Premium Essay

Critically Evaluating an Argument

In: Social Issues

Submitted By floetry61
Words 297
Pages 2
Title | Investigating a Problem and Refining a Solution |

Assessment Part A: Investigating and Rating Sources of Information | Is the website from Kathleen credible? | The website from Kathleen is credible. | The website from Kathleen is not credible. | | Is the website from Kathleen relevant? | The website from Kathleen is not relevant. | The website from Kathleen is somewhat relevant. | The website from Kathleen is highly relevant. | | Is the survey from Martine credible? | The survey from Martine is credible. | The survey from Martine is not credible. | | Is the survey from Martine relevant? | The survey from Martine is not relevant. | The survey from Martine is somewhat relevant. | The survey from Martine is highly relevant. | | Is Naureen's story credible? | Naureen's story is credible. | Naureen's story is not credible. | | Is Naureen's story relevant? | Naureen's story is not relevant. | Naureen's story is somewhat relevant. | Naureen's story is highly relevant. | | Is the American Medicine article credible? | The American Medicine article is credible. | The American Medicine article is not credible. | | Is the American Medicine article relevant? | The American Medicine article is not relevant. | The American Medicine article is somewhat relevant. | The American Medicine article is highly relevant. | | Is the article from Deanne credible? | The article from Deanne is credible. | The article from Deanne is not credible. | | Is the article from Deanne relevant? | The article from Deanne is not relevant. | The article from Deanne is somewhat relevant. | The article from Deanne is highly relevant. | |

Assessment Part B: Identify the Steps and Refine a Solution to a Problem | Policy A: Issue – The policy is highly…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Critically Discuss the Arguments for Free Trade, Paying Attention to Winners and Losers

...1. Critically discuss the arguments for free trade, paying attention to winners and losers. Free trade as an argumentative policy which has being discussed up till these days since it was established. Debaters formed by two groups of people where one kept being supportive and one held back against this policy. Although the opposing side lists out three points which are unbalanced development, economic dependence and environmental problems to prove that free trade is harmful to less developed countries. On the other hand, supporters try to use increase production and efficiency, economic growth and employment opportunity and consumer satisfaction to prove that all parties benefit from free trade where less developed countries only be less benefits. In this essay, as one of the members supporting free trade agreement I will look deeper into all six points and prove how the advantages within far more excel the disadvantages. Firstly, increase production and efficiency is the most significant advantage of free trade among the above three points. As different countries specialized in different fields, by making use of this comparative advantage, they can allocate resources in the most efficient way where therefore export increases a country’s production demand and import increases competitions between companies where they have to decrease price as a result, the resources are bought cheaper due to competition. With the example shows in Diagram 1, it can convince the theory......

Words: 1129 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Critically Evaluate Locke’s Argument Against Innate Ideas

...Critically Evaluate Locke’s Argument against Innate Ideas In the enquiry, Locke talks of the notion of innate ideas as being ‘an established opinion amongst some men,’ this opinion can be seen as a direct conflict with Locke’s empiricism. Locke’s philosophical standpoint is that the mind gains ideas and concepts solely through experience; he argues that when we are born, we are born tabula rasa, a blank slate free from any knowledge or understanding and it is as we grow and experience the world around us that we form knowledge. The notion of innate ideas and principles then is clearly in complete contrast with Locke’s epistemology and as such Locke needs to show the arguments in favour of innate ideas to be flawed. I will show how Locke focuses his attack on one major assertion for the innate concept thesis, known as the great argument; how his two major problems with this argument are unfounded and how we can hold onto the concept of innate ideas in light of Locke’s criticisms. The great argument which Locke views as the main argument in favour of innate ideas goes as such: 1: If a principle is universally accepted then it is innate (as are the ideas which make it up) 1 2: There are some principles which are universally accepted 3: These principles (and the ideas which make them up) are innate This argument can be seen as fairly self-explanatory, but it does seem to rely completely on two major assumptions. Firstly, that all universally accepted principles must be......

Words: 1664 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Critically Evaluating the News

...Critically Evaluating the News It is important to make a critical evaluation of any news story. People shouldn’t believe everything they hear on the news because it is possible for a reporter to somehow get their information wrong because of someone that is not completely honest or not getting both sides of the story. Although I am sure news reporters try to make sure that they do have all of the correct information there is always that small chance that they don’t. There is also the possibility of maybe having a misprint in the news as well. I feel that the headline I chose “Obama presses Congress for deal to end spending cuts” is very clear and accurate because it goes into detail about what President Obama is trying to do and what can happen if they do not make a deal. It basically states the issue and the consequences of the issue if it is not resolved. I do not really think that there were any facts ignored in this article although I am not one hundred percent into politics and economics to be completely sure. I think that the story had a lot of alternative perspectives because the author mentioned that if a deal was not made Spetalnick (2013), “Thousands of Americans who serve their country would see their wages cut and hours reduced”. It also stated other things that may or will happen as well. The author does assume that there are no signs of negotiation (Spetalnick, 2013). It is very important to make distinctions when doing a......

Words: 430 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Discuss and Critically Evaluate the Arguments Put Forward by the Specific Ingredients Perspective and the Common Factors Perspective, Regarding the Mechanism and Effectiveness of Counselling and Psychotherapy.

...Discuss and critically evaluate the arguments put forward by the specific ingredients perspective and the common factors perspective, regarding the mechanism and effectiveness of counselling and psychotherapy. Since its development during the 19th century more than three hundred and fifty distinct popular counselling and psychotherapy strands have emerged into the modern counselling field (Sparks, Duncan & Field, 2008). The years prior to psychotherapy’s birth were dominated by psychoanalytic and psychodynamic approaches and its practice was largely restricted to physicians (Miller, Hubble, Chow & Seidel, 2013). Psychotherapy’s arrival was not unnoticed from opposing schools of thought who were quick to question its scientific basis. Traditionally Eysenck (1952) not only challenged psychotherapy’s efficacy but also argued that it was “potentially harmful” (Miller, Hubble, Chow & Seidel, 2013:88). However, supporters of psychotherapy refuted Eysenck’s (1952) view and debate surrounding the fields worth began to accumulate. As a result psychotherapy research for the next few decades would focus on determining whether therapy was effective (House & Loewenthal, 2009). Subsequently, a plethora of studies that demonstrated its efficacy emerged (Smith Miller & Glass, 1980; Lambert & Bergin, 1994; Ahn & Wampold, 2001). So much so, that early studies revealed the treated population fared much better in comparison to their untreated counterparts (Sparks,......

Words: 4608 - Pages: 19

Premium Essay

Evaluating an Argument

...Constitution’s Fourth Amendment restrictions on unreasonable searches (Washington Post, 2013). The judge also rejected the applicability of the 1979 ruling that offered no constitutional protection to metadata, with the argument that Americans’ “relationship with technology has changed drastically now that cellphones and tablet computers are so ubiquitous and powerful and that the government ability to collect information in bulk and hold it in perpetuity changes the context decisively from the 1979 case.” The concluding part of the article argues that the NSA’s activities will continue to litigate in court and in the court of public opinion. If the government is to emerge from Mr. Snowden’s revelations with the authorities that officials insist are crucial, it have to do more to demonstrate why they are essential and how Americans’ privacy is being protected. The style of argument used in this article is an inductive argument, in the sense that the author is attesting that the truth of the conclusion necessarily follows the premises of the argument. According to Jackson and Newberry (2010), an inductive argument is one in which the argue attempts to demonstrate that the truth of the conclusion probably follows from the premises (pg. 119). The first premise of the argument is that bulk collection of phone and call records by are potentially powerful tool. The second premise is if these records are abuse could reveal sensitive facts about nearly every American’s life. ......

Words: 900 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Evaluating a Historical Argument

...Evaluating a Historical Argument 1. The main purpose of this article is the debate over whether the United States should annex the Philippines to the US territories or not.  2. The key question that the author is addressing is: why did the US decide to establish an overseas empire? 3. The most important evidence in this article is: a) “The [decision] for annexing the Philippines empire provides a powerful case study—for some, a cautionary tale—regarding the unintended consequences of intervening in foreign lands” (Hollitz Thinking through The Past, ch.4, pg. 79, paragraph 3). In that case, the consequence happened to be a bloody military bath on both sides. b) “…some scholars argue that democratic or popular influences play an important role in shaping policy” (Hollitz Thinking through The Past, ch.4, pg. 79, paragraph 4). Popular influences did play an important role in deciding on whether annexing Philippines were a wise decision or not. However, it didn’t necessarily mean the government had to listen to it. c) “…by the 1960s, the Vietnam War had created doubts among many Americans about popular influence on government policy and the motives of elite policy makers” (Hollitz Thinking through The Past, ch.4, pg. 80, paragraph 8). Here, they realized that just because something is popular doesn’t mean it is good for the public as a whole. d) “…American leaders realized the economic benefits of overseas expansion and led the nation to war with Spain to......

Words: 565 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Critically Evaluate the Arguments for and Against Mining and Export of Uranium

...Queensland 8. Conclusions This report was prepared under the joint auspices of the unions and environmental and social justice groups listed on the cover. March 2013. Authors: R. Taubenfeld, D. Sweeney, J. Green High Risk – Low Return: The case against uranium mining in Queensland In October 2012 the LNP government broke its clear commitment not to allow uranium mining in Queensland. This commitment was the position of the LNP at the March 2012 state election and was reaffirmed after they took office. In the absence of open, inclusive and evidence based policy making, the Newman LNP government has set up the Uranium Implementation Committee. The Committee has not sought broad community input and has not been asked to assess the arguments for and against uranium mining in Queensland. The Committee’s mandate is the far narrower task of recommending how uranium mining should be managed, not whether it should occur. Why should Queensland forego the economic benefits of uranium mining when some other states permit uranium mines? In a nutshell, it is because the economic benefits are grossly overstated and are outweighed by the wide-ranging environmental, public health and weapons proliferation problems and risks. Uranium accounted for 0.19 per cent of Australia's export revenue in 2011/12 (the last available figures)1. By the most generous estimate, uranium accounts for 0.015% of all jobs in Australia.2 For Queensland, there is the additional limitation that the state......

Words: 8778 - Pages: 36

Free Essay

What Is Non-Cognitivism? Critically Evaluate the “Wishful Thinking” Argument Against Non-Cognitivism

...particular view of non-cognitivism is mostly targeted by the wishful thinking argument. I will then outline the main problem brought up by the wishful thinking argument. I will then outline the expressionist’s responses to the wishful thinking argument using David Enoch and James Lenman’s solutions to the problem, and show the flaws in their arguments. Therefore I will come to the conclusion that the wishful thinking argument is a valid objection to non-cognitivism. Non-Cognitivism Non cognitivism is the objection to the claim the moral facts express belief. According to this view they are not either true or false, neither do the assert anything about the world. Seeing as moral facts cannot be seen as true and no one can have knowledge of something that is not true, non-cognitivism implies the moral knowledge is impossible. The three main forms of non-cognitivism are; prescriptivism, emotivism and expressivism. In this essay I will be addressing the problems found in the expressivism branch of non-cognitivism. Expressivism Expressivism is the view that sentences about moral facts are not to descriptive terms, and do not relate to the real world problems. They are used for expressing either positive or negative attitude towards the object of the sentence. The Wishful-thinking argument This is an argument that rejects non-cognitivism presented by Cian Dorr (2002). The outline of this argument is the fact that we can come to a conclusion about how the world is, based on......

Words: 1686 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay


...Argument Essay Unit: Lesson Plan and Class Activities Global Learning Outcomes for this Unit *In the course of completing the assignment students will: • Learn to compose an argumentation-oriented thesis • Defend their thesis with academic-quality research that is properly sourced and cited as per the standard of university level writing • Anticipate and respond to counterarguments • Learn to critically engage the revision process through draft writing, instructor conferencing, and peer commentary • Respond the work of their peers as peer reviewers while providing relevant, productive feedback Class 1 – Introducing the Classical Argument Essay *Daily Learning Outcomes: • Reflect on Informative Essay • Introduce Classical Argument Essay • Break down the assignment sheet *Activity 1: Individual Reflection / Class Discussion (15 min) - Students open their portfolios and journals then reflect for ~10 minutes on their experiences during the Informative Essay Unit - Discuss reflections as a class *Activity 2: Introduce Classical Argument (20 min) - Have students bring a hard copy of the assignment to class with a highlighter: a. Get into groups of 4 b. Read the sheet aloud, highlighting all the action verbs c. Discuss the sheet as a group as instructor makes rounds *Activity 3: Mini-Lecture on Assignment /Questions (15 min) - Powerpoint slides “The Features of an Academic Argument” -......

Words: 4392 - Pages: 18

Free Essay

Thinking Critically

...outcome, given the consequences?  The best outcome for this situation would be to allow the energy companies limited access to the reserve. Strict regulations set upon the energy companies in order that they dispose of waste properly and do not disturb the ecosystem they are drilling in. This is best because the country can benefit from the gas that is drilled and the animals can continue to strive, even the rare Sage-Grouse. Critical thinking and ethics go hand in hand because decisions that require ethical compos should be taken seriously. Using all the facts and evaluating the outcomes before making a logical and morally right decision is what critical thinking does with ethics. In conclusion the ethical and moral responsibility should be governed with a more strict hand. The ecosystem will be affected by any type of drilling and the energy companies are growing in numbers each year. Thinking critically about what is best for the land at hand would require more than one mind to make fair decisions rather than one or two people who fear for their livelihood. References To Drill or Not to Drill. (2004, July). Nightline, (), . Retrieved from Nicholas Manias. (2013). Ethics Applied. Retrieved from Nicholas Manias, ETH/316 website....

Words: 579 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Critically Asses, with Reference to William James, the Arguments from Religious Experience.

...someone who has been inspired by their beliefs and experience of God would be Martin Luther King. For James, no use of drugs or auto-suggestion could produce the visions and voices which often play a part in religious conversion. Nor could they produce the moral change conversion brings. In constructing his argument James was influenced by the work of the mystic St Teresa of Avila who argued that the genuineness of a religious experience is the permanent change it creates in someone’s character and whether it is consistent with the teaching of the church in what it reveals. But this does not prove that the claimed religious experience reveals God: it demonstrates only the sincerity of the believer. If I sincerely believed I had received a vision from God, it would change my life, perhaps for the better but my sincere belief might still be mistaken. Others pointed out that the fact that what a voice says fits in with Church teaching in no way proves the person heard the voice of God rather than a voice in their own mind. If this is the case, there is still no objective way to differentiate between religious experiences, drug induced visions and hallucinations and James’ argument is further weakened. In addition many people claim that the common core of religious experiences do reveal a consistent picture of God, for example, visions and voices reveal a God who communicates with his people. In response, many philosophers have pointed out that, for example, the majority of......

Words: 1684 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Critically Evaluating Reflective Practice

...[pic] Reflective Practice EDU 2071-N Critically Evaluating Reflective Practice. Leigh William Adams. M1106275 D.O.S: 10/12/2015 Word count: 2000 Introduction. This essay will look at the use of reflective practice in a vocational construction setting, it will look at various practitioners’ theories and how they may be implemented into the current strategy. Reflective practice can be an essential tool in vocational based professional learning settings where people learn from their own experiences, rather than from formal learning or knowledge transfer. It may be the most important source of personal professional development and improvement. It is also an important way to bring together theory and practice; through reflection a person is able to see and label forms of thought and theory within the milieu of their work. The essay will also look at the use of reflective practice with learners at a behavioural school. Each section will cover different topics, section one will cover the understanding of critical reflection, section two will show how critical reflection is used for behaviour, section three shows its use in the construction industry and section four will briefly cover other authors and their respective models. Section 1. In order to be effective teachers must be reflective; they must continuously review their practice, discuss it with their colleagues, consider their learners’ responses and seek to develop...

Words: 2279 - Pages: 10

Free Essay


...Classic Model for an Argument No one structure fits all written arguments. However, most college courses require arguments that consist of the following elements. Below is a basic outline for an argumentative or persuasive essay. This is only one possible outline or organization. Always refer to your handbook for specifics. I. Introductory Paragraph o Your introductory paragraph sets the stage or the context for the position you are arguing for. o This introduction should end with a thesis statement that provides your claim (what you are arguing for) and the reasons for your position on an issue. A. Your thesis: o states what your position on an issue is o usually appears at the end of the introduction in a short essay o should be clearly stated and often contains emphatic language (should, ought, must) B. Sample Argumentative Thesis o The production, sale, and possession of assault weapons for private citizens should be banned in the U.S. II. Body of your Argument A. Background Information o This section of your paper gives the reader the basic information he or she needs to understand your position. This could be part of the introduction, but may work as its own section. B. Reasons or Evidence to Support your Claim o All evidence you present in this section should support your position. This is the heart of your essay. Generally, you begin with a general statement that you back up with specific details or examples. Depending on how long your argument is, you will need to......

Words: 684 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Critically Evaluating an Academic Article

...Matalan is the UK’s leading out of town fashion and homeware retailer and operates through 216 stores in the UK with an e-commerce platform and 11 overseas franchise stores. The company also operates with a purely online direct store and after their recent success with bathroom furniture saw the 2015 launch of Matalan value bedroom furniture from children’s pieces as well as higher end options, Maker (2015, p.13). Matalan Retail Limited was taken private in December 2006 by the acquisition of its parent company, Matalan Plc (now delisted and known as Matalan Limited), by Missouri Bidco Limited, subsequently renamed Matalan Finance Limited. Matalan Finance Limited has subsequently become a public limited company and is ultimately controlled by the Hargreaves family. This strategic starting point ensures the company’s performance is aligned positively with the ever-changing influences that may affect business environment. The radical and on-going changes occurring in society creates an uncertain environment and have a very big impact on the function of the whole organisation. I will conduct a PESTLE analysis concentrating on possible issues that may affect Matalan PLC. Matalan PLC is sensitive to a number of political factors being a department store supplying clothing alongside footwear and housewares. One of these factors consist of changes to the UK governments national minimum wage, as of 1st April 2016 rates rose from £6.70 to £7.20 for employees of a certain age GOV UK,...

Words: 1231 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Examining Arguments

...Examining Different Arguments Pamela C Purvis HUM/111 July 29, 2012 Jennifer L. Bingham, JD Examining Different Arguments Title | Examining Different Arguments Related to the Choice of a Career | Assessment Part A: Critically Evaluating an Argument | Build your mindmap. | Arts and Sciences (Advantage): Lots of flexibility in career choices: Logically Sound | Arts and Sciences (Disadvantage): Leads to a career in food service - 'Do you want fries with that?': Irrational Appeal | Education (Advantage): The best way to make a difference in the world: Either/Or Thinking | Education (Disadvantage): Guaranteed low paying job: Overgeneralization | Nursing (Advantage): People always will need nurses: Logically Sound | Nursing (Disadvantage): Too much schooling (according to Theo, the Law student): Overgeneralization | Information Systems and Technology (Advantage): No other degree concentration is as innovative (according to Grace): Either/Or Thinking | Information Systems and Technology (Disadvantage): Too limited in scope for much advancement in business situation (according to Ritesh): Shifting the Burden of Proof | Business (Advantage): Infinite career options (according to Ritesh): Overgeneralization | Business (Disadvantage): Boring work, stuck behind a desk all day: Overgeneralization | Health and Human Services (Advantage): All the benefits of Arts and Sciences, but vastly more focused and......

Words: 649 - Pages: 3