this report is to outline the reasons of the collapses of ABC Learning Centre, Centro Properties Ltd and Hastie Group and the main financial disclosure issues raised. This report also includes amendments done by the Australian regulator to prevent such collapses and a discussion of directors’ duties to ensure the true and fair view of financial statements. 2. Brief background and the cause of financial problem 3.1 ABC Learning Centre In 2008, the ABC wrote off a loss of $437million, an amount which exceeds total profits of $300million in previous years (Schwab 2008). This means that ABC was indeed making losses since it was listed in 2001. The problem arose when new audit company, Ernst &Young, the new appointed audit team, found out that the company had reported payments from the developers as normal revenue hindering the fact that most centres were actually losing money. Moreover, an approximately of $206million indirect subsidy from the Federal Government via Child Care Benefit were reported (Rush & Downie 2006). Another problem is that its intangible assets consisted of various operating licenses worth $3.05billion on its balance sheet representing more than 70% of its total assets while the valuation of such assets remained questionable (Baaqeel 2011). Related-party transactions had also contributed to the misleading profit reported. ABC paid $27million to Austock who is a major shareholder of ABC as transaction fees, and $74million to Queensland Maintenance Services (QMS), that had the same…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Fiduciary Duties

...FIDUCIARY DUTIES AND OTHER RESPONSIBILITIES OF CORPORATE DIRECTORS AND OFFICERS Morrison & Foerster LLP Christopher M. Forrester Celeste S. Ferber RR DONNELLEY EZ START XBRL We Tag. You Validate. We File. With the release of the proposed rule, the SEC will require the use of XBRL for financial reporting starting as early as 2009 for some companies. RR Donnelley is uniquely qualified to give you guidance on how your company can prepare for the SEC mandate. As the market leader in XBRL filings, we have been helping leading companies successfully tag and file XBRL financials since the inception of the SEC Voluntary Filing Program. RR Donnelley’s proven EZ Start XBRL full-service solution is designed to save you crucial time. With EZ Start, we do the initial tagging for you, reducing the time spent mapping and validating XBRL tags to under ten hours. Our goal is to transfer knowledge to your financial team to ensure a firm understanding of the taxonomies, mapping process and SEC requirements. To learn more, visit FIDUCIARY DUTIES AND OTHER RESPONSIBILITIES OF CORPORATE DIRECTORS AND OFFICERS MORRISON & FOERSTER LLP Christopher M. Forrester Celeste S. Ferber RR Donnelley Global Capital Markets Copyright© 2008 Morrison & Foerster LLP (No claim to original U.S. Government works) All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic...

Words: 49138 - Pages: 197

Free Essay

Corporate Law Duties of Directors

...discussing the issues that are confronted by the directors of Hampton Park Pty Ltd (HP). The directors, William, Jack, Susan and Gail had their company liquidated shortly after declaring the dividend to their members. Unbeknown to the directors, the Chief Financial Officer of HP, George has been withholding information regarding the company’s deterioration of their financial position. Although late in realizing, George also failed to inform the board regarding the change in the dividend payment rules before the signed off their financial statement in 2010. The new payment rules that was enforced on 28 June 2010 stated in s254T of the Corporations Act 2001 points out that the company’s asset must exceed the liabilities immediately before the dividend is declared and the excess must be sufficient for the payment of the dividend. The company than went into liquidation after the dividend was paid. These issues will be discussed in further detail throughout the essay by examining the directors’ duty of care and the directors’ duty to not trade whilst insolvent and whether there is any breaches of these duties. These duties are set up to allow directors hold accountability and to minimize risk of wrongful or illegal behavior. Duties of a “Director” The term “director” is clarified under s 9 of the Corporations Act 2001, which states that “definition of a 'director' includes those appointed to the position of a director, an alternate director and those acting in the position even......

Words: 2108 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Director Duties

...Introduction The welfare of a company depends on the shoulders of the directors and the directors are also responsible for the interests of the company as well as shareholders. Directors are basically fiduciary agents and they owe duties to the company, directors' are appointed by the company's shareholders to run the company's affairs for the benefits of the shareholders. Moreover, no company can get success without having the good and honest directors, so company success can only be achieved, if the directors of the company fulfil their duties and complete enforcement of the director's duties. Therefore directors play very significant role in any corporate governance system. Director's general duties are based on the certain common law rules and equitable principles. Lord Judge Bowen explains director's duties in these beautiful words that “directors are described sometimes as agents, sometimes as trustees and sometimes as managing partners. But each of this expression is to be used not as exhaustive of their powers and responsibilities, but indicating useful points of view from which they may for the moment and for the particular purpose be considered.” The Chapter 1 of this paper is amid to critically analyze that what are the duties and responsibilities of directors under Companies Act 2006. The duties of directors alone are of no importance if they cannot be fully enforced, the chapter 2 of this piece of work relates to the system of enforcement which provides the......

Words: 8848 - Pages: 36

Premium Essay

Fair Trade

...Source: DE ECONOMIST 150, NO. 3, 2002 HOW FAIR IS FAIR TRADE? ** BY ROBBERT MASELAND AND ALBERT DE VAAL* Summary This paper investigates to what extent fair trade programmes, are indeed ‘fair.’ This is accomplished by comparing fair trade with free trade and protectionist trade regimes on their compliance of the criteria set by the fair trade movement itself. This comparison is made using comparative cost based models and economies of scale models. It is found that whether or not fair trade is superior to free trade or protectionism is highly dependent on a number of characteristics of the products to which fair trade is applied as well as on the context within which international trade takes place. 1 INTRODUCTION A long-standing debate in development economics has been the one between advocates of free trade and proponents of protectionism in developing countries. While the former argued that free trade would offer large opportunities for poor countries to improve their situation, the latter considered trade to be harmful to poorer countries and typically preferred a combination of protectionism and development aid. This opposition tended to dominate the discussion about the role of international trade in the Third World. Bhagwati 1993 , Krueger 1990 However, in recent years, a third position has come up. This position maintains that international trade can be beneficial to developing countries as long as it is performed in a just manner. The idea behind this is......

Words: 10145 - Pages: 41

Free Essay

Justifying Fiduciary Duties

...McGill Law Journal ~ Revue de droit de McGill JUSTIFYING FIDUCIARY DUTIES Paul B. Miller* Fiduciary duties are critical to the integrity of a remarkable variety of relationships, including those between trustee and beneficiary, director and corporation, agent and principal, lawyer and client, doctor and patient, parent and child, and guardian and ward. Notwithstanding their variety, all fiduciary relationships are presumed to enjoy common characteristics and to attract a core set of demanding legal duties, most notably a duty of loyalty. Surprisingly, however, the justification for fiduciary duties is an enigma in private law theory. It is unclear what makes a relationship fiduciary and why fiduciary relationships attract fiduciary duties. This article takes up the enigma. It assesses leading reductivist and instrumentalist analyses of the justification for fiduciary duties. Finding them wanting, it offers an alternative account of the juridical justification for fiduciary duties. The author contends that the fiduciary relationship is a distinctive kind of legal relationship in which one person (the fiduciary) exercises power over practical interests of another (the beneficiary). Fiduciary power is a form of authority derived from the legal capacity of the beneficiary or a benefactor. The duty of loyalty is justified on the basis that it secures the exclusivity of the beneficiary’s claim over fiduciary power so understood. Les obligations fiduciaires sont essentielles......

Words: 25852 - Pages: 104

Premium Essay

The Role of Non-Executive Directors

...NON-EXECUTIVE DIRECTORS Essentially the non-executive director's (NED) role is to provide a creative contribution to the board by providing independent oversight and constructive challenge to the executive directors. NED could act as the 10th man in ‘10th man idea’ where his/her role is to disagree no matter how improbable the idea nine people agree on something. He/ She may present a case for an alternative viewpoint — no matter how ridiculous the idea sounds. If his evidence is still inferior and conflicts with the consensus of the other nine men, then they go through with their original plan. If the tenth man’s ideas prove to be superior, they explore his ideas further. Therefore, with NED argument and consultation, the decision that come out from boardroom has been consolidated and unbiased. The 1992 Cadbury Report initiated a debate about the main functions and responsibilities of non-executive directors. Today, it is widely accepted that non-executive directors have an important contribution to make to the proper running of companies and, therefore, more widely to the economy at large. As the Cadbury Report said, they: “should bring an independent judgement to bear on issues of strategy, performance and resources including key appointments and standards of conduct.”     There is no legal distinction between executive and non-executive directors. As a consequence, in the UK unitary board structure, non-executive directors have the same legal duties,......

Words: 1142 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Deconstructing Independent Directors

...“Deconstructing Independent Directors”(*) María Gutiérrez Maribel Sáez Universidad Carlos III de Madrid and ECGI Universidad Autónoma de Madrid January 2012 Abstract In this paper we argue that boards of directors lack the mandate, the incentives and the ability to control insiders, especially in jurisdictions where the main agency problem arises between controlling and minority shareholders. We analyze the problems that render independents an inefficient monitoring device for companies with concentrated ownership structures and conclude that the current focus of the regulators and codes of best practice on empowering independents is ineffective and companies would be better off choosing their board members at liberty. Nevertheless, we also present two different proposals for reform: independents as gatekeepers for the regulator and independents as surrogates of the minority. Both proposals are based on the idea that if independent directors are expected to monitor controlling shareholders their most important characteristic should be accountability rather than mere independence. JEL Classifications: G32; G34; K22 Keywords: Independent directors, Board of directors, Concentrated ownership, Monitoring, Corporate Law (*)The authors wish to thank, Jesus Alfaro, Magda Bianco, Fernando Gómez Pomar and Assaf Hamdani and seminar audiences at AEDE 2010 and SIDE 2011 for many useful comments. The contents of this paper are the sole responsibility......

Words: 17280 - Pages: 70

Free Essay

Directors Duties and Responsibilities

...Executive Summary ________________________________________ ‘Do directors have to be accounting standard gurus?’ ‘How do directors spot the ticking bomb buried deep in a massive board pack? These are some of the questions making top headlines following the Centro case decision made by Justice Middleton of the Federal Court on the 27 June 2011. The issue of contention was whether the directors had sufficiently carried out a review of the financial statements, and if they had, whether the information was consistent with the directors’ knowledge of the company’s operations and whether the accounts contained all material information that should have been reported on and known to the directors. ASIC successfully won the case with the eight defendants (Chief Executive Officer, Chief Financial Officer, Chairman and 5 other non-executive directors) found guilty of failing to identify and disclose significant errors in the 2007 consolidated financial statements of Centro Properties Limited, Centro Property Trust and Centro Retail Trust (collectively referred to as Centro). Financial statements are essential for the accurate assessment of risks faced by any company. The decision in the Centro case clearly emphasises this point. Directors should be well equipped with basic accounting knowledge and be conscious of their duty to properly assess and review financial statements. It was also highlighted that directors should be warned against simply delegating financial......

Words: 2605 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

The Fair Presentation Requirements of International Accounting Standard 1 Will Undermine the Uk’s View of True and Fair

...The Fair Presentation Requirements of International Accounting Standard 1 will Undermine the UK’s View of True and Fair During the last 20/30 years there has been an increase in trade and communication. It is easier for people to do business across the world as the new technology allows this to be possible. The problem with this is that different countries have different ways of accounting standards, and therefore there is a problem on how to account standards. Hence, during the last years the debate on whether to use Fair presentation or the True and fair View is becoming a major concern. Fair presentation and the true and fair concept may seem as a similar concept, however, they do differ as well. While the former is the concept for United States, the latter is used in the UK, EU, Singapore, Australia and New Zealand. The IASB job is to prepare a “high quality global accounting standard that requires transparent and comparable information in general purposes financial statements”. According to the International Accounting Standard Board (IASB) the fair presentation is the concept which should be used, while the UK’s company act believe it’s the true and fair view ( TFV). The latest version of International accounting standard (IAS1) was brought into action from July 1998. This adopted both concepts, and it “required fair presentation and disclosure of compliance with IAS and a limited true and fair view override if compliance is misleading” . Fair presentation comes...

Words: 1713 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Directors Duties Section 228(1) of the Companies Act 2014 details the eight fiduciary duties directors of companies are obliged and compelled by law to comply with. The question is why it is necessary through the application of law to limit director’s decision making responsibility. The potential for directors to abuse their positions of power with regards to company’s assets in the daily running of the company seems limitless even when directors are in their own perception acting bona fides with regards to their decisions. Section 228(1) is so important and appropriate to business law as Directors are persons who according to Callanan(2007,p207) ‘have been entrusted with powers for the benefit of others’ but the potential to damage one person or persons to benefit another is so highly possible that the law is compelled to control directors decisions. Section 228(1) (d) addresses a directors duties ‘to not use the company’s property, information or opportunities for his or her own or anyone else’s benefit’. The case of Regal Hastings v Gulliver (1942) is one which has involved much debate throughout the years. The directors of Regal although acting in their opinion bona fides, through holding a position as directors were privy to information that, had they not held their position as directors would not have been able to benefit from the transaction that they undertook. The key point behind this case was that directors are exposed to sensitive and sometimes exclusive information and......

Words: 2154 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

With Reference to the Zimbabwean Context, Discuss the Extent to Which Directors Are Fulfilling Their Duties?

...Directors perform various duties within a company and these involve the coordination, leading, controlling and planning of a company’s resources so that set objectives and targeted are achieved. According to Abbort (1996), Directors are persons to whom the management of the company is entrusted. In Zimbabwe every company has the statutory obligation to have at least two directors of them one shall be a true ordinary resident of Zimbabwe; this requirement is according to the Companies Act (24:03) section 169(1). Some of the duties of directors are discussed below: To select competent executive officers It is the primary duty of a board of directors to select and appoint executive officers who are qualified to administer the company’s affairs effectively and soundly. It is also the responsibilities of the board of directors to dispense with the services of officers who prove to be unable to meet reasonable standards of executive ability and professionalism. A good example was portrayed by Econet PVT LTD directors who selected a highly educated directorate of executive officers with the likes of DouglasMboweni who is qualified and competent. To effectively supervise the company’s affairs The charter and degree of supervision required of an organization’s board of directors to assure a soundly managed organization involves reasonable business judgement and competent and sufficient time to become informed of the organization’s affairs. Directors cannot avoid responsibility for...

Words: 1404 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

Duty of Care

...Donoghue v Stevenson (duty of care) The first element in a claimant’s case negligence is whether the defendant owed him a duty to take reasonable care. Duty of care therefore, exists as a control devise in order to determine who can bring an action for negligence and in what circumstances. When a person suffers loss as a result of negligent conduct, they will want to shift that loss on to the person who caused it though negligence action. When a negligence action is brought to court, the judge will usually be able to rely on precedent to determine whether a duty of exists. But what if there is no precedent? What test should the judge use to determine whether a duty of care exists? Negligence liability has existed in one form or another for centuries, but until the 19th century there was no concept of duty as we now know it. Liability existed within defined relationships such as doctor-patient or employer-employees. Where a case fell outside a recognised relationship, there was no test for determining whether liability existed or not until the most famous case in legal history Donoghue v Stevenson in 1932. In Donoghue, the claimant suffered illness as a result of consuming a ginger beer bought by her friend. She could not sue the retailer nor the manufacturer as she had no contract with both of them. On the facts the café owner would have been liable to the friend for breach of contract in selling him a defective product, if the friend had suffered damage. However the......

Words: 1080 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Fiduciary Duties

...Title: Fiduciary obligations may spring up by reason of relationships of trust and confidence or confidential relations. Introduction Fiduciary is an important issue arises in business relationships, in partnerships, it helps create a fair business environment for all the parties when working together, in agency, it protects the principles' benefits, in corporations, it may lead the business operates properly and legally. Therefore, fiduciary obligations are closely related to co-operations Trust and confidence are the most important elements in these fiduciary relations, in this essay, the relationship of a fiduciary obligation and above relations will be demonstrated and explained. Table of Content Introduction P.1 Table of Content P.2 The Basic Concept of Fiduciary P.3 Fiduciary Concepts and Obligation vs Partnership Relations P.6 Fiduciary Concepts and Obligation vs Corporate Relations 1. Directors P.8 2. Promoters P.11 Conclusions P.13 Bibliography P.14 The Basic Concept of Fiduciary Fiduciary, under oxford’s dictionaries’ definition, is trustee who is given control or powers of administration of property in trust with a legal obligation to administer the beneficiary’s interest, and the Cambridge dictionary defines “relating to the responsibility to look after someone else's money in a correct way”. It is obvious that the fiduciary concept involves the element of mutual...

Words: 2685 - Pages: 11

Free Essay


...topic Directors of Company While engaging ourselves in making this report, we gained useful information related to the procedures of election of directors and also find the eligibilty criteria for the election of directors other issue related to director of company. We have worked hard in making this report. We hope that it will fully serve its purpose. We appreciate your support in making this report and we also look forward to your feedback which will be helpful for us. Please check the enclosed report. Sincerely, Syed Abid Haider Mohammed Waqas Manzoor Encl. (1) LETTER OF ACKNOWLEDGEMENT All thanks to Almighty GOD, who is most merciful, who granted and helped us to work on this report. We would like to express our gratitude towards our parents for their kind co-operation and encouragement which helped us in completion of this report. We would also like to extend our gratitude towards our faculty Mr. Muhammad Zia Kayani, who gave us an opportunity to do a research and to make a report related to our course outline. We have made a report on Directors of Company Respectfully yours, Syed Abid Haider (12784) Mohammed Waqas Manzoor (12782) TABLE OF CONTENTS 1. LETTER OF TRANSMITTAL 1 2. LETTER OF ACKNOWLEDGEMENT 2 3. TABLE OF CONTENT 3 4. DEFINITION OF DIRECTOR 4 5. KINDS OF DIRECTORS 8 6. APPOINTMENT OF FIRST DIRECTOR 11 7. ELECTION OF DIRECTOR 14 8. METHOD OF VOTING 17 9. LOANS TO DIRECTORS 19 10. POWERS AND DUTIES OF DIRECTORS 23 11...

Words: 4829 - Pages: 20

Free Essay

Duties of Directors

...Directors of a company normally have exclusive power to manage the company’s business and exercise its powers. At common law, the duties were owed to the company, to employees, to individual shareholders and creditors. 1.0 Duties of Directors to the company It is convenient to categorise the duties of directors into fiduciary duties which arise because they are quasi-trustees of the assets of the company. The word ‘fiduciary’ refers to trust and confidence. ‘A fiduciary is someone who has undertaken to act for or on behalf of another in a particular matter in circumstances which give rise to a relationship of trust and confidence’(Bristol and West Building Society v Mothew [1998] Ch1 per Millet LJ at p.18). Fiduciary duties of the directors of a company considered are imposed on them by equity for the protection of the persons for whom they act. Directors’ fiduciary duties are mandatory element of company law; they are imposed by the courts all directors of all companies. A director of a company holds an office not an employment, and is on duty all the time while holding the office: there are no off-duty hours when the director is free from his or her fiduciary duties (Gwembe Valley Development Co. Ltd v Koshy [1998] 2 BCLC 613) Some people argue that that is inappropriate to apply the concept of a fiduciary, which is derived from the concept of trustee, to company directors. Trustees are supposed to be prudent, risk-averse people whose priority is to preserve the capital......

Words: 620 - Pages: 3