Premium Essay

'Caliban Has a Better Set of Values Than Stephano or Trinculo.' by Considering the Presentation of Caliban, Evaluate This View.

In: English and Literature

Submitted By gracedevivo
Words 1011
Pages 5
‘Caliban has a better set of values than Stephano or Trinculo.’ By considering the presentation of Caliban, evaluate this view.
When considering the presentation of Caliban it is important to acknowledge the differences in context and perception between Shakespeare’s audience and a modern one. An Elizabethan audience might be inclined to agree with Stephano and Trinculo’s values because they could probably identify with them. Stephano and Trinculo are white and European and not gentry. A modern post-colonial audience would probably have more understanding of issues such as slavery and the exploitation of indigenous peoples and so are more likely to be sympathetic to Caliban and more critical of Stephano and Trinculo.
From a 21st century critical perspective, Caliban’s values could be seen as natural and honest. Amanda Mabelard says that “Caliban’s bad behaviour is like that of a child”; by this she means that he does bad things but this is because his values have been imposed on him by Prospero, who has been his only father figure. Caliban’s affinity with nature can be seen when he says “When thou cam’st first / Though strok’st me and made much of me; wouldst give me / Water with berries in’t and teach me how / To name the bigger light and how the less / That burn by day and night.” In general the characters who are of high class speak in verse, suggesting they are educated and cultured. By having Caliban speak in a similar manner Shakespeare demonstrates the possibility of Caliban having values equal to or surpassing those of his European oppressors. On the other hand, however, Caliban says “You taught me language and my profit on’t / Is I know how to curse.” During the Elizabethan period, swearing and cursing would have been considered something a more boorish type of person would do, and to a degree this is still the case. This could be one perception that can…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Caliban vs. Prospero

...have Prospero’s enemies on board. We later find out that this storm was, in fact, created by Prospero himself for the purpose of trapping his enemies on his island. At first it may seem that this was an act of vengeance by the part of Prospero and it may be, but he asks Ariel if his enemies are okay (Line 217). By Act 2 Scene 1, we meet Prospero’s enemies. Here it becomes more obvious that Prospero wants vengeance as he is making Alonso suffer by thinking his son, Ferdinand, is dead because of the storm. This scene showcases another plot of Prospero’s, which is to kill off Alonso. Prospero, through Ariel, makes all but Antonio and Sebastian fall asleep. This way, Antonio and Sebastian can speak their minds without worrying of consequence. This leads to Antonio persuading Sebastian to kill his father so Sebastian can take his father’s throne. This plan is nearly seen through except that Prospero, again through Ariel, wakes up Gonzalo and stops the plan. This scene shows that Prospero is conflicted; he isn’t sure if he should take revenge on his enemies by killing them, or just forgive his enemies and heal the social order. This middle part of the play is the tipping point for Prospero. In the beginning his plan was to get revenge on his enemies and even told this to his daughter, but in the coming scenes, Prospero realizes that he wants emotional vengeance and that can only be achieved by healing the social order. This hypothesis makes an appearance in Act 3 Scene 3 when......

Words: 677 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Evaluate the View That Religion Is an Important Source of Moral Values in Contemporary Socities

...“Evaluate the view that religion is an important source of moral values in contemporary societies” The debate as to whether religion is a vital source of moral values in contemporary society is continuous. Sociologists aim to know and understand exactly how and if religion plays any role in current society. This leads us to ask what exactly religion is. According to sociologists, there are three main ways of defining religion: substantive, functional and social constructionist. Max Weber (1905) describes substantive religion as a belief in a superior or supernatural power that is above nature and cannot be explained scientifically. Substantive definitions are exclusive – they draw a clear line between religious and non-religious beliefs. To be a religion, a set of beliefs must include beliefs in God or the supernatural. Functional definitions, however, are inclusive – allowing sociologists to include a wide range of beliefs and practices. Emile Durkheim (1915) defines it in terms of contribution it makes to social integration rather than specific belief in a higher being. Milton Yinger (1970) identifies functions that religion performs for individuals, such as answering ‘ultimate questions’. Whereas, the final definition is social constructionist takes an interpretivist approach focusing how religion is defined by the individual. This definition believes that it is impossible to produce a single universal definition of religion to cover all cases since in reality different......

Words: 5435 - Pages: 22

Premium Essay

Aligning the Is Organization Within the Enterprise Has Its Set of Unresolved Issues. Why Is This Exercise Such a Contemporary Issue

...Question: 1. Aligning the IS Organization within the Enterprise has its set of unresolved issues. Why is this exercise such a contemporary issue? [25] The alignment of business and IT has been a major management concern for decades. Two recent surveys revealed that it continues to be a top priority for CIOs. A contributing issue is the lack of functional relationships between business and IT, complicated by the complexity of the service delivery mechanism. There is also the attitude that a quick application fix, if implemented, will be the magic bullet that solves the problem and increases confidence and collaboration within the business units receiving the IT service. We can look at the IS organisation aligning within the Enterprise in the context of the Strategic Information Systems Planning (SISP) which entails establishing a program for implementation and use of information systems in ways that will optimize effectiveness of information resources and use them to support the objectives of the organization. In order to fulfill alignment the plan should:- ❖ Be deeply embedded in business issues ❖ Continue to meet Data Processing and MIS Needs ❖ Have objectives and priorities derived from business imperatives ❖ Provide long term benefits and advance business strategy First, let’s look at why alignment problems occur. In some organizations, alignment difficulties can begin as communication problems when business and technical staff speak......

Words: 4424 - Pages: 18

Premium Essay

'Lear's Suffering Is Due to the Stripping Away of His Identity'. by Considering the Dramatic Presentation of King Lear, Evaluate This View.

...'Lear's suffering is due to the stripping away of his identity'. By considering the dramatic presentation of King Lear, evaluate this view. Shakespeare presents that the stripping away of King Lear's identity is largely responsible for much of his suffering throughout the play. Lear's identity can be seen as lost partly through his own actions, as well as the actions of others, in particular that of his daughters, Goneril and Regan. It can be argued that Lear's loss of identity is down to his own actions. Hence, he can be seen as responsible for causing his own suffering. According to A.C. Bradley 'The idea of the tragic hero as being destroyed simply and solely by external forces is quite alien to him (Shakespeare); and not less so is the idea of the hero as contributing to his destruction only by acts in which we see no flaw'. Bradley's emphasis on the tragic flaw implies that Shakespeare's character's bring their fates upon themselves and thus deserve to face the consequences. An example of this can be seen in Act 1, when Lear fragments his land and divides it between his daughters. The fragmentation of the land is symbolic of the way that Lear also fragments his identity. As king, Lear identifies himself solely on his position of power, and therefore by giving away his land his is also giving away the control he previously maintained over his kingdom, and thus his identity. However, Lear mistakenly believes that he can give up certain aspects of his role,......

Words: 1784 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

The Development of Desires and Magical Intervention in the Tempest

...Prospero’s demise. Caliban, by inflating Stephano’s ego with compliments of his bravery and courageousness, leads Stephano to the idea of becoming the island’s king. Ariel, additionally, plays a role in this scene as his magical interventions are showcased once more and continue to play a role in the development of the characters. Furthermore, the personalities of the characters in this scene are emphasized and highlighted along with their relationships with one another. This scene contributes to the development of the play so far in that it prompts a future storyline of Stephano attempting to become the king of the island. Caliban, who has become infatuated with Stephano, prompts him to agree to kill Prospero and take Miranda as his wife to become the king of the island. Stephano, who has been shown to possess a significant ego, takes Caliban’s compliments and praise and agrees to this proposition. Caliban’s hatred for Prospero has been shown throughout the play, as he has made threats and curses upon him such as: “A southwest blow on ye/And blister you all o’er” (1.2.325). This scene highlights his resentment once again as he tells Stephano and Trinculo of his misfortunes at the hand of Prospero as he states that Prospero “by his cunning hath cheated [him] of the island” (3.2.34-35). Throughout Caliban’s story he additionally showers Stephano in compliments of his bravery and courageousness as he refers to him as his “valiant master” (3.2.38) and states that Stephano is......

Words: 1308 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

The Tempest

...The Tempest The tempest by Shakespeare has a range of slaves, all different in nature and appearance. In this play, Shakespeare, through the use of the different slaves brings up the issue of colonisation in its different forms. This essay will explore the dissimilarities between Caliban and Ariel. Ariel, undeniably Prospero’s favourite off the two, is an air spirit as his/her name suggests who was enslaved by Sycorax and is more willing to do tasks ordered by Prospero. Caliban, Sycorax’s son is a very ill-tempered and unwilling slave who does not hold his master in the highest regard. This essay will analyse Caliban and Ariel’s different and temperaments, their attitudes towards freedom and their relationship with Prospero. Ariel and Caliban are very different in temperament and appearance. Caliban, whose name can be rearranged to spell Cannibal, is dark skinned, bad tempered creature who is not overly attractive. People in Shakespeare’s time and perhaps even now, may perceive him as wicked based on his appearance. This would be due mainly to the idea of predetermination. This is basically the idea that people are the same inside as they are out and deserve whatever treatment afforded by their looks and were made to fulfil a certain purpose, which can be clearly identified by their appearance. Caliban temperament is seen mainly through his speech. He has a negative attitude towards language. He suggest that it does not do him much good, as he says "You taught me language,......

Words: 1190 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

Task 1: Describe How the Debt Collection Industry Has Evolved and Evaluate the Impact This Sector Has on the Uk Economy.

...Industry has evolved and evaluate the impact this sector has on the UK economy. The debt collection industry has evolved dramatically and it has a strong impact on the UK’s economy. One of the earliest examples of credit goes back to 1572 when moneylenders and pawnbrokers provided ‘survival’ credit however it was not until the late 19th century that instalment credit became available and this was the start of the debt collection industry. Initially the debt collection industry was local based field collectors who would make personal visits to overdue customers. ‘In the early days of merchandising, the proprietor was his own credit manager. His customers were not numerous, and he knew most of them personally. To each applicant of credit accommodation he applied a threefold test. Can he pay? Will he pay? When will he pay? If the answers to these questions were satisfactory, the customer got the goods and the charge went “on book.”’ (Effective collection Methods). The tactics employed at this stage were very much by way of threat and intimidation towards the debtor. These were the early days of debt collection therefore no legislation or guidelines were published therefore the debt collection industry really did work on ‘bullying tactics’ and even threat of exposure to other people and the threat of bankruptcy. However the evolution of tactics employed by the debt collection industry is only a recent change in comparison to the length of time debt collection has been......

Words: 916 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Evaluate the View That Religion Is an Important Source of Moral Values in Contemporary Societies.

...years, there has been a great differ in the views of society and how people see religion and how important and influential it is to our moral values in contemporary societies today. This essay will look at why various different theory ideologies and their ideas about religion, and how it influences us day to day in our lives. The definition of a religion can vary depending on who you ask. The simplest definition of a religion is that for a religion to become a religion, there must be a belief of the supernatural and must also be a belief in God. The functionalists hold a different perspective on religion. Functionalists see religion as being there to fulfil the needs of society for example, functionalists feel that religion sets certain norms and values for society and gives people morals. Durkheim see's religion as something that contributes to society, rather than to any specific belief in god or any supernatural life form. For functionalists, society is a system of interrelated parts with basic needs that must be met in order to survive. Religion plays a key function for society as it creates social solidarity and a value consensus. Durkheim says that the key feature of religion is not a belief in gods or the supernatural, but a fundamental distinction between the sacred and the profane, as long as you see what you worship as sacred then Durkheim says that it is fine to be a religion. Durkheim believes in the collective conscience - a set of shared norms, values,......

Words: 1069 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Explore the Ways in Which Shakespeare Presents Men in Power in the Tempest Showing How Your Understanding Is Illuminated by Your Study of the Presentation of Men in Dr Faustus

...Shakespeare voices some of his views about the world he was living in. Along with themes of power, men and control, colonization also seems to be a main focus of Shakespeare throughout The Tempest, as almost every character ponders upon how he would rule the island on which the play is set if he were its king. Dr Faustus was written during the reign of England’s Queen Elizabeth I by Christopher Marlowe. It focuses on the main character, Dr Faustus, selling his soul to the devil in exchange for all the luxuries the world has to offer “twenty-four years of all voluptuousness.” Both plays present men questing for power and have left their mark on the modern world of literature. Shakespeare highlights the dominant themes power and control through the characters of Prospero and Antonio. Throughout the play many of the characters are in constant battle for power and freedom sometimes resulting in them succumbing to malevolent deeds. Prospero personifies the imperialist omnipotent ruler as he enslaves Caliban son of Sycorax and rightful ruler of the island. He uses the informal pronoun and pejorative phrase “thou most lying slave” to demonise and demoralise Caliban. The play explicitly portrays relationships between a man who possesses power and a man who is subject to that power. Shakespeare presents these characters to us to convey the innate nature of men and contest their way of thinking in a Patriarchal society. The relationship Prospero has with Caliban is full of hatred,......

Words: 1866 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Tempest Information

...This is a good article. Click here for more information. The Tempest From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia (Redirected from The tempest) This article is about the Shakespeare play. For other uses, see The Tempest (disambiguation). The shipwreck in Act I, Scene 1, in a 1797 engraving by Benjamin Smith after a painting by George Romney The Tempest is a play by William Shakespeare, believed to have been written in 1610–11, and thought by many critics to be the last play that Shakespeare wrote alone. It is set on a remote island, where Prospero, the rightful Duke of Milan, plots to restore his daughter Miranda to her rightful place using illusion and skilful manipulation. He conjures up a storm, the eponymous tempest, to lure his usurping brother Antonio and the complicit King Alonso of Naples to the island. There, his machinations bring about the revelation of Antonio's lowly nature, the redemption of the King, and the marriage of Miranda to Alonso's son, Ferdinand. There is no obvious single source for the plot of The Tempest, but researchers have seen parallels in Erasmus's Naufragium, Peter Martyr's De orbe novo, and eyewitness reports by William Strachey and Sylvester Jordain of the real-life shipwreck of the Sea Venture on the islands of Bermuda, and the subsequent conflict between Sir Thomas Gates and Sir George Somers. In addition, one of Gonzalo's speeches is derived from Montaigne's essay Of the Canibales, and much of Prospero's renunciative speech is taken...

Words: 9690 - Pages: 39

Free Essay


...ADRIAN and FRANCISCO, lords CALIBAN, a savage and deformed slave TRINCULO, a jester STEPHANO, a drunken butler MASTER of a ship BOATSWAIN MARINERS MIRANDA, daughter to Prospero ARIEL, an airy spirit IRIS, the rainbow, messenger of Juno CERES, goddess of the harvest JUNO, queen of the gods and wife of Jupiter: the goddess of riches, the air and of marriage NYMPHS REAPERS SPIRITS The scene: an uninhabited island The Tempest ACT I SCENE I. On a ship at sea: a tempestuous noise of thunder and lightning heard. Enter a Master and a Boatswain Master Boatswain! Boatswain Here, master: what cheer? Master Good, speak to the mariners: fall to't, yarely,or we run ourselves aground: bestir, bestir. Exit Enter Mariners Boatswain Heigh, my hearts! cheerly, cheerly, my hearts!yare, yare! Take in the topsail. Tend to themaster's whistle. Blow, till thou burst thy wind,if room enough! Enter ALONSO, SEBASTIAN, ANTONIO, FERDINAND, GONZALO, and others ALONSO Good boatswain, have care. Where's the master?Play the men. Boatswain I pray now, keep below. ANTONIO Where is the master, boatswain? Boatswain Do you not hear him? You mar our labour: keep yourcabins: you do assist the storm. GONZALO Nay, good, be patient. Boatswain When the sea is. Hence! What cares these roarersfor the name of king? To cabin: silence! trouble us not. GONZALO Good, yet remember whom thou hast aboard. Boatswain None that I more love than myself. You are......

Words: 17157 - Pages: 69

Premium Essay

Caliban and Colonialism

...Musings on Caliban and colonialism In the Tempest, the audience’s first introduction to Caliban is preceded by Prospero’s exchange with Ariel. Ariel’s passive servitude, respectful attitude and general compliance and integration into the human world contrast deeply with Caliban, and this juxtaposition continues throughout the play and serves to illustrate the theme of colonialism, and its different levels, that his character embodies and explores. There are a number of qualities that set Caliban apart from the rest of the characters in the text. Prospero calls him names such as ‘demi-devil’, ‘hag-seed’ and ‘strange fish’ are myriad. While they might appear pejorative, and were probably meant that way by Prospero, these names also link Caliban to the island of his origin. Caliban is, indeed, a spirit of non-human form and the son of a powerful witch. Yet it could be argued that Prospero has projected his own prejudices onto these terms and appropriated their true concepts to highlight his own authority. Some choose to read this as Shakespeare’s response to Montaigne’s oxymoronic vision of the noble savage. Shakespeare’s contemporary, Montaigne argued that the uncivilised societies of the indigenous American tribes were in fact naturally noble, which he believed was superior to the artificial constraints of the civilised, western world. In his essay, Of Cannibals, he explores the perpetually conflicting relationship between nature and nature, and the intersectionality...

Words: 448 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Better Than This Yet to Come

...with all these, it’s when we may say you can go on, success doesn’t mean plentiful money it’s just satisfaction with what you have, all people need success it’s better to have a peaceful mind than money wealth. How, when can we have success?, Studying its alternative way used by many to reach their life summit, try to think of famous people using their talents to gain their hopeful moments and tremendous life standard, this is the right time to use your talents and abilities before the sunset, try to check these people utilizing their motives and potential, why not me and you. If you want to play golf like Tiger woods’; it needs you take a moment of time, practice it, learn it, accept challenges, take time to initiate and just live simple, you will Run all the balls from a distance to the pits. If you want buckets like Michael Jordan; not only strong hands and muscle just love the game also, think to play more than him, appreciate the forerunner of the game live simple, patience and it will be done. If you want play tennis ball as Marley; you better visit gymkhana, appreciate a Swedish man Roger, yes Get to know wiliams daughters, follow through their path, just Believe what you see. If you want preach as Gaither in songs; just try to know alto, tenor, soprano and bass in detail, try to sing More than Guy Penrod, David Phillips and even Don Moen, yes Trust in God he’s always there to help you, just make a couple Of inspiring and praising songs. There are so...

Words: 444 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

“the Fact That Girls Do Better Than Boys Is More to Do with Factors Outside of the School Rather Than Factors Inside of the School.” to What Extent Do You Agree with This View?

...“The fact that girls do better than boys is more to do with factors outside of the school rather than factors inside of the school.” To what extent do you agree with this view? If we look at exam results such as GCSEs and A levels there is a clear picture of girls outperforming boys. Girls are also more likely to pass their A levels and go on to university. These gender and differential educational achievement have been explained by the influence of factors both inside and outside of the school. Many sociologists have argued that it is factors inside the school that have led to this increase in girls’ performance. It has been argued that feminism has had a huge role in female achievement in education. Mitsos and Browne say that teaching has been feminised and teachers have lower expectations of boys. They say that women are more likely to be classroom teachers and this is therefore giving girls positive role models. There has also been the change in teaching resources used at schools as many sexist images have been removed and they are less likely to stereotype girls into passive roles. Interpretivists say that teachers have lower expectations of boys. Teacher’s expectations may lead to a self-fulfilling prophecy of poor behaviour. Negative labelling may explain why there are more disruptive boy and why boys are more likely to be excluded from school. Jackson agrees with this view arguing that schools label boys negatively which leads to self-fulfilling prophecy. The......

Words: 959 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

The Tempest

...Reality in The Tempest The Tempest, by William Shakespeare, tells the story of a magician, Prospero, who, along with his daughter, Miranda, was usurped by his brother Antonio and King Alonso of Naples. After twelve years of living an island, Prospero uses his magic to create a tempest that sinks Antonio and Alonso’s ship, bringing them to the island. Prospero’s plan for revenge includes his daughter falling in love with the king’s son, Ferdinand; his servant Ariel fooling Alonso and his men; and his slave Caliban getting intoxicated with two men from the ship. Prospero uses his magic to change the emotions of Miranda, Alonso, and Caliban, placing them under different illusions. One of the primary themes in the play is that an altered state of reality that the characters go through that influence their decisions and actions. Thus, the false infatuation that Miranda and Ferdinand mistake for love changes both their actions and opinions. Additionally, Caliban, Trinculo, and Stephano are all given courage because of their drunkenness and plot to kill Prospero, a plan they never would have dreamed about if they were sober. Miranda and Ferdinand both go through severe personality changes because of their illusion of love. The two lovers had come from very different backgrounds; Ferdinand, a royal family with riches, and Miranda, just her father and two servants. Their relationship is new territory for Miranda for she had never seen man besides Prospero; therefore, she......

Words: 1139 - Pages: 5