Free Essay

Argument Against Wearing School Uniforms

In: English and Literature

Submitted By saramoss
Words 1124
Pages 5
Argument Against Wearing School Uniforms
Theirs is an ongoing discussion in the nation about school uniforms, whether or not they help with behavior problems and scores (“An Argument Against School Uniforms”). Kade A., A sixth grade student, when asked about school uniforms she said, “no, I don’t like them because they are uncomfortable and makes her and maybe the people around feel like their wearing church clothes all the time” (“An Argument Against School Uniforms”). “Clothes are a sources of expression for children, an as kids get older they become increasingly resentful of uniforms. By instituting a uniform policy, schools are taking away kids individuality. Schools need to decide if that sacrifice is worth making” (“An Argument Against School Uniforms”). “School Uniform use was not significantly correlated with any of the school commitment variables such as behavior, or substance use of (drugs). In addition, students wearing uniforms did not appear to have any significantly different academic preparedness, proschool attitudes, or peer group structures with proschool attitudes other than students” (“An Argument Against School Uniforms”).
Middle School/Junior High is a time of maturing, physically, mentally, academically and emotionally. Schools need to create an environment that encourages students individuality and motivate them to challenge themselves and inspire self confidence. Some people feel that school uniforms diminish creativity and self expression (“An Argument Against School Uniforms”). The people against school uniforms view school uniforms as symbol of tyranny of schools, which impedes free and complete development of personality. These people opine that school uniforms make students servile and submissive. According to these people against school uniforms, school uniforms should be done away with, because they just help in producing submissive citizens rather than free thinkers of future (“People Against School Uniforms”). People who are against uniforms are put on extra financial burden on parents. The parents have to buy school uniforms along with other fashion clothing. According to the people against school uniforms, school uniforms are money making tools of schools. Often, school uniform manufacturers pay sums to schools to seek monopoly on uniforms of specific schools. Children are constantly growing and manufacturers take advantage, and parents are left with no choice but to bear the costs of expensive school uniforms (“People Against School Uniforms”).
More importantly, even if we don't like the idea of school uniforms, people should have a choice regarding the matter. That's all part of freedom you must have the courage to let others be free to choose. Although, you have to sit still even when their choice (in favor of school uniforms) isn't what you would choose for yourself or your children, because that's taking away your right of choice (“School Uniforms Pros & Cons”). School Uniforms are an upfront expense for families who live off of hand-me-downs and used clothing. Programs to recycle used uniforms and funding to provide poor children with no cost or reduced cost uniforms would need to be in place (“Pros & Cons Of School Uniforms”).
School uniforms will restrict the outward expression of a child's unique individuality. School's primary function is to educate, but secondarily is a platform for socialization where clothing can play a role. We should not be teaching our children to blend (“Pros & Cons Of School Uniforms”). In the rare event of an emergency (such as a natural disaster) identification of students by their parents could be difficult if all children are wearing the same exact things (“Pros & Cons Of School Uniforms”). Many well intended adults have justified the use of school uniforms for many different reasons. No matter what you dress students in, they will always find a way to pass judgment upon their peers. If it's not based upon the style of clothes worn there are many other superficial ways to judge people and form cliques (“Argument About Uniforms”).
Many students of public schools believe that school uniforms should not be introduced because it is restraining people's freedom of expression and does not create diversity. One example how uniforms restrict learners are that "without the outlet of expression in their clothes, students may turn to inappropriate hair styles, jewelry, or makeup" (“Public School Uniforms”). Yes judging people upon their appearance can be bad in schools. However making everyone wear the same type of clothes is not going to make the problem magically disappear (“Argument About Uniforms”). As stated by the Public School Review, under the First Amendment, it argues that uniforms stifle children who feel robbed of their individualism. A second supporting example as to why uniforms are an awful proposal are because uniforms may not be comfortable for all students and they cannot wear their uniforms outside of school, and thus, there is the double cost of both uniforms and casual wardrobe. In school, if a child is trying to learn, but is not comfortable with the uniforms' fabric, it would cause a great burden and distraction to one's learning (“Public School Uniforms”).
Although a uniform can get boring with the same clothes and same color every day, uniforms have proven to lower hostility in many schools. The first example clarifies how “uniforms have reduced tardiness, skipped classes, suspensions, and discipline referrals"(“Public School Uniforms”). Barbara Bernstein, executive director of the New York Civil Liberties Union, reaffirmed the opinion of the A.C.L.U. when she stated that requiring school uniforms is not only illegal, it is not the solution to the school system's problems"(“Against School Uniforms Implementation”). Others think that focusing on education in the school system is extremely important, but uniforms should not be seen as a tool to maintain/acquire that focus (“Against School Uniforms Implementation”). If children are focusing more on their clothes and what items they or other students do/do not have - the school needs to re-evaluate the strength of their curriculum. What children are wearing in the classroom should have no bearing on what is expected of them as students (“Against School Uniforms Implementation”). If safety is a concern, we shouldn't be looking to a uniform to correct the issue if the concern is children not focusing on school work, or getting poor grades, again, uniforms should not be seen as a 'solution' (“Against School Uniforms Implementation”).
It is true that social classes still exist, even when students are in uniforms. Why, Though, strengthen the dividing lines between those classes by permitting students to show off their most expensive items in school? Schools are learning environment, and has no place for negative social stratifications. Uniforms only try to bridge the gap between social classes, through attempting to have everyone on the same common ground “Uniforms really level the playing field between the haves have the have-nots,” observed Long Beach District spokesman Richard VanDerLaan.…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Argument Against Wearing School Uniforms

...Argument Against Wearing School Uniforms Theirs is an ongoing discussion in the nation about school uniforms, whether or not they help with behavior problems and scores (“An Argument Against School Uniforms”). Kade A., A sixth grade student, when asked about school uniforms she said, “no, I don’t like them because they are uncomfortable and makes her and maybe the people around feel like their wearing church clothes all the time” (“An Argument Against School Uniforms”). “Clothes are a sources of expression for children, an as kids get older they become increasingly resentful of uniforms. By instituting a uniform policy, schools are taking away kids individuality. Schools need to decide if that sacrifice is worth making” (“An Argument Against School Uniforms”). “School Uniform use was not significantly correlated with any of the school commitment variables such as behavior, or substance use of (drugs). In addition, students wearing uniforms did not appear to have any significantly different academic preparedness, proschool attitudes, or peer group structures with proschool attitudes other than students” (“An Argument Against School Uniforms”). Middle School/Junior High is a time of maturing, physically, mentally, academically and emotionally. Schools need to create an environment that encourages students individuality and motivate them to challenge themselves and inspire self confidence. Some people feel that school uniforms diminish creativity and self expression (“An...

Words: 293 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

The Advantages of Wearing Uniform

... | Task: It is a good idea to wear school uniform | Nowadays almost schools require students to wear uniform when going to school as a compulsory discipline. Apparently wearing uniform | |brings great advantage for society, school and students’ family. Although a strick uniform policy has its own controversy disadvantages, | |with humorous benefits it gives about economy, school image, simplicity, wearing uniform is still necessary for students. | |Initially, it reinforces the idea that wearing uniform creates equality among students despite of diversity of races and cultural | |backgrounds. Once ago when students were free to choose their clothes to go to school, rich students were apparently well-dressed, while | |other poor students couldn’t afford expensive and pretty clothe, this often makes them less confident and even be isolated. Now in the same | |outfit, students don’t need to be worried the thought that they are worse off than other students. There will be no discrimination between | |wealth and poverty. Wearing uniform also leads to the sense of community and unity. | |Another benefit of wearing uniform is that it save time as well as money for both students and their family. Although a uniform is not very | |cheap, parents can cut down the expense of normal clothes. Because uniform is not fashion clothes, students don’t need to catch......

Words: 590 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

School Uniforms

...  According to the Institute of Education Sciences, 19 percent of public schools in the United States require students to wear uniforms. This causes a great debate between both parents and school principals of whether or not students should be forced to wear uniforms. I believe that forcing students to do so is completely against the individual rights of these growing and learning kids. There are many reasons supporting the ridiculousness of requiring school uniforms. Growing teens and children should be able to express their individuality by wearing what they want as long as it is appropriate to the Code of Conduct and school "Dress Code." Many kids, including myself, often like to represent a sports team by wearing a shirt or pair of pants after a good win the night before. Kids love to interact with their friends through their favorite teams and it is always a great conversation starter. Also there are a lot of teenagers like to dress appropriate to how they are feeling on that particular day. Many kids use colors to express how they feel. A student may dress with brighter colors on a day they are happy about something, compared to somebody dressing dark if they are upset. Students also like to dress comfortably based around how they feel physically. After a tough practice at a school sport the night before, kids can be sore or just fatigued. I always like to wear sweat pants on days like these. On a confident, energy filled day, I may want to wear a pair a khakis and a......

Words: 689 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Cons of a Student Wearing Uniforms

...The cons of enforcing a student to wear uniforms to school: When children are young they grow and develop their minds, their personalities, express that of who they are. They become individuals of their own person and what their interest is. Enforcing a child to wear a uniform this takes away their creativity of self-expression and who they are. We want to teach them that everybody is different and they are to accept those that are different from themselves. This cannot be done when every student is wearing the same thing. We cannot teach them to accept others that may be interested and self-express themselves such as one student may want to wear basketball shorts and t-shirt’s showing that he is into sports while another may want to wear dress pants, shirt and a tie to express that he is more mature and wants to pose a professional look onto himself. Students can also lose focus on their education where they will be seeking other outlets for self-expression and individuality such as tattoos, pierces, unacceptable hair styles and colors. Uniforms can also create a financial burden to families that may not be able to afford the required clothing when they can go to a Goodwill or thrift store and buy gently used items for their children to wear or even get hand me downs to clothe their child. If schools require certain colors this can also make them targets for hazing from other schools, this puts their lives into danger as well. Schools should want to push students to be......

Words: 365 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

School Uniforms

...Professor Benham ENC1101 4/18/2013 School Uniforms Did you ever notice how the students in the school dress a little to revealing? Well school uniforms would help get rid of that problem so the students could concentrate more on school work. Wearing schools uniforms would help make students’ lives simpler. The students would no longer have to worry about what to wear every morning. School should be based on how the students learn, not how they look. They should enforce the school uniform policy so that no one has to worry what everyone else is wearing and concentrate on schoolwork. According to Gary, “School uniforms are a great way to maintain a level of social equality among the students.” School uniforms make everyone equal. In this way, everyone would be at the same level. School uniforms would help the student in many ways. Students would no longer be worry about what to wear. Getting ready for school would be much faster and easier. The students would have a great benefit wearing schools uniforms. Students will feel more comfortable in the school, and there will be no difference between the “rich” kids and the poor ones. School uniforms are good for many reasons. School uniforms are cheaper that buying jeans and shirts for school and that is a benefit for the parents of the students that are in the school. Also the students won't have to worry about the clothes that they have to wear to school. According to Marian K, “School uniforms can save parents a lot......

Words: 1266 - Pages: 6

Free Essay

School Uniforms

...School Uniforms By Kendall Cole June 2014 AED/200 - CONTEMPORARY ISSUES IN AMERICAN EDUCATION Instructor: Christine Duhamel University of Phoenix Since the late 1990's school uniforms have been worn in mostly urban school districts across America. Initially, they were opposed by stakeholders, especially the students. School uniforms were accused of stripping students of their creative expression. After a while, uniforms were tolerated, it was realized that wearing uniforms helped to create a positive learning environment. “School uniforms are being advocated for a range of social, educational and familial issues” (Bodine, 2003, p. 67). There are so many issues students have to deal with when they attend school. Some of these issues create negativity in the student’s educational career. Stakeholders must come up with ways to help make learning environments and experiences more positive. Wearing school uniforms will help to create a positive learning environment. Since the turn of the new millennium, school uniforms have become common place and a trend in large school districts across America. In 1996, former President Bill Clinton mentioned school uniforms in his State of the Union Address (DeCosta, 2006 p. 49). Former President Clinton said, " And if it means that teenagers will stop killing each other over designer jackets, than our public schools should be able to require their students to wear school uniforms" (Mitchell,1996). Children have so many issues......

Words: 2297 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

School Uniforms

...School Uniforms: The Pros and Cons in schools (Final Paper) ChaMyra Lewis-Jackson ENG 122 English Composition II Mr. Brandon Bond December 23, 2014 School Uniforms: The Pros and Cons in schools In our country many concerns and issues about safety in our schools have caused a big disturbance which have led school districts to require uniforms for their students. Long ago, some parents seem against or incapable of singling out the "clothes" line with their children, to the point where the new trending styles took a toll and started influencing the kids' attire decisions in a big way. The safety of the students and environment which was surrounded by gang violence and other concerning distractions became an important matter for a lot of individuals within the school districts. School uniforms and dress codes can play a significant role in the drastic change with student in a learning environment (Boutelle, 2008). That’s why school uniforms should be implemented as a policy for students in different districts, because many reports have shown after enforcing this policy students showed a dramatic improvement in their academics, attendance and behavior. Most advocates imply that if all students are required to wear uniforms would give the students an opportunity to find a sense of unity and equality with one another which will help with the confidence of some that didn’t feel like they belonged. Uniforms would also diminish bullying and give students a better frame of......

Words: 1683 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

School Uniforms

... The School Uniform Debate: Measuring Effectiveness Pete Cade Jr. May 2015 Abstract With the rising numbers of violence in schools coupled with a decline in academic achievement, many stakeholders have begun to condemn the state of public school education. The situation has prompted schools across the country to look for unorthodox approaches to improve schools and the performance of their students. The result has led to a spreading initiative that dictates what students can wear. More than just a dress code policy, school uniforms take into account colors and styles from head to toe. Even with the ongoing debate of being constitutional, the trend continues to be adopted throughout the United States. The argument of limiting self-expression is far outweighed by the benefits of increased academic performance and student safety. This paper will outline the ongoing results from adding uniform policies to schools and analyze the debate of the pros and cons of wearing school uniforms. The School Uniform Debate: Measuring Effectiveness The Initial Movement Traditionally imposed by private and parochial schools, uniform policies are being implemented by U.S. public schools in rising numbers. Proponents note that school uniforms make schools much safer for students, encourage children to focus on learning and most significantly – that it puts a halt to socioeconomic disparities. On the same issue, opponents consider the mandates as an infringement on student’s......

Words: 2666 - Pages: 11

Free Essay

School Uniform

...cons about implying school uniforms. I want everyone to know that there are two ways to view if school uniforms should be implied to every public school. There are two sides to the story, but when it comes to picking one over the other, it's your decision to make. I will explain every detail about why schools should or should not have uniforms. In this case. I am having difficulty choosing a side because I agree with both, but everyone has a different perspective. The issue of use of uniforms in public schools has produced a lot of discussion in the recent years. A high number of key stakeholders in the educational sector think that uniforms may reduce negative conduct that is connected to student dress such as school violence, absenteeism, teasing and gang related activities. The main argument that opponents are advancing is that uniforms get in the way of students right to choose dress, violating their right to speech. While public schools have always had policies on dress code, there is a need to evaluate whether uniforms in public schools have any significance.The practice of requiring public school students to wear school uniforms began during the 1990s. Proponents argued that school uniforms led to better academic Bible believers need to support interventions that work to eradicate violence in schools. Although school uniforms may have been originated from Catholic schools and English schools, isolated American school districts used school uniforms prior to the......

Words: 2581 - Pages: 11

Free Essay

School Uniforms

...School Uniforms School uniforms are becoming a popular trend amongst schools. Students and even most parents don’t agree with the enforcement with school uniforms; stating that uniforms take away the right of self-expression. School uniforms are not a negative thing to have. Yes, uniforms limit what the students have to choose to wear to school every day, but it doesn’t limit them from learning; the only reason they are in school. Student treat school as a fashion show, so eliminating that puts the students’ full focus on schoolwork. Although requiring students to wear school uniforms may violate their self-expression in some ways, a uniform are supposed to be looked upon as a positive thing, because they eliminate bullying, combine social classes and gives the school campus a professional look. The most common argument against school uniforms is that they take away the students right to self- expression. Yes, school uniforms limit what the students have to wear, but he/she can still have their own ways of self-expression. Students can still express their style of choice by the way he/she styles their hair and what accessories they choose to wear. Their shoe choice is also a form of self-expression. Students can make the uniforms their own style without breaking the dress code. Just because a student can’t wear the most fashionable jeans to school doesn’t mean that his/her rights are taken......

Words: 727 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

School Uniforms

...School Uniforms: Turning Our Kids Into Soulless Conformists In text one “School uniforms; pros and cons” (2012) Ann Svensen explains the pros and cons’ of school uniforms. She looks at the subject from different angels and involves and focuses on two main arguments. The first argument she elucidates is the affect that school uniforms have on reducing school crimes and increasing the student’s disciplinary excellence. As for this argument Svensen talks about an informal statistic that showed, that school crime had highly declined over the years in California’s Long Beach Unified School District, after the urban made a mandatory uniform policy. Secondly she writes about, how many experts believe that school uniforms is a negative thing, because it is a violation of the students rights and freedom to express them self. Furthermore, it takes away their individuality. Journalist Laura Clark argues that school uniforms improve pupils in text two “School uniforms improve pupils’ behaviour both in and out of school”(2007). In her article she includes quotes from different professors, who argues that school uniforms makes the students more well behaved both out of and in school. Her main arguments are that school uniforms prevents bullying based on social status and the children don’t have to be insecure or think about their clothing. Furthermore, she argues that it decreases crime since the students know that people outside school will be able to catch them based of their......

Words: 1146 - Pages: 5

Premium Essay

School Uniforms

...a popular trend amongst schools. Students and even most parents don’t agree with the enforcement with school uniforms; stating that uniforms take away the right of self-expression. School uniforms are not a negative thing to have. Yes, uniforms limit what the students have to choose to wear to school every day, but it doesn’t limit them from learning; the only reason they are in school. Student treat school as a fashion show, so eliminating that puts the students’ full focus on schoolwork. Although requiring students to wear school uniforms may violate their self-expression in some ways, a uniform are supposed to be looked upon as a positive thing, because they eliminate bullying, combine social classes and gives the school campus a professional look. The most common argument against school uniforms is that they take away the students right to self- expression. Yes, school uniforms limit what the students have to wear, but he/she can still have their own ways of self-expression. Students can still express their style of choice by the way he/she styles their hair and what accessories they choose to wear. Their shoe choice is also a form of self-expression. Students can make the uniforms their own style without breaking the dress code. Just because a student can’t wear the most fashionable jeans to school doesn’t mean that his/her rights are taken away. School is a place to learn. Outside of school, kids can wear and......

Words: 466 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

School Uniforms

...Should uniforms be mandatory at school? School uniforms are becoming accepted, attractive and fashionable trend among students nowadays. Have you ever thought why should we wear uniforms in school? Some people think that that wearing uniforms must not be made compulsory at schools, since they think that it means schools limit student’s rights to choose what they want to wear and what clothes makes them comfortable, thus violating their self-expression. On the other hand, some people believe that school uniforms must be mandatory because uniforms improve educational skills; students focus more on the purpose of school which is to gain knowledge, decreases social discrimination and uniforms are cost effective and also time-saving School uniforms assist in improving the learning process by enhancing person’s attitude towards success. Uniforms create learning atmosphere. School uniforms greatly benefit both the students and schools themselves by creating an environment in which the students are able to concentrate more. Therefore, school uniforms aides in incrementing attendance records, achieving good grades by students and improving social behavior. Numerous individuals express their temperament partially, by their attire. In fact, an appealing uniform heightens a good self-image. Identical clothing in school, assists in accomplishing desires. When students are enforced to wear the same kind of clothes every day to their classes, they develop a sense of discipline which......

Words: 761 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Implementing School Uniforms

...Implementing School Uniform Policy in Public Schools Jennifer Phillips Sullivan University Abstract School uniform policies have become an important debate among public schools in the United States. The school district in Long Beach, California was the one of the first public schools to adopt a mandated uniform policy. The success that this school had, along with other schools that followed this path, does not seem to be enough evidence to convince other school leaders that school uniforms has a great impact on the students in behavior and academic success. Arguments among school leaders, parents, and students range from not enough statistical research to prove that the uniforms better the student’s safety and education, to the expense of uniforms compared to every day clothes. The evidence that the public schools have that participate in school uniforms seems to outweigh the petty arguments of a few critics. Keywords: school uniforms, safety, students, faculty, education Implementing School Uniform Policy in Public Schools School uniform policy is an ongoing debate spreading across our country. According to Schatcher (2005), “by the end of 2002 twenty-three percent of all elementary schools had adopted uniforms, and several middle and high schools had followed the pattern” (p.46). Presidents George W. Bush and Bill Clinton were both supporters of mandating uniform policies in the public schools. Clinton endorsed the policy through his State of Union......

Words: 2564 - Pages: 11

Premium Essay

School Uniforms

...Every school is in essence a learning environment. That which aids learning is acceptable, and that which hinders it should be unacceptable. Add to this the fears of school violence and student safety and you can see why many school boards are calling for school uniforms. In this article we will look at school uniforms and the potential benefits and problems associated with school uniforms along with legal issues and whether they are in fact truly effective. School uniforms serve a number of purposes. A good deal of research has been undertaken in regard to the use of the school uniform, and the net result has been the wider use of school uniforms in more recent years. Also to increase school safety, to encourage our students to experience a greater sense of school identity and belonging, to encourage an improvement in student behavior, to reduce school clothing costs, to encourage a high level of program participation and to improve and expand academic excellence. School uniforms range from the formal to the informal. Some schools that have implemented school uniforms have chosen what one usually thinks of in connection to Catholic schools: nice pants and white shirts for boys, jumpers and white shirts for girls. However, most public schools are turning to something more casual and more acceptable to parents and students: khakis or jeans and knit shirts of varying colors. The latter appear to be more affordable too because they can be used outside of school. Many......

Words: 2109 - Pages: 9