Premium Essay

Analyze the Performance of Metcash and Woolworths

In: Business and Management

Submitted By PennyZhao
Words 2467
Pages 10
In this valuation report, we will analyze the performance of Metcash and Woolworths (Australia) in the past six years from 2007 to 2012 and make some forecasts in order to aid investors in making decisions about investments between these two companies. Two methods of DCF valuation and relative valuation are used during the analysis. Firstly, we estimate FCFF with calculated WACC to determine the two companies’ stock price, comparing their actual current stock price. Secondly, we analyze P/E Ratio, P/S Ratio and EV/EITDA Ratio to make a comparison between the two companies and average industry. Our estimation will show that both Metcash and Woolworth are undervalued and suitable for investment
1. Overview : Metcash Limited(MTS) and Woolworths Limited(WOW) 3 1.1 Metcash Limited 3 1.2 Woolworths Limited 3
2. Metcash DCF valuation within FCFF approach 4 2.1 Weighted average cost of capital 4 2.1.1 Cost of equity 4 2.1.2 Cost of debt 4 2.1.3 Capital structure analysis 5 2.1.4 Effective tax rate analysis 5 2.2Estimation of FCFF 6 2.2.1 Growth rate expectation 6 2.2.2 FCFF and present value 6
3. Woolworths Limited DCF valuation within FCFF approach 7 3.1 Weighted average cost of capital 7 3.1.1 Cost of equity 7 3.1.2 Cost of debt 8 3.1.3 Capital structure analysis 8 3.1.4 Effective tax rate analysis 9 3.2 Estimation of FCFF 10 3.2.1 Growth rate expectation 10 3.2.2 FCFF and present value 10 4. Relative Valuation 11 4.1 Price Earnings Model (P/E Ratio) 11 4.2 Price to Sales Model (P/S Ratio) 13 4.3 Enterprise Value to EBITDA Multiple 14
5. Summery and recommendation 15
6. Reference list 17

1. Overview : Metcash Limited(MTS) and Woolworths Limited(WOW)

1.1 Metcash Limited

Metcash Limited…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Sustainability Reporting - Woolworths

...Contents Executive Summary 1 Introduction 2 Defining Sustainability 2 What Sustainability means to Woolworths 3 Corporate Stakeholders of Woolworths 3 Woolworths Drive for Change 5 Integrated Reporting 6 Why Integrated Reporting? 6 Woolworths Integrated Reporting 7 The Future of Integrated Reporting 7 Conclusion 8 Word Count: 1995 Executive Summary This report examines the new world of sustainability reporting, and the complex web of stakeholders. It focuses particularly on the demands for new kinds of transparency which serve the interests of the environment and society. In this report, Woolworths, one of our major competitors has been analyzed in order to understand how they have evolved the concept of sustainability and how they have applied it to their organizational level. As a result, Woolworths has placed our organization at a competitive disadvantage. The report finds Woolworths future prospects as a positive template in managing our organization. Their engagement on sustainability issues with their stakeholders, customers, suppliers, investors and employees through their Sustainability Strategy have placed them in the lead. This report provides an opportunity on sustainability and integrated reporting for our organization. Introduction Over the years there has been an increase in pressure and concern over the impact that organizations have had on the environment and the society. As a result, organizations are being......

Words: 2140 - Pages: 9

Premium Essay

Woolworths Ltd Strategic Analysis

...-------2 Part A: Woolworths Ltd Strategic Analysis---------------------------------------------------------------2 SWOT analysis for Woolworths Ltd------------------------------------------------------------------------3 Key Capability Analysis---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------4 Major stakeholder analysis for Woolworths Ltd---------------------------------------------------------5 Assessment of Business Level Strategy---------------------------------------------------------------------6 PART B: Woolworths Ltd Strategic Review--------------------------------------------------------------6 Analysis of Key Strategic Plan Elements-------------------------------------------------------------------6 Stakeholder implication assessment for growing the Multi-channel strategy----------------------7 Stakeholder implication assessment for growing the Cost consciousness strategy----------------8 Strategy Map---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------10 Balanced Scorecard-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------11 Conclusion-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------12 Appendix--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------13 Reference PART A: Woolworths Ltd Strategic......

Words: 2961 - Pages: 12

Free Essay


...9 August 2012,Woolworths today launched Australia’s first drive-thru supermarket allowing customers to collect their shopping without having to get out of their car. The first ‘click & collect drive-thru’ service will be at Woolworths Warringah Mall in Sydney and is free to use. From today, Woolworths customers can access the ‘click & collect drive-thru’ service when they shop at Woolworths Online ( via their smartphone, tablet or PC. Once an order is complete, customers select the drive-thru option, choose a collection time between 10am and 7pm everyday and collect their groceries by presenting identification at the Woolworths drive-thru bay where an attendant will pack their shopping into the boot of their car. Since the launch of our highly successful ‘click & collect’ service, Woolworths received a large amount of customer feedback, especially from mums and dads, asking when woolwoths is going to offer a drive-thru service “Woolworths ‘click & collect drive-thru’ will appeal to a broad range of customers; mums and dads who don’t want to unload the kids from the car when picking up their shopping and our time-poor customers who don’t want to spend time finding parking, going in-store or waiting for home delivery. “This is another way Woolworths Online is using innovation and technology to improve ocustomer’s shopping experience. Woolworths is offering customers practical and simple solutions that will allow them......

Words: 369 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Woolworths Case Study

...product range, is Woolworths diluting its vales proposition? Value proposition is a promise to be delivered by the company to the customer, a statement that summarises why a customer should buy their products. The CEO of Woolworths has stated clearly that their products will add more value on the basis of “quality, innovation, freshness and unique placements”. This value proposition is in line with the company’s strategic plan of providing good quality products, superior packaging and excellent customer relations. Woolworths has adopted a differentiation strategy, whereby it is out-competing its competitors based on these qualities. Thus in order for this company to continue having a sustainable competitive advantage over its rivals and continue to serve its niche high income and the newly discovered middle-income (Black diamonds) target markets, this strategy needs to also be maintained. For a company and its strategy to successfully compete, the company must continually scan the environment it operates in, ensure that its strategy is aligned with that environment, and ensure that the company has the capabilities to execute the strategy. Woolworths scanned the environment and acknowledged that the global economic recession was severely affecting its target market spending power and were as a result, loosing business to competitors like Pick ‘n Pay and achieving lower profit margins. Thus by lowering its product prices and adding more product lines, Woolworths ensured that......

Words: 572 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Case: Woolworths

...1. By dropping prices and increasing product range, is Woolworths diluting its value proposition? No, Woolworths is not diluting its value proposition by dropping prices and increasing its product range. Own-brand products bring great value and perceived quality, synonymous with the Woolworths brand. Reduced input costs do not result in a product quality alteration and therefore I suggest that no negative impact exists. Reduced pricing to remain competitive during tough economic conditions is a necessary move. Lost revenues due to margin erosion can be replaced via additional product lines. Retail strategy continues to be aimed at the niche high-income market. Entry into the ‘black diamonds’ new market opportunity does not dilute the value proposition. - Represents a new market development and extension of product range within the higher LSM market. - Purchasing power of the new segment is relevant and cannot be ignored. - Value proposition supports offering within the new market. 2. When the economic conditions change for the better, should Woolworths withdraw some of the added products? Please Explain. No, Woolworths must not withdraw any of the added products. Before Woolworth introduced the added products, research and developments studies were conducted and it became apparent that there was the market for product range introduced New product lines shall never be seen as the cheaper substitutes, instead product line extension.......

Words: 588 - Pages: 3

Free Essay

Business Report Woolworths

...Business Report | Woolworths | | Jiaye Li (Paul) 31757 | BAE-7 | 2013/6/10 | Word count: 1210 | Table of contents Executive Summary 1 1 Introduction 2 2 Evaluation of the Woolworths in terms of ethic 3 3 Evaluation of the Woolworths in terms of share price history 5 3.1 A brief description of the trends 5 3.2 An evaluation based on the trends 6 4 Recommendations 6 References List 8 Executive Summary The purpose of this report is to evaluate whether Woolworths is worth for invest and offer some suggestions to the client who is concerned about Woolworths in terms of ethical and share price. First of all, it provides the definition of ethical investing and background information about Woolworths. Secondly, it will briefly describe the situation of pokies machines in Australia and explain why gambling industry is unethical. Then, this report will illustrate the trends of Woolworths share price history over a 10-year period and give an evaluation based on the trends. The result of this report shows that although Woolworths is a profitable business entity, it has ethical problems in terms of gambling. This report recommends that Woolworths is not an appropriate choice for investor at the present time. Nevertheless, this report also advises that the client should be better to note the latest news of Woolworths to ensure whether it is worth investing in the future because Woolworths might abandon investing in gambling in the......

Words: 1598 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay


...1. Currently, the food retail industry is a highly competitive market in Australia as a great number of retail supermarkets are competing for the largest market share in this market, with giant retail companies such as Woolworths, Coles, IGA and Aldi sharing the main market. More so than ever, organizations need to offer customers value for money. Customers want the best quality products at the lowest possible prices. With such tough competition it is vital for organizations to understand what their customers want. Strategy management refers to the process of identifying, choosing and implementing activities that will enhance the long-term performance of an organization by setting direction, and by creating ongoing compatibility between the internal skills and resources of the organization, and the changing external environment within which it operates. Strategy competitiveness illustrates company’s outstanding competitive edge compared with its competitors due to the use of successful and suitable business strategy in terms of the business management, this is achieved when a firm successfully formulates and implements a value-creating strategy. Aldi has a no-nonsense approach to running its business. Whereas other food retailers have elaborate displays, additional services and promotions that draw customers into the business, Aldi’s core purpose is to ‘provide value and quality to our customers by being fair and efficient in all we do’ . Everything Aldi does is focused......

Words: 599 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Woolworths Limited

...Woolworths Limited Business Model [pic] 7241MGT Business Process Models Major Assignment Semester I, 2005 Abstract The firm selected for this project is Woolworths Limited which is an Australian leading retail company made up of a number of businesses all providing the customers with quality, range, value and everyday low prices. Woolworths is built on a passion for retail, attention to detail, working hard, ensuring the safety of their valuable customers and people, and having fun. Woolworth’s mission is to deliver to customers a better shopping experience - each and every time. The project initially carries out preliminary business analysis where it recognizes the market structure and describes the value chain in that industry segment that earns the companies income. Further analysis has been done about the changes that have been done in this segment in past two decades. Also the challenges Woolworths faces from its competitors are described. It identifies Porter’s five forces model influencing the company viz. Substitutes, Rival groups, Buyers, Sellers and Potential New Entrants. The project has done the strategic analysis of the industry’s current position and identified the likely challenges Woolworths may face in the near future. It also studies the various risks which has impact on the company such as “Cyclical risk”,......

Words: 2909 - Pages: 12

Premium Essay


...Assignment 1-BSBHRM506A Woolworths limited is a major Australian Company with extensive retail interests throughout Australia and New Zealand. Woolworths is the largest food/retail company with well-known brands including Big W, Dick Smiths electronics and Dan Murphy’s. Woolworth’s strong Market capitalisation and sales are a key point in the Company’s growth. Woolworths is also a company that makes a significant economic contribution with more than 180,000 team members across metropolitan and regional Australia. It has annual contribution to the economy estimated to be in excess of $96 billion dollars and 652,400 full time equivalent jobs, training more apprentices than any other company in Australia. Woolworths in every state has its own structure, for example State Manager, Assistant Manager and Area managers. South Australia being the smaller state has 5 Area Managers for 85 stores. New South Wales being the larger state, has 16 Area Managers for 270 stores each managing between, 12-22 stores and employs 200 staff or more in each store. Each store is based around this structure to try and give the Store Managers as much assistance to help support their employees and in turn benefits the customers. To centralize their customers and their HR Management, Woolworths will use other divisions; for example, Big W will use some of the infrastructures from Dan Murphy’s. HR departments in large companies can get enormous amounts of employee inquiries that can...

Words: 1597 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Starbucks Analyze

... 1. Analyze the buyer decision process of a traditional Porsche customer. Porsche has traditionally developed a low volume and increasingly fragmented auto market. The availability of only a few high end models created an image of exclusivity. It is the image of exclusivity that is most important to Porsche consumers. They want their car to represent how successful they are. 2. Contrast the traditional Porsche customer decision process to the decision process for a Cayenne or Panamera customer. As opposed to the traditional Porsche consumer who is concerned with the way the car sounds, vibrates, and feels, a consumer deciding between the Cayenne and Panamera will take into consideration factors such as size and practicality. Interestingly, both consumers are likely to be focused on factors such as speed and brand image. 3. Which concepts from the chapter explain why Porsche sold so many lower-priced models in the 1970’s and 1980’s? • Cultural Factors (social class): having a Porsche is always meant for upper class status, and having a Porsche allows customers to relate with this class. The Porsche 914 was an alternative presented to consumers who could not afford a traditional Porsche, but wanted the image of the brand. • Personal Factors (economic situation): in the 1970’s and 80’s, Porsche took into consideration consumers with lower income, so they produced affordable vehicles based on the social class, the status, and the......

Words: 439 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Strategic Finance Issues - Woolworths Ltd

...Executive summary This report presents a detailed financial performance analysis of Woolworths Limited for Financial Years (FY) 2013 and 2014. The report takes an approach that aims to highlight industry trends before commenting on the financial performance of the company. This critical analysis is carried out through the examination of important financial ratios to assess the short-term solvency (liquidity), long-term solvency, profitability, management’s efficiency, and market based ratios of Woolworths. Finally, the report ends with a concluding comment offering input on the managerial directions that are currently taken by Woolworths and how market value will continue to increase based on sound decisions and management. Table of contents 1. Introduction............................................................................................................... 7 2. Economic Outlooks…............................................................................................... 7 3. Industry Profile………………….............................................................................. 7 4. Ratio Analyses…………………………………………………….......................... 8 4.1 Liquidity Analysis................................................................................................... 8 4.2 Long-Term Solvency Analysis.................................................................................9 4.3 Profitability Analysis......................................

Words: 3378 - Pages: 14

Free Essay

The Company Results of Woolworth Limited

...Michael Luscombe Chief Executive Officer Tom Pockett Finance Director Company Results Full Year ended 28 June 2009 Highlights for Financial Year 2009 • This has been a successful year with our business performing well overall in a difficult economic climate • The result is the outcome of our consistent delivery against our clearly defined strategies — proving that Woolworths is built to deliver sustainable results over the long term • The result reflects increased customer acceptance of our offers underpinned by the reinvestment in all our businesses to ensure the momentum continues to build long term shareholder value. We will continue to refine our brands to changing customer expectations • Our strong new store rollout across all brands continued during the year • FY09 saw enhanced Rewards development and launch of new initiatives • We are well positioned for future growth with a strong balance sheet and cash flow 2 Highlights – Full Year 2009 Successful year with solid results across our business FY09 Sales - Group - ex Petrol EBIT NPAT EPS ROFE $49.6b $44.1b $2,815.5m $1,835.7m 150.7¢ 31.9% Growth1 52 v 52 7.5% 8.5% 13.4% 14.9% 13.8% 1.1%pts Growth 52 v 53 5.4% 6.6% 11.3% 12.8% 11.7% 0.5%pts Well positioned for achieving long term sustainable profitable growth 1. Reflects growth normalised to remove the impact of the 53rd week in FY08 3 Highlights for the year 4 Rollout of New Formats – Australia & NZ "We will continue to......

Words: 6463 - Pages: 26

Free Essay

Woolworth in Ghana

...Individual Assignment Woolworths in Ghana Individual Assignment Woolworths in Ghana Executive Summary This report analyzes the current marketing strategies of Woolworths in Ghana from four perspectives: products, price, project and promotion. Also, it will briefly mention the company’s successful marketing strategy in other African countries. According to what Woolworths has accomplished in Ghana, the recommendations in this report are generated based on the findings and analyses of Ghana environment. In particular, Ghana’s social, political, legal and economic factors will be presented as they relate to the commercial atmosphere. The recommendations, which are meant to help Woolworths define its future development, are as follows: • Seek more opportunities in Ghana and open more Woolworths C&GM stores in Accra. • Utilize social media to build strong brand awareness among Ghanaians. • Maintain positive, healthy relationships with the government of Ghana for further development. Table of Contents Executive Summary 1 Table of Contents 2 Introduction 3 Company Description and Current Marketing Strategy Analysis 4 Company Description and Analysis 4 Scope and Limitations 5 Description of Current Marketing Strategy of Woolworths 5 Product 5 Place 6 Promotion 6 Price 6 Market/Business Environment Analysis and Recommendations 8 Economic 8 Social 9 Political 10 Legal 10 Reference List 12 Introduction Woolworths is a......

Words: 1975 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

Woolworths Sustainability Evaluation

...Assessment 3.1 Social and Environmental Component Evaluation of Woolworths Limited’s Corporate Responsibility Report Skye Childs 2095183 Dan Francis-Staite 2113169 Emma Welsh 2138113 Contents: Title page 1 Content page 2 1.0 Executive Summary 3 2.0 Stakeholders outline 6 3.0 Sustainability assessment: 10 3.1 Social 10 3.2 Environmental 12 4.0 Bottom of the Pyramid Market Engagement: 15 5.0 United Nations Global Compact Principles (UNGC): 16 6.0 Social & Environmental Issues 17 7.0 Recommendations 21 8.0 Conclusion 23 9.0 Appendix 25 10.0 References 36 1.0 Executive Summary This report contains an evaluation of the sustainability of Woolworths Limited’s 2015 Corporate Responsibility report. To identify how effectively Woolworths managed stakeholders, we briefly outlined them and applied the ‘Freeman’ model. We also categorized them using the ‘Fassin’ model to identify stakeholders, stakewatchers and stakekeepers. As a large corporation, Woolworths prioritises it’s engagement with stakeholders that contribute to the economic bottom-line. Large investment into suppliers at each stage of the supply-chain coupled with the company’s capability to consistently purchase large quantities of inventory results in strong relationships with suppliers. Woolworths is effectively able to demand, achieve and maintain very low prices. This......

Words: 6818 - Pages: 28

Premium Essay


...Metcash Originating in the 1920's as a family business, Metcash Limited (Metcash) is Australia's leading wholesale distribution and marketing company specialising in grocery, fresh produce, liquor, hardware and other fast moving consumer goods. Metcash has 4 divisions, often referred to as business pillars, each operating in a distinct wholesaling industry segment: All business models are fully owned by Metcash with the exception of Mitre10, which is 50.1% owned. IGA>D A grocery wholesaler which serves 2,500 independent retail grocery stores (including IGA branded stores) across Australia. IGA>D operates 6 major distribution centers, carrying dry, chilled and frozen grocery products. IGA>D supports independent retailers with a comprehensive range of services including: 24 hour retail system, in-store training, retail development and store equipment service to assist in expanding, refurbishing or building new sites. IGA Fresh A division of IGA>D focuses on fresh food (fruit, vegetables, meat, deli and bakery) supply to independent retailers. ALM Australian Liquor Marketers is Australia and New Zealand's leading broad range liquor wholesaler. ALM operates from 18 distribution locations across the country. Larger ‘off-premise’ customers are supplied through the main distribution system; a specialist ‘on-premise’ distribution arm, Harbottle On-Premise (HOP) supplies pubs, clubs and restaurants. ALM also provides marketing support and a range of......

Words: 518 - Pages: 3