Free Essay

Biological Approach to Depression

In: Philosophy and Psychology

Submitted By kittykat0191
Words 1090
Pages 5
Outline and evaluate the Biological Approach to Depression
According to the biological approach all psychological illnesses have a physical cause; it focus is on the treatment not the cure this can support the reason why relapse rates are high for individuals with depression. The biological approach to abnormality states that abnormality is caused by a range of different physical factors: Genetics and chemical imbalances in the brain. It is suggested that people possess certain genetic characteristics that make them more prone to developing abnormal behaviour such as depression. It is also thought that chemical imbalances in the brain produce abnormal behaviour, for example a lack of serotonin causes depression. This approach is better at explaining endogenous depression. Family, twin and adoption studies are used to research into depression. Supporting evidence for the biological approach is that depression is universal, as they are increasing and found cross culturally.
Weismann (1987) stated that family evidence suggests that a person is 10 times more likely to suffer from depression, if a parent or sibling has a similar disorder. This could be because living with a person who is depressed could be depressing. However, according to a behavioural explanation this behaviour could have being modelled as the female could identify with the eating disorder and use them as a role model. Also family studies are conducted using retrospective data (looking back) and rely on correct and accurate diagnosis and records which aren’t always reliable. This could be because older generations may not have being diagnosed with an eating disorder because there was a stigma attached and didn’t seek the help they needed.
Mc Guffin et al (1996) conducted an experiment based on nearly 200 pairs of twins found that when an identical twin had depression. There was a 46% chance that the other twin would also have the disorder and results for non identical twins were 20%. However, twin studies pose a number of problems. On the fact of it they suggest a genetic cause. The more genes people share the more likely they are to share the characteristic. One firm conclusion we can draw of course is that anorexia is not entirely genetic otherwise there would be 100% concordance in identical twins. So even if there is a genetic component other factors must also be at work, such as the behaviour being modelled through vicarious reinforcement, according to the behavioural approach. The major problem is in ruling out environmental factors. Not only do twins share the same genes they also share very similar environments. Twins are often dressed similarly, have the same friends, same interests, same social class and environment. However, ID twins are always the same sex, unlike non-ID twins that can be brother and sister. This last factor is particularly relevant when considering eating disorders because of their much greater prevalence in girls. When considering genetic causation it is also worth mentioning that the effect may not be direct. Perhaps genes are influencing a characteristic which in turn is increasing the risk of eating disorders. For example, as we’ll see with the cognitive model, many anorexics have perfectionist personality traits and there is evidence to suggest that this personality type is itself genetic. The data on much of the genetics research is from clinic samples, which are obviously not representative of the general population, particularly because such samples tend to be quite small because of the difficulty of finding twins where one or both have an eating disorder, which means that population validity is limited.
Harrington et al (1993) compared people who have being adopted with their biological and adopted parents. He found that up to 20% of those relatives suffered from the disorder compared with 5-10% of their adoptive relatives. In conclusion this shows a higher rate of depression in their biological parents compared to adopted parents. However, these are not representive groups as they have given their child up for adoption which could be linked to depression. If the biological parents gave their child up for adoption due to depression then there would be depression in the family history. Also you need to know the need to know the age the child was adopted as the behavior could have being modelled according to a behavioral approach.
The biological approach also states that the depression could be due to an imbalance of chemicals. It suggests that in depression serotonin levels are low which could have being inherited. This is supported by the success of Prozac and other anti-depressants which increase serotonin. However, this could be a placebo effect where the cognitive approach states the individual thinks they are feeling better because they are taking the drugs.
The endocrine system and depression suggests a link between chemical imbalances/ bodily changes and depression. The female menstrual cycle involves changes in the level of oestrogen and progesterone over the monthly cycle. The week or two prior to the menstruation some women become irritable, gain mood swings, decreased concentration and depression. This is linked to changes related to hormonal fluctuations.
This is supported by Abranowitz et al (1982) studied female admissions to one psychiatric hospital and found 41% entered on the day before or on the first day off their menstrual period. However, this could have being because of the stress of the admission which can affect the period cycle. Also not every individual would be admitted into a psychiatric hospital with depression, you need to know what the disorder they had. The women on the pill wouldn't be accounted for.
The strengths of the biological approach is that it decreases the stigma associated with labeling someone as ‘abnormal’ because it is thought that the abnormality is not the fault of the individual, it is merely down to chance and luck. This means that people who suffer with depression are now more widely accepted and they are able to lead easier lives. Also it a very scientific approach to abnormality and allows research to be undertaken which can prove or disprove theories of what causes depression. However, it gives the person diminished responsibility for their own wellbeing as they put their trust in the doctors and other professionals to look after their best interests. Also it is unclear whether chemical imbalances in the brain are the cause of the depression or symptoms of it. The biological approach is reductionist because it assumes that humans are merely biological and that all of our thought processes occur due to chemicals and innate programming, it doesn’t take into account other approaches view points.…...

Similar Documents

Free Essay

Biological Approcach

...The aim of phychosurgery is to use physical procedures to treat mental disorders such as depression by destroying sections of the brain or by severing nerve connections that connect the frontal lobe to the rest of the brain. In the past it was belived that these would re-generate into healthy connections, however this idea was later proven to be invalid. As well as depression, psychosurgery has also been used for people with severe OCD, bi-polar disorder and schizophrenia. This first assumption of the biological approach is that behaviour is caused by physical structures in the body ( i.e, the brain, hormones, neurotransmitters). It therefore follws that biological psychologists belive that mental illness have a physical cause and so psychosurgery links to this as it aims to treat mental illness by physically altering brain structure. The biological approach also assumes that different parts of the brain have different functions (i.e., localisation of function) and so psychosurgery links to this as surgery on a specific area will affect a certain behaviour/function (i.e damage to the frontal lobe will affect personality and emotions). This idea underlies psychosurgery as the intention is to disrupt a particular brain function in order to suppress the symptoms of mental illness. The historical basis for psychosurgery came from the case of Phieas Gage which highlighted that the frontal lobes are linked to personality (but not intelligence or memory). Furthermore, Moinz......

Words: 495 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Outline and Evaluate Research Into the Biological Approach to Abnormality

...The biological approach to abnormality assumes that psychopathology is largely down to the four main physiological factors: infection, neuroanotmy, neurochemistry and genetics. Infection is the result of pathogens entering the blood stream and entering the blood brain barrier or the nervous system. These pathogens cause diseases of the brain. For example in 1900's 3rd stage syphilis caused dementia and finally death. However this part of the biological approach is a very small explanation of abnormality, and with large advancements modern medicine is becoming decreasingly unseen. Another issue is multi-finality. For example schizophrenia has been associated with the flu during pregnancy, however not every expectant mother with flu has a schizophrenic child. A lot of other factors are involved in the disease, and simply labelling flu as the only cause is going to cause issues in the understanding of multiple factors. Neuroanatomy refers to the different activities and structures of the brain regions and tissue. This is often tested through MRI scans of normal people and comparing to those mentally ill. One example is schizophrenia where the ventricles appear enlarged and the amount of grey matter in the brain is reduced. It is however hard to differentiate between causation and effect, as not knowing which proceeds which can only lead to guess work in terms of causation. Another issue is not every mentally ill person has the same structural abnormalities, and where one......

Words: 399 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Outline and Evaluate Biological Approach to Stress

...Outline and evaluate the Biological approach to abnormality The biological approach suggests that psychological disorders should be treated medically, as this model puts forward the idea that any psychological abnormality is causes by genetic factors and body malfunctions. The model as 4 different elements that may be the cause of psychological abnormalities; viral infections, biochemistry, brain damage, genetic factors. Several studies have been carried out by different researchers to investigate the theories of the model. Biochemical elements, is one of the highly researched parts of this model, where Weinberger in 2002 carried out research that suggested the 22nd chromosome doubled the risk of developing schizophrenia, another study carried out by Zubieta in 2000, where PET scans helped figured out that 30% higher levels of dopamine, serotin and norepinephrine were i9n people with bipolar disorder. On the other hand Janowsky carried out a study to show how biochemical imbalances lead to manic depression. While souse carried out a study in 2010 where genomes of 1000 autistics and 1200 non autistic participants, results showed that autistic participants carry 20% more copy number variation which suggests that this may be caused due to genetics. The viral infections elements were also researched by brown in 2000 where findings suggested that there’s a link between respiratory infections and the second trimester of pregnancy, which may results in the foetus developing......

Words: 448 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Depression

...Depression Paper Jennifer Ridgeway Herrick PSY/270 August 18, 2013 Tanya Harrell Depression Paper Most people’s moods will come and go without incident. Their feelings of elation or sadness are understandable reactions to daily events and do not affect their lives greatly or the lives of people around them. The moods of people with mood disorders, in contrast, tend to last a long time. Their mood colors all of their interactions with the world and interferes with normal functioning of their daily lives. (Comer, 2011) According to the American Journal of Psychiatry, Patients with bipolar disorder differ from patients with unipolar depression by having family histories of mania with an earlier onset and by having more episodes over a lifetime. Their study was designed to determine whether additional aspects of course of illness, the presence of medical diseases, childhood traits, and other familial illnesses separate the two groups. The group of bipolar patients had an earlier onset, a more acute onset, more total episodes, andmore familial mania and were more likely to be male. These differences were relatively independent of each other. The bipolar patients were also more likely to be hyperactive as children. The unipolar patients had a significantly greater number of lifetime medical/surgical interventions than the bipolar patients, even when age was controlled. Alcoholism was more prevelant in the families of the bipolar patiens, even when alcoholism in the......

Words: 1212 - Pages: 5

Free Essay

Biological

...fast off which have the added benefit of helping to reduce shaking. Depression is related with low levels of the neurotransmitter serotonin this is treated by using anti-depressants which tries to increase the levels of serotonin by stopping the reuptake of it because serotonin gets fired from one neuron to another across a synapse, which they then go into receptors but after they are fired reuptake happens (where the serotonin is absorb by the firing neuron) SSRI’s work by blocking reuptake of the serotonin so it stays in the receptors for longer. Both of these therapies are clearly related to the biological assumption because they are both on about neurotransmitters and biological substances. There are many strengths for the biological approach one of them is that chemotherapy has led to many successful practical applications. For example antipsychotics have helped schizophrenia patients, and the result of this is that chemotherapy is now the NHS treatment of choice and it has led to a better quality of life for many people. Another strength of the biological approach is that it is scientific (this means that it can be proven, objectively tested) The independent variable can be manipulated easily and all the other variables can be controlled other than the dependent variable which can then show how much the independent variable has an effect on the dependent variable. A weakness of the biological approach is that it is reductionist (it over simplifies behaviour)......

Words: 1331 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Depression

...world was falling apart, and there was not anything that you could do to fix it? Unfortunately, this is the case for millions of people every day who suffer from major depression. Major depression can present itself in many forms, display various symptoms, and have different treatment options based on the individual’s level of depression. Although some do not consider major depression severe, it is a disease that can cripple and destroy one’s life if they do not receive adequate help. Major Depressive Disorder (MDD) is a mood disorder having a clinical course involving one or more episodes of severe psychological depression lasting two or more weeks each with no intervening episodes of mania (Major Depressive Disorder, n.d.). Major depression makes it almost impossible to sleep, eat, study, and enjoy the everyday joys in life. Major Depression can last for six months and range from mild to severe if not treated. A person suffering from major depression has a much shorter life span compared to people not suffering from depression (Major Depressive Disorder, 2013). This crippling disease often leads to cowardly actions by people suffering and they end up committing suicide due to frustration. Researchers have found that approximately 3.4% of suicidal cases in the United States are a result of depression. This is a major cause of concern in our society. Major Depressive Disorder is the leading cause of disability in the United States for ages 15-44 (National......

Words: 1704 - Pages: 7

Free Essay

Biological Approach to Treatment of Depression.

...Presented here it is a critical evaluation of biological approach for treatment of depression. Antidepressant are the most common biological treatment for this type of disorder, but treatments such as Electroconvulsive Therapy (ECT), alteration in sleep patterns following body temperature cycle are also used to relief the symptoms of depression. However antidepressant drugs provide an effective and inexpensive help, studies have found that the behavioural effects of these drugs could take over two weeks before showing any benefit and any perceived effect before this period would be a placebo effect (Kalat, 2001). Some studies proposed the existence of a two models markers for depression: Biological/endogenous & psychological/reactive depression. Based on this assumption an endogenous depression would only respond to a pharmacological treatment while a psychological depression would only respond to psychological treatment (Free & Oei, 1989). Further we will evaluate the effectiveness of a combined (cognitive-behavioural therapy and antidepressant) intervention in order to achieve a better outcome on treatment of depression. Depression is one of the most common illnesses and is characterised by symptoms such as loss of energy, sadness, difficulty in concentration and in the most serious cases the patient can contemplate or commit suicide. Research found that women are more likely to suffer from depression, with depressive episodes more probable to occur between 25 to 44......

Words: 1773 - Pages: 8

Free Essay

Biological Approach to Abnormality

...The purpose of the biological perspective is to determine the physiological basis of psychology and most importantly behaviour.  The perspective primarily uses the experimental method and has been criticized for being too reductionist and for using non-human animals. Strengths By knowing the physiological basis of behaviour we can treat symptoms with drugs evolutionary theory can explain things that would otherwise be unexplainable Weaknesses It is difficult to seperate genetic influence from environmental influence It's reductionistic Can't explain altruism well Historical Context  The biological perspective was created as a reaction to the theory of dualism, that the mind and the brain are two seperate entities. Some important researchers in the development of the biological perspective are: Plato-nativism Darwin- Outlined evolution and the idea of nativism and heredity Jean Baptiste Lamarck-studied heredity Phineas Gage- Brain injury has the ability to affect behaviour II. Key Concepts Heredity- influence of genes Nativism- certain traits are inately hardwired at birth Evolution Hemisphere specialization Neurotransmission Localization Evolution Selye’s General Adaptation Syndrome (GAS = Alarm, Resistance, Exhaustion) Biological preparedness Basic Assumptions There are four main basic assumptions of the biological perspective: Behavior is biologically determined Behavior has a genetic basis Localization of function Animals may be......

Words: 575 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Depression

...about clinical depression? What are the implications for treatment? Shvawn Christensen Psych 435 Athabasca University What does research indicate about clinical depression and what are the implications for treatment? The purpose of this paper is to logically provide a review about the biological and situational aspects of depression and the various forms of treatment. I will define what depression is, evaluate who depression affects and why, then proceed with the description of the most widely used methods of treatment, behavioral therapy and prescribed medication. I What is Depression? When it is referred to as your mood no one is exempt from some imbalance from time to time. This would be considered as normal day to day stress and living. However a diagnosis of depression is arrived at after a person has had or displayed a long struggle with feelings of sadness and hopelessness. As well if these feelings continue to affect and interfere with the person’s daily life. Unipolar and Bipolar are two types of mood disorders that can affect anyone of us. [People only troubled by depression would be diagnosed with “unipolar disorder” as this emotional disorder only affects one end of the mood continuum. However “bipolar disorder” affects both emotional ends of the mood continuum. People with this disorder will experience periods of both depression and mania] (Weiten & McCainn, 2007, p. 591) Depression has a negative......

Words: 2238 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Biological Approach

...Essay plan: ‘Discuss the biological approach to psychopathology’. PARAGRAPH 1- A01: Intro- explain the biological approach including key assumptions. • Biological approach regards abnormality as an illness or disease. • Assumes all mental disorders are related to some change in the body. • Mental disorders are related to the physical structure and functioning of the brain. • Seen people with psychological abnormality as ‘patients’ who are ‘ill’ and require ‘treatment’ to ‘cure’ them of disease. • Four possible factors that cause abnmormality: 1. Genetic Factors 2. Biochemistry 3. Infection 4. Brain Damage PARAGRAPH 2- AO1/2: Explain one cause of abnormality according to the biological approach and give supporting evidence. Brain damage. • Suggests that mental illnesses are caused by abnormal brain structure due to genes, development, illness or trauma. • Damage to the structure of the brain can lead to abnormal behaviour. • Once brain damage has caused mental illness there is little to be done to stop it. Examples • Alzheimer- a type of dementia caused by the malformation and loss of cells in a number of areas of the nervous system. • Alcohol and drugs can also damage the brain, which may result in korsakoffs syndrome – prefound impairment of memory most commonly caused by alcohol. Evidence. • Lawrie showed that an average schizophrenic lateral ventricle were 40% bigger than controls. This suggests that brain damage has caused......

Words: 833 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Evaluate the Biological Treatments of Depression.

...(MAOIs) and trycyclics (TCAs) are effective in reducing depressive symptoms. Antidepressants have been tested in trials with placebos and have found to be effective in reducing symptoms of severe depression in around 65% to 75% compared with around 33% for placebos – Gitlin 2002. Gitlin carried out a clinical trial testing selective serotonin re-uptake inhibitors (SSRIs) and placebos. He found that SSRIs were effective in reducing symptoms of depression in around 75% of patients compared with 33% for placebos. However the 33% of patients that felt better after taking the placebo drug suggests that the cause of depression is not all down to biological reasons but possibly cognitive too and that it may be about the way we think. There were factors that caused limitations to this study, the study was correlational, and this means that the cause and effect was not established between depression and the supposed cause. Hollon did a follow up study to see whether or not SSRIs are effective in treating the actual cause of depression or not. He found that those who were withdrawn from cognitive therapy had a relapse rate of 31% and those withdrawn from drug therapy had a relapse rate of 76%. This shows that drugs only treat the symptoms of depression rather than the actual underlying cause of depression. Therefore it is palliative. It is clear that drugs do not necessarily offer a long term cure as in many cases; symptoms recur when the drugs are no longer taken. To argue about......

Words: 768 - Pages: 4

Free Essay

Biological Explanations for Depression

...factors A01 – Family studies >having a 1st degree relative (parent or sibling) with depression appears to be a risk factor for depression >the studies select people who already have depression (probands), and then examine whether other family members have been, or might be, diagnosed with depression -if there is a genetic link for this disorder, the probands’ relatives should show higher rates of depression than the rest of the population Harrington et al (1993) >found that around 20% of proband’s close relatives have depression compared to 10% for the general population A01 – Twin studies >basis is that identical (monozygotic) twins are clones of each other and have all the same genes -fraternal (dizygotic) twins share just half of their genes -we assume that the environment shared by the twins is roughly the same for both types of twin McGuffin et al (1996) >studied 177 probands with depression with their same-sex co-twins >concordance rate was 46% for identical twins and 20% for fraternal twins >suggest that depression has a large heritable component A01 – Adoption studies Wender et al (1986) >studies the biological relatives of adopted individuals who had been hospitalised for severe depression >found a much higher rate of severe depression in the biological relatives of the depressed group than in the biological relatives of a non-depressed control group (nature may be a stronger component than......

Words: 1744 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Depression

...Research Paper: Victory Over Depression Abstract: In today’s society depression can be seen as taboo and something that is not socially acceptable. However, it is the ongoing reality for many women. The struggle with depression in the life of women is more common than not, whether it is undiagnosed or diagnosis it is prevalent regardless of ones socioeconomically background. The paper will explore depression onset, treatment and explore how individuals can have work towards having complete victory over depression. Class session 9 – “Fox Meadows Assisted Living”, page 177-178, Sweeney-Feld and Oetjen textbook.  The case study questions that you must respond to are found on page 178. The review of each team case should not exceed 12 double spaced pages, not including your APA cover page and a reference page. All type must be Times Roman 12 point pica. Use the APA style for citing all sources The team management paper (e.g., case analysis) accounts for 25 points, or 25 percent of your grade Background: The black box of depression can potentially have an unpredictable impact on the life of an individual. Those who struggle with this diagnosis on a day to day basis at times cannot predict the outcome of the situation if left untreated. That National Alliance of Mental Illness reports nearly 15 million Americans averaging one and ten adults experience some form of depression annually. The statistics amongst women are considerably startling because......

Words: 2589 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

Depression

...Depression Margarita Perez 2/19/15 Psychology 101 Carrington College On-Line In today’s society, millions of people are affected everyday with depression, in which it is very difficult for them to see a positive side. It has been proven that with the right medication and treatment there is hope. What is depression? Depression comes in so many forms and it affects every individual different. This can be from major disorder, anxiety, and clinical disorders. Depression is a serious medical illness and it is not something that is just made up in a person’s mind. When one begins to feel sad, loss, anger, or frustrated for no reason, this can be some of the early signs of depression. Depression impacts the brain that causes chemical changes and imbalances in the brain. Who is at risk? It has been said that one in every ten people will suffer from some type of depression. As depression continues to affect millions of Americans, it is also one of the most common serious brain diseases in the United States. One fact of depression that hold true, is depression is highly more common in women than it is in men. This may be due to female hormones, but yet we need to take into account that men are less likely to admit they may be depressed and seek medical care. Other factors of who may be at risk is age. Major depression is most likely to affect adults between the ages of 45 to 50. Race is yet another risk factor, which we see in Blacks and Hispanic Americans. The CDC......

Words: 1568 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Depression

...Depression is not an inclination, nor is it a feeling. It is an emotional instability that influences numerous individuals. It has been around for a huge number of years. Depression comes in numerous structures. It influences all races, ethnicities, and religions. Depression is defined as “a condition of mental disturbance characterized by such feelings to a greater degree than seems warranted by external conditions, typically with lack of energy and difficulty maintaining concentration or interest in life”. (New Oxford American Dictionary). Major depressive disorder also known as unipolar depression or recurrent depressive disorder is the most severe depressive disorder out of all of the depressive in my estimation.  Major depressive disorder is a condition in which affects a person’s family, work or school life, sleeping, eating and general health. It is important to emphasize that we can understand the mechanics of this disorder and how it affects people with major depressive disorder. Etiology By understanding who gets a particular illness it is possible to better develop methods to control, treat, and prevent a particular condition. However, depression is so widely experienced by so many people it is important to establish the patterns that might further help manage this disorder. It is clear that depression impacts many people personality and professionally, it dramatically reduces the quality and quantity if creative and productive work and often ruining people’s......

Words: 1907 - Pages: 8