Free Essay

Comparative Economic

In: Social Issues

Submitted By dddd1
Words 1088
Pages 5
2014s3C300_TMA1a by Dawud Abdirahman


Dawud Abdirahman

Student Reference Number: 130002288



1000 Words

Do you think Ha-­‐Joon Chang’s idea of ‘Institutionalist Political Economy’ (IPE) provides a better explanation for government intervention than the concept of market failure?

In this essay, the author discusses, if Ha-­‐Joon Chang’s idea of ‘Instituionalist Political Economy (IPE)’ provides a better explanation for government intervention than the concept of market failure. The essay – which is part of a course module assignment in Public Policy and Management Studies at the School of Oriental and African Studies – discusses both theories, and articulates their merits and constraints as per the author’s views. Various examples have been employed to support these views. Market failure is a concept within economic theory describing when the allocation of goods and services by a free market is not efficient. That is, there exists another conceivable outcome where a market participant may be made better off without making someone else worse-­‐off. (The outcome is not Pareto optimal.) Market failures can be viewed as scenarios where individuals' pursuit of pure self-­‐ interest leads to results that are not efficient – that can be improved upon from the societal point-­‐of-­‐view (Ledyard 2008, Krugman and Wells 2006). The first known use of the term by economists was in 1958 (Bator, 1958), but the concept has been traced back to the Victorian philosopher Henry Sidgwick (Medema, 2007). Market failures are often associated with time-­‐inconsistent preferences, information asymmetries, public goods, non-­‐competitive markets, externalities, or principal-­‐ agent problems.

Government intervention in a particular market often arises due to the existence of a market failure. Micro-­‐economists, are often concerned with the causes of market failure and possible means of correction. This plays an important role in many types of public policy decisions and studies.

However, policy interventions, such as taxes, subsidies, bailouts, wage controls, and regulations, including attempts to correct market failure, may also lead to an inefficient allocation of resources, also referred to as government failure (Weimer and Vining, 2004).

Often than not, a choice between imperfect outcomes, i.e. imperfect market outcomes with or without government interventions provided. In any case, once a market failure exists the outcome is not Pareto efficient. Mainstream neoclassical and Keynesian economists believe, it may be possible for a government to improve the inefficient market outcome, while several heterodox schools of thought disagree with this.

The question of the proper role of government in the marketplace is an old and fundamental one. Throughout the world, Public Officials deal with this issue, a task made more urgent by recent efforts to privatize public responsibilities and "reinvent" government. Looking for objective standards by which such decisions can be made, public officials increasingly have turned to the concept of market failure. Use of the market failure concept is widespread, both in teaching curricula in practicing government circles and in legal analysis.

The shortcomings of the market failure concept have been known for some time, but with little consequence, since its use continues to be widespread. Yet alternative economic approaches, which provide a better-­‐grounded conceptual framework for understanding issues of government intervention, do exist.

Originally used only as a normative concept to define applicable situations for government intervention in markets, the concept of market failure took on additional characteristics as it matured. Transformed into a diagnostic tool used by policymakers to objectively determine the scope and magnitude of the intervention. Here, policy analysts will most likely apply least intrusive interventions to allow the market to correct itself i.e. Tax expenditure vis-­‐à-­‐vis Creation of a government monopoly. Although the concept does provide a means for diagnosing and essentially treating “the disease” affecting the market, it does not really provide analysts and other decision makers with the desired or for that matter complete explanations for government interventions.

On the other hand, the Institutionalist Political Economy (IPE), an alternative theoretical framework suggested by Ha-­‐Joon Chang to overcome the limitations of the market failure concept, provides solutions.

By carefully undoing the core, rarely questioned assumptions of neoliberalism, Chang dissects the theoretical and practical limitations of neoliberalism’s discourse on the state and market. He provides a far richer and deeper critique than others who have dismissed neoliberalism for its anti-­‐interventionist rhetoric. A compelling argument and strong evidence is provided, which retains a very timely relevance, in its criticisms of neoliberalism’s partial, misleading contribution about the role of the government. The four main points raised in Chang’s Breaking the Mould; the definition of the free market; the definition and the implications of market failure; the market primacy assumption (namely the view that the market is logically and temporally prior to other institutions, including the state); and the analysis of politics, clearly elaborate serious flaws in how the Market failure concept is implemented (Chang, 2002).

In conclusion, admittedly, the IPE provides goes further in putting emphasis on key issues. For example, it puts emphasis on the role of political factors in determining state policy and the fundamentally political nature of the market and applies the political economy logic to the analysis of the market, and not just to the analysis of the state as in the Market failure concept. The roles of institutions in affecting human actions, including those within and surrounding the state are also clearly understated. For the stated reasons, I believe Ha-­‐Joon Chang’s idea of ‘Institutionalist Political Economy’ (IPE) provides a better explanation for government intervention than the concept of market failure

Bibliography John O. Ledyard (2008). "Market failure," The New Palgrave Dictionary of Economics, 2nd Ed. Abstract. Paul Krugman and Robin Wells (2006). Economics, New York, Worth Publishers Francis M. Bator (1958). "The Anatomy of Market Failure," Quarterly Journal of Economics, 72(3) pp. 351–379 Steven G. Medema (2007). "The Hesitant Hand: Mill, Sidgwick, and the Evolution of the Theory of Market Failure," History of Political Economy, 39(3), p p. 331-­‐358. 2004 Online Working Paper. Mankiw, Gregory; Ronald Kneebone, Kenneth McKenzie, Nicholas Row (2002). Principles of Microeconomics: Second Canadian Edition. United States: Thomson-­‐Nelson. pp. 157–158 Weimer, David; Aidan R. Vining (2004). Policy Analysis: Concepts and Practice. Prentice Hall. Douglass C. North and Robert P. Thomas. The Rise of the Western World: A New Economic History. Cambridge, U.K.: Cambridge University Press, 1973 H-­‐ J Chang (2002) ‘’ Breaking the Mould: an institutionalist Political Economy’’ alternative to neoliberal theory of Market and state Rod Hague and Martin Harrop (Comparative Government and Politics) Palgrave, Macmillan. 9th Edition…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Comparative Summary

...Comparative Summary The health care industry in the United States is big business in proportion to gross domestic product (GDP). Americans spend approximately two trillion dollars on health related expenditures (Baker, & Baker, 2013). The industry is expected to experience positive growth over the next two decades (Baker, & Baker, 2013). Coupled with this growth is the pressing need to control costs. This is especially so in government funded reimbursement programs, such as Medicaid and Medicare (Gapenski, (2008). As the American population ages, the demand for increasingly efficient health care organizations is essential to a positive outcome for the industry. Health care is one of the world’s most complex undertakings, there are innumerable processes at every level. For-profit Financial Environment For-profit organizations must make a return on investments and services rendered. They must meet their obligations and must satisfy private investors and shareholders (Finkler, & Ward, 2006). With a return on investment being one of the top priorities, motivation can be fostered to provide high efficiency with a superior product. In this case, a superior service. Mountain Star Healthcare Mountain Star facilities are owned and operated by the larger parent company Hospital Corporation of America (HCA). This private company began trading shares in the stock exchange in 2011 (Hospital Corporation of America, 2013). Their goal is to approach service expansions with the patient......

Words: 1237 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay


...China is the global leader in clothing manufacturing and exports. But the shift is happening for very obvious reasons.” BBC new 29/08/2012. Using the theory of comparative advantage, discuss the possible reasons why this shift is being observed. Globalisation from the facts of Economics ‘is considered by a rise across borders in the flow of goods, services and financial resources alongside with a rise in international movement of technology material and characters’ Boyes & Melvin (2011). As it was announced on BBC News (2012) about how Chinese companies are moving to Bangladesh to make clothes even though China is a worldwide leader in the manufacturing businesses. Absolute advantage involves the specialism of trade benefit among countries, well as according to the law Comparative advantage is that ‘when one Country has fewer efficiency then it has absolute disadvantage with detail to the further Countries production of both merchandises, there is still a source for commonly useful trade’ Simatele (2013). Heckscher- Ohlin (H-O) theory is founded on two theories, the H-O theorem and the factor price Equalisation theorem. The following essay will outline the trade established on Absolute advantage, H-O Theorem, the theory of Comparative advantage and the way the theory opportunity cost can be used to explain Comparative advantage then examples will be given to illustrate the movement of Chinese firms to Bangladesh to make clothes. Lastly a conclusion will be given to sum......

Words: 2295 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

Comparative Politics

...POL 101 Politics: Comparative Introduction State Role in Development Hypothesis—Development covaries with state capability in complex, population-dense world. Definitions of Key Terms state— territory, population, government, international capacity state capability—delivery of essential functions; providing physical security, efficient institutions to assure rule of law, competent administration development—diversified commons with overlapping, cross-cutting allegiances, interactive networks of communication, invention, production, distribution, innovation, regeneration, sanctioned by performance-linked status quality of life—pervasive literacy, discretionary leisure, opportunities for self-improvement and life-long education, various sets of friends and associates, choice of urban or country life, privacy, with adequate prosperity and technological sophistication to make it all work Comments ● Republic of Kazakhstan: Kazakhstan’s development of immense mineral reserves and massive economic prospective (major foreign investments in oil sector) co-varies with its state capability of efficient administration, primarily from competent leaders, like President Nursultan Nazarbayev. ■ Republic of Latvia: Under the rule of successful and competent administration, Latvia has been able to restore economic growth in times of global hardship, co-varying with its efforts in establishing a status as a world educator in transferring that knowledge to member states...

Words: 704 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Comparative Analysis

...Comparative Analysis Rural hospitals across the world are being affected financially. Rural communities are less wealthy; the majority of the residents are uninsured. They tend to use the emergency room as their primary care, putting a financial burned on the hospital. In 1986 the Emergency Medical Treatment and Labor Act (EMTALA) was enacted by congress as part of the Consolidated Omnibus Reconciliation Act (COBRA). EMTALA allows uninsured patients to receive care with an emergency condition regardless of insurance status or the ability to pay. The law states the patient may not be turned away and care cannot be delayed due to pay concerns. EMTALA requires the hospital to stabilize the patient before transferring or discharging the patient (Encyclopedia of Everyday Laws, 2013). According to The Center for Disease Control (CDC), about 135 million people visit the emergency room each year and hospitals lose approximately $34 billion in unpaid medical bills. With the passing of the Patient Protection Affordable Care Act many unnecessary or preventable emergency room visits will be eliminated. My action plan for Ashe Memorial Hospital is to design a program to decrease the number of uninsured patients using the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (PPACA). By decreasing the number of uninsured people, it will also: • decrease the number of emergency room visits • increase the number of people to receive preventative care • increase the quality of patient......

Words: 995 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Comparative Hrm

...Comparative HRM: China and Australia * Introduction Over the last few decades, as a rising number of globalisation of business transactions and organisations are seeking to develop and operate in foreign markets, the need for comparative human resource management studies are increased (Brewster & Mayrhofer (eds.) 2012), there are a lot of differences in HRM in different countries and regions, such as institutional culture, organisational structures, recruitment and development and relation of employee (Crystal & Iles 2013). The comparative human resource management provides a better understanding of different national settings on the management task (Hollinshead 2010). Two countries from different institutional and legal systems which are China and Australia will be comparatively analysed in this essay. Firstly, the overview of both countries and culture dimensions will be analysed. Secondly, three HR features will be outlined respectively include culture, organisational structures, and the content of Human Resource Management. in addition, a critical evaluation will be given for how and why these features in these two countries developed in the way that they have. Moreover, a comparative analysis of how HRM has developed in each country will be given, as well as that approach to HRM. * Background and Different Culture between China and Australia The study of the influences of culture is a key role in HRM (Brewster & Mayrhofer (eds.) 2012). Moreover, due...

Words: 4835 - Pages: 20

Premium Essay

Comparative Summary

...Comparative Summary Cynthia Deeble HCS/577 September 8, 2014 Sandra Di Pietro Comparative Summary Currently in the United States the Medicaid program is the third largest source of health insurance for powerless populations. The Medicaid program was introduced into law in nineteen sixty five, which is known as the Social Security Amendments Act. Before this law was passed, health care services for the under privileged were provided through several programs sponsored by the state and local governments, charities and community hospitals (Briggs, 2013). In the first program medical providers received payments, for medical services from the state on behalf of individuals who were receiving public assistance. The medical assistance program for the aged was created in nineteen sixty. This program was designed to help elderly individuals who didn’t qualify for public assistance, but was in need of assistance with medical expenses. The Medicaid program provides three types of medical protection coverage which include health insurance for low income families with children, and individuals with disabilities. Also offers long-term care for older American’s along with individuals who are considered disabled. The last coverage that was offered was a supplemental coverage for low-income Medicare beneficiaries whose services were not covered under their current plan like outpatient treatments, and prescription drugs (Briggs, 2013). Medicaid is a joint federal and state......

Words: 1247 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Comparative Summary

...Comparative Summary M W HCS/577 February 24, 2014 Comparative Summary According to Finkler & Ward (2006), “health care is an enormous part of the US economy, representing 17% of all personal consumption expenditures annually” (p. 7). The health care industry has multiple components, diverse types of providers, and many different types of health care organizations playing an integral part in the delivery of health care. Health care is provided by different health care financial environment namely for-profit organization (FP), not-for-profit organizations (NFP), and governmental organizations (Finkler & Ward, 2006). This paper will identify one entity from each health care financial environment identified from the previous week’s worksheet and will describe the financial structure of each financial environment. This paper will also address the policies that make this financial environment unique and identify which financial management practices are prevalent in the financial environment. This paper will also explain why effective financial management is more difficult in health care than in other industries. Entities FP, NFP, and government facilities exist throughout the country. This paper identifies the first entity FP healthcare organization JFK Medical Center. The second entity is Naples Community Hospital (NCH), a NFP healthcare organization, and the third entity is the Veterans Administration, a government funded facility. JFK Medical Center is a......

Words: 1536 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Paper Rifkinada Economic Comparative Analysis Between China Morocco

...INTRODUCTION TO CHINESE ECONOMY AND POLICIES A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS BETWEEN THE MOROCCAN ECONOMY AND THE CHINESE ECONOMY Submitted to: Dr. Prof. XU Tongsheng Submitted by: RIFKI Nada Graduate Student Master of International Business Date Submitted: December 2, 2014 JIANGXI UNIVERSITY OF FINANCE AND ECONOMICS SCHOOL OF INTERNATIONAL TRADE AND ECONOMICS Introduction The purpose of this essay is to present a comparison between the Moroccan economy and the Chinese economy in broad lines. The comparison will focus on the analysis of the economies sectors, their respective current account balances and the business environment in each of both countries. Thesis Although both economies are quite different regarding their economy ’s structures and economic growth patterns, it is evident that the initiatives their respective governments took into joining the world’s trading system benefited their economies on the long run. The recent world crisis gave raise to new challenges for both the Moroccan and the Chinese economy and gave urge to restructure the structure of their nation’s economy. Roadmap This essay is divided in three parts. The first two part, describe respectively the Moroccan and the Chinese economies. In the last third part, I will compare both economies in regards to the information given in the first and second parts. Describing each of these two economies –in the first and second parts, I will start by giving general information and an overview of the...

Words: 6742 - Pages: 27

Free Essay

Comparative Advantage

...Comparative Advantage Christopher L Kearney University of Phoenix ECO/GM 561 International Economics Watson T. Ragin June 27, 2011 Comparative Advantage This writing will begin by defining the concept of comparative advantage while comparing the automobile industry in the United States and the industry in Japan and expound of the similarities and differences of both of the countries. According to comparative advantage is defined as the ability of a business entity to engage in production at a lower cost than another entity. Comparative Advantage, rather than absolute advantage is useful in determining what should be produced and what should be acquired through trade. Japan is the country being compared to the United States. Japan is in Eastern Asia and has a population of 126.9 million with the capital Tokyo. Most people who reside in the climate speak Japanese and the major religions practices are Shintoism and Buddhism. The money unit used in the country is yen and the country exports vehicles, computer parts, chemicals, scientific instruments, and watches. Whereas, the United States is l in North America, bordering the North Atlantic Ocean and the North Pacific Ocean, between Canada and Mexico and has a population of 317.6 million with the capital being Washington DC. The predominate language in the United States is English and the major religion practice is Christianity. The currency used in the United States is the American Dollar. The...

Words: 1265 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Comparative Advantage

...Advantage and Comparative Advantage According to the classic model of international trade introduced by David Ricardo (19th-century English economist) to explain the pattern and the gains from trade in terms of comparative advantage, it assumes a perfect competition and a single factor of production, labor, with constant requirements of labor per unit of output that differ across countries. The basis for trade in the Ricardian model is the differences in technology between countries. As a result, there are two different ways to describe technology differences: the first method, called absolute advantage, is the way most people understand technology differences; and the second method, called comparative advantage, is a much more difficult concept. Absolute advantage is the simplest measure of economic performance. It is the ability to produce a good at a lower cost, in terms of real resources than another country. Absolute Advantage is neither necessary nor sufficient for a country to export a good. In other words, a country has an absolute advantage economically over another, in a particular good, when it can produce that good more cheaply or it can produce more of the good than another country can, with the same amount of resources. In fact, absolute advantage appears when multiple products are being considering. For example, if the country “A” has an economic advantage against the country “B” at producing the product “X”, and the country “A” has an economic......

Words: 1112 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

A Comparative Study of Political, Economic and Social-Cultures Issues of the Russia and India

... A comparative study of political, economic and social-cultures issues of the Russia and India Prepared for: Dr. Joe Zhou Peng Submitted: 11 May 2015 Prepared by: Zahara CitraArifin 006 Table of Contents INTRODUCTION 1 Task 1 1.1 Economy of Russia and India 2 Terrorist aspects of globalization 2 1.2 Political System of Russia and India 3 Discrimination against Woman 4 Corruption 4 1.3 Socio-Cultural of Russia and India 5 Hofstede’s Cultural Dimension of Russia and India 5 Written and Unwritten Laws 6 Task 2 2.1 Culture Shock 7 2.2 Cross Cultural Training ...

Words: 2545 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay


...Compare the extent to which one or more social groups reflect the cultural context in at least two texts on your comparative course. The King’s Speech is a great example of a cultural divide. It shows the social classes of two families. Of course the Monarchy’s family, headed by The Duke and the family of a normal man, Lionel Logue. This is a great technique of demonstrating to the audience just how different the two social classes are in every aspect of their lives. First, there is a contrast between the doctor’s house and the royal house. Indeed, the doctor’s house is darker; the furniture is simple and looks poor. The wall is rotting, certainly because of the humidity of the room. It shows that the doctor surely is too poor to have heating. In the royal house, we can see that there is light, brightness, and the furniture is smart. Then, there is a contrast too between the clothes. The King wears wealthy clothes, beautiful suit; his wife has a fur coat which symbolizes wealth and both are always immaculately presented. In turn, the doctor wears a modest jacket with a bowtie, it symbolizes a modest life, and while not looking poor he cannot compete with the dress code of The Duke and his family. All these differences show the appurtenance of the two characters in two different social classes. There are at least eight social classes in England, but I will speak only about two of them. First, the social class named “gentry class” or “gentleman class”. This class regroups......

Words: 874 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Comparative Summary

...Comparative Summary Financial statements and policies are important to all organization and in health care it is a measurement to reflect how well the organization is operating. This paper will look at 3 types of organizations: Nonprofit, for profit and government hospitals and examine the financial structures and the unique policies in each environment. It is important to understand the similarities and difference to fully grasp the significances and differences within the health care community. The first organization to examine is not for profit healthcare organizations. Not for profit organizations governed by a board of trustees and a required to comply with federal and local laws and regulations regarding charitable donations and fiscal compliance. There are three major organization that issue financial standards for not for profit organizations to follow regarding here financial status. The organizations are the Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB), the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants (AICPA), and the U.S. Federal Office of Management and Budget (OMB) (Mercer, 1999). In order to maintain a not for profit status the organization must comply with the IRS reporting measures and provide. The rules with the IRS can be found under section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code and is how an organization can be tax exempt. Beyond federal guidelines “many states require that contributions, gifts, grants, etc., and functional expenses be......

Words: 1182 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Comparative Economic Analysis & Growth Recommendations - Honduras

...Country of Honduras – Comparative Economic Analysis The country of Honduras is located in Central America with neighboring countries of Guatemala, El Salvador and Nicaragua. This country is located along the Caribbean Sea although does have western port access to the Pacific Ocean through the Gulf of Fonseca, with territorial waters of the gulf divided between Honduras, neighboring El Salvador, and Nicaragua. The country is mostly mountainous which has hindered communication and a sense of nationhood among its people. Development in this country has been extremely slow (National Geographic). The purpose of this analysis is to determine specific areas in need of economic improvement, and to make recommendations towards that overall economic condition of the Honduran economy. Historical Legacy and Context: Economically, Honduras ranks as the second poorest nation in the western hemisphere, second only to the country of Haiti. Other statistics report Honduras is the third poorest nation in all of Latin America, ahead of only Nicaragua and Guyana (Cordero). In analyzing a nation’s economy, it is important to look at history, how the country came into existence. Any country’s philosophy towards its economic development will have been influenced by the basic beliefs that have survived since the nation’s inception, so a general background is a logical starting point (Angresano, J.). The original inhabitants of this nation were the indigenous tribes of Central America,......

Words: 6381 - Pages: 26

Premium Essay

Comparative Advantage

...International Economics ECON22185 Assessment title: Analyse how, according to the Heckscher-Ohlin model of international trade, factor endowments explain a country’s comparative advantage and determine which types of goods a country will produce, export and import. According to J.Sloman (2010) comparative advantage is defined as ‘a country has a comparative advantage over another in the production of a good if it can produce it at a lower opportunity cost: i.e. if it has to forgo less of other goods in order to produce it.’ David Ricardo had developed the basic theory of comparative advantage which was further developed by two Swedish economists, Bertil Ohlin and Eli Heckscher who developed the Heckscher-Ohlin model in 1933 which explains why countries trade goods and services with each other and how factor endowments determine which goods a country would produce, export and import. Factor endowments are the amount of labour, capital, land and entrepreneurship that can be exploited for manufacturing in a country. Labour and capital are the two factor endowments that the Heckscher-Ohlin model refers to. The Heckscher-Ohlin model assumes that the only difference between countries that are trading was the relative abundances of labour and capital they had. The model contained two countries, two goods that it could produce and two factor endowments; labour and capital, which is why it is sometimes referred to as the......

Words: 1163 - Pages: 5