Free Essay

Critical Review on Whose Face Do You See - Melvin Burgess

In: English and Literature

Submitted By alynchan
Words 2504
Pages 11
Mirror: Who Am I?
For our short story analysis, we have chosen Whose Face Do You See by Melvin Burgess, a British author whose focus is on children and young teen’s story. “Whose Face Do You See” tackles the dilemma and contradiction of the comatose Marianne, and those of her loving parents. In this story, mirror played a very important role in helping the main character to rediscover herself, this leads us to wonder about how we people really see in this world. Therefore in a two-way mirror, which side are you on?
The primary literary technique that is used in this story is monologue. It is the only way the story is portrayed as through the eyes of the mother and Marianne so that the story is presented with the emotions of the characters. The italicised parts of the short story represent the inner speech of Marianne while the normal text represents the mother’s point of view. This pattern continues all the way until the very last line of the story where Marianne’s speech is no longer italicized. The significance of this change will be discussed later in the next few paragraphs.
Each character is similar in their characteristics. Marianne is in a state of comatose with poor medical prognosis of ever opening her eyes again. In her despair she had developed a secondary will that denied her very existence. Marianne’s split will saw herself as a separate existence, and through it, she hopes to lessen the suffering the “other” Marianne might have to go through, if she were to die. Through her henceforth doppelganger, Marianne maintained the façade of denial until she was shown her own reflection on the mirror. Through the mirror, the revelation of herself proved to be a catalyst for her acceptance of who she is, and sparking a miracle which to see her waking up once more.
Marianne’s characteristics can be described as polarized, having a mirrored personality during her denial phase and her true self when she accepted that she is indeed the very Marianne that she tried to deny. The Marianne during her denial phase was emphatic, mournful and self-denying. This can be seen through her monologues where she responds to the things that happen around here. As seen in line 76, Marianne asks the mother to leave her alone as she sees the mother as a stranger and she might be mistaken for Marianne.
It showed her empathy and resistance towards Marianne’s mother, Julie. Her monologue showed her rather futile attempt at shutting Julie, and her father, Ant out of her, but she just couldn’t do it. Her mournful characteristics is shown when she despair that the doctor’s prognosis of her not every waking up again, her spark of hope was brutally killed, and she returned to locking herself up within the mirrored world of hers.
Marianne’s personality during the phase where she finally broke the spell of denial and accepted who she really was brings forth her hopeful, and yearning characteristics out to see. After being shown the reflection of herself, instead of the static picture that was placed beside her, Marianne finally saw her true self, rather than the see-through image of what’s around her. This was greatly characterized when her father, Ant, not willing to give up hope till the very end, gave his last final attempt at invoking Marianne’s inner self. At that time, Marianne is seen yearning for that touch, that love that she couldn’t feel when she was in the denial state. Through the mirror, Marianne saw her own face, not others, but hers, and it finally dawn upon her that she is, who, she really think it is.
Marianne’s parents are described as a very loving, hopeful and strong parents, they stood by Marianne day and night since the time she passed out, and Ant in particular, was a strong man, holding out, not giving up till the every end, and that, was what that instilled some sort of consciousness into Marianne that made her move. Julie too, is a loving mum, bringing Marianne her belongings, keeping the faith for her daughter to open her eyes again.
In this story, there are numerous conflicts that happened within and between each character. The first conflict that is presented is within Marianne herself, she is torn between accepting and ignoring her identity. A process from ignorance to denial to finally accepting her identity is also filled with conflict within herself again and again. In line 77, Marianne says she would like to block the mum out if she is able to. Then again in line 97, she pities the mother and wishes that she could tell the mother to give up and that Marianne is no more. This shows that Marianne is being ignorant towards her true identity.
Marianne also conflicts with herself as to whether or not she wants to live or die. This is shown in line 153 where she wishes to wake up just to wish everyone goodbye. That shows her eagerness to live as she retains her memories. This is also debunks the statement by the doctor saying that she had no more personality in line 106 where we can clearly see that Marianne has the will of a person throughout the story. She is able to think and talk to herself about letting herself live or die mentally. Later on where she realises that she has a past with no present or future, she slowly turns her thoughts to dying rather than living on to trouble people around her. This is shown line 169 where she pleads mentally to her parents to turn her off.
The stage where she denies that she is Marianne is shown in line 233, where she strongly deny she is Marianne when the parents, with their last hope, shows Marianne a mirror to enable her to see herself, hoping that she will recognize herself. She immediately refutes her image and again strongly insists that it is not her when she tells herself that she did not move in line 241. The word “never” is very significant as it shows both her determination and confusion over the fact that she is a vegetable. The scene is almost like a battle between two people, the subconscious Marianne and the real Marianne. It plays out to two personalities fighting for a right to remain in the body and in the line “I never move” is like the subconscious Marianne who is speaking on behalf of the defeated real Marianne, claims victory over the real Marianne by destroying any hope of waking up.
The two words “MY face” in line 266 is very significant as they play many roles in the last stage of accepting and confirming her identity. First, when the doctor leans towards her face, she has just come to realise that all the while she had been ignoring and denying herself. By saying that it is her face, she accepts that she has an identity. Secondly, the fight between the subconscious Marianne and the real Marianne has finally come to an end, with the real Marianne confirming her victory by mentioning these two words as proof that she is now in control of her body, no longer requiring others to speak for her. It should be noted that the word “my” is capitalised; its meaning being that she claims for herself her territory that is hers. Moreover, she was excited and glad to know that the hope of the real Marianne is finally realising, this is shown in line 258 where she feels like crying because of the overwhelming fact that she is in control of her body again. Her joy of seeing herself moving her own mouth in the mirror further reassures her that she is the real Marianne and that she is no longer a vegetable. There is a hyphen in between the words “it” and “I”, meaning a pause or rather in this case, an indication of evidence that she could see herself returning, by seeing herself moving her mouth, emphasising the control she has over her body.
Julie Sams who is Marianne’s mother, is also portrayed with an inner conflict of her own. In the beginning of the short story, she is symbolised as the hope that never dies. In her conversation with the doctor, she keeps mentioning hope and wish that her daughter will wake up even though the doctor is very pessimistic about it. She does everything she could to wake Marianne up, including bring pictures of Marianne’s friends, toys and even CDs. This shows her determination and optimistic view that one day her daughter will come out from her coma, this is shown in line 62, she repeatedly ask Marianne to squeeze her hand and told Marianne that she would wait for her patiently no matter how long it takes for her to response. This could probably be one of the reasons why Marianne is also so determined; she probably inherited it from her mother. However, she slowly changes her mind to terminate the daughter’s life through the gentle nudges of the husband, Ant Sams.
Ant Sams who is the father of Marianne, he is a realism-like person, he tries to be rational and calm but deep down inside he is just as torn as the mother. Being a realistic person as he is, he knows it is the right thing to remove Marianne’s life support devices and to let her go. Although influencing the wife to change her thoughts to let Marianne go, deep down inside he wants Marianne to wake up as it is shown in line 222, he did not give up until the very last minute and he tried to use the mirror as the last measure of hope. Ironically, the mother is seen as the symbol of hope but the father is actually the last person to do something to wake Marianne up. This also signifies the element of uncertainty in the story which foreshadows the awakening of Marianne since it was thought to be medically impossible.
Conflict between the parents to whether or not to pull out Marianne’s tube is also present in the story. In line 114, it is mentioned in the mother’s monologue that the parents have already decided before to pull out her tubes but cannot bring themselves to actually do it. This is due a very big factor; should they do it too soon, they risk cutting short their daughter’s life. But if they did it later, they also risk delaying their decision and may never do it. The mother also comforts herself in knowing that when they pull out the tubes, Marianne would not suffer and die within the week.
Dr. Morris, Marianne’s doctor, also has a conflict with the parents as he is doubtful of Marianne ever waking up. The most significant point of this conflict is line 123 where the mother asks the doctor’s opinion on whether or not Marianne should continue to live. In the following reply, the doctor simply states that Marianne is dead in line 125. This quashes every hope that the mother has in the doctor about Marianne waking up. He also pushes for Marianne to be terminated as the hospital requires the facilities that Marianne is currently using as mentioned in line 108.
The mirrors, both the physical one that Ant places in Marianne’s hand and the metaphorical one that Marianne was facing, are symbolic throughout the story. The metaphorical mirror, which represents her denial and ignorance of ever being Marianne, is a contrast between a picture that she sees of herself and what she cannot control. At first before waking up, it was as if she was looking at the picture of a stranger, one that the mother keeps calling Marianne. It did not occur to her that she was seeing a picture of herself but rather a memory that was so distant and probably never getting back. The metaphorical mirror which leads her to denial of her true identity also causes her to overlook the situation, all the while viewing the whole situation in a two way mirror. A two way mirror is both partially reflective and transparent, that allows viewing from the darkened side but not vice versa. In this context, Marianne is looking at the situation from the darkened side which represents the negative side but not in the positive light.
However, when the father presents the physical mirror to Marianne, she sees a reflection of herself. At first thought to be just another version of a picture, it proved to be a powerful tool in reawakening Marianne. Although she was not sure what she did was working as stated in line 251, the constant shouting of the mother further motivated her to move some more. It was as if the darkened side two-way mirror was lighted up and she saw a reflection of herself, with her reflection moving as she did as in the line 258. The final line of the story where Marianne’s dialogue is no longer italicized represents the idea that she is now awake and her words represents her full assurance that she is Marianne.
This short story connects to all of us because through Marianne’s metaphorical mirror, it reflects to how we people overlook things and we tend to insist on what we believe rather than opening ourselves to other options. As in the case of Marianne, most of us are afraid of stepping into our shoes and wish we could run away from reality if we can. However, we should learn from Marianne, who although tried to give up on ever returning to her former self, was brave enough to try again and eventually won the battle against coma. This is an important lesson that all of us can take home because it is lesson which knows no bounds, age or situation. The mirror symbolizes the external outlook that we have on our life and that we should stop looking from the dark side and start stepping out into the positive light and take charge to control our actions.
In conclusion, this story is both compelling and interesting as it shows not only the anguish faced by people who have loved ones in a coma but the struggle a thirteen year old girl has within herself. Her spirit to never give up although at the end against all odds is admirable and a heroic act. This serves as a beacon of hope for all those who are facing a similar situation and that one day, they will see themselves in the mirror again.

Reference
Dakss, B. (2005, February 12). Women Speaks Again After 20 Years. The Early Show – CBS News. Retrieved March 28, 2011, from http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2005/02/11/earlyshow/main673281.shtml
Whose face do you see?. British Council (BBC). Retrieved March 28, 2011, from http://www.teachingenglish.org.uk/try/britlit/whose-face-do-you-see…...

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Crash Critical Review

...Moyosore Bankole Communication 300 September 30, 2012 Critical Review Introduction Race and gender relations are one of the most explored themes in movies, music, books, and etc. Often times, ineffective communication leads to the misinterpretation of each other’s actions, leading to inaccurate race bias. This race bias can be referred to as racism. Typically people in society are somewhat discreet about their racism and it is not something they openly admit to. The movie Crash, daringly tackles the issues of intercultural communication, and race in an unconventional way. It takes racism and makes it an open conversation amongst the characters to ensure the viewers can clearly identify each characters racial bias. As the characters in this movie communicate, there is frequent use of racial slurs, profanity, as well as racially driven insults and stereotypes, to further exaggerate the bigotry present in the film. Crash provides a series of examples that show just how powerful effective and ineffective communication can be when it comes to social relations. This film touches on various communication theories and concepts, in which many of the scenarios presented in Crash can be explained. These theories and concepts include: symbolic interaction theory (self concept), assumptions of communication accommodation theory (indirect stereotyping), assumptions of expectancy violations theory (violation valence), and cultural communication. Synopsis Director Paul......

Words: 2169 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

How Do You See the Relationship Between Islam and Terrorism?

...Rdavis UNCG The Islamic World Islam and Terrorism: How do you see the relationship between Islam and terrorism? Many of us Americans do impulsively equate Islam with terrorism. I can’t say that this has always been true for me. Even before I started educating myself about the Middle East and the Muslim religion I would think twice before making those knee-jerk judgments. Being an African American women in a Christian based America, I have learned about racism 1st hand, the hypocrisy of the Christian church and that things are not always one sided. Growing up in the Heart of New York City also showed me how many races of people from different cultures and religions have lived amongst each other relatively peacefully. Islam is said to be the world’s second largest religion. If Islam equaled terrorism the U.S. and other parts of the world would have been under tremendous fire by the Muslims for many years. I don’t feel that Islam equates terrorism. We all have our differences but we are all human. With that said there are moral and immoral humans, there are moral Muslims and immoral Muslims. The violence we see today stems from a radical form of Islam and I believe this to be different from the mainstream beliefs of the Islamic community. There are differences between Islam and Islamism. Islamism is said to be a complex ideology of Islam. This ideology is often identified as radical and political. Islam is a......

Words: 2205 - Pages: 9

Free Essay

What Do You Say After You Say Hello? by, Eric Berne Book Review by Suresh a M,

...What Do You Say After You Say Hello? By, Eric Berne Book Review by Suresh A M, I semester, MBA, JSSCMS Eric Berne was a psychoanalyst who became well known in the 1970s for his system of "transactional analysis", the transactions in question being mostly those between a young child and its parents. He proposed various structures for this relationship based on the roles parent/adult/child that every person plays and presents life stories as scripts that can be good or bad. This book is considered by many to be Eric Berne's sequel to Games People Play. Although Berne published other books since Games People Play was released in 1964, most of those works were oriented towards those trained in psychotherapy and not towards the individuals who made Games People Play a two-year bestseller. The book is his last book completed just before his death in 1970. Berne's bad luck was that he wrote the book in 1970 when psychology was going through a bad patch with a flood of bizarre systems appearing. The good gets lost with the bad and transactional analysis now tends to be labeled as an outmoded California fashion related to Freudianism. In the preface he says that the book is "primarily intended as an advanced textbook of psychotherapy, and professionals of different backgrounds should have no difficulty in translating into their own dialects the short and simple annals of transactional analysis. No doubt some non-professionals will read it too, and for that reason I have tried to......

Words: 2271 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Monkey See Monkey Do

...house you realized that Deffens is very flirtatious with a women named Julie. Julie is the court administrator for Judge Anderson. Later on, the intern went back to the court house to file papers and Deffens asked the intern to drop something off to Julie. It was an envelope with her name on it, nothing official. The intern soon realized that it was not sealed, the flap was left open and you see five ten dollar bills and a note that read “Armstrong”. After reading that note, you made a connection with the name Armstrong. Deffens had received an appointment for a case named Armstrong and the money was a type of compensation or “kickback” for the appointment. The intern then talked to Deffens about what he/ she found and he basically tells the intern that it happens all the time and everyone does it. He also tells the intern how everyone is webbed in this somehow; Judge Harris pays Judge Townshend’s wife seventy-five thousand dollars a year for two days a week and he, Deffens, buys lunch and takes the judges out to his box seats for NASCAR and basketball. First of all, the definition of ad litem is “legal Latin meaning for the purposes of the legal action only. A Guardian Ad Litem is a guardian appointed to prosecute or defend a suit on behalf of a party who is legally incapable of doing so, such as an infant or an insane person” (Farlex, 2013). Following that, not everyone can afford an attorney’s which mean that people were being appointed to attorneys that will do defend...

Words: 934 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Critical Reviews

...Writing a Critical Review Education Development Unit, University of New South Wales What criteria can be used for evaluating an article? The following criteria are useful: • the timeliness of the article • the degree to which the article makes an original contribution • the logic of the view put forward • the validity of the evidence put forward • the theoretical framework used Is the framework valid? Has the framework been applied appropriately? • the methodology used Is the methodology appropriate? Is the methodological approach explained clearly? Does the methodological approach have any weaknesses? Is the study sufficiently comprehensive and thorough? Is anything important omitted in the research? • the findings Are the findings presented and described clearly and fully? Do the findings seem sound? Could the data be interpreted in another way? Do/does the author(s) account for everything in the data or do they ignore something that might be important? • the validity of the conclusions • the thoroughness with which the article treats the topic • its value compared to that of other articles on the topic • the appropriateness of the article for the intended audience • the extent to which it might satisfy the specific needs of a specific user. Centre for Academic and Professional Literacies, Institute of Education, University of......

Words: 1214 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Critical Review

...INTRODUCTION In this report i shall be analysing the different variations in the dissertation by Mr Ashimi Adefesobi in comparison to my own work. i shall be viewing the different strengths and weaknesses i have encountered within the report on both of the dissertation to see if in the future, where improvements are required within my own work and in Mr Ashimi Adefesobi’s. i shall start by reviewing each section of the dissertation followed by structure, language and format at the end. Abstract and Background it is important to include an abstract along with background information before proceeding to the main body which is the literature review. unfortunately Mr Ashimi Adefesobi lacked the presence of an abstract, thus, lacking key information as to what the study entails and the main findings presented within the study. Furthermore due to the lack of headings I've had to assume that the background information and introduction must of been interlinked as after a very disorganised set of paragraphs the heading for literature review appears. within these paragraphs i briefly understood the main concern was the chain reaction from regulations of bank capital requirements and the impact it has on bank capital structure. unfortunately the aim of the research was void as it was not clear as to what exactly he's focus was on, he's aim was unclear, what he wished to analyse changed frequently as he's focused drifted from aim to aim. this section was not concluded either and......

Words: 1462 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Based on the Descriptions in the Text, Where Do You See Yourself on the Kolb Inventory?

...Vietnam War Student Project I. Introduction Wars are fought for many reasons: to protect a nation's interests, to expand territory, to defend a country from an aggressive neighbor, to force one country to think or behave like another, to gain influence and political power. The reasons that a government has for going to war have a lot to do with how much support it gets from its people. If the general population strongly opposes a war, it is very difficult for a government to continue conducting it. Australia became involved in a war in Vietnam because our leaders were determined to stop the spread of communism in southeast Asia. Vietnam is a long, narrow country located south of China and due west of the Philippine Islands. North Vietnam, which bordered communist China, became independent of French colonial rule in 1954. So did South Vietnam. Under Ho Chi Minh, North Vietnam became a communist country which aggressively tried to spread communism to the south. Australia first tried to prevent the spread of communism in South Vietnam by sending the Australian Army Training Team Vietnam in 1962, at which point 10,000 US military troops were in place. US president Jimmy Carter and the Prime Minister of South Vietnam asked for additional help from Australia. To build up Australian forces, Sir Robert Menzies introduced national service in 1964. In April 1965, Australia dispatched its first troops to South Vietnam. When Harold Holt succeeded Menzies as Prime Minister in......

Words: 525 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Where Do You See Yourselves in the Future

...Where do I see myself in the future? The way I see myself in the future is not something I often think about. To tell you the truth, it scares me a little to know that in one short decade I will be thirty- one years old, and that my years of youth are coming to an end. However, thinking about this question gave me a chance to analyse my goals and ambitions. I am a simple individual that have big dreams in life. In many years from now, I believe I am able to achieve the three most basic things in life which are family, love and a satisfaction career. A vision I’ve always had of myself years ahead from now is a wealthy business woman that owns a coffee shop. Instead of having my coffee shop on the main street, my coffee shop would tuck away from main street which is away from the hustle and bustle of the city. I hope to provide a comfy environment which my customer could truly relax themselves and enjoy their coffee. The interior of my coffee shop has custom mural and exposed brick walls which create a warm atmosphere. Reclaimed woods were used for the bars, tables and condiment stations. Some good oldies song will be played as background music hovering around the shop and the level of its volume is just moderate. It will be wonderfully set up while being photogenic at the same time. I’ve picture myself sitting on the cashier of my coffee shop welcoming every customers with warm greeting. Besides that, I will place a variety of books in the shop and customers are welcome to...

Words: 1562 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

What Do You See When You Look in the Mirror

...Witherspoon What Do You See in The Mirror? Have you ever looked at yourself in the mirror and were proud of what you saw, just to step on the scale and feel like someone is playing a trick on you? Weight is a funny thing when you are looking at the aspect of being healthy and having a productive life. Being considered a healthy person has less to do with your weight on the scale and more to do with an accurate body fat percentage. Even people who exercise and look physically fit could be considered obese when it comes down to looking at the average weight/height chart. When looking at the weight/height chart also known as The Metropolitan Life Table you first need to know some history behind it. The table was created in 1943 by a company known as the Metropolitan Life Insurance Company and was later revised in 1983 (Steven B. Halls, 2008). It was designed to determine which people would have the lowest death rate (Steven B. Halls, 2008). A huge glitch to this is it was made particularly for people within the 25-29 age group and for people who were considered average height for that time (Steven B. Halls, 2008). So to say if you are tall or really short this table was not designed for you (Steven B. Halls, 2008). The original table also specified that the person should have on 1” heels and their clothes should weight approximately 3 lbs., before any revisions were made (Steven B. Halls, 2008). When looking at weight one thing you need to take into......

Words: 818 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Critical Review

...Critical Review of Cizek, Gregory J. (2005). High-Stakes Testing: Contexts, Characteristics, Critiques, and Consequences In Richard Phelps (Ed.), Defending Standardized Testing (pp. 23-54). New York, New York: Psychological Press. By Cheryl LeBlanc-Weldon When I decided to delve into the issue of high-stakes testing, I purposefully set out to find its defenders. Critical thinking is important to me and part of the process of thinking critically is to view a variety of perspectives on an issue in order to obtain an informed understanding and from that, an opinion. As an experienced educator, I have participated in standardized testing in a variety of ways. I have administered and graded tests in both Mathematics and Language Arts. I believe that currently in Nova Scotia we don’t have the type of high-stakes testing they have in the USA and other parts of the world. Our students do not need to achieve a certain level of achievement on the standardized tests they take in order to grade and teachers are not fired or have their salaries docked when students fail to achieve the benchmarks. Still, the provincial tests our students write do have a degree of importance in that the results are published for media and public consumption (which directly affects the opinion people form of the health of our education system) and certain resources are channeled into schools with the weakest performance. In addition, the way students view themselves and their abilities are......

Words: 3001 - Pages: 13

Premium Essay

Critical Review of "Does the Internet Make You Dumber"

...Introduction Nicholas Carr’s 2010 article titled “Does the Internet Make You Dumber” is an attempt to shadow the usefulness of the internet as a whole in a negative light. This short article, originally published in the Wall Street Journal, makes a fervid bid to discredit the internet and persuade individuals that we as a society were smarter before we began relying so heavily on the internet as an avenue to gain information. Carr manages to adequately present and support his very one-sided view of the argument without attempting to make room for a counter argument at all. I personally am of the opinion that Carr is being short sighted; he is beginning with a conclusion and bending the narrative to support his point of view. Summary It is a difficult task to summarize Carr’s article while including the sort of emotional one-sidedness he presents in the full text of the article. The short article is packed with references to studies performed by prominent universities and research groups, all of which contend that the internet is stripping the ability to think critically out of our minds today. This really is the main point of Carr’s article which he seems to circle around and come back to frequently; our ability, as a whole society, to think critically is perceived as being diminished and this will the ruin of man. While Carr doesn’t specifically make this assertion directly in his article, he is circling the topic the entire time and in his concluding paragraph states:...

Words: 815 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

How to Do a Critical Reading

...Critical Reading 1. Preview. Look “around” the text before you start reading. ... 2. Annotate. Annotating puts you actively and immediately in a "dialogue” with an author and the issues and ideas you encounter in a written text. ... 3. Outline, Summarize, and Analyze. ... 4. Look for repetitions and patterns. ... 5. Contextualize. ... 6. Compare and Contrast. When you write about literature . . . Some Tips for Academic Writers Sentence Style 1. Use simple sentences as rubrics (pointers). 2. Use compound sentences to suggest balance and to present pairs of ideas of equal value. 3. Use complex sentence to emphasize the most important ideas and to subordinate less important ideas. 4. Avoid "empty" sentence frames that say little or restate the obvious. 5. Use present tense when referencing details in a literary work except for passages written in the past tense. 6. Incorporate short, key quoted phrases into analytical sentences. 7. Avoid the use of such words and phrases as "you" and "the reader" that often lead to wordiness. 8. Avoid the phrase, "In conclusion," when opening the concluding paragraph. 9. Avoid gratuitous complements and superlatives. Paragraph Development 1. Use Pattern 1 paragraph frames for most paragraphs in the body of academic essays. 2. Begin body paragraphs with claims as topic sentences that repeat key concepts from the thesis sentence. 3. Always introduce the speaker, context, and/or significance of block......

Words: 4605 - Pages: 19

Premium Essay

Critical Review

...Clinical Operational Management – Assignment 2 (Critical Review Essay) Article Reviewed Clarke, C., Harcourt, M., & Flynn, M. (2013). Clinical Governance, Performance Appraisal and Interactional and Procedural Fairness at a New Zealand Public Hospital. Journal of Business Ethics, 117(3), 667-678. http://dx.doi.org/http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s10551-012-1550-9 Introduction This is a review of article titled, “Clinical Governance, Performance Appraisal and Interactional and Procedural Fairness at a New Zealand Public Hospital” by Clarke, Harcourt, and Flynn (2013) which focuses on performance appraisal (PA). The intention of the article is two-fold. It explores how nurses perceive fairness in the process of their PA and how the perceptions can affect the effectiveness of PA. Twenty-two participants of nurses from a single department of a public hospital participated in interviews and focus groups held over a period of two months. Qualitative data collected through the interviews and focus groups were taped, transcribed and subsequently interpreted by thematic analysis. The article concluded that injustices were perceived the greatest in procedural justice. Participants felt that there was insufficient notice given to prepare. The article found that employees valued regular communication of expectations and progress prior to PA. The article recommends greater formalization of PA process and adequate training for both the appraiser and employee for a PA process to be...

Words: 1829 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Where Do You See Yourself in Five Years?

...Where do you see yourself in five years? “Not looking at the price tag when I shop.” Everyone has goals for themselves, for some it’s getting out of bed in the morning, for others it’s finishing school, no matter what the goals are they are all important as long as they are reachable. For me, my goals include becoming more organized with my school work, improving my studying skills, becoming a travel nurse after finishing school, and living the life style I was raised in. These are all pretty reasonable goals, but the question is if they will be met. In order for me to become more organized with my school work I need to spend more time each day after class putting the lessons in order with the home work and with the material that needs to be studied. Using the hundreds of dividers that I own would also be an easy way to keep everything in the right place so it is easy to find. Labeling the binders I use for my class would help with my problem of organization, also bringing the same binder to the same class it belongs to would help tremendously. This is an important goal because being organized would make studying and fallowing along with most teachers much easier. This goal of mine should be accomplished by the second week of school. I will know it is achieved when I am more confident in class because I am on track if not ahead of my teacher. Improving studying skills is a very important goal of mine. You don’t pass tests with luck or good attendance, good grades are...

Words: 932 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

What Do You Understand About the Amazon Tribe and the Issues It Faces?

...Q: What do you understand about the Amazon Tribes and the issues it faces? From this extract, we understand several things about the Amazon Tribes and the issues it faces. Firstly, we discover that the tribe is ‘isolated.’ The word ‘isolated’ implies that the tribe has no contact with the outside world. In the next paragraph, we learn that the tribes are also self-sufficient as they are able to grow their own crops for food such as ‘maize, sweet potato, pumpkins, bananas and peanuts.’ This implies that despite the lack of resources these people were provided in the Amazon Rainforest, they have the skills to be able to craft their own supplies such as food in order to survive. In addition, we also learn that, like any other societies in the world, the Amazon tribe has their own unique culture. We learn that the men of the tribes wear ‘cotton waistbands and some have headdresses.’ Not only does this show that these tribes have their own unique traditions as previously mentioned, but it can also indicate that there are different hierarchy levels in the tribe. We get the impression that the ones that wear ‘headdresses’ are the chief or main leader of the tribe and the others are just normal members of the tribe. Similarly in the English society, our queen wears the crown to symbolize her status. Furthermore, one of the issues faced by the Amazon tribe is the fact that there is a chance of the tribe being captured again. This is because many tribes like this have moved to......

Words: 646 - Pages: 3