Free Essay

Airline Deregulation

In: Science

Submitted By Jasper3608
Words 525
Pages 3
Give credit where credit is due. Twenty years ago, the Carter Administration and Congress, behind the ceaseless efforts of Alfred E. Kahn, former chairman of the now defunct CAB (Civil Aeronautics Board), deregulated the airlines, a move that has saved consumers billions of dollars. Drinking large dipper fulls from the Conservative/Libertarian intellectual well, the Carter Administration acted on the assumption that a freer market would be better able to meet consumer demands, than a government bureaucracy. The federal role is now limited to safety regulation carried out by the Federal Aviation Administration. (FAA)
Before deregulation, innovation and change by the airline industry was smothered. It took years for airlines to petition and the CAB to approve new routes. Rates were strictly controlled. It was virtually impossible for new airlines to enter the market.
Since deregulation airlines are cheaper to fly, safer, while at the same time the number of passenger miles has dramatically increased. A few facts are illuminating.
Price Reductions
The average fare per passenger mile is about 9% lower since deregulation. Crandall and Ellig [1] report savings of $19.4 billion per year for consumers. Contrary to conventional wisdom, the Government Accounting Office (GAO) [2] reports that, ``The average fare per passenger mile, adjusted for inflation, has fallen since deregulation about as much at airports serving small and medium-sized communities as it has at airports serving large communities.'' The theoretical possibility that deregulation would be a boon to major markets at the expense of smaller communities has proven ill founded.
Improved Service Quantity
Reductions in fares spurred middle class families, previously priced out of the air flight market, to fly. In 1997 airlines flew 5.7 billion miles compared to 2.5 billion in 1978. This improved service was not limited to large markets. The GAO reports that, ``The quantity of air service, as measured by the number of both departures and available seats, has increased since deregulation for all three airport groups [small, medium, and large].''
Improved Safety
Assessing safety is inherently difficult because airline accidents are low-probability episodic events. Nonetheless the number of fatal accidents per million aircraft miles were significantly smaller in the 1980s and 1990s after regulation, than in the 1970s. Only one year in the last two decades experienced a higher rate of fatal accidents per passenger mile than 1978, the year preceding deregulation. The GAO confirms that this improved safety record is limited to large markets serviced by jets. The GAO report concludes that it ``did not find any statistically significant differences between the trends in air safety for airports serving small, medium-sized, and large communities.''
Recently there has been significant consolidation in the airline industry as less efficient firms are absorbed or go out of business. Nonetheless, the positive benefits of deregulation are likely to continue as the Internet allows consumers to search for minimum fares.
The Heritage Foundation [3] offers some additional proposals to further deregulate and improve the airline industry. These steps include the privatization of airports, market-based pricing for takeoff time slots, and encouragement of foreign competition. This last measure can alleviate the possibility of anti-competitive monopolies…...

Similar Documents

Premium Essay

Effect of Deregulation on Airline Industry

...Since deregulation, the number of low cost carriers (also known as LCCs) has steadily increased to a point in which they have become a major component in the air transportation industry. There are many attributes that make a carrier a low cost carrier and allows them to operate cheaply and efficiently. Two important ones are having employees working multiple roles and fast turnaround times. With employees working multiple roles, there is less of a need for specialized staff and training. If a flight attendant can also work as the cleaning crew, there is not a need for two different employees on the company payroll. This consolidation leads to greater efficiency and lowered cost to the company. Indirectly these multi-purpose employees also contribute to faster turnaround times. In the example of flight attendants that also assist in cleaning the cabin, at the end of a flight, instead of having the flight attendants get off the aircraft have the cleaning crew come and clean, the present staff can do the task reducing time on the ground. Like in many businesses, airlines equate time to money. The more time an aircraft is on the ground the less money these carriers are going to make. Faster turnarounds means more legs are able to be flown in a day and a better perception of customer service (because customers are not sitting around waiting to board). One article that looks closely at Southwest Airlines (a now popular low cost carrier) reported that Southwest airlines has “the...

Words: 331 - Pages: 2

Free Essay

Transportation Deregulation

...Dean A DeFrank Transportation Principles Embry Riddle University Module Two Deregulation All modes of travel have experienced great changes through the years. Those changes were the government getting out of the travel management business and allowing the free market to determine the course of these modes of travel. The following will describe in simplistic form the effects of deregulation on each mode of travel. Airline Deregulation: The Airline Deregulation Act of 1978 removed government control over fares, routes and creation of new airlines. The Civil Aeronautics Board (the governing body on airlines during regulation) powers of regulation were removed thus allowing the industry to be exposed to market forces. The Act, however, did not remove or diminish the regulatory powers of the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) over all aspects of air safety. Airline deregulation has enabled more competitive pricing and increased carrier flexibility. Prior to deregulation, airline pricing was regulated by the Civil Aeronautics Board. Additionally, air routes were also controlled tightly. With more freedom, carriers can offer more effective options to those who wish to use airfreight as a means of shipment. Railway deregulation: Railroad Revitalization and Regulatory Reform Act of 1976 eased regulations on rates, line abandonment, and mergers. Four years later, Congress followed up with the Staggers Rail Act of 1980. The most important features of the Staggers......

Words: 576 - Pages: 3

Premium Essay

Airline

...SWOT analysis for Air China The airline industry has undergone significant restructuring in recent years.Airlines, formerly rivals in a highly regulated industry, have become opportunisticseekers of co-operation. In today's world, mega-carriers and small airlines areworking together rather than competing with one another. Forms of co-operation include sub-contracting, code sharing, franchising and theformation of global marketing networks. Such alliances allow firms to focus on their respective core competencies, while drawing the benefits of scale economies. In essence,co-operation among rivals has led to increased competitiveness. This has accelerated thetrend of joint marketing, and the airline industry has become characterized by the desireto belong to a global network. The tendency has been to strive for a global presence. The case of Air China Air China was founded on the 1st of July 1955. Its headquarters is based in Beijing. Itengages in international and domestic passenger and cargo flight services. To unify itsfacility image and simplify its repairs and maintenances, its fleet of 118 aircraftexclusively consists of Boeing models. It has established hub-spoke style passenger andcargo transport network. The hub of this network is Beijing International Airport.The company is operating 339 routes, which consists of 53 international and 286domestic, operating more than 1,000 scheduled flights on weekly basis, serving 29 citiesin 19 countries. About 66 per cent of its...

Words: 1739 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Southwest Airlines

... Analysis of Strategic Structure of Southwest Airlines     Uploaded by so cerious on Jun 26, 2006 [pic] |Analysis of Strategic Structure of Southwest Airlines | | | |Twenty-nine years ago, Rollin King and Herb Kelleher got together and decided to start a different kind of airline. They began with one | |simple notion: If you get your passengers to their destinations when they want to get there, on time, at the lowest possible fares, and | |make darn sure they have a good time doing it, people will fly your airline. | | | |Within 28 years, Southwest Airlines became the fifth largest major airline in America. With the addition of service to Buffalo-Niagara | |International Airport on October 8, 2000, fly more than 57 million passengers a year to 57 great cities (58 airports) all over the | |Southwest and beyond. And she does it over 2,600 times a day. | | ...

Words: 4348 - Pages: 18

Premium Essay

Deregulation

...planned merger with American Airlines, Mother Jones blogger Kevin Drum highlighted a novel counterargument. Mr Drum says that it is still "an open question whether deregulation was such a boon for the flying public in the first place," and points to a 2012 article by Phillip Longman and Lina Khan. In that piece, published in the Washington Monthly (where I was once an intern), Mr Longman and Ms Khan argue that airline deregulation has slowly killed mid-sized airports and the cities that depend on them. Here's the thesis: Over the years, most Americans have adopted a pretty standard line about the results [of airline deregulation]. On the one hand, complaining about the indignities of flying—overbooked, late, or cancelled flights; surly flight attendants; and, more recently, terrible in-flight food service and high fees for checked baggage— has become a staple of American life, much like complaining about Internet providers or health insurance companies. On the other hand, we’ve told ourselves, at least the increased competition has made air travel cheaper. And at least most of us can still get where we need to go by air.But now we find ourselves at a moment when nearly all the promises of the airline deregulators have clearly proved false. If you’re a member of the creative class who rarely does business in the nation’s industrial heartland or visits relatives there, you might not notice the magnitude of economic disruption being caused by lost airline service and......

Words: 895 - Pages: 4

Premium Essay

Airline Industry, Budget Airlines

...Australian incorporated company, is a subsidiary of QANTAS currently managed by CEO Bruce Buchanan Industry Both companies operate mainly in Asia Pacific region’s budget passenger airline industry. However, both are not fully integrated as they do not build their own aircraft. Both companies only offer economy class for its flights, which travels within Asia Pacific region and to selected international destinations. Core activities include ? Activity Analysis: First, you identify the activities you undertake to deliver your product or service; Value Analysis: Second, for each activity, you think through what you would do to add the greatest value for your customer; and Evaluation and Planning: Thirdly, you evaluate whether it is worth making changes, and then plan for action. Access the industry’s future growth Current- life-cycle position of the industry Generally, based on the information given, it seems that the airline industry in overall is on a decline. This is supported by the fall in premium air passengers by 25% and the declaration of bankruptcy by Japan Airline However, due to these factors, the initial public offering of Tiger Airways, another budger airline and the prediction of increase in revenue in Jetstar’s operation by Bruce Buchanan, it is likely that the budget airline industry is growing at a rate more than 10%. Key issues affecting future growth |  |Description ......

Words: 2329 - Pages: 10

Free Essay

The Impact of Deregulation on the Airline Industry

...The Impact of Deregulation on the Airline Industry The aviation industry in the United States was facing several problems such as falling productivity, high inflation, rising labor costs, higher fuel costs and low economic growth. These problems led to the deregulation of the airline industry in 1978 with the Airline Deregulation Act that removed the various controls that influenced the decision power of the companies. The deregulation lasted about three years and the main objective was to increase competition between airline carriers and lower service prices. The deregulation began with the easing of tariffs and liberalization of routes. During the regulations, customers paid high rates and hadn’t many options because there weren’t many airlines companies. After the deregulation, increased competition, new companies have emerged due to lowering barriers entry of new airlines industries and the price decreased. In this competitive environment, the company has increased its investments in quality and marketing as well as the efficient use of its fleet in order to attract more consumers. Also, the cost control has become a major factor in the management of airlines. However, the rapid growth of the airline industry has triggered some problems like congestion at some airports, travel delays and low runway capacity especially during peak hours of travel. These problems are caused due to increased demand and the lack of investment in some airports. The opening of foreign......

Words: 1307 - Pages: 6

Premium Essay

Airline

...299 – Competitive Strategy Southwest Airlines Introduction The domestic US airline industry has been intensely competitive since it was deregulated in 1978. In a regulated environment, most of the cost increases were passed along to consumers under a fixed rate-of-return based pricing scheme. This allowed labor unions to acquire a lot of power and workers at the major incumbent carriers were overpaid. After deregulation, the incumbent carriers felt the most pain, and the floodgates had opened for newer more nimble carriers with lower cost structures to compete head-on with the established airlines. There were several bankruptcies followed by a wave of consolidation with the fittest carriers surviving and the rest being acquired or going out of business. Analysis of the airline industry To determine the profitability of the airline industry, we will do an industry analysis using Porter’s five-forces framework. This industry analysis will help us in understanding the size of the Potential Industry Earnings (PIE), and how much of this the different participants can extract. Rivalry among competitors There is intense rivalry among different airlines. In the pre-deregulation days, airlines competed mostly on things like service, meals and in-flight movies etc., since prices were mandated by the Civil Aeronautics Board. In the post-de-regulation era, this rivalry has taken on the form of severe price competition, with airlines ruthlessly undercutting each other with......

Words: 2475 - Pages: 10

Premium Essay

Airlines

...our living atmosphere. Currently, the airlines in European Union are belt-tightening in order to reduce emissions, however, the outcome is not satisfactory at present, for instance, there is problem on the emission trading scheme. Thus, creating more environmental regulations for airlines in the European Union is necessary as to tackle the emission problem more effectively. Data from the Guardian UK shows that the plane industry occupied the second place in the National Carbon Calculators which takes 4,375 per person per year in average. Despite there are environmental policies regulating the carbon emissions by the airbus within the European Union, such as setting levels of carbon emissions for airlines, it is not well-performed. Under the regulations, those airlines could reduce their emissions could sell their surplus permits to the other airlines that unable to lower their emissions. They are more likely to buy extra permits from other airlines across the industry in order to increase their emissions. Roger Harrabin, the Environment Analyst of BBC, states that under this Carbon Trading Scheme proposed by the European Union, the airlines could evade the commandment by buying more permits from others. Some of the airlines institutions such as British Airways and Air France hold a view that they are encouraged to buy extra permits instead of reducing their carbon emissions. This case revealed that the carbon emissions by the airlines are not being reduced under the......

Words: 1727 - Pages: 7

Premium Essay

Airlines

...1: Case Study European Airline Industry Strategic Management Contents |Main Body |4-10 | |1 Introduction |4-5 | |2 Summary of macro-environment analysis |5-7 | |3 Summary of industry environment analysis |7-8 | |4 Other critical factors for the airline industry |8-9 | |5 Future directions/recommendations |9-10 | | | | |Appendices |11-26 | |1 Macro-environment analysis |11-16 | |2 Industry environment analysis |17-26 | Reference List 27 Main Body 1. Introduction The European airline industry is a vigorous industry with changing trends that relate to the overall European economy. Traditionally, the European airline industry was mainly comprised of full-service carriers, such as Lufthansa and British Airways. Nevertheless, this situation changed quite swiftly (Datta & Chakravarty n.d.). Government deregulations freed European airline markets from......

Words: 7962 - Pages: 32

Premium Essay

Airline Deragulation

...Interamerican University of Puerto Rico School of Aeronautics Airline Deregulation a Failure Jose Manuel Lopez Team 4 AWCS 2000 Prof. Ocasio Airline deregulation is a failure while the commercial airliner industry has sky rocketed in safety, lower fares. But the industry itself has seen many companies merge and this has made the top 5 airline companies have more power in the market than before the 1978 Airline deregulation act. If we look at them now their control in the market is at an 80% with normal traffic fares and the International fares all together. This make it so the top 5 airline companies have more control than they did before giving these airlines more control of routes and this created a series of unforeseen problems at the time the high congestion of air traffic, delays of flights, overcrowded airports that made the airports targets for terrorist attacks which made air travel more difficult, how this would affect the workers of these companies in making, and customer unsatisfactory, and “The limited Reemergence of monopoly power” stated by Alfred E. Khan Professor of Political Economy, at University of Cornwell, and former economic advisor to President Carter and chairman of the Civil Aeronautics Board. Airline deregulation while it blossomed in some areas it started to create a growing problem where companies started to exclude competition and this would create an industry that more and more airlines would have to merge with the bigger companies......

Words: 325 - Pages: 2

Premium Essay

Airlines

...Strategic Report for Southwest Airlines Tycen Bundgaard John Bejjani Edmund Helmer April 12, 2006 Table of Contents EXECUTIVE SUMMARY............................................................................................... 3 COMPANY BACKGROUND ....................................................................................... 6 PORTER’S FIVE FORCES............................................................................................ 10 MARKET DEFINITION .............................................................................................................. 10 INTERNAL RIVALRY ................................................................................................................. 11 ENTRY ....................................................................................................................................... 12 SUBSTITUTES AND COMPLEMENTS ........................................................................................ 14 SUPPLIER POWER ..................................................................................................................... 15 BUYER POWER .......................................................................................................................... 18 FINANCIAL ANALYSIS.............................................................................................. 19 OPERATION FINANCIALS .................................................................................

Words: 8674 - Pages: 35

Free Essay

Deregulation

...Codi Feuerzeig  Economics 104  Professor Robert Pollin  TA: Evelyn Kwakye  May 7, 2015     Deregulation       During the 1970s and 1980s the United States government went through a period of  deregulation.   Deregulation is a reduction of government involvement and control within an  industry.  Did this deregulation lead to the 2008 financial crisis?  This is a hot button topic that is  highly debated and causes a great deal of controversy.  The financial crisis of 2008, known as the  Great Recession, impacted the entire country and practically every individual citizen.  Many  politicians, such as Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi, look for an easy blame or a scapegoat,  for example, the deregulation by the Bush Administration.  Pelosi has been quoted saying ​ "​ the  Bush Administration's eight long years of failed deregulation policies have resulted in our  nation's largest bailout ever, leaving the American taxpayers on the hook potentially for billions  of dollars" (Gattuso).​   The issue with that statement is that the economic deregulation she speaks  of did not take place during the Bush Administration, but many years prior and the laws of that  time are not controversial in today’s economic situation.  Rather more recent regulatory laws are  to blame for the financial crisis of 2008.      Why did we Regulate in the First Place?    The Great Depression is unopposed when it comes to economic downfalls in the United  States.  The financial h...

Words: 1874 - Pages: 8

Premium Essay

How Did the Deregulation of Air Transportation in Europe Foster Entrepreneurial Behavior and Innovation in the European Airline Industry over the Last Twenty Years

...How did the deregulation of air transportation in Europe foster entrepreneurial behavior and innovation in the European airline industry over the last twenty years? Case studies: SAS Airline & Ryanair Master Thesis in Entrepreneurship and Dynamic Business Contexts Spring 2007 Supervisor: Håkan Bohman Entrepreneurship Master Program Authors: Gilles Helterlin and Nuno Ramalho Acknowledgements We would like to express our gratitude to all who have contributed to the realization of this Master Thesis. A warm thank to our supervisor, Håkan Bohman from USBE (Umeå School of Business), for his guidance, his precious help and his advises during the last months. To Mr. Lundvall, from LFV (Luftfartsverket), Mr. Valinger from Scandinavian Airline and Mr. Wilsberg from SAS Braathens, Jessica Eriksson and Thomas Pettersson from USBE, thank you for your availability, willingness in answering our questions and for their so precious collaboration with interviews, comments and suggestions. Thank you also Sweden for the wonderful moments we have spent here. We will never forget your nature (your elks), your cold winter (-30°C), your long nights in winter and your short nights in late spring!! It has been a great experience and adventure up there in Northern Sweden!! We will miss you… Finally we would like to thank particularly the Studentexpedition for its kindness, without forgetting our family and friends (from Sweden, France, Portugal and Greece) for their everlasting daily......

Words: 79741 - Pages: 319

Premium Essay

Airline Industry

...perhaps has shown the most changes in market model is the airline industry in the United States. The airline industry can be analyzed different before and after deregulation and before and after the terrorist’s attacks of September 11th. These events have changed the industry in terms of both airfares and market concentration in major airports. Prior to deregulation in the 1970’s the Department of Transportation (DOT) served its goal by looking after the public interests. Once the focus of the DOT shifted to assuring airlines were operating under strict safety standards and procedures this gave a chance for airlines to take on any domestic route it felt capable of performing. Deregulation resulted in structural changes for airlines. Following deregulation, most of the largest airlines began to operate in the now well known hub-and-spoke system, which allowed for efficient connections for passengers from small- and mid-sized cities, but it also has increased airline concentration at hubs. As a result, the net effect has been to increase the choice of carriers at non-hub cities and to increase the frequency of service but also to increase the market concentration at hub cities. According to Parkin, (2011) most governments use a mechanism for allocating airport boarding gates and facilities, in some cases it even allows for competitive bidding for boarding gates and landing rights thus encouraging competition among airlines, and it also might encourage airport authorities......

Words: 1852 - Pages: 8