Premium Essay

Critically Discuss the Issue of Priority Setting Within the Nhs

In: Social Issues

Submitted By debbie1964
Words 4311
Pages 18
NRSBN 3004
Nursing in a
Changing Society

Module Leader: Sue Bailey
Word Count: 3159

Critically Discuss the Issue of Priority Setting
Within the NHS

It is no surprise that the role of the nurse has had to change over the last few decades; nurses are dynamic, vital members of a successful health care team. RCN (2009) The role they play is crucial in order to provide a consistent and quality service from health promotion and prevention strategies to clinical treatment, rehabilitation and palliative care. (NHS,2008). Nurses contribute greatly to a modern health care system hence the emergence of many specialist nurse practitioners who have undertaken additional specialist education in order to provide advanced nursing care and nurse prescribing services. RCN (2009) However in order for nurses to uphold the pledge of lifelong learning (NMC, 2008), it is imperative that they improve both clinically and academically and have an understanding of some of the important and current issues within the NHS. One such issue apparent over the last decade, and the cause of much recent debate has revolved around ‘priority setting’ within the NHS. Therefore the focus of this essay will be to critically analyse the subject of priority setting in relation to rationing and funding in the healthcare setting.

“It is a matter of fact that rationing exists. It existed under the previous Government, and it exists now. Only when we recognise that rationing is a natural part of any service provided by the state can we make the necessary decisions as to how to apportion limited resources,” (Fabricant, 1998)
Michael Fabricant MP, Standing Committee on Health Bill, 1998.

From its launch in 1948, the aim of the NHS was to provide a comprehensive health care system designed to secure improvement in the mental and physical health of people (Baggott, 2004). A…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Critically Discuss the Arguments for Free Trade, Paying Attention to Winners and Losers

...1. Critically discuss the arguments for free trade, paying attention to winners and losers. Free trade as an argumentative policy which has being discussed up till these days since it was established. Debaters formed by two groups of people where one kept being supportive and one held back against this policy. Although the opposing side lists out three points which are unbalanced development, economic dependence and environmental problems to prove that free trade is harmful to less developed countries. On the other hand, supporters try to use increase production and efficiency, economic growth and employment opportunity and consumer satisfaction to prove that all parties benefit from free trade where less developed countries only be less benefits. In this essay, as one of the members supporting free trade agreement I will look deeper into all six points and prove how the advantages within far more excel the disadvantages. Firstly, increase production and efficiency is the most significant advantage of free trade among the above three points. As different countries specialized in different fields, by making use of this comparative advantage, they can allocate resources in the most efficient way where therefore export increases a country’s production demand and import increases competitions between companies where they have to decrease price as a result, the resources are bought cheaper due to competition. With the example shows in Diagram 1, it can convince the theory......

Words: 1129 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Issues with Revenue Recognition Within the Software Industry

...Issues With Revenue Recognition within the Software Industry The Isoft Example Financial Controller-SoftWarehouse Ltd This report has been prepared for the Board of Directors of SoftWarehouse Ltd for elucidation about the contentious issues that have given rise to the publication of the article concerning Isoft’s issues with revenue recognition. Finally, it will also assess whether or not these issues are likely to affect SoftWarehouse Ltd. TABLE OF CONTENTS Executive Summary: 3 Introduction: 5 Part 1- Examining the Isoft Ltd example: 5 PART 2 - The issues faced by software companies in relation to revenue recognition: 6 Part 3- Issues raised that may impact SoftWarehouse Ltd: 7 Part 4 - Future changes in revenue recognition standard: 8 Conclusion: 9 Reference List: 10 Executive Summary: This report has been prepared for the Board of Directors of SoftWarehouse Ltd for elucidation about the contentious issues that have given rise to the publication of the article concerning Isoft’s issues with revenue recognition. Finally, it will also assess whether or not these issues are likely to affect SoftWarehouse Ltd. In January 2006, Isoft, a Manchester based supplier of software applications for the healthcare sector, announced that its profit would be below market expectations due to a required change in its accounting policy for revenue recognition. Isoft was forced to reverse revenue of approximately £70m in 2005 and £55m in 2004 – when Deloitte......

Words: 2561 - Pages: 11

Free Essay

Cultural Issues Within Public Schools

...Cultural Issues Within Public Schools Western society has many cultural markers which make up the society as a whole. Due to rapid expansion by both native residents and those who migrate here, the cultures temperature has changed and is still evolving. Change is not always easy and there is a constant attempt to gain balance. Racial divide is a longstanding cultural norm within the public school system. It is a ugly mark on our culture both in and out the school system. Racial tensions begun with the segregation of “whites” and “black”; this also included other races grouped in the minority category. Eventually schools were integrated but not without disproportionate education levels among the races. White students were known to have both better quality books and educators, even within the same school, than “minority” students. Today the racial culture has simmered a bit, however, disparities are still present among both the races and economic classes. This creates a dynamic that goes beyond the school system and effects every other aspect of our society. The unequal education levels creates a huge divide within the job markets, thus directly impacting the economic pulse and furthering the class divide. In addition to the impending economic divide, race plays a huge part in classroom relations among both students and teachers. Students have always had to find a way to relate to those of different races, which has not been so easy throughout the years. Each...

Words: 716 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Ethical and Legal Issues Within Wal-Mart

...Introduction Wal-Mart is commonly known for its low prices, clean appearance, and large variety of products; however, the super store has constituently been the center of many ethical issues. From working conditions, wages, benefits, product issues, and even bribery, Wal-Mart has been shrouded in ethical disputes for years. In the next few pages I intend on discussing these issues, the impact they have had on the company, and the actions that management has taken in response to them. Predatory Pricing To begin discussing the ethical issues that Wal-Mart has faced in regards to predatory pricing, we must first understand what predatory pricing is. According to; predatory pricing is “the act of setting prices low in an attempt to eliminate the competition” (, 2013). Although many of us would think that a business could set whatever prices they choose; we would be wrong. A company cannot set prices with the intent of running another company out of business, and doing so is illegal. A company can, however, sell items at a lower cost because they are able to run more efficiently, have better, less expensive supply channels, or simply do not have the overhead of their competitors. Wal-Mart has been the focus of many lawsuits regarding predatory pricing. In fact, as recently as this year, Wal-Mart lost a price cutting lawsuit in Arkansas and was ordered to stop selling drugs and health products below their own cost (White, 1993). In addition...

Words: 1562 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Contemporary, Feminist Issues Within Canada

...perspective of the media or within a historical context, women at a national premise have a greater awareness in the struggle of gender equality and female identification. Feminism looks at how the social, economic and political structures affect and shape women at the individual level. Accordingly, feminist theories analyze the relationship between gender differences, gender inequality and oppression. The idea of ‘waves’ in Canadian Feminist movements have been both diverse and dynamic in the act of coalition to obtain specific goals and broader changes in society. At the beginning of the 20th century, industrialization and nation-building came attached with a gender ideology that prescribed the public/private division between male and females. In modern-day Canada, issues concerning equal rights in the public and private sphere of women have become more relevant to the female community. In contemporary Canada, the discussion of sex work and the ‘entertainment industry’ is a controversial subject to many women. The traditional view is expressed to view these workers as individuals who have chosen this path as ‘immoral criminals’ or ‘victims’ of aggression. There is not much sympathy for these women as they are degraded to be invisible within Canadian society. Given the blind eye, these sexual deviants have historically served as an representation to regulate women of the public sphere. However, it is necessary to make distinctions of the ‘hierarchy’ within Canada’s......

Words: 1578 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Discuss the Effects of the Fcpa on Fraud Within the United States.

...The Foreign Corrupt Practices Act is a federal law that prohibits companies from paying bribes to foreign political figures and government officials for the purpose of obtaining business. FCPA has become a major compliance focus recently, especially the past three years. The FCPA has two sets of provisions, the accounting provision, enforced by the Securities and Exchange Commission, and the anti-bribery provisions, enforced by the U.S. Department of Justice. In the act, there are three types of entities prohibited from making improper payments: issuers, domestic concerns, foreign nationals and businesses. In my opinion, FCPA is working effectively within the U.S.. In 2009, more than three times as many FCPA cases were brought in 2009 comparing with those in 2005, The reason is because the government has been stepping up EFPA enforcement actions more than ever. Moreover, the Securities and Exchange Commission has also created a dedicated FCPA unit, and added attorneys and supervisors. Throughout developing a FCPA due diligence process on third parties and intermediaries, the organizations can create more economic and potential benefits. For those U.S. companies doing business abroad, there are something they need to think about. First, the cost imposed by the FCPA is high if conducting the business in a country with high corruption level. In the other hand, the FCPA may create a uneven playing field somehow for American businesses and the foreign competitors would......

Words: 261 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Research and Critically Discuss the Impact of Financial and Nonfinancial Incentives on Firm’s Performance.

...Assignment Topic Research and critically discuss the impact of financial and nonfinancial incentives on firm’s performance. Course Course Title: Human Resource Management Course Code: BUS 304 Section: 01 Submitted By Tahmaina Akter ID: 111011174 Submitted To “Rakib Jafor” Adjunct Faculty University of Liberal Arts Bangladesh Date of Submission: 13 December, 2013 Research and critically discuss the impact of financial and nonfinancial incentives on firm’s performance Introduction: The organizations are focused on the motivational elements to increase the productivity of employees. One of the several methods used to increase the motivation of employees is the incentive application. It is very common at organizations that there are often financial and non-financial incentive applications in order to award the employees with a high performance level and to encourage the ones with lower performance levels for higher performance. The main purpose of such applications is to establish a fair management structure within the organization; to contribute to the motivations of employees as a social being and therefore to increase their productivity and efficacy by enhancing their job satisfaction levels. Business organizations are facing significant challenges on internal and external work environment, so organizations can’t maintain institutional performance without providing incentives to their employees based on their efficient and effective work. Theoritical...

Words: 1303 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Discuss Issues in Classification and Diagnosis of Schizophrenia

...continuous disturbance over 6 months with one month of symptoms, no other sign of mental illness and no other known organic cause e.g. drug abuse or brain tumour. However, issues of classification and diagnosis involve looking at possible problems of reliability and validity. In terms of the issues with reliability it is often found that inter-rater reliability is low, meaning that psychiatrists often have difficulty agreeing on diagnosis. Pre 1970’s a lot more people were diagnosed in the USA than in the UK, highlighting that classification may not be reliable. Nevertheless, improvements of the DSM in 1991 led to improvements, but some reviews of schizophrenia classification has still highlighted the issue of low inter-rater reliability, however, psychologists now have other diagnostic tools to help improve reliability of classification and diagnosis e.g. standardised interviewing techniques and computer software. Additionally, concerns have been raised about the reliability of symptoms to be used in classification. Research by Klostercater found that out of 489 admissions to a German unit, positive symptoms were deemed to be more reliable however, others would argue that symptoms are too varied and it is too difficult to gain objective information to ever give an accurate diagnosis. Additionally , further issues of reliability of classification and diagnosis came from a study which found that even 50 US surgeons could not agree what is in fact meant by ‘bizarre’......

Words: 815 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

“Owner-Managers of Smes Can Determine the Employment Relationships Within Their Own Business.” Considering Both the Internal and External Influencing Factors, Draw on Relevant Literature to Discuss This Statement Critically

...Module: MGT 3000 Human Resources and Entrepreneurship Title: “Owner-managers of SMEs can determine the employment relationships within their own business.” Considering both the internal and external influencing factors, draw on relevant literature to discuss this statement critically Word Count: 2162 (excluding references) Employment relationship is a legitimate concept commonly adopted around the globe refering to the link between employees, or workers, and employer, which employees are performing work or services under certain conditions in return for remunerations. It has been a paramount concept of a ‘industrial relations perspective ’ on contemporary employment and management over the past two decades (Trevor and Mike, 2010: 7). When considering employment relationships in small and medium-sized entreprises (SMEs), we are mentioning largely about how these firms recruit, supervise, train, reward, manage disputes with and separate from employees as well as the more extensive relationship between employers and employees (Ram, 1999: 604). Being the main vehicle that employees gain access to their employment rights and benefits associated with social security and labour law, as well as the determinant of the scope and structure of employers’ authorities towards their employees (ILO, 2011), obligations and reciprocal rights between employee and employer are constructed via employment relationships. Looking into this fast-growing economy with ever......

Words: 2499 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Priority Lists of Hrm Issues

...Priority Lists of HRM Issues Priority #1: Supervisor span of control Justification: Effective span of control for one supervisor typically is 5-8 people depending on the drivers of the department and the experience of the supervisor. In Bob’s case, it may have been more beneficial to begin with him supervising 5 people and taking on more as his experience grew. Or, he should have not been hired. Action to be taken: Evaluate how many direct reports each supervisor currently has and look at realigning or delayering as possibilities. HR Domain: Organizational Design Priority #2: Realigning salaries based on performance measures and not hierarchical job titles Justification: Employees have been promoted into positions and have been unwilling or lacked the skills to be effective employees in their positions. As responsibilities have been taken away the organization has not decreased their salaries to reflect it. Other employees are performing at higher levels while knowing their supervisors are have less responsibilities but high salaries. Star performers will be lost due to frustrations and lack of rewards. Action to be taken: Implement a performance based reward system. Employees that consistently meet their company’s goals and objectives need to be rewarded by moving the ranks at the sacrifice of employees who are not. HR Domain: Performance Management and Appraisal Priority #3: Supervisory training Justification: Two employees were slotted into positions......

Words: 819 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Ethical Issues Within Organizations

...Ethical Issues Within Organizations Introduction I have been afforded the opportunity to serve in two distinctly different organizations. In my full-time vocation, I serve as pastor of Seigle Avenue Presbyterian Church. In my part-time career, I am a military officer serving as a chaplain for the 145th Air National Guard. In this paper, I will discuss and examine the United States military and the standards of ethic and integrity within the organization. Specifically, I will the Air National Guard as a backdrop to determine conclusions, access organizational climate and provide feedback as it relates to ethics and integrity. Later in the paper I will name five steps leaders can consider to prevent, control or minimize destructive behaviors. Further, I will create clear distinctions between organizational compliance and organizational integrity and list elements that must be included to improve the integrity of the organization. Finally, I will share my opinion of my personal ethical stance; cultural relativist or universal ethicist. Upon defending my position, I hope to clarify my ethical stance and support this stance in my leadership as a military chaplain and officer. The United State Air Force In 1997, I was commissioned to serve in the Air Force National Guard in the rank of 1st Lieutenant. I joined the Air Guard because I wanted to serve in ministry beyond the local parish. Additionally, I embraced the core values of the Air Force and wanted the integration of......

Words: 2458 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Discuss Critically the Opportunities and Risks of Distance in International Expansion

...Globalization has certainly made the world a smaller and interconnected place. The reduction in trader barriers and technological advancements in communication and transportation have given firms the opportunity to expand internationally by accessing untapped markets and resources. However, companies routinely exaggerate the attractiveness of foreign markets, which leads to expensive mistakes. This essay shall discuss the opportunities and risk associated with distance in international expansion. According to Ghemawat (2001), distance between two countries can manifest itself along four basic dimensions: cultural, administration, geographic and economic. Geographic distance, for instance, affects the costs of transportation and communications and is particularly importance to companies that deal with heavy or bulky products. Cultural distance, by contrast, affects consumer’s product preferences. It is a crucial consideration for any consumer goods or media company but it is much less important for a cement or steel business. Administrative distance involves historical and political associations shared by countries that greatly affect trade between them. Economic distance states that the wealth or income of consumers is the most important economic attribute, which creates distance between countries and has a marked effect on the levels of trade and types of partners a country trades with. The opportunities and risk associated with distance are based on the four dimension...

Words: 732 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Critically Analyse the Effectiveness of Leadership in the Nhs

...HS 3001 LEADERSHIP AND CHANGE Critically analyse the effectiveness of leadership in the NHS Summary This essay will discuss and critically analyse the effectiveness of leadership role of senior nurses in the NHS. The essay will examine the definition of leadership, different theories of leaderships and how it can be implicated to nursing practice including changes that should be made to make nursing leaders more effective in NHS health care settings. Leadership is an important topic that is highly looked at in NHS. Policy makers approves that nurses have a leadership responsibility in clinical and managerial aspects of things in health care settings. Introduction There are so many different definition of leadership. According to Alimo-metcalfe and Lawler (2001) which stated ‘there is no single, robust definition of leadership available within UK organisations today’. Also according to Huber (2006) ‘leader use their power to bring teams together, spark innovation, create positive communication and drive forward toward group goals’ However, the most common definition that is used is by Northouse (2004), This defined leadership as ‘a process whereby an individual influences a group of individual to achieve a common goal’. This definition confines the fundamental nature of leadership but at the same time it has acknowledged that due to wild ranges of leadership perspective, there will be many definitions of what leadership means depending on the importance of......

Words: 1000 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Ethical Issues Within the American Red Cross

...once again bogged down by the overpowering donations that poured in for Hurricane’s Katrina and Rita. On top of all that the ARC failed to get a grip on the financial disasters at its local chapters - unscreened volunteers walked away with ATM cards loaded with donated funds and some manager’s padded their own bank accounts with fundraiser donations (Holguin). For an organization that is supposed to help the country in disaster relief, the ARC has added monetary complications as the icing on the cake. The organizational structure of the American Red Cross needs to be taught that ethical compliance is its first priority; otherwise issues will continue to present themselves when the ARC is needed most. Mandatory, in-person, ethical classes should be held every year for employees and volunteers to help reinforce the ARC’s claim that they are fixing their internal issues. Also, executive leadership needs to be held accountable for their actions and not given monetary compensation upon their dismissal or resignation. Each of these things would help mend the American Red Cross’s image and help show the public that they have truly learned from past mistakes. References American Red Cross. (2006). September 11th Response & Recovery. The American Red Cross. Retrieved from American Red Cross. (2012). About Us. The American Red Cross. Retrieved from CDS Global. (2011, May 16). American Red Cross Case......

Words: 752 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Discuss the Issue on Trips

...Poseidon entered into a “cross-currency interest rate swap” convert francs to dollar 3. Principle payment were to be made at the end of the year 3 4 5, large individual payment which Linda proposed to hedge by having Poseidon purchase the francs from FirstAmerica Bank and locking in the future exchange rates. Poseidon had look at alternative of term in contracts but Linda convinced that by having long term contract it will significantly save a lot money for Poseidon and fewer transaction to make. Convinced that the money is so large and could change entire francs in US and told Poseidon if they use many other bank it will be risk for them and get least money… Linda was a good liar. The Question: After a while he has aware of several issue that led him to question Linda how she do business: 1. she convince Poseidon not to talk with any other investment bank about the structure as to keep accuracy of pricing and fairness. Normally the cost of “slippage” would probably not exceed 10 basis point (1/10 of 1%) 2. The actual price that Linda quoted, she explain that the price different exist because of the credit risk oof dealing with corporate counterpart and liquidity. She quoted 3 years for 12.80% , 5 years for 13.40% which is 80 basis point different which even much more that the current bond rate in France. Wow, it is the most profitable he ever seen. Which mean $ 12.5 million profit. And no clear reason why Poseidon agree but only they are lacked of......

Words: 1617 - Pages: 7