Free Essay

Critical Think Rand Essay

In: English and Literature

Submitted By akki007
Words 618
Pages 3
1. Is Rand correct in saying that if you accept altruism, then you end up with a lack of self-esteem and a lack of respect for others?
I do not believe that Rand is correct in saying this. Accepting altruism does not mean that you have a low self-esteem or a lack of respect for others. I see it as quite the opposite. A person accepting altruism has the utmost respect for other humans. By acting in a altruistic or selfless way, by saving a drowning stranger for example, a person is showing his or her respect for the value of life. Just because we don’t know the person in danger doesn’t mean that they don’t have a family or loved ones that would feel pain if that person were to die (or drown as in my example). 2. Is Rand criticizing ideal or reciprocal altruism? Do you think that she would differentiate between the two? Would you?
Rand seems to be criticizing reciprocal altruism. I think that Rand would differentiate between the two but would have more of an understanding or willingness to follow ideal altruism. I would differentiate between the two and I feel that a reciprocal altruism is more on my side of the board. I do not agree with it 100% but I can look back and find instances where I did something only because I would want someone to do it for me in the future. 3. Comment on the following quotation: “The proper method of judging when or whether one should help another person is by reference to one’s own rational self-interest and one’s own hierarchy of values: the time, money or effort one gives or the risk one takes should be proportionate to the value of the person in relation to one’s own happiness.” What might the social and political outcome be if that approach were implemented?
As far as a political outcome is concerned, I feel that this approach has already been implemented. Politicians only care about themselves and are not willing to get anything accomplished unless it will benefit them. How much it will benefit them will determine how much time they will fight the issue and how much money they will throw at it.
Socially, this approach can be seen from time to time. Even if we don’t want to admit it, most of us have used it at one point in our lives. Even down to the simplest things like an argument at school. Let’s say a boy is arguing to another boy about how to play kickball. You are walking by and hear the argument. You agree with what the first boy is saying but the other boy is big and known to have a short temper. Instead of engaging in the argument and backing up the first boy, you keep your mouth closed and continue walking. You have just made the conscious decision that the risk was too high to get involved and thus not worth your time. 5. Go back to Chapter 3 and reread, in the excerpt from Ruth Benedict’s paper “Anthropology and the Abnormal,” the section about “unbridled and arrogant egoists” as being typical of Western civilization. What might Rand’s comment be about that remark? I think that Rand would take offense to the remarks about western civilizations being nothing more than unbridled and arrogant egoists. I say this because Ayn Rand was born in Russia and made the conscious decision to move to America because of her dissatisfaction for her home country. Of all the countries she could have moved to, she chose to move to America because it was the least “Marxist” country in the world.…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Critical Essay

...scavenged the area with others around that time in search for gold (Rees). While the gold rush was ultimately not as successful as he had hoped, London took many stories and experiences from the search (Rees). Initially, while these two stories both show the man vs. nature theme, they are different in context. “The Open Boat” surrounds itself around a group of four men who take on the violent sea in a bathtub sized dinghy. These four men, the Oiler, the Correspondent, the Cook, and the Captain all try and work together in brotherhood to survive. As they progress, it seems as though nature always finds a way to lessen their optimism. Whether it’s through the annoying bird who finds a seat upon the Captain’s head or the boat capsizing once they think they are going to make it to shore. In the end after capsizing, they all end up surviving except the Oiler which is ironic seeing that he was the hardest working, most diligent, and the one who always kept the group level-headed. “To Build a Fire” focuses on an older gentleman, rather new to the art of hiking the Yukon trail, trying to survive in frigid life-threatening temperatures. Like “The Open Boat”, he does have a companion, a husky. He and the dog fight these conditions together going through a number of different obstacles varying from having the ice break beneath his feet to having the snow covered limb over the fire snap and kill the fire. “And then it happened. At a place where there were no signs, where the soft,......

Words: 1483 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Critical Response Essay

...Critical Response Essay 1. If Fred were a Utilitarian, what would he do? Utilitarianism is a consequentialist theory where right and wrong depends on the consequences of one’s actions for everyone who might be affected by them. In other words, Utilitarian individuals want a system that will bring good to society than any other system. The philosophy of consequentialism is also based on the belief that the moral and ethical value of one’s action should be judged by the consequence of such action. In the case where Fred has signed a confidentiality agreement with Greyarea Inc. he is unable to leak out any information to the public about his research findings. If he were to tell anyone else that the cigarettes are more harmful, then the consequences of him being sued by the company due to a breach of the contract would be the repercussions. This is not to say that if Fred did give out the information about the truth of their newly developed cigarettes, he would be right or wrong. In the case with his company, he will be considered doing wrong. If Fred were a Utilitarian he would want to bring good to the society as a whole by letting the public know that the cigarettes in production is actually more addictive and has a higher chance of developing cancer in smokers. He would disregard the repercussions that would affect his family and career even when he is financially secure. His moral beliefs would tell him that his actions are for the greater good and so much more......

Words: 588 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Critical Evaluation Essay

...Critical Evaluation Essay Crystal Eastman, a 1920's feminist, expresses her thoughts on woman's rights and how if woman are given these rights it will change the way women view their position in life. While fighting for the right to vote, woman views were respected by men. Several feminists are socialists or communists, few are active leaders within the feminists movements. Many legal issues were resolved to make it easier for woman to achieve numerous professions, trades or unions that were once just for men. The future must bring in early coaching for each boy and girl. They must learn that it's both manly and feminine to provide for their family in whatever career choice they choose, and to be able to stand on their feet alone. Conjointly children should learn that it's both manly and feminine to be able to know how to cook, clean, sew, take care of themselves and their children. Eastman's article contains ethos, Pathos and Logos while discussing the argument concerning woman’s rights. Woman's rights have invariably been something society has struggled with throughout history. Eastman states in her essay “that the vast majority of women as well as men are without property, and are of necessity bread and butter slaves under a system of society which allows the very sources of life to be privately owned by few, and she counts herself a loyal solider in the working-class army that is marching to overthrow that system.”(Eastman). This statement by Eastman might......

Words: 586 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Critical Response Essay

...Critical Response Essay: Fred’s Dilemma In respect to the given example of Fred, the view of utilitarian would propose that the person should do whatever is going to offer him or her the most pleasure while obtaining the least pain possible from it. Considering this case, the utilitarian perspective would most likely indicate that Fred should keep the job because by doing so it would provide him with pleasure in many different ways. Some of the reasons he might consider keeping the job are his desperate need for money to support his family. On the contrary, a utilitarian would not consider keeping the job because the company is adding more addictive and toxic ingredients to their products which can cause cancer and many other diseases to their consumers. According to the given scenario, it would not matter if Fred quits his job, because then the company will offer the position to some other applicant who will gladly accept the job with full benefits. Also by quitting the job, Fred would not be able to expose the company’s activities because he signed the confidentiality agreement. In addition, through this theory it is possible to consider that the pain he would obtain if he does quits the job, would be higher due to his financial situation to support his family and also due to finding a another job anytime soon because of the economy. Therefore, the view of a utilitarian would propose that Fred should keep his job because he would obtain more pleasure for him and his......

Words: 444 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Critical Essay

...Clarissa English 1B Essay #1 05/04/2014 “Lust” The the short story “Lust” by Susan Minot is about teenage sex, written in a first person point of view. The main character of the story is the narrator herself. She describes herself in terms of her relationship with other people, mostly boys, to build the character instead of describing her physical appearance as a sexually active girl who lives in a co-ed dorm. It’s not like a typical story where the writer describes how the character’s eyes, hair, and body look like. She does not even reveal her name in the story. Although the narrator is reliable in telling the story as a first person “I”, she sometimes uses “you”, which makes the story less reliable. Readers can only imagine what she looks like; however, we as readers know how she feels. The narrator does not provide descriptions about her feelings and emotions in the first few paragraphs. She tells readers stories about her experience sleeping with different boys emotionlessly, making no sense at all to readers what she is trying to tell us. Each experience has little descriptions, proving that her relationship with those boys is not that intense. For example, in her experience with Tim, she describes herself as “…then came back to me, a body waiting on a rug” (229) and she also admits “They held the door of the goat house and wouldn’t let us out till we showed them our underpants” (231). It implies that she is so vulnerable of herself to boys in her life. She has no...

Words: 856 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Critical Think Piece

...” When the game of cricket was being played at home at the Oval; many took the time to make it a family occasion. They woke up early to cook and pack coolers to carry to the Oval. People in the Caribbean grew up listening to cricket commentary on the radio and transistor before television became accessible to everyone. According to narrator, all these devices were available to Tanti Merle for her to experience the cricket without him having to carry her to the Oval. Cricket is such a popular sport in the Caribbean that is available on all mediums. In Perspectives of Caribbean Psychology, clinical psychologist Dr. Kai Morgan and sport psychologist Leapetswe Malete states that Trinidadian author V.S. Naipaul “suggests that cricket plays a critical role in the development of a sense of identity (self and national), and self-worth among the West Indian people.” (562) We see this in the poem which Tanti Merle is supporting the Combined Islands because she is from St. Vincent however the narrator supports Trinidad. This match allows them to foster a shared national identity amongst people from their own countries and a personal identity because they have a sense of belonging by having an affiliation with a particular team. Simultaneously, it has brought them together and forged an identity for West Indians on the whole. Through the use of language and performance, we also get the experience of a cricket match it its final moments, “Excitement in de Oval like you never see in you......

Words: 1876 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Critical Argument Analysis Essay

...Critical Argument Analysis Essay ENG/215 1/26/2015 Jennifer Rainville | Immigration Control Introduction Illegal immigration is a big problem in the United States. If you ask around where you live you will get so many different views and arguments. Realistically immigration has resulted in the laws having more illegal immigrants live and work here in the United States. I have read three different articles on the pros and cons of illegal immigration. Immigration is becoming a normal thing in the United States and it shouldn’t be. Summary In the article “Let Us Give Thanks to Our Immigrants” by Rupert Murdoch, he shows some evidence to support his agreeing with illegal immigration. He shows support on how they have contributed to the education in America. Whereas in the articles “The Winners in Immigration: Public Prisons,” by Aubrey Pringle, and “Republican Views on Immigration,” by RepublicanViews.org shows support on why immigration is not good for the United States. Murdoch shows that many of the high paying jobs in the United States are held by immigrants or children of immigrants. Whereas Pringle and RepublicanViews.org shows that our government is suffering because of all the illegal immigrants in our country. Argument Murdoch is pro-immigration. He has provided evidence to show why he supports immigration. He also was an immigrant himself and all his family was from Scotland. He does state though that these days it’s hard to talk about the benefits...

Words: 1059 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Critical Essay

...machine costsb Total costs a Optimus $208 Sentinel $584 18 42 144 200 $570 72 100 $798 Machine costs include lease costs of the machines, repairs and maintenance. b Manufacturing overhead was allocated to products based on machine hours at a rate of $25 per hour. “I have heard quite a bit about this new costing system they call ABC. Joyce, my most senior accounts assistant knows a bit about this and has collected some information for me. However, we both are not very sure what cost drivers mean and why we need so many “cost pools” as they call it. I mean, even with all the many cost pools, the total manufacturing overhead is still the same, is it not? If so, then what is so good about this ABC? Do you think it would be useful for us? I have all the information Joyce collected here (Appendix B). Could you please include everything in your report? Thanks for your help!” Management Accounting Page 4 CASE ANALYSIS REQUIRED: Prepare a report (no more than 10-pages) for Maureen Pistana that addresses the following: a) The number of temporary workers required for July using both regression equations and explaining which regression equation is more appropriate for Michael Fowler; b) The purpose of a predetermined overhead rate and how it is calculated and the reason for its application; c) The over- or under-application of overhead in July, how this affects profit and what to do with it for Gordon Stapleton; d) The......

Words: 1739 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

English Critical Essay

...Adrian English 112-Asp4 Prof. Henderson Critical essay- Final Draft The Pressure of Acceptance Throughout the years many have felt the pressure of being accepted by others. This theme of acceptance is shown in many works of literature. Two specific works of literature that this theme is portrayed in is “Salvation” by Langston Hughes and “Shooting an Elephant,” by George Orwell. In “Salvation” Hughes is pressured by the whole church to feel something that he couldn’t; in “Shooting an Elephant” Orwell is pressured by the town natives kill an animal he felt was harmless. In other words they both did something they are not proud of in order to please the majority. In “Shooting an Elephant” Orwell shows the consequences of not being accepted and pressures of being accepted. “All I knew was that I was stuck between my hatred of the empire I served and my rage against the evil-spirited little beast who tried to make my job impossible”. (Orwell pg. 296) Not only does this quote show the unacceptance Orwell received but also that he was indecisive of whose side he was on, whether it was the empire or the town people. The natives hated him because of his position, but he hated his position, too, which shows they had some kind of common ground. Then there came a time when the town people were in need of him: a “sub-inspector at a police station the other end of the town rang me up on the phone and said that an elephant was ravaging the bazaar. Would I please come and do......

Words: 1439 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Critical Thinking Essay

...Critical Thinking Essay Student Name PHL 251 – Critical Thinking University of Phoenix For Professor March 4, 2011 Critical Thinking Thinking impacts every moment of our lives and in performing the thinking challenge the realization that thinking could potentially be above everything else in our lives else was astounding. My first instinct was to place my family above thinking on the chart but then realized without thought, my wife and I may never have met. The actuality of the situation is that we think to breathe, walk, talk, and function; in chapter 13 we have found that we need accurate data provided by our senses and memory: clear, concise, contextually accurate language; controlled and effective feelings; clear structure; and solid logic. (Kirby, 2007) Each sense in our body feds the thought process, when we touch a hot stove senses tell our brain you are being burned and we pull back our hand away. From the point of a sensation we develop a memory, for good or for bad, to ensure that we either repeat or eliminate that action and we call these situations experiences. The burning on the stove is an experience we do not want to repeat; however, our first kiss with passion and warmth is something most people keep as a pleasant experience and try to replicate it. My wife and have been married for over 22 years and she never had a driver’s license until after we were married. In our relationship she is the emotional strength and I am the......

Words: 885 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Critical Essay

...Creative Critical Essay On tonight’s Radio Show we are joined by one of the most credited screenwriters of our generation, Peter Moffat, to discuss his mesmerizing, gripping version of Shakespeare’s ‘Macbeth’. Throughout the film it manages to hold on to many important foundations of the text and also captivates an audience from young to old; thanks to his modernised and current adaption. Peter welcome to our show. It’s an honour. So what made you decide the setting of the story should be in a high-end restaurant? Yes! My team and I sat down thinking, how can we make this adaptation different from others? How can we add a contemporary spark into this gory story? And then we thought, “O yes a restaurant will be good” then we went from there. This is the era of TV chefs where all your family follow recipes from the likes of Gordon Ramsey and Heston Blumenthal. It is something easy to understand and show the story’s themes of blood which symbolizes the guilt like a stain on the Macbeth’s conscience. We thought there’s no other environment that can translate Macbeth in a modern way better than a restaurant kitchen as Shakespeare’s Macbeth was a soldier who slaughtered others at war, so we made a modernised scene of the chef, Macbeth chopping up a pigs head, showing the similarities. Peter, the audience and I realises you tried to answer one of the greatest Shakespearean mysteries, did the Macbeths ever have a child? Yes, I think the audience pick upon this whilst......

Words: 502 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Critical Response Essay

...Critical Response Essay Life is full decisions, some harder than others, but those hard decisions have to be made sometimes for the wellbeing of others. Medical technology is beginning to take of the medical field and is making ethical decisions and issues a thing of the past. Due to this there are has been some debate on whether or not the technology in the medical field is harming the medical profession or not. Some people agree with the topic others do not and think that the medical team should be the ones making the decisions not the computers. The passage, Medical Technology and Ethical Issues by William E. Thompson and Joseph V. Hickey, explains the dilemma of technology in the medical field, and the different sides of it. The technology that is being referred to is the RIP computer. This is a computer program that doctors us to help make decisions about whether to administer lifesaving actions to patients that are dying or to let them die. In the passage critics and supporters take opposing sides to the issue of technology being used in the medical field. Some believe computers will be making the decisions, while others believe it just provides data to make decisions on who to treat. On the debate of the use of the RIP in medical field has two main positions, the critics and the supporters. The critics disagree with the technology because, they say that it is a “frightening example” of the overreliance of computer technology that makes decisions that should......

Words: 796 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Critical Think

...Critical and Creative Thinking in Society Situation of Public Interest Reported in 2013, the Veteran Affairs (VA) hospital in Phoenix Arizona was involved in a scandal where alleged 40 patients died awaiting health care. In addition, Phoenix VA officials were misrepresenting data to make patient wait times appear better than they actually were. As result, VA officials were given bonuses for the misrepresentation of data. In some cases veterans were waiting on appointments for over a year. In addition, Sam Foote, a retired VA physician claimed the use of secret lists being used to help falsify the reporting of patients. (Robbins, 2014) The use of critical thinking may have been able to prevent this situation from taking place. In the VA Scandal described above it is clear that the VA wanted to compensate the employees for providing better service to the patients by decreasing the wait times for patients. Although, controls were not put into place to ensure the employees were not falsifying data. Prior to implementing the bonus program, the VA could have put more thought into the planning process. For example, the VA could have implemented external auditors into the bonus program to assure the employees were doing the right thing. In addition, the VA could have put some thought into how they could have provided a well thought out plan to improve healthcare for veterans. The Art of Thinking People have tasks, obligations and obstacles to face every day. In......

Words: 1011 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Critical Essay

...that the U.S. fights terrorism with "hunches and the power of luck in addition to intelligence and skill” said Rich Jawuak at Gawker. Carrie, the series' deeply troubled main character, makes Homeland a nobler and richer character study than the average TV thriller, and her character's nature raises intriguing questions about whether the U.S. needs to rely on brilliant but unpredictable wild cards in order to combat terrorism. It portrays Islam accurately: Homeland may be about terrorism from the Middle East, but it's also a show that "sees the beauty of Islam rather than reducing it to a geopolitical force," says Alyssa Rosenberg at Think Progress. Nick Brody is a converted Muslim, and the episode ends as he and his daughter bury a Koran that was desecrated after touching the floor. It's impressive to see a TV show that makes Islam a critical point of a main character's identity, and takes pains to ensure that its depictions of the religion are accurate. Homeland is not just a remarkable drama about post 911. It is also a remarkable drama, in its own subtle, sophisticated way, about being a young professional woman in 2012. The fact that no one ever obsesses over Carrie Mathison's gender is precisely the point. Almost every television show with a strong female protagonist derives a lot of its drama from the tension between motherhood, wifedom, and work. But Homeland doesn't put Carrie in that box; it is a totally different show (Tucker, 2012). Homeland was definitely......

Words: 756 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Critical Thinking Essay

...Essay Using relevant SSK19 readings, in particular the four dimensions of reflective practice presented in Pavlovich (2007, 283), discuss the fundamental role that critical thinking plays in evaluating arguments at university. Most of us would believe that we make good decisions; but most of us find it uncommon practise to use the tool of critical thinking to enhance our thinking process which enables us to make better decisions. This essay with provide examples of critical thinking when evaluating arguments by using the different dimensional levels of reflective processes. Critical thinking in evaluating arguments is stated as an essential skill for student at university level, but can only be used to its best when it grouped with the tool of reflection. Most do believe, reflection and critical thinking go hand in hand as a process, just like a personal experience cannot be truly acknowledged within if you don’t ask the question, analyse, understand or action. The fundamental role that critical thinking plays in university arguments is that it allows the student to analyse, evaluate and draw conclusion by using their own mind and not be persuaded by other external or biased opinions. Pavlovich’s reading “The development of reflective practise through student journals” (Pavlovich 2007) refers to the four dimensional levels that she believes is the summary of reflective practise. The four dimensions of reflective method are, describing the experience, analysis of the......

Words: 1390 - Pages: 6